Effect of non-acoustic parameters on heterogeneous sonoporation mediated by single-pulse ultrasound and microbubbles

Sonoporation—transient plasma membrane perforation elicited by the interaction of ultrasound waves with microbubbles—has shown great potential for drug delivery and gene therapy. However, the heterogeneity of sonoporation introduces complexities and challenges in the realization of controllable and predictable drug delivery. The aim of this investigation was to understand how non-acoustic parameters (bubble related and bubble-cell interaction parameters) affect sonoporation. Using a customized ultrasound-exposure and fluorescence-imaging platform, we observed sonoporation dynamics at the single-cell level and quantified exogenous molecular uptake levels to characterize the degree of sonoporation. Sonovue microbubbles were introduced to passively regulate microbubble-to-cell distance and number, and bubble size. 1 MHz ultrasound with 10-cycle pulse duration and 0.6 MPa peak negative pressure were applied to trigger the inertial collapse of microbubbles. Our data revealed the impact of non-acoustic parameters on the heterogeneity of sonoporation. (i) The localized collapse of relatively small bubbles (diameter, D < 5.5 μm) led to predictable sonoporation, the degree of which depended on the bubble-to-cell distance (d). No sonoporation was observed when d/D > 1, whereas reversible sonoporation occurred when d/D < 1. (ii) Large bubbles (D > 5.5 μm) exhibited translational movement over large distances, resulting in unpredictable sonoporation. Translation towards the cell surface led to variable reversible sonoporation or irreversible sonoporation, and translation away from the cell caused either no or reversible sonoporation. (iii) The number of bubbles correlated positively with the degree of sonoporation when D < 5.5 μm and d/D < 1. Localized collapse of two to three bubbles mainly resulted in reversible sonoporation, whereas irreversible sonoporation was more likely following the collapse of four or more bubbles. These findings offer useful insight into the relationship between non-acoustic parameters and the degree of sonoporation.     

超声造影剂微泡非线性动力学响应的机理及相关应用

随着生命科学及现代医学的发展, 一体化无创精准诊疗已经日益成为人们关注的焦点问题, 而关于超声造影剂微泡的非线性效应的相关机理、动力学建模及其在超声医学领域中的应用研究也得到了极大的推动. 本文对下列课题进行了总结和讨论, 包括: 1)基于Mie散射技术和流式细胞仪对造影剂微泡参数进行定征的一体化解决方案; 2)通过对微泡包膜的黏弹特性进行非线性修正, 构建新的包膜微泡动力学模型; 3)探索造影剂惯性空化阈值与其包膜参数之间的相关性; 以及4)研究超声联合造影剂微泡促进基因/药物转染效率并有效降低其生物毒性的相关机理.     

Effects of extracellular matrix rigidity on sonoporation facilitated by targeted microbubbles: Bubble attachment,bubble dynamics,and cell membrane permeabilization

In this study, we investigated the effects of extracellular matrix rigidity, an important physical property of microenvironments regulating cell morphology and functions, on sonoporation facilitated by targeted microbubbles, highlighting the role of microbubbles. We conducted mechanistic studies at the cellular level on physiologically relevant soft and rigid substrates. By developing a unique imaging strategy, we first resolved details of the 3D attachment configurations between targeted microbubbles and cell membrane. High-speed video microscopy then unveiled bubble dynamics driven by a single ultrasound pulse. Finally, we evaluated the cell membrane permeabilization using a small molecule model drug. Our results demonstrate that: (1) stronger targeted microbubble attachment was formed for cells cultured on the rigid substrate, while six different attachment configurations were revealed in total; (2) more violent bubble oscillation was observed for cells cultured on the rigid substrate, while one third of bubbles attached to cells on the soft substrate exhibited deformation shortly after ultrasound was turned off; (3) higher acoustic pressure was needed to permeabilize the cell membrane for cells on the soft substrate, while under the same ultrasound condition, acoustically-activated microbubbles generated larger pores as compared to cells cultured on the soft substrate. The current findings provide new insights to understand the underlying mechanisms of sonoporation in a physiologically relevant context and may be useful for the clinical translation of sonoporation.     

