Instrumental validation in capillary electrophoresis and checkpoints for method validation

Capillary electrophoresis (CE) is increasingly being used in regulated and testing environments which demand validation. The design, development and production of CE instrumentation should be governed by qualifications which ensure the quality of the finished product. The vendor should therefore provide guidelines and procedures which assist the user in ensuring the adequate operation of the instrumentation and especially in designing installation qualification (IQ) and operational qualification/performance verification (OQ/PV) procedures. OQ/PV should test those functions of an instrument which directly affect the CE analysis, i.e. voltage, temperature, injection precision and detector function. In validation of CE methods care should be taken that those aspects which directly affect the precision of peak parameters are appreciated. The relationship between CE instrumentation, chemistry and validation parameters is discussed and guidelines are presented for definition of a CE method for submission to regulatory authorities.     

Method validation and qualification of instruments for atomic spectrometry

This work describes the analytical procedures for atomic absorption and inductively coupled plasma (ICP) techniques that have to be used in order to obtain a license to sell drugs in the USA. The qualification of atomic absorption spectrometers and ICP instruments is described. The method validation characteristics, e.g., accuracy, precision, linearity, range, detection limits, and quantification are discussed. The time involved and the quality of documentation are pointed out. The consequences for laboratory personnel and operating costs are also discussed.     

Infrared-based temperature measurements in capillary electrophoresis

In capillary electrophoresis (CE), the temperature inside the capillary is one of the most important parameters. In a concept for Analytical Instrument Qualification (AIQ) of CE systems, the temperature accuracy and stability have to be included. This fact requires an accurate look at the measurement of temperature which is generated by the applied electrical power. The generation of Joule heating is measured on the outside of the capillary using an infrared (IR) thermometer. The thermometer linearity is demonstrated over a wide range of various electrical field strength, buffer systems, and different capillary inner diameters. A slope of 6.3 °C m/W was found for the optimal thermometer capillary distance of 8 mm. Furthermore, the temperature measurements are highly precise, depending almost solely on the current variability. The proposed method is compared with three methods calculating the temperature from the conductance, the electroosmotic velocity, or the current. These indirect methods estimate slopes ranging from 7 to 10 °C m/W. In addition, the maximal suitable electrical power per unit length is estimated. Joule heating can often be tolerated up to 4 W/m. However, sensitive analytes can already be affected by using more than 1 W/m. In conclusion, the consideration of the temperature is essential for not only Analytical Instrument Qualification, but also certainly useful for method optimisation and method transfer.     

Separation and quantification of paraquat and diquat in serum and urine by capillary electrophoresis

The use of capillary electrophoresis (CE) for simultaneous qualitative and quantitative detection of paraquat (PQ) and diquat (DQ) in both serum and urine was investigated. The two herbicides were extracted from biological fluids with liquefied phenol. Serum required a deproteinization with chloroform and ammonium sulfate as pretreatment. The extracts were hydrodynamically injected and the complete separation was carried out in 10 min, using a capillary tube (75 microm i.d., 500 mm) of fused silica containing 50 mM phosphate buffer (pH 2.50) as the carrier. UV absorbance detection at 200 nm was performed by an on-column detector. The analytes were characterized by their respective migration times. Analytical recoveries were 52.6% for PQ and 62.6% for DQ in serum, and 71.4% and 59.3%, respectively, in urine. The linearity was studied up to 4 mg/L and the limits of detection (LODs) were better than 5 pg/mL in serum or urine. The CE method described was applied to the characterization of two lethal poisonings and results were related.     

Selecting parameters and limits for equipment operational qualification

While operational qualification (OQ) is a well-established term within equipment qualification, users of equipment often become unsure when it comes to implementation. The biggest problem is how to select procedures and acceptance criteria. Should these be the vendor's specifications or should the users define their own limits, and, if so, how? Should all instruments of the same type have the same values or should these be optimized for each individual instrument? This article will provide an overall strategy and specific examples for HPLC on how to select procedures and acceptance limits that are based on efficient use of resources, on practicality and on the intended use of the equipment.     

