Column comparison and method development for the analysis of short‐chain carboxylic acids by zwitterionic hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography with UV detection

Short‐chain carboxylic acids are relevant in pharmaceutical, food quality control, and biomedical analysis. In this study, 11 acids commonly found in drugs and in food products were selected. Wine was chosen as matrix for testing the method. The test compounds were used for comparing the selectivity of four 150 × 2.1 mm zwitterionic hydrophilic interaction LC (HILIC) columns (ZIC‐HILIC 5 μm, 200 Å, and 3.5 μm, 100 Å, ZIC‐pHILIC 5 μm, ZIC‐cHILIC 3 μm, 100 Å) while varying the conditions to optimize for low UV wavelength detection and achieve high sensitivity. Retention using potassium phosphate and ammonium carbonate as mobile‐phase components at pH 6.0, 7.5, and 8.5–8.9 was studied considering recent hypotheses on HILIC mechanism‐related with the Hofmeister series effect and ion hydration. An isocratic method with UV detection at 200 nm and mobile phase consisting of 75% acetonitrile and 10 mM potassium phosphate at pH 6.0 applied to a ZIC‐cHILIC column was found provisionally optimal and partially validated for the 11 analytes. Satisfactory results (R² from 0.9940 to >0.9999), and recoveries from 93–106% for all analytes evidenced the method as suitable for wine analysis. To the best of our knowledge, no previous study has reported on the direct ZIC‐HILIC separation and UV detection of the acids considered here in wine.     

Comparison between evaporative light scattering detection and charged aerosol detection for the analysis of saikosaponins

Saikosaponins are triterpene saponins derived from the roots of Bupleurum falcatum L. (Umbelliferae), which has been traditionally used to treat fever, inflammation, liver diseases, and nephritis. It is difficult to analyze saikosaponins using HPLC-UV due to the lack of chromophores. Therefore, evaporative light scattering detection (ELSD) is used as a valuable alternative to UV detection. More recently, a charged aerosol detection (CAD) method has been developed to improve the sensitivity and reproducibility of ELSD. In this study, we compared CAD and ELSD methods in the simultaneous analysis of 10 saikosaponins, including saikosaponins-A, -B₁, -B₂, -B₃, -B₄, -C, -D, -G, -H and -I. A mixture of the 10 saikosaponins was injected into the Ascentis^® Express C18 column (100 mm × 4.6 mm, 2.7 μm) with gradient elution and detection with CAD and ELSD by splitting. We examined various factors that could affect the sensitivity of the detectors including various concentrations of additives, pH and flow rate of the mobile phase, purity of nitrogen gas and the CAD range. The sensitivity was determined based on the signal-to-noise ratio. The best sensitivity for CAD was achieved with 0.1 mM ammonium acetate at pH 4.0 in the mobile phase with a flow rate of 1.0 mL/min, and the CAD range at 100 pA, whereas that for ELSD was achieved with 0.01% acetic acid in the mobile phase with a flow rate at 0.8 mL/min. The purity of the nitrogen gas had only minor effects on the sensitivities of both detectors. Finally, the sensitivity for CAD was two to six times better than that of ELSD. Taken together, these results suggest that CAD provides a more sensitive analysis of the 10 saikosaponins than does ELSD.     

Improving the universal response of evaporative light scattering detection by mobile phase compensation

Mobile phase compensation, first reported for the charged aerosol detector (CAD), was used as a suitable method to overcome problems related to the mobile phase-dependent response of the evaporative light scattering detector (ELSD). Mobile phase compensation was effectively performed both in the flow injection- and in gradient modes. Without compensation, the response factors of the ELSD for six sulfonamide drugs differed by a factor of two when varying the mobile phase composition between 10 and 90% acetonitrile. This change could be effectively eliminated using the technique of mobile phase compensation, where a secondary pump with a reversed gradient was used to provide the detector with a constant composition of the mobile phase. For identical experimental conditions, the ELSD showed a nearly constant, albeit somewhat reduced, response with compensation. This indicates that under such conditions, the ELSD behaved as a concentration-sensitive detector. The analysis of sulfonamides drugs at 0.05% level using gradient UPLC-ELSD separation with mobile phase compensation is demonstrated.     

Hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography in the separation of a moderately lipophilic drug from its highly polar metabolites--the cardioprotectant dexrazoxane as a model case

This paper presents a systematic study of the retention behavior of a model bisdioxopiperazine drug, dexrazoxane (DEX) and its three polar metabolites (two single open-ring intermediates-B and C and an EDTA-like active compound ADR-925) on different stationary phases intended for hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC). The main aim was to estimate advantages and limitations of HILIC in the simultaneous analysis of a moderately lipophilic parent drug and its highly polar metabolites, including positional isomers, under MS compatible conditions. The study involved two bare silica columns (Ascentic Express HILIC, Atlantis HILIC) and two stationary phases with distinct zwitterionic properties (Obelisc N and ZIC HILIC). The chromatographic conditions (mobile phase strength and pH, column temperature) were systematically modified to assess their impact on retention and separation of the studied compounds. It was found that the bare silica phases were unable to separate the positional isomers (intermediates B and C), whereas both columns with zwitterionic properties (Obelisc N and ZIC HILIC) were able to separate these structurally very similar compounds. However, only ZIC HILIC phase allowed appropriate separation of DEX and all its metabolites to a base line within a single run. A mobile phase composed of a mixture of ammonium formate (0.5 mM) and acetonitrile (25:75, v/v) was suggested as optimal for the simultaneous analysis of DEX and its metabolites on ZIC HILIC. Thereafter, HILIC-LC-MS analysis of DEX and all its metabolites was performed for the first time to obtain basic data about the applicability of the suggested chromatographic conditions. Hence, this study demonstrates that HILIC could be a viable solution for the challenging analysis of moderately polar parent drug along with its highly polar metabolites including the ability to separate structurally very similar compounds, such as positional isomers.     

