The Potential Scope of the Ultrasonic Surface Reflection Method Towards Mechanical Characterisation of Isotropic Materials. Part 2. Experimental Results

Background

This paper is Part 2 of a study on the scope of the ultrasonic Surface Reflection Method (SRM). Part 1 deals with the theoretical conditions for a satisfactory usage of this method.

Objective

This second part validates the practical feasibility and reliability of the SRM method by comparison with the conventional Transmission Method (TM) in cases where the latter is applicable.

Methods

Two experimental devices (one for SRM and one for TM) are developed and measurements of shear and bulk moduli are carried out at ultrasonic frequency (610 kHz) and at room temperature.

Results

The experimental conditions in terms of sample geometry, pulse characteristics and interfacial transmission required to obtain a given accuracy on the measurement are stated. The SRM is then validated against other experimental methods and is used to determine the shear modulus of a carbon black filled neoprene at ambient temperature (T?=?21 °C) and ultrasonic frequency.

Conclusions

The benefit brought by this method is well demonstrated: a unique measurement allows the determination of all the moduli of a highly damping isotropic material (carbon black filled neoprene) not achievable by other methods.

     

The Potential Scope of the Ultrasonic Surface Reflection Method Towards Mechanical Characterisation of Isotropic Materials. Part 1. A Theoretical Analysis

Background

This paper deals with the possible field of application of ultrasonic Surface Reflection Method (SRM) to achieve the mechanical characteristics of isotropic materials. This method is based on the measurement of the amplitude of the reflected wave at the interface between reference material and the material to be characterised. Objective: The purpose of Part 1 of this paper is to establish the theoretical conditions for the applicability of SRM.

Methods

First, the theoretical formulas necessary to obtain the mechanical properties of the material to be tested will be established. Then, on the basis of these analytical formulas, the validity of the results for the material to be studied will be discussed according to the choice of the mechanical properties of the reference material through uncertainty calculations. The measurand error of SRM is then compared to that of traditional methods (transmission, transmission in water bath, pulse-echo).

Results

The analytical solution to the inverse problem (the mechanical characteristics of the tested medium based on those of the reference medium and the waves’ amplitude) will be given. From this analytical solution, an analysis of the measurand error will be performed and a method for choosing the reference material will be proposed.

Conclusions

It appears that SRM is better suited than traditional methods in two specific cases: measurement of small deviations of mechanical properties from a reference material or characterisation of high damping materials. In Part 2 of this paper, the practical conditions of applicability of the method are described and then applied to different kinds of materials.