The dynamic range of protein expression: a challenge for proteomic research

Proteomic research, for its part, is benefiting enormously from the last decade of genomic research as we now have archived, annotated and audited sequence databases to correlate and query experimental data. While the two-dimensional electrophoresis (2-DE) gels are still a central part of proteomics, we reflect on the possibilities and realities of the current 2-DE technology with regard to displaying and analysing proteomes. Limitations of analysing whole cell/tissue lysates by 2-DE alone are discussed, and we investigate whether extremely narrow p/ranges (1 pH unit/25 cm) provide a solution to display comprehensive protein expression profiles. We are confronted with a challenging task: the dynamic range of protein expression. We believe that most of the existing technology is capable of displaying many more proteins than is currently achievable by integrating existing and new techniques to prefractionate samples prior to 2-DE display or analysis. The availability of a "proteomics toolbox", consisting of defined reagents, methods, and equipment, would assist a comprehensive analysis of defined biological systems.     

Proteomics. Concepts and perspectives

Within the last five years the field of proteomics has changed the understanding of molecular biology. Proteins manifest physiological as well as pathophysiological processes in a cell or an organism, and proteomics describes the complete protein inventory in dependence on in vivo parameters. Disease mechanism or drug effects both affect a protein profile and, vice versa, characterising protein profiles reveals information for the understanding of disease and therapy. Analytical methods for proteomics are based on conventional tools for protein characterisation. The technical challenge is the complete coverage of physico-chemical properties for thousands of proteins. Nucleic acids display a relative chemical homogeneity and therefore genomics was considered more promising in the past than proteomics. Further improvements in proteomics technologies will likely change this course with proteomics complementing genomics as a tool to study life sciences.     

2-DE proteomic analysis of the model cyanobacterium Anabaena variabilis

Cyanobacteria are photosynthetic bacteria capable of producing hydrogen and secondary metabolites with potential pharmaceutical applications. A limited number of cyanobacterial 2-DE proteomic studies have been published, most of which are based on Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803. Here, we report the use of 2-DE, ESI-MS/MS and protein bioinformatics tools to characterize the proteome of Anabaena variabilis ATCC 29413, a heterocystous nitrogen-fixing cyanobacterium that is a model organism for the study of nitrogen fixation. Using a 2-DE workflow that included the use of a detergent-based extraction buffer and 3-10 nonlinear IPG strips resulted in the identification of 254 unique proteins, with significantly better coverage of basic and low-abundance proteins that has been reported in 2-DE analyses of Synechocystis sp. A set of protein bioinformatics tools was employed to provide estimates of protein localization, hydrophobicity, abundance and other properties. The characteristics of the A. variabilis proteins identified in this study were compared against the theoretical proteome for this organism, and more generally within the cyanobacteria, to identify opportunities for further development of 2-DE-based cyanobacterial proteomics.     

An optimized procedure for solubilization, reduction, and transfer of human breast cancer membrane-enriched fraction by 2-DE

The separation of integral and peripheral membrane proteins is still a challenge, although many achievements have been made in the 2-DE-based membrane proteomics. Using a human breast cancer cell line, MCF-7, we investigated the influences of Tris, reducing reagents, cup loading, and SDS on membrane protein solubilization and separation by 2-DE. The addition of Tris to the sample solution improved the solubilization of the membrane-enriched fraction, and the best-quality gel patterns were obtained at 20 mM Tris. Tributylphosphine (TBP), a reducing agent, was not optimum in the 2-DE process because it not only decreased the solubilization of hydrophobic proteins but also caused some proteins, such as hsp60, prohibitin, and actin, to be resolved to a string of spots. However, when combined with DTT, TBP could improve the resolution of 2-DE patterns. Cup loading significantly facilitated the entrance of membrane proteins into IPG strips and over 1000 protein spots with high resolution were visualized. Adopting this strategy, an ATP synthase alpha chain was resolved into two adjacent spots for the first time in 2-DE gel patterns through the adding DTT in the middle of the IEF. A high SDS concentration in the equilibration buffer enhanced the transfer and increased the staining intensity of 50% of the protein spots in the gels, but also resulted in losses of some spots.     

