Ion mobility-mass spectrometry

This review article compares and contrasts various types of ion mobility-mass spectrometers available today and describes their advantages for application to a wide range of analytes. Ion mobility spectrometry (IMS), when coupled with mass spectrometry, offers value-added data not possible from mass spectra alone. Separation of isomers, isobars, and conformers; reduction of chemical noise; and measurement of ion size are possible with the addition of ion mobility cells to mass spectrometers. In addition, structurally similar ions and ions of the same charge state can be separated into families of ions which appear along a unique mass-mobility correlation line. This review describes the four methods of ion mobility separation currently used with mass spectrometry. They are (1) drift-time ion mobility spectrometry (DTIMS), (2) aspiration ion mobility spectrometry (AIMS), (3) differential-mobility spectrometry (DMS) which is also called field-asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) and (4) traveling-wave ion mobility spectrometry (TWIMS). DTIMS provides the highest IMS resolving power and is the only IMS method which can directly measure collision cross-sections. AIMS is a low resolution mobility separation method but can monitor ions in a continuous manner. DMS and FAIMS offer continuous-ion monitoring capability as well as orthogonal ion mobility separation in which high-separation selectivity can be achieved. TWIMS is a novel method of IMS with a low resolving power but has good sensitivity and is well intergrated into a commercial mass spectrometer. One hundred and sixty references on ion mobility-mass spectrometry (IMMS) are provided.     

Formation of multimeric steroid metal adducts and implications for isomer mixture separation by traveling wave ion mobility spectrometry

Steroid analysis is essential to the fields of medicine and forensics, but such analyses can present some complex analytical challenges. While chromatographic methods require long acquisition times and often provide incomplete separation, ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) as coupled to mass spectrometry (MS) has demonstrated significant promise for the separation of steroids, particularly in concert with metal adduction and multimerization. In this study, traveling wave ion mobility spectrometry (TWIMS) was employed to separate multimer steroid metal adducts of isomers in mixtures. The results show the ability to separate steroid isomers with a decrease in resolution compared with single component standards because of the formation of heteromultimers. Additionally, ion‐neutral collision cross sections (CCS) of the species studied were measured in the mixtures and compared with CCSs obtained in single component standards. Good agreement between these values suggests that the CCS may aid in identification of unknowns. Furthermore, a complex mixture composed of five sets of steroid isomers were analyzed, and distinct features for each steroid component were identified. This study further demonstrated the potential of TWIMS‐MS methods for the rapid and isomer‐specific study of steroids in biological samples for use either in tandem with or without chromatographic separation.     

Supercharging Protein Complexes from Aqueous Solution Disrupts their Native Conformations

The effects of aqueous solution supercharging on the solution- and gas-phase structures of two protein complexes were investigated using traveling-wave ion mobility-mass spectrometry (TWIMS-MS). Low initial concentrations of m-nitrobenzyl alcohol (m-NBA) in the electrospray ionization (ESI) solution can effectively increase the charge of concanavalin A dimers and tetramers, but at higher m-NBA concentrations, the increases in charge are accompanied by solution-phase dissociation of the dimers and up to a ~22% increase in the collision cross section (CCS) of the tetramers. With just 0.8% m-NBA added to the ESI solution of a ~630 kDa anthrax toxin octamer complex, the average charge is increased by only ~4% compared with the “native” complex, but it is sufficiently destabilized so that extensive gas-phase fragmentation occurs in the relatively high pressure regions of the TWIMS device. Anthrax toxin complexes exist in either a prechannel or a transmembrane channel state. With m-NBA, the prechannel state of the complex has the same CCS/charge ratio in the gas phase as the transmembrane channel state of the same complex formed without m-NBA, yet undergoes extensive dissociation, indicating that destabilization from supercharging occurs in the ESI droplet prior to ion formation and is not a result of Coulombic destabilization in the gas phase as a result of higher charging. These results demonstrate that the supercharging of large protein complexes is the result of conformational changes induced by the reagents in the ESI droplets, where enrichment of the supercharging reagent during droplet evaporation occurs.     

Isomer separation and gas-phase configurations of organoruthenium anticancer complexes: Ion mobility mass spectrometry and modeling

We have used ion mobility-mass spectrometry combined with molecular modeling for the separation and configurational analysis of three low-molecular-weight isomeric organoruthenium anticancer complexes containing ortho-, meta-, or para-terphenyl arene ligands. The isomers were separated using ion mobility based on traveling-wave technology and the experimentally determined collision cross sections were compared to theoretical calculations. Excellent agreement was observed between the experimentally and theoretically derived measurements.     