Microstreaming velocity field and shear stress created by an oscillating encapsulated microbubble near a cell membrane

Sonoporation mediated by microbubbles is being extensively studied as a promising technology to facilitate gene/drug delivery to cells. However, the theoretical study regarding the mechanisms involved in sonoporation is still in its infancy. Microstreaming generated by pulsating microbubble near the cell membrane is regarded as one of the most important mechanisms in the sonoporation process. Here, based on an encapsulated microbubble dynamic model with considering nonlinear rheological effects of both shell elasticity and viscosity, the microstreaming velocity field and shear stress generated by an oscillating microbubble near the cell membrane are theoretically simulated. Some factors that might affect the behaviors of microstreaming are thoroughly investigated, including the distance between the bubble center and cell membrane (d), shell elasticity (χ), and shell viscosity (κ). The results show that (i) the presence of cell membrane can result in asymmetric microstreaming velocity field, while the constrained effect of the membrane wall decays with increasing the bubble-cell distance; (ii) the bubble resonance frequency increases with the increase in d and χ, and the decrease in κ, although it is more dominated by the variation of shell elasticity; and (iii) the maximal microstreaming shear stress on the cell membrane increases rapidly with reducing the d, χ, and κ. The results suggest that microbubbles with softer and less viscous shell materials might be preferred to achieve more efficient sonoporation outcomes, and it is better to have bubbles located in the immediate vicinity of the cell membrane.     

New insights on the role of ROS in the mechanisms of sonoporation-mediated gene delivery

Reactive oxygen species (ROS) are hypothesized to play a role in the sonoporation mechanisms. Nevertheless, the acoustical phenomenon behind the ROS production as well as the exact mechanisms of ROS action involved in the increased cell membrane permeability are still not fully understood. Therefore, we investigated the key processes occurring at the molecular level in and around microbubbles subjected to ultrasound using computational chemistry methods. To confirm the molecular simulation predictions, we measured the ROS production by exposing SonoVue® microbubbles (MBs) to ultrasound using biological assays. To investigate the role of ROS in cell membrane permeabilization, cells were subjected to ultrasound in presence of MBs and plasmid encoding reporter gene, and the transfection level was assessed using flow cytometry. The molecular simulations showed that under sonoporation conditions, ROS can form inside the MBs. These radicals could easily diffuse through the MB shell toward the surrounding aqueous phase and participate in the permeabilization of nearby cell membranes. Experimental data confirmed that MBs favor spontaneous formation of a host of free radicals where HO was the main ROS species after US exposure. The presence of ROS scavengers/inhibitors during the sonoporation process decreased both the production of ROS and the subsequent transfection level without significant loss of cell viability. In conclusion, the exposure of MBs to ultrasound might be the origin of chemical effects, which play a role in the cell membrane permeabilization and in the in vitro gene delivery when generated in its proximity.     

超声联合微泡增强细胞内药物递送的研究进展*

超声联合微泡介导的细胞内药物递送是通过微泡的声空化与细胞的相互作用而实现的。作为一种非侵入式的、非病毒的、具有靶向性的、可在成像技术引导下的药物递送技术,超声联合微泡在临床应用上具有独特的优势。该文围绕超声联合微泡实现药物递送的发生机理,从微泡的声学动态响应、细胞响应、细胞外物质进入细胞的动态过程及临床试验进展4方面对超声联合微泡增强细胞内药物递送技术近年来的发展进行综述,并就机理性研究未来的发展提出了建议和思考。     

Barrier-breaking effects of ultrasonic cavitation for drug delivery and biomarker release

Recently, emerging evidence has demonstrated that cavitation actually creates important bidirectional channels on biological barriers for both intratumoral drug delivery and extratumoral biomarker release. To promote the barrier-breaking effects of cavitation for both therapy and diagnosis, we first reviewed recent technical advances of ultrasound and its contrast agents (microbubbles, nanodroplets, and gas-stabilizing nanoparticles) and then reported the newly-revealed cavitation physical details. In particular, we summarized five types of cellular responses of cavitation in breaking the plasma membrane (membrane retraction, sonoporation, endocytosis/exocytosis, blebbing and apoptosis) and compared the vascular cavitation effects of three different types of ultrasound contrast agents in breaking the blood-tumor barrier and tumor microenvironment. Moreover, we highlighted the current achievements of the barrier-breaking effects of cavitation in mediating drug delivery and biomarker release. We emphasized that the precise induction of a specific cavitation effect for barrier-breaking was still challenged by the complex combination of multiple acoustic and non-acoustic cavitation parameters. Therefore, we provided the cutting-edge in-situ cavitation imaging and feedback control methods and suggested the development of an international cavitation quantification standard for the clinical guidance of cavitation-mediated barrier-breaking effects.     

