Parallel, fluorous open-tubular chromatography using microstructured fibers

Although commonly used in gas chromatography, open-tubular columns for liquid chromatography have seen their development hindered by a number of factors both theoretical and practical. Requiring small diameters, great lengths and specialized detection systems to achieve a proper chromatographic response, columns of this sort have largely been ignored despite the highly desirable column performance an optimized system would provide. Here, we introduce the use of microstructured fibers (MSFs) as a platform for the development of multiplexed open-tubular liquid chromatography (OTLC) columns. The multiple, parallel silica channels presented by the MSF act as a promising substrate for an OTLC column, as they have diameters near the ideal range for interactions (1–3 μm), minimize flow-induced backpressure through their many uniform paths, and increase the loading capacity compared to a single capillary channel of similar size. Additionally, with outer diameters comparable to regular fused silica capillaries, MSFs can easily be employed in conventional chromatographic systems, eliminating the need for specialized equipment. Finally, MSF columns of this type can be functionalized using silane coupling techniques to allow the introduction of a wide variety of stationary phase chemistries. While in this report we explore the potential and limitations of fluorine-functionalized MSFs as OTLC columns, other stationary phase materials could easily be substituted by choosing appropriate silanization reagents. Particular attention here will be paid to the physical and performance characteristics of the fabricated columns, as well as avenues for their improvement and implementation.     

Estimation of the band broadening contribution of HPLC equipment to column elution profiles

Summary Methods to determine the contribution of the chromatographic equipment to the total band broadening which involve replacing the column by a union or a capillary tube are not suitable as they involve a fundamental change in the chromatographic system. The linear extrapolation method, based on the estimation of the relative influence of the instrument variance on solutes with different capacity factors, is a more attractive alternative method since the column remains in the chromatographic system. This method is only valid when a number of conditions are satisfied. By meeting these conditions the error in the instrument variance by using the linear extrapolation method was determined. At the same time, ways to minimise these errors were studied. Use of the linear extrapolation method in combination with conventional columns of 4.6 mm i.d. appears to yield inaccurate results. In combination with microbore columns the method can be used, provided the columns have a maximum length of 5cm and contain a packing material with a particle size of 2 or 3μm. The error in the determined instrument variance is then of the order of 2μl².     

Band broadening in size-exclusion chromatography of polydisperse samples

Understanding and controlling the band broadening is essential to obtain accurate molar-mass distributions by size-exclusion chromatography (SEC). In this paper, band broadening in SEC is reviewed from a contemporary perspective. The observed band broadening is due to dispersion inside and outside the chromatographic column (undesirable band broadening) and to the polydispersity of the sample (desirable SEC selectivity). The various contributors to band broadening are discussed. Integrity plots are introduced as a tool to evaluate the performance of specific SEC columns at given experimental conditions. For narrow polymer standards on single SEC columns the observed peak width is dominated by the chromatographic dispersion. MALDI-ToF-MS is demonstrated as an alternative to determine the PDI of narrowly distributed samples. The plate heights encountered at very high reduced velocities are found to be lower than expected. This is advantageous for fast separations by SEC.     

On the fallacies of the “ABT-concept”

Summary It has been known for almost 20 years that in practice the widths of peaks eluted isothermally from a capillary column working under good conditions increase linearly with increasing retention time. The use of this plot, following the ABT-concept, to derive useful data to express the quality of capillary columns is challenged. The ordinate intercect of the plot results from the column contribution to the band broadening of a non-retained peak, which is easy to predict from the Taylor-Golay equation, and from the equipment contribution. With modern instruments it is easy to keep that second contribution to a reasonably low value for 0.25 mm i.d. columns. The first cannot be reduced to zero as claimed by some authors. Furthermore the two contributions are additive, following the variance addition rule. Consequently the peak width versus retention plot is no longer linear when the equipment contribution becomes large. These facts make the so-called ABT-concept seriously misleading. Other rules derived from practical experience and sound theoretical considerations are given for checking capillary columns.     

Open tubular liquid chromatography: Recent advances and future trends

Nano-liquid chromatography (nanoLC) is gaining significant attention as a primary analytical technique across various scientific domains. Unlike conventional high-performance LC, nanoLC utilizes columns with inner diameters (i.ds.) usually ranging from 10 to 150 μm and operates at mobile phase flow rates between 10 and 1000 nl/min, offering improved chromatographic performance and detectability. Currently, most exploration of nanoLC has focused on particle-packed columns. Although open tubular LC (OTLC) can provide superior performance, optimized OTLC columns require very narrow i.ds. (< 10 μm) and demand challenging instrumentation. At the moment, these challenges have limited the success of OTLC. Nevertheless, remarkable progress has been made in developing and utilizing OTLC systems featuring narrow columns (< 2 μm). Additionally, significant efforts have been made to explore larger columns (10–75 μm i.d), demonstrating practical applicability in many situations. Due to their perceived advantages, interest in OTLC has resurged in the last two decades. This review provides an updated outlook on the latest developments in OTLC, focusing on instrumental challenges, achievements, and advancements in column technology. Moreover, it outlines selected applications that illustrate the potential of OTLC for performing targeted and untargeted studies.     