Dialysis-assisted two-dimensional gel electrophoresis

2-DE is an important tool in proteomics research. However, intrinsic gel-to-gel variability of 2-DE often masks the biological differences between the samples and compromises quantitative comparison of protein expression levels. Here, we describe a modification of 2-DE that results in improved matching and quantification of proteins. This was accomplished by performing IEF of two samples in two IPG strips separated by a dialysis membrane. After IEF running, the strips were separated and the SDS-PAGE dimension was accomplished on two individual gels. After gel staining with CBB, ImageMaster 2D Platinum software (Amersham) was used for spot detection and quantification. Analysis of protein extracts from C2C12 myoblasts by this method resulted in 99% spot-matching efficiency and CV in stain intensity (% volume) was less than 0.5 for 98% of spots. We conclude that this technique, called dialysis-assisted gel electrophoresis, gives superior spot matching and quantitative reproducibility compared to IEF conducted on separate strips.     

Solubilization of cellular membrane proteins from Streptococcus mutans for two-dimensional gel electrophoresis

Membrane proteins are rarely identified in two-dimensional electrophoretic (2-DE) proteomics maps. This is due to low abundancy, poor solubility, and inherent hydrophobicity leading to self-aggregation during the first dimension. In this study, membrane proteins from the Gram-positive bacterium Streptococcus mutans were solubilized using three different methods and evaluated by 2-DE. In the first method, the extraction was performed using sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) followed by solubilization with a chaotropic buffer and precipitation with methanol/chloroform. The second method was based on temperature-dependent phase partitioning using Triton X-114 followed by purification using the ReadyPrep 2-D clean-up kit from Bio-Rad. The third method involved extraction using the organic solvents trifluoroethanol (TFE) and chloroform, which produced three separate phases. The upper aqueous phase, enriched with TFE, gave the highest overall protein yield and best 2-DE resolution. Protein spot identification by nanoelectrospray quadrupole time of flight (QTOF)-tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) revealed known membrane and surface-associated proteins. This is the first report describing the successful solubilization and 2-D electrophoresis of membrane proteins from a Gram-positive bacterium.     

Large-gel two-dimensional electrophoresis-matrix assisted laser desorption/ionization-time of flight-mass spectrometry: an analytical challenge for studying complex protein mixtures

The large-gel two-dimensional electrophoresis (2-DE) technique, developed by Klose and co-workers over the past 25 years, provides the resolving power necessary to separate crude proteome extracts of higher eukaryotes. Matrix assisted laser desorption/ionization-time of flight-mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF-MS) provides the sample throughput necessary to identify thousands of different protein species in an adequate time period. Spot excision, in situ proteolysis, and extraction of the cleavage products from the gel matrix, peptide purification and concentration as well as the mass spectrometric sample preparation are the crucial steps that interface the two analytical techniques. Today, these routines and not the mass spectrometric instrumentation determine how many protein digests can be analyzed per day per instrument. The present paper focuses on this analytical interface and reports on an integrated protocol and technology developed in our laboratory. Automated identification of proteins in sequence databases by mass spectrometric peptide mapping requires a powerful search engine that makes full use of the information contained in the experimental data, and scores the search results accordingly. This challenge is heading a second part of the paper.     

Application of thiophilic chromatography to deplete serum immunoglobulins in sample preparation for bidimensional electrophoresis

Serum is a typical sample for non-invasive studies in clinical research. Its proteome characterization is challenging, since requires extensive protein depletion. Methods used nowadays for removal of high-abundance proteins are expensive or show quite often a low loading capacity, which has strong repercussions on the number of samples and replicates per analysis.In order to deplete immunoglobulins (Igs) and albumin (HSA) from 1 mL serum samples, we have developed a protocol based on a combination of thiophilic chromatography, not previously used in clinical proteomics, and a HSA-specific resin. Ig/HSA-depleted samples, immunoglobulinome and albuminone were analyzed by 2-DE. Thiophilic chromatography, coupled with HSA-depletion, allows a good 2-DE resolution as well as the visualization of new spots. Moreover, it yields enough protein to evaluate technical variability and facilitate subsequent protein identification. To validate the protocol, we carried out a preliminary comparative study between triplicate Igs/HSA-depleted serum samples from healthy control individuals and recently diagnosed/untreated rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patients. RA patients showed several acute phase proteins, as well as additional serum proteins, differentially and significantly regulated.Therefore, thiophilic chromatography can be used as an efficient and economical method in 2-DE to deplete immunoglobulins from large human serum samples before a more extensive fractioning.     