Monitoring the effect of sonoporation on the cells using electrochemical approach

Sonoporation is applied to enhance the permeability of the cell to bioactive materials by employing the acoustic cavitation of microbubbles. This phenomena would be helpful in molecular biology, delivery of large molecules into the cells and gene therapy. Many methods have been applied to monitor the biological effects and trace of sonoporation on the cells such as scanning/transmission electron microscopy, confocal imaging and flow cytometry. Here, we monitored the effect of sonoporation on the cells using electrochemical method with an integrated three electrode system. Electrochemical responses of stimulated cells, compared to flow cytometry and electron microscopy results, presented different patterns of sonoporation in the cells detectable by cyclic voltammetry. In addition, confocal microscopy from actin stress fibers and young’s modulus measured by AFM revealed the correlation of cell mechanics and amount of induced sonopores in the cells. This method could be applied as a new trend in cellular mechanochemical studies.     

Radionuclide tumour therapy with ultrasound contrast microbubbles

Radionuclides have shown to be effective in tumour therapy. However, the side effects determine the maximum deliverable dose. Recently, it has been demonstrated that cells can be permeabilised through sonoporation using ultrasound and contrast microbubbles. The use of sonoporation in treatment of tumours may increase the anti-tumour efficacy of radionuclide treatment. The mechanisms as well as the effects sonoporation in tumour treatment strategies are still not understood. The purpose of this study is to determine the effects of ultrasound and contrast microbubbles on the internalisation of the radionuclide (111)In-DOTA-Tyr(3)-octreotate in tumour cells. To optimize ultrasound settings for ultrasound adjunctive tumour therapy we incubated rat pancreatic CA20948 tumour cells with two dyes (MW 40 and 70 kDa). The uptake levels were compared with cells treated with ultrasound and contrast microbubbles for different ultrasound settings. The highest molecular uptake was found with addition of contrast microbubbles (ratio of 10 bubbles to 1 cell) and with the ultrasound setting: duty cycle 0.013%, mechanical index (MI) 0.42, and treatment times of 30 and 60 min. These settings were used to enhance the internalisation of (111)In-DOTA-Tyr(3)-octreotate. We found a 160% higher internalisation of (111)In-DOTA-Tyr(3)-octreotate by tumour cells adjunctively treated with ultrasound and contrast microbubbles compared to untreated cells. These results show that adjunctive tumour treatment with the radionuclide (111)In-DOTA-Tyr(3)-octreotate and ultrasound contrast microbubbles may be feasible. When using adjunctive ultrasound contrast microbubble treatment, a lower radionuclide doses are required to reach the same anti-tumour effect.     

微气泡激发的声微流对细胞声孔效应的影响

理论及实验研究了微气泡激发的声微流对声孔效应的影响。实验采用低幅度(0.05~0.3MIPa)连续超声波信号照射MCF-7细胞,PEI:DNA的复合质粒和造影剂气泡的混合溶液,通过扫描电子显微镜测量细胞膜声孔效应。结果表明声孔大小随着激励声压的幅度和照射时间的增加而增大,平均孔径范围为100 nm~1.25μm。基于Marmottant微气泡振动模型的理论计算结果表明微气泡振动所产生的声微流引起的剪切力在低幅度超声引发声致穿孔作用中起着关键作用。      

Preparation and in vitro evaluation of an ultrasound-triggered drug delivery system: 10-hydroxycamptothecin loaded PLA microbubbles