Contribution of the polymer standards' polydispersity to the observed band broadening in size-exclusion chromatography

The contribution of the polydispersity of polymer standards to the observed band broadening in size-exclusion chromatography was evaluated. Initially, theoretical predictions based on an equation by Knox et al. were found to overestimate this contribution, greatly due to the fact that the polydispersity values specified by the manufacturers are upper limits and therefore too high to be applied in this context. An improved estimate of the polydispersity values was obtained from the size-exclusion chromatography results and these new values were used to reassess the polydispersity contribution to band broadening. For two of three columns tested the best molar-mass-distribution parameters, i.e. those the least affected by extra-column and intra-column band broadening effects, can be obtained for polymers with a molar mass in the effective range of the given column and at rather low mobile-phase flow rates. At those conditions, for low-molar-mass polymers, the estimated polydispersity index values approach the theoretical ones derived from a Poisson distribution.     

Development of a positive pressure driven micro-fabricated liquid chromatographic analyzer through rapid-prototyping with poly(dimethylsiloxane) Optimizing chromatographic efficiency with sub-nanoliter injections

A rapid and low-cost means of developing a working prototype for a positive-displacement driven open tubular liquid chromatography (OTLC) analyzer is demonstrated. A novel flow programming and injection strategy was developed and implemented using soft lithography, and evaluated in terms of chromatographic band broadening and efficiency. A separation of two food dyes served as the model sample system. Sample and mobile phase flowed continuously by positive displacement through the OTLC analyzer. Rectangular channels, of dimensions 10 μm deep by 100 μm wide, were micro-fabricated in poly-dimethylsiloxane (PDMS), with the separation portion 6.6 cm long. Using a novel flow programming method, in contrast to electroosmotic flow, sample injection volumes from 0.5 to 10 nl were made in real-time. Band broadening increased substantially for injection volumes over 1 nl. Although underivatized PDMS proved to be a sub-optimal stationary phase, plate heights, H, of 12 μm were experimentally achieved for an unretained analyte with the rectangular channel resulting in a reduced plate height, h, of 1.2. Chromatographic efficiency of the unretained analyte followed the model of an OTLC system limited by mass-transfer in the mobile phase. Flow rates from 6 nl min⁻¹ up to 200 nl min⁻¹ were tested, and van Deemter plots confirmed plate heights were optimum at 6 nl min⁻¹ over the tested flow rate range. Thus, the best separation efficiency, N of 5500 for the 6.6 cm length separation channel, was achieved at the minimum flow rate through the column of 6 nl min⁻¹, or 3 ml year⁻¹. This analyzer is a low-cost sampling and chemical analysis tool that is intended to complement micro-fabricated electrophoretic and related separation devices.     

Kinetic optimisation of open-tubular liquid-chromatography capillaries coated with thick porous layers for increased loadability

The kinetic optimisation of open-tubular liquid chromatography (OTLC) columns has been revisited by taking the thick-film effects for porous coatings on retention, column resistance, band broadening and mass loadability into account. Considering the most advantageous case (i.e. where the retentive layer allows for the same high internal diffusion coefficient as conventional porous particles), calculations show the need for the development of coating procedures leading to porous films filling up approximately 50-70% of the total column diameter. Furthermore, to achieve optimum kinetic performance for separations of small molecules with total analysis times of less than 8h (k'=9), total column diameters should be less than 6 μm with lengths typically greater than 0.8m for N values of 125,000-500,000 at a pressure of 400 bar. The use of elevated temperature LC (90°C) is also shown to increase the allowable total column diameter to up to 9 μm for a larger range of N values (100,000-880,000).     

Direct determination of band broadening in size exclusion chromatography

A simple method to correct the measured extent of band broadening in size exclusion chromatography for the contribution of narrow (polydisperse) standards is presented. It is based on the assumptions that commercial polymer standards can be described by a Poisson distribution and the additivity of peak variances. Two sets of standards (polystyrene from two suppliers) were investigated under normal working conditions, i.e. a combination of four columns with different porosities and a flow rate of 1 ml/min. Furthermore, the polystyrene standards were used to determine the extent of band broadening for four additional combinations of columns (varying in their separation range and porosities) as a function of the elution volume. The assumption of a constant peak variance for band broadening turned out to be a (very) rough approximation for some combinations of columns, but all results taken together demonstrate that this assumption is not generally applicable. Qualitative agreement between theory and experiment was found with a rearranged van Deemter equation.     