Characterizing ion mobility and collision cross section of fatty acids using electrospray ion mobility mass spectrometry

This study investigated the ion mobility (IM) and the collision cross section (CCS) of fatty acids (FAs) using electrospray IM MS. The IM analysis of 18 FA ions showed intriguing differences among the saturated FAs, monounsaturated FAs, multi‐unsaturated FAs, and cis‐isomer/trans‐isomer with respect to the aliphatic tail chains. The length of aliphatic tail chain present in the ion structures had a strong influence on the differentiation of drift, while the number of double bond showed a weaker influence. The tiny drift differences between cis‐isomer and trans‐isomer were also observed. In the CCS measurements, two internal standards were involved in the mobility calibration and accuracy estimation. It insured our empirical CCS values were of high experimental precision (±0.35% or better) and accuracy (±0.25% or better). Moreover, the mass‐to‐charge ratio (m/z) – mobility plots obtained by ion mobility spectrometry with mass spectrometry analysis of FAs – was used to investigate the structural relationship between the molecules. Each series of FAs sharing a similar structure was aligned in the linear plot. Finally, the developed procedure was applied to the determination of FAs in rat adipose tissues, and it allowed the presence of 13 FAs to be confirmed with their exact masses and CCS values. These studies reveal the direct relationship between the behaviors in IM and the molecular structures and thus may provide further validations to the FA identification process. Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Towards the analysis of high molecular weight proteins and protein complexes using TIMS-MS

In the present work, we demonstrate the potential and versatility of TIMS for the analysis of proteins, DNA-protein complexes and protein-protein complexes in their native and denatured states. In addition, we show that accurate CCS measurement are possible using internal and external mobility calibration and in good agreement with previously reported CCS values using other IMS analyzers (<5 % difference). The main challenges for the TIMS-MS analysis of high mass proteins and protein complexes in the mobility and m/z domain are described. That is, the analysis of high molecular weight systems in their native state may require the use of higher electric fields or a small compromise in the TIMS mobility resolution by reducing the bath gas velocity in order to effectively trap at lower electric fields. This is the first report of CCS measurements of high molecular weight biomolecules and biomolecular complexes (~150 kDa) using TIMS-MS.     

Travelling wave ion mobility mass spectrometry studies of protein structure: biological significance and comparison with X-ray crystallography and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy measurements

The three-dimensional conformation of a protein is central to its biological function. The characterisation of aspects of three-dimensional protein structure by mass spectrometry is an area of much interest as the gas-phase conformation, in many instances, can be related to that of the solution phase. Travelling wave ion mobility mass spectrometry (TWIMS) was used to investigate the biological significance of gas-phase protein structure. Protein standards were analysed by TWIMS under denaturing and near-physiological solvent conditions and cross-sections estimated for the charge states observed. Estimates of collision cross-sections were obtained with reference to known standards with published cross-sections. Estimated cross-sections were compared with values from published X-ray crystallography and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy structures. The cross-section measured by ion mobility mass spectrometry varies with charge state, allowing the unfolding transition of proteins in the gas phase to be studied. Cross-sections estimated experimentally for proteins studied, for charge states most indicative of native structure, are in good agreement with measurements calculated from published X-ray and NMR structures. The relative stability of gas-phase structures has been investigated, for the proteins studied, based on their change in cross-section with increase in charge. These results illustrate that the TWIMS approach can provide data on three-dimensional protein structures of biological relevance.     

Ion Mobility-Mass Spectrometry Reveals Conformational Changes in Charge Reduced Multiprotein Complexes

Characterizing intact multiprotein complexes in terms of both their mass and size by ion mobility-mass spectrometry is becoming an increasingly important tool for structural biology. Furthermore, the charge states of intact protein complexes can dramatically influence the information content of gas-phase measurements performed. Specifically, protein complex charge state has a demonstrated influence upon the conformation, mass resolution, ion mobility resolution, and dissociation properties of protein assemblies upon collisional activation. Here we present the first comparison of charge-reduced multiprotein complexes generated by solution additives and gas-phase ion-neutral reaction chemistry. While the charge reduction mechanism for both methods is undoubtedly similar, significant gas-phase activation of the complex is required to reduce the charge of the assemblies generated using the solution additive strategy employed here. This activation step can act to unfold intact protein complexes, making the data difficult to correlate with solution-phase structures and topologies. We use ion mobility-mass spectrometry to chart such conformational effects for a range of multi-protein complexes, and demonstrate that approaches to reduce charge based on ion-neutral reaction chemistry in the gas-phase consistently produce protein assemblies having compact, ‘native-like’ geometries while the same molecules added in solution generate significantly unfolded gas-phase complexes having identical charge states.     