10-Hydroxycamptothecin (HCPT) loaded PLA microbubbles, used as an ultrasound-triggered drug delivery system, were fabricated by a double emulsion-solvent evaporation method. The obtained microbubbles were characterized by scanning electron microscope (SEM), transmission electron microscope (TEM), X-ray diffraction (XRD), differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and confocal laser scanning microscope (CLSM). In addition, the effect of diagnostic ultrasound exposure on BEL-7402 cells combined with HCPT-loaded PLA microbubbles was evaluated using cytotoxicity assay, CLSM and flow cytometry (FCM). It was found that the HCPT-loaded PLA microbubbles showed smooth surface and spherical shape, and the drug was amorphously dispersed within the shell and the drug loading content reached up to 1.69%. Nearly 20% of HCPT was released upon exposure to diagnostic ultrasound at frequency of 3.5 MHz for 10 min. Moreover, HCPT fluorescence in the cells treated only with the HCPT-loaded PLA microbubbles was discernible, but less intense, while those treated with the microbubbles in conjunction with ultrasound exposure was evident and intense, indicating an increased cellular uptake of HCPT by ultrasound exposure. Cytotoxicity test on BEL-7402 cells indicated that the HCPT-loaded PLA microbubbles combined with ultrasound exposure were more cytotoxic than the microbubbles alone. The results suggest that the combination of drug loaded PLA microbubbles and diagnostic ultrasound exposure exhibit an effective intracellular drug uptake by tumor cells, indicating their great potential for antitumor therapy.     

Cavitation microstreaming and stress fields created by microbubbles

Cavitation microstreaming plays a role in the therapeutic action of microbubbles driven by ultrasound, such as the sonoporative and sonothrombolytic phenomena. Microscopic particle-image velocimetry experiments are presented. Results show that many different microstreaming patterns are possible around a microbubble when it is on a surface, albeit for microbubbles much larger than used in clinical practice. Each pattern is associated with a particular oscillation mode of the bubble, and changing between patterns is achieved by changing the sound frequency. Each microstreaming pattern also generates different shear stress and stretch/compression distributions in the vicinity of a bubble on a wall. Analysis of the micro-PIV results also shows that ultrasound-driven microstreaming flows around bubbles are feasible mechanisms for mixing therapeutic agents into the surrounding blood, as well as assisting sonoporative delivery of molecules across cell membranes. Patterns show significant variations around the bubble, suggesting sonoporation may be either enhanced or inhibited in different zones across a cellular surface. Thus, alternating the patterns may result in improved sonoporation and sonothrombolysis. The clear and reproducible delineation of microstreaming patterns based on driving frequency makes frequency-based pattern alternation a feasible alternative to the clinically less desirable practice of increasing sound pressure for equivalent sonoporative or sonothrombolytic effect. Surface divergence is proposed as a measure relevant to sonoporation.     

Synergistic effects of negative-charged nanoparticles assisted by ultrasound on the reversal multidrug resistance phenotype in breast cancer cells

We have fabricated a negative-charged nanoparticle (Heparin-Folate-Tat-Taxol NP, H-F-Tat-T NP) with dual ligands, tumor targeting ligand folate and cell-penetrating peptide Tat, to deliver taxol presenting great anticancer activity for sensitive cancer cells, while it fails to overcome multidrug resistance (MDR) in MCF-7/T cells (taxol-resistant breast cancer cells). Ultrasound (US) can increase the sensitivity of positive-charged NPs thereby making it possible to reverse MDR through inducing NPs’ drug release. However, compared with the negative-charged NPs, positive-charged NPs may cause higher toxic effect. Hence, the combination of negative-charged NPs and US may be an efficient strategy for overcoming MDR. The conventional procedure to treat with NPs followed by US exposure possibly destruct multifunctional NPs resulting in its bioactivity inhibition. Herein, we have further improved the operating approach to eliminate US mechanical damage and keep the integrity of negative-charged NPs: cells are exposed to US with microbubbles (MBs) prior to the treatment of H-F-Tat-T NPs. Superior to the conventional method, US sonoporation affects the physiological property of cancer cells while preventing direct promotion of drug release from NPs. The results of the present study displayed that US in condition (1 MHz, 10% duty cycle, duration of 80 s, US intensity of 0.6 W/cm² and volume ratio of medium to MBs 20:1) combined with H-F-T-Tat-T NPs can achieve optimal reversal MDR effect in MCF-7/T cells. Mechanism study further disclosed that the individual effect of US was responsible for the enhancement of cell membrane permeability, inhibition of cell proliferation rate and down-regulation of MDR-related genes and proteins. Simultaneously, US sonoporation on resistant cancer cells indirectly increased the accumulation of NPs by inducing endosomal escape of negative-charged NPs. Taken together, the overcoming MDR ability for the combined strategy was achieved by the synergistic effect from individual function of NPs, physiological changes of resistant cancer cells and behavior changes of NPs caused by US.     

