基于复杂网络的金融风险跨市场传导机制研究——以金融危机时期(2007~2009年)数据为例

金融系统具有典型的非线性复杂系统的特征,其多层次和多重反馈特性使得金融风险跨市场传导效应更加复杂多变。选取2007~2009年金融危机时期的相关数据,构建金融网络,并采用最小生成树(MST)的方法对金融风险跨市场传导机制进行实证分析。结果表明:我国金融市场具有明显的小世界特征;金融危机期间金融市场内部各子市场间的关联程度显著加强;股票、债券、房地产和外汇市场是系统重要性市场,需要重点监控;对金融风险跨市场传导的潜在路径进行了识别,为宏观审慎监管提供了理论基础。     

尾部风险网络视角下的金融机构系统性风险贡献研究

金融机构的尾部风险关联模式及结构在金融系统性风险的形成演化中发挥重要作用。利用CoVaR指标及分位数回归方法,衡量金融机构之间的尾部风险传染强度,进而建立金融机构尾部风险动态网络。分析全连接网络及阈值法下过滤网络的全局和局部拓扑结构特征及其动态演化规律。建立面板数据回归模型,研究网络拓扑结构特征对金融机构系统性风险贡献的影响。实证研究发现,全连接网络的节点强度,能有效地衡量金融机构尾部风险传染强度及承受强度,并揭示其动态变化规律;各机构的尾部风险传染强度及承受强度排序匹配性存在差异;随着时间推进,各金融机构间的平均尾部风险传染路径缩短、系统性风险更易迅速累积和爆发;滞后一期的节点出度、节点入度及聚集系数越大,相应金融机构的系统性风险贡献越小;滞后一期的节点介数和节点接近中心度越大,相应金融机构的系统性风险贡献越大。研究结果对于金融机构的宏观审慎监管及系统性风险管理,提供了一个全新的基于金融机构尾部风险网络的视角。     

Rollover risk and endogenous network dynamics

Using a dynamic network formation model, solved numerically, we study banks’ rollover decisions. We find that when the existence of linkages between market participants generates an informational externality, the newly formed network is conditioned by past architectures. Moreover, this inertia is strongly dependent on macroeconomic conditions, such as investors’ risk appetite. Simulations show that for intermediate values of the risk appetite’s parameter the financial network exhibits tipping points, i.e., the inability to maintain a threshold number of linkages may push the market into a gridlock. In this context, we study also how policy instruments, such as taxes and subsidies, affects debt rollover. Since a reduction in the policy level plays the same role as an improvement in economic fundamentals, the creation of interbank connections can be stimulated by it. Thus, in order to restart lending after a major stress situation in the interbank market a considerable reduction in the policy level is required, advising a counter-cyclical policy similar to the ones recently proposed with respect to capital requirements.     

微信社群互动行为对用户理财产品投资组合风险决策的影响

微信社群如何影响用户理财产品购买决策是当下金融产品营销的一个重要理论问题。本研究依据效价理论提出感知风险、感知收益与用户理财产品的投资组合风险决策的关系模型,并将用户的微信社群互动纳入模型。基于287个用户问卷数据,129个微信社群的互动行为数据,以及用户理财产品实际购买行为的数据分析,发现用户购买理财产品的投资组合风险决策受到其感知风险与感知收益的影响,而且微信社群的互动频率负向影响用户感知风险与用户投资组合风险决策之间的负向关系、微信社群的消极情绪会加强感知风险对用户投资组合风险决策的负向影响并削弱感知利益对于用户投资组合风险决策的正向影响。本研究扩展了有关用户理财产品决策影响因素的分析视角,并对理财产品的用户管理有借鉴价值。     

基于双风险因子调整的剩余收益经营与投资最优决策模型

一般来说,公司净资产基于投向可以分为净经营性资产和净金融性资产。这两种净资产所面临的风险属性是不同的,净经营性资产承担的是经营性风险,而净金融性资产承担的则是金融性风险。作为公司多元化经营的决策者,在公司净资产一定的情况下,如何合理分配经营性投资与金融性投资间的比例并作出最优的投资决策,以达到公司价值最大化？本文基于一般形式的三阶段剩余收益模型,根据净经营性资产具有经营风险,净金融性资产则具有金融风险的风险识别与判断,从理论上构建出双风险因子调整的剩余收益经营与投资决策模型(Operation and Investment Decision Model of Dual-risks RIM, OIDM-DRRIM)。同时,利用中国资本市场1997年到2014年的经验数据进行实证检验,研究结果表明,所构建的OIDM-DRRIM具有非常好的适用性,公司经营决策者可以根据该模型计算出净经营性资产和净金融性资产之间的最优分配比例,进而作出使公司价值最大化的经营与投资决策。     

