Hydrophilic interaction chromatography: A promising alternative to reversed‐phase liquid chromatography systems for the purification of small protonated bases

The overloaded band profiles of the protonated species of propranolol and amitriptyline were recorded under acidic conditions on four classes of stationary phases including a conventional silica/organic hybrid material in reversed‐phase liquid chromatography mode (BEH‐C₁₈), an electrostatic repulsion reversed‐phase liquid chromatography C₁₈ column (BEH‐C₁₈+), a poly(styrene‐divinylbenzene) monolithic column, and a hydrophilic interaction chromatography stationary phase (underivatized BEH). The same amounts of protonated bases per unit volume of stationary phase were injected in each column (16, 47, and 141 μg/cm³). The performance of the propranolol/amitriptyline purification was assessed on the basis of the asymmetry of the recorded band profiles and on the selectivity factor achieved. The results show that the separation performed under reversed‐phase liquid chromatography like conditions (with BEH‐C₁₈, BEH‐C₁₈+, and polymer monolith materials) provide the largest selectivity factors due to the difference in the hydrophobic character of the two compounds. However, they also provide the most distorted overloaded band profiles due to a too small loading capacity. Remarkably, symmetric band profiles were observed with the hydrophilic interaction chromatography column. The larger loading capacity of the hydrophilic interaction chromatography column is due to the accumulation of the protonated bases into the diffuse water layer formed at the surface of the polar adsorbent. This work encourages purifying ionizable compounds on hydrophilic interaction chromatography columns rather than on reversed‐phase liquid chromatography columns.     

Ion‐exchange vs reversed‐phase chromatography for separation and determination of basic psychotropic drugs

Ion exchange chromatography, an alternative to reversed‐phase (RP) chromatography, is described in this paper. We aimed to obtain optimal conditions for the separation of basic drugs because silica‐based RP stationary phases show silanol effect and make the analysis of basic analytes hardly possible. The retention, separation selectivity, symmetry of peaks and system efficiency were examined in different eluent systems containing different types of buffers at acidic pH and with the addition of organic modifiers: methanol and acetonitrile. The obtained results reveal a large influence of the salt cation used for buffer preparation and the type of organic modifier on the retention behavior of the analytes. These results were also compared with those obtained on an XBridge C₁₈ column. The obtained results demonstrated that SCX stationary phases can be successfully used as alternatives to C₁₈ stationary phases in the separation of basic compounds. The most selective and efficient chromatographic systems were applied for the quantification of some psychotropic drugs in fortified human serum samples. Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Evaluation and comparison of n‐alkyl chain and polar ligand bonded stationary phases for protein separation in reversed‐phase liquid chromatography

Protein retention is very sensitive to the change of solvent composition in reversed‐phase liquid chromatography for so called “on–off” mechanism, leading to difficulty in mobile phase optimization. In this study, a novel 3‐chloropropyl trichlorosilane ligand bonded column was prepared for protein separation. The differences in retention characteristics between the 3‐chloropropyl trichlorosilane ligand bonded column and n‐alkyl chain modified (C₂, C₄, C₈) stationary phases were elucidated by the retention equation . Retention parameters (a and c) of nine standard proteins with different molecular weights were calculated by using homemade software. Results showed that retention times of nine proteins were similar on four columns, but the 3‐chloropropyl trichlorosilane ligand bonded column obtained the lowest retention parameter values of larger proteins. It meant that their retention behavior affected by acetonitrile concentration would be different due to lower |c| values. More specifically, protein elution windows were broader, and retentions were less sensitive to the change of acetonitrile concentration on the 3‐chloropropyl trichlorosilane ligand bonded column than that on other columns. Meanwhile, the 3‐chloropropyl trichlorosilane ligand bonded column displayed distinctive selectivity for some proteins. Our results indicated that stationary phase with polar ligand provided potential solutions to the “on–off” problem and optimization in protein separation.     