Combining capillary electrophoresis with mass spectrometry for applications in proteomics

Mass spectrometry (MS)-based proteomics is currently dominated by the analysis of peptides originating either from digestion of proteins separated by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis (2-DE) or from global digestion; the simple peptide mixtures obtained from digestion of gel-separated proteins do not usually require further separation, while the complex peptide mixtures obtained by global digestion are most frequently separated by chromatographic techniques. Capillary electrophoresis (CE) provides alternatives to 2-DE for protein separation and alternatives to chromatography for peptide separation. This review attempts to elucidate how the most promising CE modes, capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE) and capillary isoelectric focusing (CIEF), might best be applied to MS-based proteomics. CE-MS interfacing, mass analyzer performance, column coating to minimize analyte adsorption, and sample stacking for CZE are considered prior to examining numerous applications. Finally, multidimensional systems that incorporate CE techniques are examined; CZE often finds use as a fast, final dimension before ionization for MS, while CIEF, being an equilibrium technique, is well-suited to being the first dimension in automated fractionation systems.     

The human heart proteome: Two-dimensional maps using narrow-range immobilised pH gradients

The analysis of complex proteomes is undertaken using a variety of techniques and technologies such as 2-DE, surface-enhanced laser desorption ionisation, and various types of MS. In order to overcome the complexities of protein expression in discrete proteomes, sample fractionation has become an important aspect of proteomic experiments. The use of narrow-range IPGs (nrIPGs) is of special importance using the 2-DE proteomics workflow, since an enhanced visualisation of a given proteome is achieved through an improved physical separation and resolution of proteins. The work described in this paper presents a series of protein maps of the human heart left ventricle proteome that have been generated using nrIPGs for the first, IEF, dimension of 2-DE. A total of 374 gel spots were excised from seven different pH gradients, covering the range pH 3-10, giving rise to a total of 388 identifications from 110 unique proteins. Using Gene Ontologies (GOs), the identified proteins were found to be associated with 97 types of GO Process, 144 types of GO Function, and 54 types of GO Component. It is hoped that the maps presented in this paper will be of use to other researchers for reference purposes.     

Using size exclusion chromatography-RPLC and RPLC-CIEF as two-dimensional separation strategies for protein profiling

Bottom-up proteomics (analyzing peptides that result from protein digestion) has demonstrated capability for broad proteome coverage and good throughput. However, due to incomplete sequence coverage, this approach is not ideally suited to the study of modified proteins. The modification complement of a protein can best be elucidated by analyzing the intact protein. 2-DE, typically coupled with the analysis of peptides that result from in-gel digestion, is the most frequently applied protein separation technique in MS-based proteomics. As an alternative, numerous column-based liquid phase techniques, which are generally more amenable to automation, are being investigated. In this work, the combination of size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) fractionation with RPLC-Fourier-transform ion cyclotron resonance (FTICR)-MS is compared with the combination of RPLC fractionation with CIEF-FTICR-MS for the analysis of the Shewanella oneidensis proteome. SEC-RPLC-FTICR-MS allowed the detection of 297 proteins, as opposed to 166 using RPLC-CIEF-FTICR-MS, indicating that approaches based on LC-MS provide better coverage. However, there were significant differences in the sets of proteins detected and both approaches provide a basis for accurately quantifying changes in protein and modified protein abundances.     

Microchip-Based Nano Chromatography and Nano Capillary Electrophoresis in Genomics and Proteomics

The growing interest in proteomics and genomics needs analytical techniques capable of detecting proteins and nucleic acids at the ng L^?1 levels due to the small amounts of various proteins and nucleic acids in living cells. During the last decade remarkable development has occurred in the evolution of chromatographic and capillary electrophotetic methods on microchips. These methods are called nano liquid chromatography (NLC) and nano capillary electrophoresis (NCE). The present review article describes the application of NLC and NCE to proteomics and genomics research The analyses of proteins and nucleic acids at low levels is described together with the optimization and future trends of nano methods in genomics and proteomics.     

Down-regulation of Vinculin in Human Colorectal Carcinoma Identified by Proteomics Analysis

In the present study, we aimed to globally profile the proteins involved in colorectal carcinoma(CRC), in order to find clues to the pathological process of CRC. Pairs of malignant tissues and their adjacent healthy tissues from patients with colorectal cancer were subject to differential proteomics analysis. Two dimensional electrophoresis coupled with mass spectrometry(2-DE/MS) was used to identify differentially expressed proteins between pairs of tissue samples. A list of proteins relevant to the progression of colorectal tumor was identified by two dimensional gel electrophoresis(2-DE)-based proteomics approach. Among the identified proteins, vinculin was found to be remarkably down-regulated in colorectal carcinoma tissues. In addition, three phosphorylation modifications within the isolated vinculin were identified by in-depth liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry(LC-MS/MS) analysis. Our results provide a basis for further understanding the pathological significance of vinculin in the regulation of carcinogenesis, invasion and metastasis of colorectal tumors.     