基于信息溢出网络的我国行业关联性研究

行业信息溢出网络是各行业之间风险关联的载体,其信息溢出的方向和强度与行业的风险传染特征密切相关。运用广义方差分解对申银万国行业一级指数同时构建行业收益率溢出网络和行业波动率溢出网络,分别从静态和动态角度分析我国行业信息溢出的总体情况和动态演化。研究发现:我国各行业间信息溢出水平较高,整体信息联动能力强,但各行业信息溢出随时间变化具有波动性和不确定性。长期情形下,收益率溢出网络和波动溢出网络对系统性重要行业的识别排序具有高度一致性,但短期内两者存在较大差异。长期内,银行业和非银行金融业是系统性重要(信息)接受行业,机械设备业是系统性重要(信息)传播行业;短期内,银行、非银行金融、国防军工、食品饮料及家用电器业是系统性重要行业,但它们的具体角色(信息接受或者传播)具有不确定性。研究结论对于政府产业政策制定及产业监管具有重要的现实意义。     

Systemic risk and optimal fee for central clearing counterparty under partial netting

We propose a novel central clearing counterparty (CCP) design for a financial network, in which the participation of banks in the CCP depends on the proportional clearing fee. We obtain the optimal fee that maximizes the CCP’s net worth. We show that partial participation of banks in the CCP at the optimal fee rate reduces banks’ aggregate shortfall and also reduces the overall systemic risk. We also carry out numerical examples to verify the theoretical results.     

Dynamic structural percolation model of loss distribution for cyber risk of small and medium-sized enterprises for tree-based LAN topology

Cyber risk due to breach can be seen as a risk of a financial loss due to breach of an institution’s IT infrastructure by unauthorized parties and exploiting, taking possession of, or disclosing data assets, thus creating financial and/or reputation damage. In this paper, as a primary contribution to the existing body of actuarial literature, we propose a structural model of aggregate loss distribution for cyber risk of small and medium-sized enterprises under the assumption of a tree-based LAN topology. Up to our knowledge, there exist no theoretical models of an aggregate loss distribution for cyber risk in this setting. To achieve our goal, we contextualize the problem in the probabilistic graph-theoretical framework using percolation models. We assume that the IT network topology is represented by a random graph allowing for heterogeneous loss topology and providing instructive numerical examples.     

利益驱动对创新网络合作行为演化的影响机理及仿真——基于复杂网络拓扑结构视角

随着合作创新的网络化发展,创新网络中各主体的利益诉求对网络演化的影响不断加深。基于不同网络拓扑结构视角下不同利益对创新网络主体合作行为的影响,建立了创新网络演化博弈模型。在无标度与小世界网络拓扑结构下,结合声誉机制、学习行为、网络环境等因素,对创新网络中合作行为的演化进行了仿真研究。结果表明:创新网络的合作行为演化受到网络结构及规模的双重影响,在无标度网络下,合作率更加稳定;合作利益的公平分配促进创新网络合作行为的演化;机会利益的诱惑导致创新网络合作行为的显著波动。     

基于R-vine-copula-CoVaR模型的金融市场风险溢出效应研究

为了挖掘国际金融市场与中国金融市场的风险溢出效应,本文首先通过ARJI-GARCH模型捕捉单个市场收益率的跳跃等典型事实特征,然后采用最大生成树(Maximum Spanning Tree,MST)算法优化的R-vine来刻画多维金融资产的复杂相依结构;最后构建R-vine-copula-CoVaR模型,测度了国际原油市场、国际黄金市场、美国股票市场与中国股票市场、外汇市场之间的风险溢出效应。实证结果表明:各市场之间均存在双向风险溢出效应,但溢出程度差别很大,国际黄金市场是风险溢出的最大爆发源,仅有中国外汇市场与中国股票市场、国际黄金市场间存在负向风险溢出;市场之间的双向风险溢出效应呈非对称性,国际原油市场与黄金市场的风险溢出效应远大于中国股票市场与外汇市场风险溢出效应;Rosenb-Latt检验表明基于R藤的CoVaR风险溢出测度更具有灵活性和有效性;后验测试结果表明R-vine-copula-CoVaR模型能有效地测度国际金融市场对中国金融市场风险溢出效应,而对中国金融市场风险溢出效应的CoVaR测度存在被高估的可能。     