Separation of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons with a C60 bonded silica phase in microcolumn liquid chromatography

A chemically bonded C₆₀ silica phase was synthesized as a stationary phase for liquid chromatography (LC) and its retention behavior evaluated for various polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) using microcolumn LC. The results indicate that the C₆₀ bonded phase offers selectivity different from that of octadecylsilica (ODS) bonded phases in the separation of isomeric PAHs. With the C₆₀ phase, PAH molecules having a partial structure similar to that of the C₆₀ molecule, e.g. triphenylene and perylene, were retained longer than with ordinary ODS stationary phases. The results also show that good correlation exists between the retention data with this C₆₀ bonded phase and with C₆₀ itself as the stationary phase.     

Comparison of the Separation Characteristics of the Organic–Inorganic Hybrid Stationary Phases XBridge C8 and Phenyl and XTerra Phenyl in RP-LC

Differences in the system constants of the solvation parameter model and retention factor correlation plots for varied solutes are used to study the retention mechanism on XBridge C₈, XBridge Phenyl and XTerra Phenyl stationary phases with acetonitrile–water and methanol–water mobile phases containing from 10 to 70% (v/v) organic solvent. These stationary phases are compared with XBridge C₁₈ and XBridge Shield RP₁₈ characterized in an earlier report using the same protocol. The XBridge stationary phases are all quite similar in their retention properties with larger difference in absolute retention explained by differences in cohesion and the phase ratio, mainly, and smaller changes in relative retention (selectivity) by the differences in individual system constants and their variation with mobile phase type and composition. None of the XBridge stationary phases are selectivity equivalent but XBridge C₁₈ and XBridge Shield RP₁₈ have similar separation properties, likewise so do XBridge C₈ and XBridge Phenyl, while the differences between the two groups of two stationary phases is greater than the difference within either group. The limited range of changes in selectivity is demonstrated by the high coefficient of determination (>0.98) for plots of the retention factors for varied compounds on the different XBridge phases with the same mobile phase composition.     

Glass capillary gas chromatography of C1−C4 mononitroalkanes. Pre-calculation of the relative retention

Summary The separation of C₁–C₄ mononitroalkanes on four wall-coated glass open tubular (capillary) columns (liquid phases: OV-101, Ucon-LB-550X, NPGS and Carbowax 20M) was investigated. Retention indices were determined and the influence of the different factors (analysis temperature, method of determining the gas holdup time and the nature of the stationary phases) on their reproducibility were studied. Linear regression equations permit the pre-calculation of the retention indices of C₁–C₄ mononitroalkanes from their properties on all liquid phases studied.     

Retention of nucleic acids in ion‐pair reversed‐phase high‐performance liquid chromatography depends not only on base composition but also on base sequence

The study on nucleic acid retention in ion‐pair reversed‐phase high‐performance liquid chromatography mainly focuses on size‐dependence, however, other factors influencing retention behaviors have not been comprehensively clarified up to date. In this present work, the retention behaviors of oligonucleotides and double‐stranded DNAs were investigated on silica‐based C₁₈ stationary phase by ion‐pair reversed‐phase high‐performance liquid chromatography. It is found that the retention of oligonucleotides was influenced by base composition and base sequence as well as size, and oligonucleotides prone to self‐dimerization have weaker retention than those not prone to self‐dimerization but with the same base composition. However, homo‐oligonucleotides are suitable for the size‐dependent separation as a special case of oligonucleotides. For double‐stranded DNAs, the retention is also influenced by base composition and base sequence, as well as size. This may be attributed to the interaction of exposed bases in major or minor grooves with the hydrophobic alky chains of stationary phase. In addition, no specific influence of guanine and cytosine content was confirmed on retention of double‐stranded DNAs. Notably, the space effect resulted from the stereostructure of nucleic acids also influences the retention behavior in ion‐pair reversed‐phase high‐performance liquid chromatography.     