Ultrasound-assisted fabrication of acoustically active,erythrocyte membrane “bubbles”

In this communication, we report an ultrasound-assisted method, utilising human red blood cell (RBC) or erythrocyte membranes, to produce acoustically active “bubbles”, intended for vasculature imaging. The resulting RBC membrane bubbles have an average size of 1.5 μm with a generally spherical morphology, altered internal aqueous compartment contents, and small gas-containing protrusions or “pockets” in between the membrane bilayer. We also found that this method produced some nanobubbles (200–400 nm diameter), due to the shedding of lipid components from the RBC membranes to compensate for the membrane structural changes. In vitro ultrasound imaging showed that RBC membrane bubbles had comparable ultrasound contrast enhancement as the standard DEFINTY^TM microbubble preparation (~13% v/v) and lower concentrations of this standard contrast agent. This current technology demonstrate a new and important application of ultrasound and of RBC membranes, having inherent biocompatibility, as potential material for the development of new types of ultrasound imaging agents, without the use of additional lipid components and pre-made microbubbles.     

Fluorescent microscope system to monitor real-time interactions between focused ultrasound,echogenic drug delivery vehicles,and live cell membranes

Rapid development in the field of ultrasound triggered drug delivery has made it essential to study the real-time interaction between the membranes of live cells and the membranes of echogenic delivery vehicles under exposure to focused ultrasound. The objective of this work was to design an analysis system that combined fluorescent imagining, high speed videography, and definable pulse sequences of focused ultrasound to allow for real time observations of both cell and vehicle membranes. Documenting the behavior of the membranes themselves has not previously been possible due to limitations with existing optical systems used to understand the basic physics of microbubble/ultrasound interaction and the basic interaction between microbubbles and cells. The performance of this new system to monitor membrane behavior was demonstrated by documenting the modes of vehicle fragmentation at different ultrasound intensity levels. At 1.5 MPa the membranes were shown to completely fragment while at intensities below 1 MPa the membranes pop open and slowly unfold. The interaction between these vehicles and cell membranes was also documented by the removal of fluorescent particles from the surfaces of live cells out to 20 μm from the microbubble location. The fluid flow created by microstreaming around ensonated microbubbles was documented at video recording speeds from 60 to 18,000 frames per second. This information about membrane behavior allows the chemical and physical properties of the drug delivery vehicle to be designed along with the ultrasound pulse sequence to cause the most efficient drug delivery.     

Sonoporation-mediated transduction of siRNA ameliorated experimental arthritis using 3 MHz pulsed ultrasound

The goal of this feasibility study was to examine whether sonoporation assisted transduction of siRNA could be used to ameliorate arthritis locally. If successful, such approach could provide an alternative treatment for the patients that have or gradually develop adverse response to chemical drugs. Tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-α) produced by synovial fibroblasts has an important role in the pathology of rheumatoid arthritis, inducing inflammation and bone destruction. In this study, we injected a mixture of microbubbles and siRNA targeting TNF-α (siTNF) into the articular joints of rats, and transduced siTNF into synovial tissue by exposure to a collimated ultrasound beam, applied through a probe 6 mm in diameter with an input frequency of 3.0 MHz, an output intensity of 2.0 W/cm² (spatial average temporary peak; SATP), a pulse duty ratio of 50%, and a duration of 1 min. Sonoporation increased skin temperature from 26.8 °C to 27.3 °C, but there were no adverse effect such as burns. The mean level of TNF-α expression in siTNF-treated knee joints was 55% of those in controls. Delivery of siTNF into the knee joints every 3 days (i.e., 7, 10, 13, and 16 days after immunization) by in vivo sonoporation significantly reduced paw swelling on days 20–23 after immunization. Radiographic scores in the siTNF group were 56% of those in the CIA group and 61% of those in the siNeg group. Histological examination showed that the number of TNF-α positive cells was significantly lower in areas of pannus invasion into the ankle joints of siTNF- than of siNeg-treated rats. These results indicate that transduction of siTNF into articular synovium using sonoporation may be an effective local therapy for arthritis.     