A protocol for the measurement of all the parameters of the mass transfer kinetics in columns used in liquid chromatography

Band broadening in chromatography results from the combination of the dispersive effects that are associated with the different steps involved in the migration of compound bands along the column. These steps include longitudinal diffusion, trans-particle mass transfer, external film mass transfer, overall eddy diffusion, including trans-column, short-range inter-channel, trans-channel eddy diffusion, and the possible, additional mass transfer contributions arising from heat friction and the thermal heterogeneity of the column. We describe a series of experiments that provide the data needed to determine the coefficients of the contributions to band broadening of each one of these individual mass transfer steps. This specifically designed protocol can provide key information regarding the kinetic performance of columns used in liquid chromatography and explain why different columns behave so differently. The limitations, accuracy and precision of these methods are discussed. Further avenues of research that could improve the characterization of the mass transfer mechanisms in chromatographic columns, possibly contributing to the development of better columns, are suggested.     

Moment analysis of chromatographic behavior of superficially porous particles

Peak parking experiments were conducted to study the chromatographic behavior in a RPLC system consisting of a column packed with superficially porous C(18)-particles and a mixture of methanol and water (70/30, v/v). The values of the surface diffusion coefficient and the retention equilibrium constant of a column packed with superficially porous C(18)-particles were comparable to those of columns packed with a C(18)-silica monolith and full-porous C(18)-silica gel particles. The flow-rate dependence of HETP was hypothetically calculated by using moment equations to clarify the influence of the structural characteristics on the chromatographic behavior. The column efficiency of a column packed with the superficially porous particles is higher in the high flow-rate range than that with full-porous spherical particles. This is attributed to the smaller contribution of the intraparticulate mass transfer in the superficially porous particles to band broadening. The moment equations are effective for the quantitative analysis of chromatographic behavior of superficially porous particles.     

Two‐dimensional chromatography as a tool for studying band broadening in size‐exclusion chromatography

Comprehensive 2‐D size‐exclusion chromatography (SEC×SEC) has been realized. SEC×SEC is not a useful technique for characterizing complex polymers. However, it is potentially an elegant tool to study band‐broadening phenomena. If narrow fractions can be collected from the first dimension, the band broadening in the second dimension is only due to chromatographic dispersion. This would allow a clear distinction to be made between chromatographic band broadening (column and extra‐column) and SEC selectivity (band broadening due to sample polydispersity). In comparison with MALDI‐MS, SEC×SEC allows the study of polymers across a much broader molar‐mass range.     

Approaches to characterise chromatographic column performance based on global parameters accounting for peak broadening and skewness

Peak broadening and skewness are fundamental parameters in chromatography, since they affect the resolution capability of a chromatographic column. A common practice to characterise chromatographic columns is to estimate the efficiency and asymmetry factor for the peaks of one or more solutes eluted at selected experimental conditions. This has the drawback that the extra-column contributions to the peak variance and skewness make the peak shape parameters depend on the retention time. We propose and discuss here the use of several approaches that allow the estimation of global parameters (non-dependent on the retention time) to describe the column performance. The global parameters arise from different linear relationships that can be established between the peak variance, standard deviation, or half-widths with the retention time. Some of them describe exclusively the column contribution to the peak broadening, whereas others consider the extra-column effects also. The estimation of peak skewness was also possible for the approaches based on the half-widths. The proposed approaches were applied to the characterisation of different columns (Spherisorb, Zorbax SB, Zorbax Eclipse, Kromasil, Chromolith, X-Terra and Inertsil), using the chromatographic data obtained for several diuretics and basic drugs (β-blockers).     

On the 3-dimensional effects in etched chips for high performance liquid chromatography-separations

In an attempt to quantify the potential of photolithographically etched micro-pillar arrays as a perfectly ordered alternative for the packed bed of spheres, the additional band broadening originating from the top and bottom plate has been investigated using computational fluid dynamics simulations. These calculations provide insight in the theoretical expectations that can be made for the experimental work that is currently being conducted by a number of groups. The calculations show that the additional band broadening contribution can be expected to go through a transient regime as a function of the axial distance along the array. In its fully developed regime and in the most relevant velocity range, the top and bottom wall contribution almost doubles the band broadening compared to the band broadening in a perfectly ordered array of non-porous, non-retentive pillars without top and bottom wall. Compared to the band broadening in an array of porous, retentive pillars on the other hand, the top and bottom wall-effect can be expected to become negligible. A simplified, phenomenological model yielding a first principles prediction of both the transient and the steady-state top and bottom wall band broadening as a function of the inter-pillar distance and the pillar height is proposed and shows good qualitative agreement with the exact calculations.     