金融控股集团内部风险传染研究

金融控股集团特有的经济关系形成集团内部错综复杂的经济网络,本文基于集团内部的股权结构和关联交易形成有向网络,构建金融控股集团内部风险传染的模型。研究结果表明:持股对手数量超过某一临界值时,风险被集团成员共同分担,成员仅需承担较小的破产成本,集团稳定;持股对手数量固定时,集团内部风险传染情况与持股比重之间不存在单调关系。集团在持股对手数量和持股比重之间存在权衡,以此减小集团内部风险传播的可能性。此外,当集团成员爆发危机后,关联交易将增大集团成员的损失,从而扩大风险以及风险传播范围。本文为金融控股集团股权分配和关联交易规模提供了理论指导。     

Financial networks with intermediation: Risk management with variable weights

In this paper, we develop a framework for the modeling, analysis, and computation of solutions to multitiered financial network problems with intermediaries in which both the sources of financial funds as well as the intermediaries are multicriteria decision-makers. In particular, we assume that these decision-makers seek not only to maximize their net revenues but also to minimize risk with the risk being penalized by a variable weight. We make explicit the behavior of the various decision-makers, including the consumers at the demand markets for the financial products. We derive the optimality conditions, and demonstrate that the governing equilibrium conditions of the financial network economy can be formulated as a finite-dimensional variational inequality problem. Qualitative properties of the equilibrium financial flow and price pattern are provided. A computational procedure that exploits the network structure of the problem is proposed and then applied to several numerical examples.     

中国银行系统的宏观审慎监管研究

全球金融危机爆发后,对银行系统实行审慎监管已成为国内外学者及相关监管机构的共识。但目前银行系统的监管研究多为微观审慎监管,宏观审慎监管研究缺乏,尤其是对中国银行网络系统进行动态建模并进行宏观审慎监管的定量研究未见。本文首先利用中国2008至2015年16家上市银行的实际数据构建动态的中国银行网络系统模型,然后使用Component VaR、Incremental VaR、Shapley value EL以及ΔCoVaR四种风险分配机制研究中国银行网络系统的宏观审慎监管方法。研究表明:对中国银行网络系统进行宏观审慎监管能够有效提升其稳定性,并且四种机制相比之下,ΔCoVaR的监管效果最为显著,而Incremental VaR则相对较差。此外,通过宏观审慎资本与银行指标之间的相关性分析,发现Incremental VaR、Shapley value EL以及Component VaR机制下的宏观审慎资本与银行的总资产具有一定的相关性,此时宏观审慎资本可以根据银行的总资产来设置;而ΔCoVaR机制下则不相关,因此宏观审慎资本可以依据各银行的系统性风险贡献大小来设置。     

Supply chain network equilibrium with strategic financial hedging using futures

In this paper, we develop a network equilibrium model for supply chain networks with strategic financial hedging. We consider multiple competing firms that purchase multiple materials and parts to manufacture their products. The supply chain firms’ procurement activities are exposed to commodity price risk and exchange rate risk. The firms can use futures contracts to hedge the risks. Our research studies the equilibrium of the entire network where each firm optimizes its own operation and hedging decisions. We use variational inequality theory to formulate the equilibrium model, and provide qualitative properties. We provide analytical results for a special case with duopolistic competition, and use simulations to study an oligopolistic case. The analytical and simulation studies reveals interesting managerial insights.     

Financial networks with socially responsible investing

In this paper, we develop a framework for the modeling, analysis, and computation of solutions to multitiered financial network problems with socially responsible investment in which both the sources of financial funds as well as the intermediaries are multicriteria decision-makers. We assume that these decision-makers seek not only to maximize their net revenues but also minimize risk with the risk being penalized by a variable weight. Furthermore, we assume that the intermediaries are socially responsible companies, who want to maximize their social responsibility levels. We make explicit the behavior of the various decision-makers, including the consumers at the demand markets for the financial products. We derive the optimality conditions, and demonstrate that the governing equilibrium conditions of the financial network economy can be formulated as a finite-dimensional variational inequality problem. Qualitative properties of the equilibrium financial flow and price pattern are provided. A numerical example is used to illustrate the model.     