Separation and characterization of oxidized isomeric lipid–peptide adducts by ion mobility mass spectrometry

Phospholipids are major components of cell membranes and lipoprotein complexes. They are prone to oxidation by endogenous and exogenous reactive oxygen species yielding a large variety of modified lipids including small aliphatic and phospholipid bound aldehydes and ketones. These carbonyls are strong electrophiles that can modify proteins and, thereby, alter their structures and functions triggering various pathophysiological conditions. The analysis of lipid–protein adducts by liquid chromatography‐MS is challenged by their mixed chemical nature (polar peptide and hydrophobic lipid), low abundance in biological samples, and formation of multiple isomers. Thus, we investigated traveling wave ion mobility mass spectrometry (TWIMS) to analyze lipid–peptide adducts generated by incubating model peptides corresponding to the amphipathic β₁ sheet sequence of apolipoprotein B‐100 with 1‐palmitoyl‐2‐(oxo‐nonanoyl)‐sn‐glycerophosphatidylcholine (PONPC). The complex mixture of peptides, lipids, and peptide–lipid adducts was separated by TWIMS, which was especially important for the identification of two mono‐PONPC‐peptide isomers containing Schiff bases at different lysine residues. Moreover, TWIMS separated structural conformers of one peptide–lipid adduct possessing most likely different orientations of the hydrophobic sn‐1 fatty acyl residue and head group of PONPC, relative to the peptide backbone. Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Evaluating the multiple benefits offered by ion mobility-mass spectrometry in oil and petroleum analysis

Ion mobility-mass spectrometry is starting to be considered as a useful tool in the deconvolution of complex oil and petroleum samples. While ultrahigh resolution mass spectrometry is the incumbent technology in this field, ion mobility offers complementary information related to species size and shape, and also the ability to resolve structural isomers. In this work, a sample of the resins portion of the Saturates, Aromatics, Resins, and Asphaltenes (SARA) fractions of crude oil was analysed using an orthogonal acceleration quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometer (oa-QToF MS) that incorporates a travelling wave ion mobility spectrometry (TWIMS) region. The ion mobility data were compared with previously acquired ultrahigh resolution Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry (FT-ICR MS) data and various nitrogen containing families were identified. Ion mobility data were processed in the typical way for the oil and petroleum industry; and the use of high resolution exact mass coupled with mobility data to provide enhanced species resolution was examined. Double bond equivalence (DBE) and carbon number groups were identified using patterns in the ion mobility data, which demonstrated the utility of ion mobility for discovering species relationships within the crude oil sample. The ability to calibrate the ion mobility cell and generate sizes for the detected ions was also recognised as potentially having particular value for the implementation of conversion or hydrotreatment processes in the oil industry.     

Ion mobility-mass spectrometry applied to cyclic peptide analysis: Conformational preferences of gramicidin S and linear analogs in the gas phase

In this paper, we present an investigation of the gas-phase structural differences between cyclic and linear peptide ions by matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization-ion mobility-mass spectrometry. Specifically, data is shown for gramicidin S (cyclo-VOLFPVOLFP where phenylalanines are D rather than L-type amino acids and the O designates the non-standard amino acid ornithine) and five linear gramicidin S analogues. Results are interpreted as evidence for a beta-sheet (or beta-hairpin) conformational preference in both linear-protonated and sodiated-cyclic gramicidin S gas-phase peptides, and a preference for the protonated-cyclic peptide to adopt a collapsed, random coil-type conformation. A comparison with solution-phase circular dichroism measurements is performed, and structures similar to those observed in the gas phase appear to be favored in low-dielectric solvents such as 2,2,2-triflouroethanol. The utility of ion mobility-mass spectrometry (IM-MS) as a means of rapidly distinguishing between linear and cyclic peptide forms in also discussed.     

Acid‐based approach for separation of peptide epimers using IM‐MS

Chiral molecules frequently remain undistinguishable using ion mobility mass spectrometry (IM‐MS), due to insufficient differences of their collision cross sections at the available mobility resolution of the ion mobility drift tubes. The influence of the complexation with organic acids on the ion mobility separation of peptide epimers is evaluated using traveling‐wave ion mobility (TWIMS). The examined epimeric tripeptides containing Arg residue with the sequence: Ac‐Phe‐Arg‐Trp‐NH₂ formed stable complexes in the gas phase, and under the increased pressure in ion mobility drift tube, noncovalent associates formed with carboxylic or sulfonic monoacids and diacids with chiral variation of certain acids. Overall, the complexation with an acid leads to the improvement in stereodifferentiation among epimeric peptides, in comparison to the analysis of pure epimers. Detailed characterization of peptide epimer‐acid associates obtained for dibenzoyl‐D‐tartaric acid by theoretical calculations and collisional dissociation studies revealed that the presence of multiple hydrogen bonding interactions between carboxylate anions and hydrogens from N―H of both the guanidinium group of arginine and the indole of tryptophan, as well as the amide backbone hydrogens in the peptide, is responsible for stability of acid‐peptide complexes and for their differentiation in the ion mobility drift tube. The specificity of complex formation toward Arg was determined in terms of complex stability. Based on the reported results, we present general conclusions regarding the utility of the acid‐based complexation in the separation of peptide isomers.     