Adsorption of the anionic surfactant sodium dodecyl sulfate on a C18 column under micellar and high submicellar conditions in reversed‐phase liquid chromatography

Micellar liquid chromatography makes use of aqueous solutions or aqueous‐organic solutions containing a surfactant, at a concentration above its critical micelle concentration. In the mobile phase, the surfactant monomers aggregate to form micelles, whereas on the surface of the nonpolar alkyl‐bonded stationary phases they are significantly adsorbed. If the mobile phase contains a high concentration of organic solvent, micelles break down, and the amount of surfactant adsorbed on the stationary phase is reduced, giving rise to another chromatographic mode named high submicellar liquid chromatography. The presence of a thinner coating of surfactant enhances the selectivity and peak shape, especially for basic compounds. However, the risk of full desorption of surfactant is the main limitation in the high submicellar mode. This study examines the adsorption of the anionic surfactant sodium dodecyl sulfate under micellar and high submicellar conditions on a C₁₈ column, applying two methods. One of them uses a refractive index detector to obtain direct measurements of the adsorbed amount of sodium dodecyl sulfate, whereas the second method is based on the retention and peak shape for a set of cationic basic compounds that indirectly reveal the presence of adsorbed monomers of surfactant on the stationary phase.     

Laterally attached liquid-crystalline polymers as stationary phases. Effect of temperature in RP HPLC and comparison with a commercial C18 stationary phase

Summary Specific side-on-fixed liquid-crystalline polymers (SOLCP) have been synthesized for use in silica-modified stationary phases in high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). The mesogenic side group of the SOLCP is composed of three benzoate-type phenyl rings with terminal alkoxy chains and is laterally linked to a polysiloxane backbone via an alkyl ester spacer arm. The dependence of the logarithm of the retention factor on the reciprocal temperature showed that the liquid-crystalline anisotropic order was conserved in the small pores (200 ? diameter) of the silica gel. The first-order nematic-isotropic transition is lost and probably becomes second-order. Adsorption enthalpies for the liquid-crystalline stationary phases have been measurement for three polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon isomers (ortho-terphenyl, triphenylene, and chrysene) and compared with those for a commercial C₁₈ phase. The adsorption enthalpies never exceeded 30 kJ mol⁻¹, i.e. ten times the thermal agitation energy,RT. They were always less on the SOLCP stationary phase than on the C₁₈ column, emphasizing the more rigid structure of the liquid crystalline phase and its mechanism based upon adsorption. Better separation of steroids, pesticides and amino acids were obtained with the LCP-coated silica than the commercial bonded C₁₈ column. Four small peptides were successfully separated by using pure water as mobile phase.     

Evaluation of an amide‐based stationary phase for supercritical fluid chromatography

A relatively new stationary phase containing a polar group embedded in a hydrophobic backbone (i.e., ACE ® C18‐amide) was evaluated for use in supercritical fluid chromatography. The amide‐based column was compared with columns packed with bare silica, C₁₈ silica, and a terminal‐amide silica phase. The system was held at supercritical pressure and temperature with a mobile phase composition of CO₂ and methanol as cosolvent. The linear solvation energy relationship model was used to evaluate the behavior of these stationary phases, relating the retention factor of selected probes to specific chromatographic interactions. A five‐component test mixture, consisting of a group of drug‐like molecules was separated isocratically. The results show that the C₁₈‐amide stationary phase provided a combination of interactions contributing to the retention of the probe compounds. The hydrophobic interactions are favorable; however, the electron donating ability of the embedded amide group shows a large positive interaction. Under the chromatographic conditions used, the C₁₈‐amide column was able to provide baseline resolution of all the drug‐like probe compounds in a text mixture, while the other columns tested did not.     