基于网络混合学习策略的股市投资者行为演化模型及仿真

针对投资者有限理性决策行为的模仿学习等特质,运用复杂网络、贝叶斯学习和社会学习理论,分别对个人投资者和机构投资者的投资行为决策机制进行系统性分析,由此构建基于网络混合学习策略的投资者行为演化机理和数理模型,并进行数理解析和模拟仿真。研究发现,投资者金融关联网络的拓扑结构对个人投资者行为动态演变具有较强影响,但对机构投资者的影响较弱;个人投资者的学习策略偏好影响其行为动态演变均衡状态的稳定性较为显著;机构投资者获取的私有信息精确度与其行为动态演变的均衡状态之间存在显著的非线性关联;投资者的初始行为状态对其投资行为动态演变均衡状态的影响效应均较弱。     

Credit default swaps and systemic risk

We present a network model for investigating the impact on systemic risk of central clearing of over the counter (OTC) credit default swaps (CDS). We model contingent cash flows resulting from CDS and other OTC derivatives by a multi-layered network with a core-periphery structure, which is flexible enough to reproduce the gross and net exposures as well as the heterogeneity of market shares of participating institutions. We analyze illiquidity cascades resulting from liquidity shocks and show that the contagion of illiquidity takes place along a sub-network constituted by links identified as ’critical receivables’. A key role is played by the long intermediation chains inherent to the structure of the OTC network, which may turn into chains of critical receivables. We calibrate our model to data representing net and gross OTC exposures of large dealer banks and use this model to investigate the impact of central clearing on network stability. We find that, when interest rate swaps are cleared, central clearing of credit default swaps through a well-capitalized CCP can reduce the probability and the magnitude of a systemic illiquidity spiral by reducing the length of the chains of critical receivables within the financial network. These benefits are reduced, however, if some large intermediaries are not included as clearing members.     

网络结构、资本缓冲与银行系统性风险传染效应——来自2007~2017年中国14个上市商业银行数据

银行体系稳健运行对国民经济健康发展具有重要意义。选取2007~2017年中国14个上市商业银行数据,利用债务矩阵构建银行网络,运用无残差完全分解模型将其分解为网络结构和资本缓冲两个因素,对我国银行系统性风险传染效应研究。结果表明:网络结构与银行系统性风险存在复杂的关联性,而资本缓冲与银行系统性风险有显著负相关关系;在金融危机期间,网络结构是诱导银行系统性风险波动的决定性因素,资本缓冲对降低银行系统性风险有重要作用。此外国有商业银行与其他银行债务关系更为紧密,对系统性金融风险贡献较大,中国银行处于网络结构中重要位置,中国工商银行和中国建设银行处于次重要位置。该结果为资本监管政策和宏观审慎政策有效实施提供了理论依据。     

Financial contagion: extending the exposures network of the Mexican financial system

Direct contagion has been widely studied in recent years and little evidence has been found to be relevant to the study of systemic risk. However, we argue that this limited contagion effect might be associated with a lack of relevant data. A common assumption for the estimation of the matrices of exposures is to apply the maximum entropy principle to deal with data gaps; such an assumption might lead to an underestimation of contagion risk. In this paper, there are no data gaps and the information set is extended from interbank exposures alone to exposures among most of the financial intermediaries in the Mexican financial system (we even include exposures to some international foreign banks). Naturally, the contagion risk of an extended network of exposures changes with respect to the interbank exposures network, as there are many more institutions which can be the source of contagion and there are more institutions which can fail due to contagion. The most important contribution of this paper is that it provides evidence on financial contagion with an extended exposures network under stressful conditions. The results presented here support the international efforts by the Bank for International Settlements, the International Monetary Fund and the Financial Stability Board to increase the amount of information available which can be used to assess systemic risk and contagion based on exposures and funding data.     

我国股市网络稳定性及其宏观影响因素——基于三种网络拓扑结构、鲁棒性的实证研究

基于金融时间序列的多重分形特征及衡量市场风险的VaR模型,建立我国沪深股市的股票关联网络,实证研究三种网络拓扑结构特征,并使用协整检验方法分析网络稳定性和宏观经济变量间的长期均衡关系。结果表明:股票价格网络不具有无标度性,多标度网络和风险网络都具有无标度性;在三种网络中,风险网络具有更强的鲁棒性。此外,股市波动率和网络稳定系数间互为格兰杰因果关系,股市波动的前期变化能有效解释网络稳定性系数的变化;网络稳定性与宏观经济变量间具有长期的均衡关系,GDP增长率、消费者物价水平CPI对网络稳定性具有正向效应,利率对网络稳定性具有负向效应。风险网络的提出有助于分析我国股市的短期风险及稳定性,并为制定系统风险防御策略提供参考。