Two-dimensional electrophoresis of liver proteins: characterization of a drug-induced hepatomegaly in rats

Two-dimensional electrophoresis (2-DE) of liver proteins was applied to further characterize an unusual drug-induced increase in hepatocellular rough endoplasmic reticulum (RER) in Sprague-Dawley rats given a substituted pyrimidine derivative. Absolute liver weights of drug-treated rats (9.9 +/- 0.4 g) increased above vehicle-treated controls (7.2 +/- 0.2 g) by 37%. Light microscopy revealed diffuse granular basophilia of the hepatocellular cytoplasm, uncharacteristic of hepatocytes and suggested cells rich in ribosomes, which was confirmed by electron microscopy. Immunostaining for cell proliferation, viz., 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine (BrdU) and proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA), indicated marked hepatocellular proliferative activity. 2-DE of solubilized liver using an ISO-DALT gel system indicated significant (p<0.001) quantitative changes in at least 17 liver proteins (12 increased, 5 decreased) compared to controls. The protein with the largest increase was homologous to acute-phase reactant, contrapsin-like protein inhibitor-6. Other markedly upregulated proteins were methionine adenosyltransferase, a catalyst in methionine/ATP metabolism and mitochondrial HMG-CoA synthase, involved in cholesterol synthesis. The complementary strategies of 2-DE coupled either with database spot mapping or protein isolation and amino acid sequencing successfully identified a subset of proteins from xenobiotic-damaged rodent livers, the expression of which differed from controls. However, the current bioinformatics platform for rodent hepatic proteins and limited knowledge of specific protein functionality restricted application of this proteomics profile to further define a mechanistic basis for this unusual hepatotoxicity.     

Protein extraction for two-dimensional electrophoresis from olive leaf,a plant tissue containing high levels of interfering compounds

The purpose of this research is to establish a routine procedure for the application of proteomic analysis to olive tree. Olive leaf tissue is notoriously recalcitrant to common protein extraction methods due to high levels of interfering compounds. We developed a protocol for isolating proteins suitable for two-dimensional electrophoresis (2-DE) from olive leaf. The remarkable characteristics of the protocol include: (i) additional grinding dry acetone powder of leaf tissue to a finer extent, (ii) after extensive organic solvent washes to remove pigments, lipids etc., using aqueous tricholoroacetic acid washes to remove water-soluble contaminants, and (iii) phenol extraction of proteins in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate. The final protein preparation is free of interfering compounds based on its well-resolved 2-DE patterns. The protocol can be completed within 3 h, and protein yield is approximately 2.49 mg.g(-1) of aged leaf. We also evaluated the protocol by immunoblotting with anti-tyrosinate alpha-tubulin antibody. To our knowledge, this is the first time that a protocol for protein extraction from olive leaf appears to give satisfactory and reproducible results. The protocol is expected to be applicable to other recalcitrant plant tissues and could be of interest to laboratories involved in plant proteomics.     

A hydroponic rice seedling culture model system for investigating proteome of salt stress in rice leaf

By using an in vivo hydroponic rice seedling culture system, we investigated the physiological and biochemical responses of a model rice japonica cultivar Nipponbare to salt stress using proteomics and classical biochemical methods. Yoshida's nutrient solution (YS) was used to grow rice seedlings. YS-grown 18-day-old seedlings manifested highly stable and reproducible symptoms, prominently the wilting and browning of the 3rd leaf, reduced photosynthetic activity, inhibition in overall seedling growth, and failure to develop new (5th) leaf, when subjected to salt stress by transferring them to YS containing 130 mM NaCl for 4 days. As leaf response to salt stress is least investigated in rice by proteomics, we used the 3rd leaf as source material. A comparison of 2-DE protein profiles between the untreated control and salt-stressed 3rd leaves revealed 55 differentially expressed CBB-stained spots, where 47 spots were increased over the control. Of these changed spots, the identity of 33 protein spots (27 increased and 5 decreased) was determined by nESI-LC-MS/MS. Most of these identified proteins belonged to major metabolic processes like photosynthetic carbon dioxide assimilation and photorespiration, suggesting a good correlation between salt stress-responsive proteins and leaf morphology. Moreover, 2-DE immunoblot and enzymatic activity analyses of 3rd leaves revealed remarkable changes in the key marker enzymes associated with oxidative damage to salt stress: ascorbate peroxidase and lipid peroxidation were induced, and catalase was suppressed. These results demonstrate that hydroponic culture system is best suited for proteomics of salt stress in rice seedling.     