Enhanced‐fluidity liquid chromatography using mixed‐mode hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography/strong cation‐exchange retention mechanisms

The potential of enhanced‐fluidity liquid chromatography, a subcritical chromatography technique, in mixed‐mode hydrophilic interaction/strong cation‐exchange separations is explored, using amino acids as analytes. The enhanced‐fluidity liquid mobile phases were prepared by adding liquefied CO₂ to methanol/water mixtures, which increases the diffusivity and decreases the viscosity of the mixture. The addition of CO₂ to methanol/water mixtures resulted in increased retention of the more polar amino acids. The “optimized” chromatographic performance (achieving baseline resolution of all amino acids in the shortest amount of time) of these methanol/water/CO₂ mixtures was compared to traditional acetonitrile/water and methanol/water liquid chromatography mobile phases. Methanol/water/CO₂ mixtures offered higher efficiencies and resolution of the ten amino acids relative to the methanol/water mobile phase, and decreased the required isocratic separation time by a factor of two relative to the acetonitrile/water mobile phase. Large differences in selectivity were also observed between the enhanced‐fluidity and traditional liquid mobile phases. A retention mechanism study was completed, that revealed the enhanced‐fluidity mobile phase separation was governed by a mixed‐mode retention mechanism of hydrophilic interaction/strong cation‐exchange. On the other hand, separations with acetonitrile/water and methanol/water mobile phases were strongly governed by only one retention mechanism, either hydrophilic interaction or strong cation exchange, respectively.     

Cucurbit(6)uril immobilized on silica: A novel high‐performance liquid chromatographic stationary phase

In the present study, one of the new generation of host molecules, cucurbit(6)uril (CB(6)), was immobilized onto silica (CB(6)/SiO₂) by a sol–gel approach. CB(6)/SiO₂ was characterized by NMR spectroscopy, Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy, thermogravimetric analysis, and elemental analysis. It was used as a high‐performance liquid chromatographic stationary phase and its chromatographic performance was systematically investigated with different types of analytes as probes. The results revealed that the CB(6)/SiO₂ stationary phase exhibited weak hydrophobic and strong hydrophilic properties. Hence, the variables for hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography, including components and pH of the mobile phase, were further investigated to explore the retention mechanism of this CB(6)/SiO₂ stationary phase. For less polar analytes, both hydrophobic and hydrophilic interactions could contribute to the retention, while for polar analytes, hydrophilic interaction may be predominant. Compared to the tetraethoxylsilane‐coated SiO₂ stationary phases, the CB(6)/SiO₂ stationary phase exhibited a different retention behavior toward basic analytes with excellent stability. It is a novel promising hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography stationary phase.     

New Fluorous Reversed Phase Silica Gels for HPLC Separations of Perfluorinated Compounds

Two new perfluoroalkyl-modified stationary phases were prepared and compared with two commercially available perfluorinated stationary phases (Fluophase RP and Fluophase Pentafluorophenyl) and a C₁₈-RP column with respect to retention times of an array of perfluoroalkyl-tagged and untagged molecules. A few highly lipophilic compounds were also included in the study. They showed high retention times on C₁₈-RP columns, but not on perfluorinated support materials. Perfluoroalkyl-tagged compounds revealed a weak interaction with the pentafluorophenyl-modified support. The interaction between perfluoroalkyl-tagged compounds and perfluoroalkyl-modified stationary phases was strong, and dependent on the chain length of the perfluoro tags. Surprisingly, there was only a small difference between the retention times of perfluorinated compounds on C₁₈-RP and C₆F₁₃-modified support. Fluorous-fluorous interactions became prevalent only with C₈F₁₇-tagged compounds on C₈F₁₇ functionalized silica gel. Compounds with two perfluoro tags showed a drastic increase in retention time, which might be due to a cooperative effect. These results demonstrate the uniqueness of fluorous-fluorous interactions based on linear perfluoroalkyl chains and open up possibilities for the design of new perfluoro tags for purifications and noncovalent attachments of catalysts or biomolecules on perfluorinated solid supports.     