Evaluation of packed capillary liquid chromatography columns and comparison with conventional-size columns

Apart from extracolumn effects peak dispersion in liquid chromatographic columns is caused by the column inlet, the packed bed, and the column outlet. A strategy applicable for independent evaluation of the individual sources of column band broadening was developed on the basis of the linear extrapolation method (LEM). This method was applied to compare the performance of packed capillary LC columns from various commercial suppliers with conventional-size columns. The columns differed widely in their performance with respect to peak shapes and widths for standard substances. The capillary columns were found well packed, but in some cases overall performance would benefit from improving the design of the area between the packed bed and the connecting capillaries, containing frits as well as dead volumes.     

High-speed LC Analysis Using Electrochemical Detection

Abstract

The chromatographic performance of an electrochemical detector incorporating a flowcell with improved dispersive charac- teristics has been evaluated for use in high-speed liquid chroma- tography. High-speed C18/3 um columns, 100 × 4.6 mn, i.d. were found to be well matched to this detector with respect to extra- column contributions to band broadening. The capabilities of this high-speed LC-EC system are demonstrated by a 3-minute separation of phenols and a 4-minute separation of catecholamines and ace- t ominophen.     

Experimental study of the depth influence on the band broadening effect in a cyclo-olefin polymer column containing an array of ordered pillars

An experimental study of a micromachined non-porous pillar array column performance under non-retentive conditions is presented. The same pillar structure has been fabricated in cyclo-olefin polymer (COP) chips with three different depths via hot embossing and pressure-assisted thermal bonding. The influence of the depth on the band broadening along with the already known contribution arising from the top and bottom cover plates has been studied. The experimental results exhibit reduced plate heights as low as 0.2, which are in agreement with the previous experimental work. Moreover, the constant values of the reduced Van Deemter expression are also in accordance with the previous studies. A more exhaustive study of the C-term band broadening is also presented, showing that comparing the space between the pillars with different open tubular rectangular channels offers a good estimation of the C-term band broadening that is obtained experimentally. These experimental results, hence, confirm that micromachined pillar array columns fabricated in COP can achieve the same performance as the ones fabricated in silicon for the presently studied pillar channel design.     

Repeatability and reproducibility of retention data and band profiles on reversed-phase liquid chromatography columns. IV. Results obtained with Luna C18 (2) columns

The reproducibility of retention data and band profile characteristics was investigated for a series of columns packed with Luna C18 (2), a silica-based, reversed-phase adsorbent. High precision data were obtained and statistically compared among five columns from the same batch (column-to-column reproducibility) and nine columns from as many different batches (batch-to-batch reproducibility). These data were acquired under five different sets of chromatographic conditions, for a group of 30 neutral, acidic, and basic compounds selected as probes following an experimental protocol previously described. This work is part of a study on the precision of chromatographic analyses. Its purpose is to illustrate the contribution of the stationary phase reproducibility to this precision.     

Chromatographic characterization of molecularly imprinted polymers

Recent efforts in the investigation of chromatographic characterization of molecularly imprinted polymers (MIPs) have focused mainly on the nature of heterogeneous binding sites. More data on the thermodynamics than on the kinetic features of MIP columns have been published. The present article addresses the sources of peak broadening and tailing, which are the main drawbacks often associated with imprinted polymers in chromatography for practical applications. With use of the theory of nonlinear chromatography, the peak properties of a MIP column, including the retention and peak broadening and tailing, can be well interpreted. Efforts to improve chromatographic efficiency using MIPs prepared by approaches different from the conventional method, including covalent imprinting and the format of uniformly sized spherical microbeads, are reviewed and discussed. This review leads to the conclusion that nonlinear chromatography theory is useful for characterizing chromatographic features of MIP columns, since a MIP is essentially an affinity-based chromatographic stationary phase. We expect more theoretical and experimental studies on the kinetic aspects of MIP columns, especially the factors influencing the apparent rate constant, as well as the analysis of the influences of mobile-phase composition on the chromatographic performance. In addition to revealing the affinity interaction by molecular recognition, slow nonspecific interactions which may be inherited from the imperfect imprinting and may be involved in the rebinding of the template to MIPs also need to be characterized. Figure The peak broadening and tailing associated often with molecularly imprinted polymers (MIPs) in column chromatography for practical applications can be well characterized by the theory of nonlinear chromatography.     

凝胶色谱与多角激光光散射联用研究聚氧化乙烯的扩展效应和链构象

采用凝胶色谱与多角激光光散射联用的方法,测定了一系列不同分子量的聚乙二醇(PEG)和聚氧化乙烯(PEO)在色谱柱中的扩展效应.扩展因子随PEG/PEO分子量的增加而增大,经扩展效应改正后得到了样品的准确分子量和分子量分布.同时建立了PEO的Z均回转半径Rgz与重均分子量Mw之间的单分散标度关系:Rgz=0.0272 Mw0.56,结果表明,长链PEO在水溶液中由于排除体积效应采取溶胀的无规线团构象.