Two-dimensional gel electrophoresis maps of the proteome and phosphoproteome of primitively cultured rat mesangial cells

Mesangial cells (MC) play an important role in maintaining the structure and function of the glomerulus. The proliferation of MC is a prominent feature of many kinds of glomerular disease. The first reference 2-DE maps of rat mesangial cells (RMC), stained with silver staining or Pro-Q Diamond dye, have been established here to describe the proteome and phosphoproteome of RMC, respectively. A total of 157 selected protein spots, corresponding to 118 unique proteins, have been identified by MALDI-TOF-MS or LC-ESI-IT-MS/MS, in which 37 protein spots representing 28 unique proteins have also been stained with Pro-Q Diamond, indicating that they are in phosphorylated forms. All the identified proteins were bioinformatically annotated in detail according to their physiochemical characteristics, subcellular location, and function. Most of the separated or identified protein spots are distributed in the area of mass 10-70 kDa and pI 5.0-8.0. The identified proteins include mainly cytoplasmic and nuclear proteins and some mitochondrial, endoplasmic reticulum, and membrane proteins. These proteins are classified into different functional groups such as structure and mobility proteins (21.2%), metabolic enzymes (16.9%), protein folding and metabolism proteins (13.6%), signaling proteins (14.4%), heat-shock proteins (7.6%), and other functional proteins (12.7%). While structure and mobility proteins are mostly represented by protein spots with high abundance, signaling proteins are mostly represented by protein spots with relatively low abundance. Such a 2-DE database for RMC, especially with many signaling proteins and phosphoproteins characterized, will provide a valuable resource for comparative proteomics analysis of normal and pathologic conditions affecting MC function or pathologic progress.     

A comprehensive two-dimensional map of cytosolic proteins of Bacillus subtilis

Proteomics relying on two-dimensional (2-D) gel electrophoresis of proteins followed by spot identification with mass spectrometry is an excellent experimental tool for physiological studies opening a new perspective for understanding overall cell physiology. This is the intriguing outcome of a method introduced by Klose and O'Farrell independently 25 years ago. Physiological proteomics requires a 2-D reference map on which most of the main proteins were identified. In this paper, we present such a reference map with more than 300 entries for Bacillus subtilis proteins with an isoelectric point (pI) between 4 and 7. The most abundant proteins of exponentially growing cells were compiled and shown to perform mainly housekeeping functions in glycolysis, tricarboxylic acid cycle (TCC), amino acid biosynthesis and translation as well as protein quality control. Furthermore, putative post-translational modifications were shown at a large scale, with 47 proteins in total forming more than one spot. In a few selected cases evidence for phosphorylation of these proteins is presented. The proteome analysis in the standard pI range was complemented by either stretching the most crowded regions in a narrow pH gradient 4.5-5.5, or by adding other fractions of the total B. subtilis proteome such as alkaline proteins as well as extracellular proteins. A big challenge for future studies is to provide an experimental protocol covering the fraction of intrinsic membrane proteins that almost totally escaped detection by the experimental procedure used in this study.     

Multidimensional liquid phase separations for mass spectrometry

Large part of the current research in biology, medicine, and biotechnology depends on the analysis of DNA (genomics), proteins (proteomics), or metabolites (metabolomics). The advances in biotechnology also command development of adequate analytical instrumentation capable to analyze minute amounts of samples. The analysis of the content of single cells may serve as an example of ultimate analytical applications. Most of the separation techniques have been developed in the last three decades and alternative approaches are being investigated. At present, the main protocols for analyses of complex mixtures include 2-DE (IEF) followed by electrophoresis in SDS polyacrylamide gel (SDS-PAGE) and chromatographic techniques. Information-rich techniques such as MS and NMR are essential for the identification and structure analysis of the analyzed compounds. High resolution separation of the individual sample components is often a prerequisite for success. High resolution proteomic analysis in the majority of laboratories still relies on the time consuming and laborious offline methods. This review highlights some of the important aspects of 2-D separations including microfluidics.