Relationships between Retention Factors and Analyte Hydrophobicity on Cyanopropyl and n‐Octadecyl Bonded Silicas,Cross‐Linked Polymers and Porous Graphitic Carbon Stationary Phases. Consequences for the Trace Analysis of Highly Polar Organic Compounds

LC retention data have been measured using various stationary phases with an emphasis on highly polar to moderately polar neutral organic compounds having octanol‐water partition coefficients (K_ow) in log units between 0 and 3. The relationships between the retention factor measured in water and the octanol‐water partition coefficient are linear but with different slopes for octadecyl (C₁₈) silicas, and two polystyrene divinylbenzene (PS‐DVB) phases with low and high surface areas. These relationships confirm that highly cross‐linked polymers can provide more than 1000‐times higher retention values than C₁₈ silicas for moderately polar analytes but close values for highly polar ones. They also explain why C₁₈ silicas and polymers are equivalent for the separation of very polar analytes. In contrast, due to a different retention mechanism, no relation exists between the retention shown by porous graphitic carbons (PGC) and analyte hydrophobicity, but highly polar analytes are in general much more strongly retained than by any other sorbent. The potential of PGC for both the extraction and the separation of analytes is shown. Due to the difference in separation mechanism, PGC is the analytical phase that should be used for confirmation of the identity of analytes instead of a cyanopropylsilica column as recommended in some environmental procedures. Applications are presented for the trace‐determination of triazines and polar degradation products in ground and surface water with detection limits below the 0.1 μg/L level.     

Dual‐mode hydrophilic interaction normal phase and reversed phase liquid chromatography of polar compounds on a single column

Adopting a stationary phase convention circumvents problematic definition of the boundary between the stationary and the mobile phase in the liquid chromatography, resulting in thermodynamically consistent and reproducible chromatographic data. Three stationary phase definition conventions provide different retention data, but equal selectivity: (i) the complete solid phase moiety; (ii) the solid porous part carrying the active interaction centers; (iii) the volume of the inner column pores. The selective uptake of water from the bulk aqueous‐organic mobile phase significantly affects the volume and the properties of polar stationary phases. Some polar stationary phases provide dual‐mode retention mechanism in aqueous‐organic mobile phases, reversed‐phase in the water‐rich range, and normal‐phase at high concentrations of the organic solvent in water. The linear solvation energy relationship model characterizes the structural contributions of the non‐selective and selective polar interactions both in the water‐rich and organic solvent‐rich mobile phases. The inner‐pore convention provides a single hold‐up volume value for the retention prediction on the dual‐mode columns over the full mobile phase range. Using the dual‐mode monolithic polymethacrylate zwitterionic micro‐columns alternatively in each mode in the first dimension of two‐dimensional liquid chromatography, in combination with a short reversed‐phase column in the second dimension, provides enhanced sample information.     

Micellar Liquid Chromatography Study of Quantitative Retention–Activity Relationships for Antihypertensive Drugs

Use of micellar mobile phases in reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC) results in hydrophobic and electrostatic sites for interaction. Modified stationary phases in micellar liquid chromatography (MLC) are structurally similar to biomembranes. To confirm this we focused on the effects of the type and concentration of surfactant (Brij 35, SDS, and CTAB) and mobile phase pH on the retention of antihypertensive drugs on modified C₁₈ stationary phases. Quantitative retention-activity relationships are proposed for the drugs and the different surfactants and compared with those obtained using aqueous–organic mobile phases. Finally, a correlation was obtained between the logarithm of retention factors (log k) and the toxicity (LD₅₀) of antihypertensive drugs. Revised: 14 September 2005 and 4 April 2006     