Quality control of piperaquine in pharmaceutical formulations by capillary zone electrophoresis

Quality control (QC) is of great importance since the pharmaceutical quality not only directly affects the curative effect of the drugs, but also relates to human health and safety closely. Capillary electrophoresis (CE) has recently become a good alternative for pharmaceutical analysis and a complementary technique to high-performance liquid chromatography since it possesses many unique advantages. In this contribution, we propose a simple and reliable capillary zone electrophoretic method for the detection of piperaquine (PQ) in pharmaceutical formulations in terms of quality control, which might be of use to those working on similar compounds. The influence of buffer type, buffer pH, buffer concentration, buffer additive, applied voltage, capillary temperature and injection amount was systemically investigated and the proposed method was then successfully applied to the quality control of piperaquine in its pharmaceutical formulations. With quinine (QN) as an internal standard to improve precision, this method was suitably validated with respect to the linearity, limit of detection and quantification, accuracy, precision, specificity and stability.     

A 14 Parameter Study of UHPLC’s for Method Development Transfer and Troubleshooting

Five ultra-high pressure liquid chromatography (UHPLC) instruments were compared to one another by examining the overall system performance and key functions of the system parts including: pump, auto-sampler, thermo-stated column compartment, and the detector. The five UHPLC systems used in this study were: ThermoFisher Vanquish, Agilent 1290 Infinity I, Agilent 1290 Infinity II, Waters Acquity I-Class, and Shimadzu Nexera X2. The identities of the systems were blinded in the results and discussion section to use this study for scientific purposes only rather than for competition and marketing. The following tests were performed to evaluate and compare the five UHPLC systems: injector linearity and precision, sample carryover, sample (autosampler) temperature accuracy, column temperature accuracy and precision, pressure ripple, pump mixing accuracy, flow rate accuracy, detector drift and noise, detector linearity, wavelength accuracy, extra-column volume, and dwell volume determination. This study presents an approach on how to test the performance of UHPLC systems along with potential problems that analysts may face when using the UHPLC systems, examples of such issues are: retention time irreproducibility, low sensitivity, method transfer failure, etc.     

Equipment qualification and its application to conductivity measuring systems

It is only possible to obtain analytical results that are suitable for their intended purpose if the equipment used is capable of producing measurements of the required quality. To ensure that this requirement is met, analysts should define the performance criteria required from the instruments, ensure that only suitable instruments are selected for analytical measurements, and confirm that these instruments continue to meet these criteria for their entire operational life. This process should be conducted on a formal, documented basis, known as equipment qualification. In addition to describing the key elements of equipment qualification for all analytical instruments, this paper gives specific guidance on its application to conductivity systems that has never previously appeared in the literature. The benefits of performing equipment qualification are highlighted and guidance is given on the selection of control standards and why the equipment vendor performing stages of equipment qualification can be of benefit to the user. The relationship between equipment qualification and method validation is discussed, including how these activities play a major role in determining the quality control measures that should be applied to routine analysis.     

Automation and validation of HPLC-systems

Summary The automation of chromatographic systems is of increasing interest to industry and research laboratories in routine applications. Besides potentially saving time or making better use of available instrumentation, automation also improves the quality of results by producing more precise and more reproducible HPLC data. The need for the validation of methods and qualification of instruments is increasingly recognised in order to ensure compliance with legal requirements (e.g. in the pharmaceutical industry) and to ensure the reliability of analytical results. Possibilities and requirements for automated HPLC systems are elaborated. Emphasis is placed on defining the goals of validation and on discussing different aspects of the validation of LC methods, system suitability tests, ruggedness of methods and the transfer of LC methods from laboratory to laboratory. Adequate strategies of HPLC method development provide very useful information on the validation and ruggedness of LC methods.     