Investigation of chaos synchronization in photonic crystal lasers

Chaotic dynamics and chaos synchronization in photonic crystal (PC) lasers with optical feedback are investigated numerically. The effect of various system parameters such as amplitude reflectivity of the external mirror “r”, external cavity length “L_e”, and injection current “I” on system dynamics is addressed in detail. Simulation results are presented using MATLAB to address system behavior. The parameters r, L_e, and I are varied over the ranges (0.05–0.25), (2.8–3.2 mm), and (1.1I_th–2I_th), respectively. The results indicate that very small parameter mismatches between the transmitter laser and receiver laser affect strongly complete chaos synchronization between them.     

Phospholipid-stabilized microbubbles: Influence of shell chemistry on cavitation threshold and binding to giant uni-lamellar vesicles

We demonstrate the feasibility of covalently linking a single microbubble to a single, giant uni-lamellar vesicle (GUV). Such a combination of GUV plus microbubble might prove useful as a new drug delivery vehicle involving microbubble cavitation-induced sonoporation of the vesicle bilayer as a release mechanism. We therefore applied the well known methodology of passive cavitation detection to measure the influence of lipid shell chemistry on inertial cavitation thresholds for externally added microbubbles. We find that cavitation threshold changes significantly with changes in either molecular weight or mole fraction of poly(ethylene glycol), historically used to impede gas dissolution and microbubble coalescence. We attribute changes in cavitation threshold to changes in microbubble resonance frequency resulting from changes in microbubble shell bending elasticity. To further demonstrate the influence of shell chemistry on microbubble behavior, we describe how several common bubble phenomena - and some new - respond to changes in lipid chain length.     

Synergistic inhibition of malignant melanoma proliferation by melphalan combined with ultrasound and microbubbles

The cavitational effects of ultrasound (US) exposure induce transient pores on the cell membrane (sonoporation). Sonoporation have been applied in the field of cancer therapy by promoting delivery of extracellular molecules such as drugs and genes into cytoplasm. In addition, it is known that using US together with microbubbles (MB) elevates permeability of these agents. In this study, by applying the US-MB strategy for melanoma chemotherapy, we evaluated the antitumor effect of melphalan combined with US-MB on a melanoma cell line (C32) in vitro and in vivo. The in vitro cytotoxic effect of the melphalan with US-MB was greater than that of melphalan alone or melphalan in combination with US. In vivo experiments using xenografts, intratumoral injection of melphalan and MB with US exposure led to a greater degree of tumor regression than did the intratumoral injection of the melphalan alone or melphalan in combination with US. These results suggest that US-MB promotes the antitumor effect of melphalan by increasing delivery of molecules into cells and that this strategy may become an effective method of adjuvant therapy against malignant melanoma.     

Development of a theoretical model describing sonoporation activity of cells exposed to ultrasound in the presence of contrast agents

Sonoporation uses ultrasound, with the aid of ultrasound contrast agents (UCAs), to enhance cell permeabilization, thereby allowing delivery of therapeutic compounds noninvasively into specific target cells. The objective of this study was to determine if a computational model describing shear stress on a cell membrane due to microstreaming would successfully reflect sonoporation activity with respect to the peak rarefactional pressure. The theoretical models were compared to the sonoporation results from Chinese hamster ovary cells using Definity(?) at 0.9, 3.15, and 5.6 MHz and were found to accurately describe the maximum sonoporation activity, the pressure where a decrease in sonoporation activity occurs, and relative differences between maximum activity and the activity after that decrease. Therefore, the model supports the experimental findings that shear stress on cell membranes secondary to oscillating UCAs results in sonoporation.