Study of RP HPLC Retention Behaviours in Analysis of Carotenoids

For determination of selected carotenoids, various types of columns for high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) with different properties have been used. The characteristics of the laboratory-used packing material containing monomeric alkyl-bonded phases (C₁₈, C₃₀) and phenyl as well as phenyl-hexyl stationary phases were studied. The retention data of the examined compounds were used to determine the hydrophobicity and silanol activity of stationary phases applied in the study. The presence of the polar and carboxyl groups in the structure of the bonded ligand strongly influences the polarity of the stationary phase. Columns were compared according to methylene selectivity using a series of benzene homologues. The measurements were done using a methanol–water mobile phase. Knowledge of the properties of the applied stationary phase provided the possibility to predict the RP HPLC retention behaviours in analysis of carotenoids including lutein, lycopene and β-carotene. The composition of the mobile phase, the addition of triethylamine and the type of stationary phase had been taken into account in designing the method of carotenoid identification. Also a monolithic column characterised by low hydrodynamic resistance, high porosity and high permeability was applied. The presented results show that the coverage density of the bonded ligands on silica gel packings and length of the linkage strongly influence the carotenoid retention behaviours. In our study, the highest retention parameters for lutein, lycopene and β-carotene were observed for C₃₀ and C₁₈ stationary phase. This effect corresponds with pore size of column packing greater than 100 Å and carbon content higher than 11 %.     

Separation behavior of basic compounds on unbonded silicon oxynitride and silica high‐performance liquid chromatography stationary phases with reversed‐phase eluents

Unbonded silicon oxynitride and silica high‐performance liquid chromatography stationary phases have been evaluated and compared for the separation of basic compounds of differing molecular weight, pK_a, and log D using aqueous/organic mobile phases. The influences of percentage of organic modifier, buffer pH, and concentration in the mobile phase on base retention were investigated on unbonded silicon oxynitride and silica phases. The results confirmed that unbonded silicon oxynitride and silica phases demonstrated excellent separation performance for model basic compounds and both the unbonded phases examined possessed a hydrophobic/adsorption and ion‐exchange character. The silicon oxynitride stationary phase exhibited high hydrophilicity compared with silica with a reversed‐phase mobile phase. An ion‐exclusion‐type mechanism becomes predominant for the separation of three aimed bases on the silicon oxynitride column at pH 2.8. Different from silicon oxynitride stationary phase, no obvious change for the retention time of three model bases on silica stationary phase at pH 2.8 can be observed.     

Comparison of a C30 Bonded Silica Column and Columns with Shorter Bonded Ligands in Reversed-Phase LC

The Carotenoid S is a new C₃₀ bonded silica stationary phase, intended for reversed-phase chromatographic applications, which is more hydrophobic and consequently shows stronger retention in comparison to conventionally used C₁₈ stationary phases. We compared the non-polar selectivities of the columns for homologous alkylbenzenes in acetonitrile—water and methanol–water mobile phases and polar reversed-phase selectivities employing the interaction indices and the Linear Free Energy Relationship models. Further, we investigated possibilities of separations of structurally closely related compounds in the groups of phenolic acids, flavones, phthalic acids and related compounds and of acylglycerols on the new C₃₀ column and with different types of columns for reversed-phase chromatography, including shorter alkyl C₄, C₈, C₁₈ and phenyl bonded stationary phases. The C₃₀ column has in some aspects properties similar to the non-endcapped Nova-Pak column for separation of some acylglycerols with equal equivalent carbon numbers, but enables separations of longer chain triacylglycerols in a single gradient run.

     

Effect of water on the retention on diol and amide columns in hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography

The amount of water adsorbed on polar columns plays important role in hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography. It may strongly differ for the individual types of polar columns used in this separation mode. We measured adsorption isotherms of water on an amide and three diol‐bonded stationary phases that differ in the chemistry of the bonded ligands and properties of the silica gel support. We studied the effects of the adsorbed water on the retention of aromatic carboxylic acids, flavonoids, benzoic acid derivatives, nucleic bases, and nucleosides in aqueous‐acetonitrile mobile phases over the full composition range. The graphs of the retention factors versus the volume fraction of water in mobile phase show “U‐profile” characteristic of a dual hydrophilic interaction–reversed phase retention mechanism. The minimum on the graph that marks the changing retention mechanism depends on the amount of adsorbed water. The linear solvation energy relationship model suggests that the retention in the hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography mode is controlled mainly by proton–donor interactions in the stationary phase, depending on the column type. Finally, the accuracy of hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography gradient prediction improves for columns that show a high water adsorption.