Dead volume–free flow splitting in capillary electrophoresis

In recent years, several dual detection concepts (DDCs) for CE were developed, which consisted of at least one nondestructive detector. For these DDCs, a linear detector arrangement could be used, which is not possible when both detectors are destructive. To overcome this problem, we developed a concept for the splitting of the CE stream utilizing commercially available flow splitters (FSs) that allow the parallel positioning of two destructive detectors. In this proof-of-concept study, T- and Y-shaped FSs were characterized regarding their suitability for DDCs. To keep it simple, a UV detector (UV) and a C⁴D were used for the characterization. The model system consisted of an acetonitrile-based background electrolyte and the two model substances, (ferrocenylmethyl)trimethylammonium iodide and caffeine. CE hyphenated to a UV detector (CE-UV) measurements revealed that the split ratio was about 50% for both FSs. CE-C⁴D was used to evaluate the peak shape in front of and behind the FSs. These measurements showed that there was no significant peak broadening introduced by the FSs. Additionally, there were no changes in the LODs in front of and behind the FSs. Furthermore, the flexibility of the new FS approach allowed the usage of capillaries with different ids (25–75 µm) for injection and detection.     

Development and validation of a capillary electrophoresis method for the characterization of protegrin IB-367.

A capillary electrophoresis (CE) method was developed to characterize protegrin IB-367, an antimicrobial peptide being developed for the treatment of oral mucositis and for other topical applications. The electrophoretic purity and levels of potential impurities/degradation products of IB-367 drug substance are determined by CE using area normalization. Electrophoresis parameters were optimized to allow optimal resolution, reproducibility and minimal analysis time. The separation and resolution between this polycationic peptide and truncated analogs determined by the CE method was much greater than those by the HPLC methods. In addition, the CE methods separates the potential impurities/degradation products from each other while the HPLC methods failed to resolve them. The CE method was validated in the aspects of accuracy, precision, linearity, range, limit of detection, limit of quantitation, specificity, system suitability and robustness. An internal standard was used for the quantitation purpose. The selection criteria of the internal standard as well as the method validation results are presented. The truncated peptide analogs were used to demonstrate the specificity of the method. These analogs were also used to evaluate the limit of quantitation of potential impurities. The relative response factors of these analogs were assessed to determine area normalization feasibility. System suitability tests were established.     

Capillary electrophoresis and ultra-high-performance liquid chromatography methods in clinical monitoring of creatinine in human urine: A comparative study

Creatinine is an important diagnostic marker and is also used as a standardization tool for the quantitative evaluation of exogenous/endogenous substances in urine. This study aimed at evaluating and comparing three analytical approaches, based on hyphenations of different separation [two-dimensional capillary isotachophoresis (CITP–CITP), capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE), ultra-high-performance liquid chromatography (UHPLC)] and detection [conductivity (CD), ultraviolet (UV), tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS)] techniques, for their ability to provide reliable clinical data along with their suitability for the routine clinical use (cost, simplicity, sample throughput). The developed UHPLC–MS/MS, CITP–CITP–CD, and CZE–UV methods were characterized by favorable performance parameters, such as linearity (r ˃ 0.99), precision (relative standard deviation, 0.22–2.97% for the creatinine position in analytical profiles), and recovery (87.1–115.1%). Clinical data, obtained from the analysis of 24 human urine samples by a reference enzymatic method, were comparable with those obtained by the tested methods (Passing–Bablok regression and Bland–Altman analysis), approving their usefulness for the routine clinical use. In this context, the UHPLC–MS/MS method provides benefits of enhanced orthogonality/accuracy and high sample throughput (threefold shorter total analysis times than the CE methods), whereas advantages of the CE methods for routine labs are simplicity and low cost of both the instrumentation and measurements.     