Separation,Quantification and Structural Study of (+)‐Catechin and (–)‐Epicatechin by Ion Mobility Mass Spectrometry Combined with Theoretical Algorithms

Two catechin epimers and their non‐covalent complexes with γ‐cyclodextrin were studied by using ion mobility coupled with mass spectrometry (IM‐MS). Rapid separation of complexes was achieved with the peak‐to‐peak resolution reaching 0.86 after optimization of IM condition. Collision cross section (CCS) was measured to explore the structural difference of complexes. A gap of 11.75 Ų between two complexes was found. Molecular modeling and theoretical CCS calculation were adopted to explain the measurement results. Two binding ways of both complexes were found and the calculated CCS corresponds accurately to the measured CCS. Quantification of catechins in mixtures was performed and the relative error was less than 15%, indicating the effectiveness of quantification by IM‐MS.     

Tandem Mass Spectrometry and Ion Mobility Reveals Structural Insight into Eicosanoid Product Ion Formation

Ion mobility measurements of product ions were used to characterize the collisional cross section (CCS) of various complex lipid [M-H]^? ions using traveling wave ion mobility mass spectrometry (TWIMS). TWIMS analysis of various product ions derived after collisional activation of mono- and dihydroxy arachidonate metabolites was found to be more complex than the analysis of intact molecular ions and provided some insight into molecular mechanisms involved in product ion formation. The CCS observed for the molecular ion [M-H]^? and certain product ions were consistent with a folded ion structure, the latter predicted by the proposed mechanisms of product ion formation. Unexpectedly, product ions from [M-H-H₂O-CO₂]^? and [M-H-H₂O]^? displayed complex ion mobility profiles suggesting multiple mechanisms of ion formation. The [M-H-H₂O]^? ion from LTB₄ was studied in more detail using both nitrogen and helium as the drift gas in the ion mobility cell. One population of [M-H-H₂O]^? product ions from LTB₄ was consistent with formation of covalent ring structures, while the ions displaying a higher CCS were consistent with a more open-chain structure. Using molecular dynamics and theoretical CCS calculations, energy minimized structures of those product ions with the open-chain structures were found to have a higher CCS than a folded molecular ion structure. The measurement of product ion mobility can be an additional and unique signature of eicosanoids measured by LC-MS/MS techniques.

Open image in new window

Graphical Abstract ?

     

The mass-mobility correlation redux: The conformational landscape of anhydrous biomolecules

Structural separations on the basis of gas-phase ion mobility-mass spectrometry are increasingly used for the analysis of complex biological samples. As a tool to elucidate biomolecular structure, ion mobility-mass spectrometry methods are unique in that direct molecular structural information is obtained for all resolved species, largely irrespective of the complexity of the sample. Computational approaches are used to interpret and discern structural details consistent with the empirical results. To a first approximation, correlations of mobility with mass allow for qualitative identification of the molecular class to which a particular species belongs. These correlations allow simultaneous characterization of different classes of biomolecules, which provides a means for combining omics measurements, such as lipidomics, proteomics, glycomics, and metabolomics, in the same analysis. Examination of the correlation of fine structure reveals that specific structural motifs, chemical functionality, chemical connectivity, and composition may also be determined, depending on the specific biomolecular class. Mapping the coarse and fine structure in ion mobility-mass spectrometry conformation space measurements provides an atlas for interpretation and discovery in complicated spectra.     

Molecular dynamics and ion mobility spectrometry study of model β-hairpin peptide, trpzip1

Here, we explore the conformations of gas phase, protonated tryptophan zipper 1 (trpzip1) ions and its six derivatives by an enhanced sampling molecular dynamics, specially the integrated tempering sampling molecular dynamics simulation (ITS-MDS). The structural distributions obtained from ITS-MDS are compared with results obtained from matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization (MALDI)-ion mobility-mass spectrometry (IM-MS). The IM-MS measured collision cross-section (CCS) profiles compare well with the calculated CCS profiles obtained from ITS-MDS. Although β-turn structures are preferred for solution phase species, the ITS-MDS and IM-MS structural analysis suggests that the γ-turn structures are preferred for gas-phase, unsolvated trpzip1 [M + H](+) ions. In addition, the data suggests that the energy landscape of the gas phase peptide ions is sensitive to the site of protonation as well as intramolecular interactions involving the lysine side chain.     