Method development and validation for the determination of indiquinoline tartrate, a novel kappa opioid agonist, and its related substances by high-performance liquid chromatography

A stability-indicating reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography method has been developed and validated for the assay of indiquinoline tartrate and its related substances. The method was established by forced degradation experiments and system suitability experiments. The chromatographic separation was achieved with a Hedera ODS-3 column (5 μm, 250 mm × 4.6 mm) and the mobile phase was constituted (flow rate 1.0 mL/min) of eluant A, aqueous acetate buffer and eluant B, CH(3)OH using a gradient elution. A photodiode array detector set at 254 nm was used for detection. The investigated validation elements showed that the method has acceptable specificity, accuracy, linearity, precision, robustness and high sensitivity with limit of detection and limit of quantitation. The method can be used for routine quality control analysis and stability testing of indiquinoline tartrate drug substance.     

Multivariate optimisation and validation of a capillary electrophoresis method for the analysis of resveratrol in a nutraceutical

A rapid and simple method based on capillary electrophoresis was developed for the quality control of nutraceuticals containing resveratrol. Setting the UV detector at 280nm, the optimisation involved the separation of 11 effervescent tablet components, including the active compounds vitamin C, vitamin B(2), flavanones and hydroxycinnamic acids. Flufenamic acid was employed as internal standard. The effects of background electrolyte concentration, acetonitrile percentage and voltage were investigated by means of response surface methodology, considering as responses the critical resolution values and analysis time. The optimum conditions were found by Derringer desirability function. The background electrolyte consisted of 23mM borate buffer, adjusted to pH 10.0 with 1M sodium hydroxide, containing 7% (v/v) acetonitrile. Temperature and voltage were set at 25 degrees C and 26kV, respectively. Applying these conditions, the analysis time was below 7min. The performances of the method were tested in terms of selectivity, robustness, linearity and range, accuracy and precision and system suitability, following ICH guidelines.     

Problems of validation of computerised instruments for accredited chemical laboratories

 Some problems of validation of computerised instruments are reviewed briefly, taking essential standards and guides into account. The significant role of certified standard reference materials is underlined. An attitude of suppliers towards the validation of instruments is presented, and producers' responsibilities and obligations are discussed. The "black-box" concept is recommended as a preliminary step for the validation of computerised instruments. Two examples for gel permeation chromatography are given that illustrate a bad manufacturer's practice (BMP) and good manufacturer's practice (GMP). In the case of BMP, a need is expressed for a guide and for regulations that should be implemented into the quality assurance system. It has been proposed that the EURACHEM/VAM draft of guidance for qualification/validation of instruments should be amended by incorporating the "black-box" approach as a preliminary procedure for validation of computerised instruments, a retrospective validation procedure if the need for current validation was not foreseen or not specified, and a procedure (or selection rules) for qualification of the supplier. Moreover, the mechanisms of inspection to control the observance of the standardised rules and commonly recognised recommendations should also be considered by international quality organisations. Received: 19 November 1996 · Accepted: 20 March 1997     

Electrospray ionization stability and concentration sensitivity in capillary electrophoresis-mass spectrometry using a flow-through microvial interface

Concentration sensitivity is a key performance indicator for analytical techniques including for capillary electrophoresis-mass spectrometry (CE–MS) with electrospray ionization (ESI). In this study, a flow-through microvial interface was used to couple CE with MS and improve the ESI stability and detection sensitivity. By infusing a peptide mixture through the interface into an MS detector at a typical flow rate for CE-MS analysis, the spatial region near the interface was mapped for MS signal intensity. When the sprayer tip was within a 6 × 6.5 × 5 mm region in front of the MS inlet, the ESI was stable with no significant loss of signal intensity for ions with m/z 239. Finite element simulations showed that the average electric field strength at the emitter tip did not change significantly with minor changes in emitter tip location. Experiments were conducted with four different mass spectrometer platforms coupled to CE via the flow-through microvial interface. Key performance indicators, that is, limit of detection (LOD) and linearity of calibration curves were measured for nine amino acids and five peptides. Inter- and intraday reproducibility were also tested. The results were shown to be suitable for quantification when internal standards were used.     