Collisional Cross-Sections with T-Wave Ion Mobility Spectrometry without Experimental Calibration

A method for relating traveling-wave ion mobility spectrometry (TWIMS) drift times with collisional cross-sections using computational simulations is presented. This method is developed using SIMION modeling of the TWIMS potential wave and equations that describe the velocity of ions in gases induced by electric fields. The accuracy of this method is assessed by comparing the collisional cross-sections of 70 different reference ions obtained using this method with those obtained from static drift tube ion mobility measurements. The cross-sections obtained here with low wave velocities are very similar to those obtained using static drift (average difference?=?0.3%) for ions formed from both denaturing and buffered aqueous solutions. In contrast, the cross-sections obtained with high wave velocities are significantly greater, especially for ions formed from buffered aqueous solutions. These higher cross-sections at high wave velocities may result from high-order factors not accounted for in the model presented here or from the protein ions unfolding during TWIMS. Results from this study demonstrate that collisional cross-sections can be obtained from single TWIMS drift time measurements, but that low wave velocities and gentle instrument conditions should be used in order to minimize any uncertainties resulting from high-order effects not accounted for in the present model and from any protein unfolding that might occur. Thus, the method presented here eliminates the need to calibrate TWIMS drift times with collisional cross-sections measured using other ion mobility devices.

Open image in new window

Graphical Abstract ?

     

Synthesis of Star-Shaped Macromolecular Schiff Base Complexes Having Melamine Cores and Their Magnetic and Thermal Behaviors

Abstract

We aim to study magnetic and thermal behaviors of some melamine cored macromolecular Schiff base complexes. In this context, tripodal ligands were synthesized by reacting melamine with 4-carboxybenzaldehyde or 4-hydroxybenzaldehyde. Then, 16 new trinuclear Fe(III), Cr(III), Mn(III), and Al(III) complexes were synthesized by reacting the ligands [tris-(4-carboxybenzimino)-1,3,5-triazine) or tris-(4-hydroxybenzimino)-1,3,5-triazine)] with pentadentate Schiff bases N,N′-bis(1-hydroxy-2-benzyliden)-1,7-diamino-4-azaheptane or N,N′-bis(salicylidene)pyridine-2,6-diamine. Later, ligands and complexes were characterized by means of elemental analysis, infrared spectroscopy, ¹H NMR, liquid chromatography–mass spectrometry, thermal analyses, and magnetic susceptibility measurements. Finally, metal ratios of the prepared complexes were determined by using atomic adsorption spectrometry. The complexes were also characterized as distorted octahedral high-spin d ³ (S = 3 × 1/2) Cr(III), high-spin d ⁵ (S = 5 × 1/2) Fe(III), low-spin d ⁴ (S = 2 × 1/2) Mn(III), and diamagnetic Al(III) bridged by ?OH group of COO^? or OH group of phenol.     

How Hot are Your Ions in TWAVE Ion Mobility Spectrometry?

Effective temperatures of ions during traveling wave ion mobility spectrometry (TWIMS) analysis were measured using singly protonated leucine enkephalin dimer as a chemical thermometer by monitoring dissociation of the dimer into monomer, as well as the subsequent dissociation of monomer into a-, b-, and y-ions, as a function of instrumental parameters. At fixed helium cell and TWIMS cell gas flow rates, the extent of dissociation does not vary significantly with either the wave velocity or wave height, except at low (<500 m/s) wave velocities that are not commonly used. Increasing the flow rate of nitrogen gas into the TWIMS cell and decreasing the flow rate of helium gas into the helium cell resulted in greater dissociation. However, the mobility distributions of the fragment ions formed by dissociation of the dimer upon injection into the TWIMS cell are nearly indistinguishable from those of fragment ions formed in the collision cell prior to TWIMS analysis for all TWIMS experiments. These results indicate that heating and dissociation occur when ions are injected into the TWIMS cell, and that the effective temperature subsequently decreases to a point at which no further dissociation is observed during the TWIMS analysis. An upper limit to the effective ion temperature of 449 K during TWIMS analysis is obtained at a helium flow rate of 180 mL/min, TWIMS flow rate of 80 mL/min, and traveling wave height of 40 V, which is well below previously reported values. Effects of ion heating in TWIMS on gas-phase protein conformation are presented.