Multi-purpose capillary electrophoresis system with concentration gradient detection

A robust, inexpensive and versatile capillary electrophoresis (CE) system for routine and rapid analysis is reported, which consists of a rugged cartridge holding a 20-mum i.d. 15-cm long capillary, and an inexpensive, universal and sensitive concentration gradient detector. The design of the cartridge simplifies the sample introduction process and makes it possible to perform many separation modes, including moving boundary capillary electrophoresis (MBCE), capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE), capillary isotachophoresis (CITP) and capillary isoelectric focusing (CIEF), on the same system. This arrangement provides more information about a sample's components since analytes can be separated by different modes performed on the same CE system. The detector only consists of a low-power HeNe laser, or laser diode, and a photodiode position sensor. Amino acids and proteins of 10(-6)-10(-3)M concentration can be separated by different capillary electrophoretic modes, and detected directly by the detector. The universal detector shows particularly good sensitivity when applied to CE separation modes having self-concentration and focusing effects. Femtomoles of proteins were separated and detected with CIEF. In addition, a short and narrow capillary allows use of high electrical fields which facilitate rapid separations. Four amino acids at millimolar concentrations were fully separated and detected in less than 80 sec by the MBCE mode when a high electric field was applied. The physical size of the whole system is much smaller than that of conventional CE instruments with UV absorbance or fluorescence detector.     

色谱类分析仪器性能确认用标准物质的筛选

分析仪器验证是制药、食品、环境等多个行业实验室质量管理的重点,为解决我国色谱类分析仪器验证评价体系中缺乏统一标准物质的问题,提出了筛选性能确认行业推荐用标准物质的原则。通过分析不同行业色谱类分析仪器标准物质使用情况和国家标准及有证标准物质的发布现状,以筛选原则为指导,筛选出93种高效液相色谱性能确认用标准物质。为保证分析仪器的稳定性和可靠性提供了标准依据。     

Copper-coated microsprayer interface for on-line sheathless capillary electrophoresis electrospray mass spectrometry of carbohydrates

A sturdy home-built sheathless CE/ESI-QTOF-MS system was developed and optimized for carbohydrate analysis. The interface and employed methodology provided a simple analytical solution to laborious CE/MS interfacing methods and to problems in characterization of complex carbohydrate mixtures that require high-resolution separation of the components. The CE/ESI interface, feasible in any MS laboratory, consists of a one-piece CE column having the CE terminus in-laboratory shaped as a microsprayer and coated with copper. The CE microsprayer was inserted into an in-house made stainless steel clenching device and the whole assembly was mounted onto a quadrupole TOF mass spectrometer. The analytical potential of the interface in terms of suitability, microsprayer performance, copper coat durability, ionization efficiency, spray stability, and sensitivity was tested first on a simple mixture of standard saccharides, which were separated, resolved, and detected with high separation efficiency. The approach was next assessed for the screening of a biological sample, a complex mixture of O-glycosylated sialylated amino acids from urine of a patient suffering from Schindler disease. Preliminary data allow this method to be considered as one of general applicability in structural glycobiology and glycomics and easy to be implemented for proteomic surveys as well.     

The next generation of capillary electrophoresis instruments: Performance of CE‐SDS protein analysis

Over the last decade, capillary electrophoresis gained tremendous importance, because it became an indispensible tool for the quality control of biologics, e.g. therapeutic antibodies. Consequently, there has been a continuous development within the CE market. Microchip techniques have been established in the last years. Further trends are complete solutions for specific applications by the usage of reagent kits. Step by step instructions and facilitated handling of the instruments are becoming more common. This work focuses on the sized‐based protein analysis with CE‐SDS. The instruments CE 7100 by Agilent Technologies, LabChip® GXII Touch HT by PerkinElmer, Maurice S. by Protein Simple and PrinCE NextI870 by Prince Technologies have been evaluated, mainly analyzing protein mixtures of different molecular weights in long series. Published data of the PA 800 plus by SCIEX are also included in the tabled results. Precision, reliability, flexibility, and speed have been identified as the most important performance parameters, others such as resolution, sensitivity, linearity, ease of use and sustainability have also been considered. All tested instruments have shown an excellent performance. Depending on application and necessities, each user can find the most appropriate one.