亲水作用色谱-电雾式检测用于5种抗病毒药物的定量分析

抗病毒药物具有广泛的应用,对人类和动物的健康有着重要的作用。但抗病毒药物紫外吸收差异大、极性分布广,要实现该类药物的同时分析较为困难。本实验以Click TE-Cys为固定相,结合电雾式检测(CAD),建立了多种抗病毒药物同时分离分析的方法。考察了不同的检测器、色谱模式、色谱柱和流动相对抗病毒药物峰形、分离选择性及检测信号响应的影响。在优化的条件下定量分析了5种抗病毒药物,结果证明该方法具有较好的日内重复性(RSD≤3.06%)和日间重复性(RSD≤5.38%)。同时,该方法还具有较宽的线性范围(0.07~2.28 mg/mL)和较高的灵敏度(LOQ≤0.04 mg/mL),可用于相关药物的定量、定性分析。     

Quantitative comparison of a corona-charged aerosol detector and an evaporative light-scattering detector for the analysis of a synthetic polymer by supercritical fluid chromatography

A corona-charged aerosol detector (CAD) was developed to improve the sensitivity, reproducibility and quantitativeness of detection as compared to evaporative light-scattering detector (ELSD) for liquid chromatography. Our laboratory used the corona CAD as a detector for supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) and evaluated its performance compared to the ELSD by using a certified reference material of poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) and a well-defined equimass mixture of uniform PEG oligomers. The corona CAD was able to detect a 10 times more dilute solution of uniform oligomers compared to the ELSD. Although the original data of molecular mass by ELSD was 4.6% smaller than the certified value of PEG 1000, molecular mass distribution obtained by corona CAD was virtually almost the same as the certified value without any calibrations.     

Strategies for the Analysis of Pharmaceutical Cocrystals Using HPLC with Charged Aerosol Detection

Several active pharmaceutical ingredients are currently being developed as pharmaceutical cocrystals as these systems often have superior properties compared to traditional pharmaceutical forms. Pharmaceutical cocrystal formers typically used are polar, small molecule acids or bases which often lack a UV chromophore. Their polar nature results in almost no reversed phase retention and their detection typically cannot be done with UV. Here we discuss approaches for the analysis of pharmaceutical cocrystals using HPLC columns designed for polar retention, ion pairing chromatography (IPC), and hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) using model cocrystal formers. Corona charged aerosol detection (CAD) was used to monitor the cocrystal formers. l-alanine was used as a model basic cocrystal former, and succinic acid and glutaric acid were used as model acidic cocrystal formers. The acidic cocrystal formers were adequately retained on a C18 column. Heptafluorobutyric acid was used as the ion-pairing reagent for l-alanine as it was unretained without the ion-pairing reagent. HILIC, a newer approach for polar compound retention, was also investigated. Using the HILIC mode, all three model cocrystal formers were retained adequately. Of all the approaches studied for the analysis of the cocrystal formers, HILIC appears to be the best choice as the same column can be used for both acidic and basic cocrystal formers. With IPC, the ion-pairing reagent permanently alters the column chemistry and dedicated columns are required for each ion-pairing reagent used. CAD detection provided a linear response in the 80–100% test concentration range for the analytes studied here.     

Polyketide analysis using mass spectrometry,evaporative light scattering,and charged aerosol detector systems

In this study, a mass spectrometer (MS), an evaporative light scattering detector (ELSD), and a charged aerosol detector (CAD) were used to analyze an erythromycin precursor (termed 6-deoxyerythronolide B). The work highlights the capabilities of each detector to analyze a representative polyketide compound that does not possess a natural chromophore, and presents the first comparison to include a charged aerosol system. Each detector was evaluated based upon limit of detection (LOD), dynamic range, and precision in the context of polyketide analysis. Due to its low LOD, wide dynamic range, and ability to provide molecular weight information, the MS was deemed the best detection option for the analysis of low-concentration, poorly identified polyketide compounds. Alternatively, both the CAD and ELSD systems studied showed better precision and accuracy. The ELSD demonstrated the best precision at 3%, but its LOD was limited to concentrations primarily greater than or equal to 1 mg/L. The Corona CAD demonstrated a LOD (0.012 mg/L) and dynamic range comparable to mass spectroscopy and therefore serves as a more cost-efficient alternative for polyketide production schemes with low titers.     

Control of impurities in l-aspartic acid and l-alanine by high-performance liquid chromatography coupled with a corona charged aerosol detector

In this study a reversed phase ion-pair high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) method using charged aerosol detection (CAD) was developed and fully validated for the pharmaceutical quality control of l-aspartic acid (Asp). With a slight modification, the method also allows the evaluation of related substances in l-alanine (Ala). The method enables simultaneous control of related amino acids and of possibly occurring organic acids contaminants. A minimum limit of quantification of 0.03% could be achieved for all occurring related substances. Moreover, the detector sensitivity of the CAD was compared with an evaporative light scattering detector (ELSD). Depending on the analyte the CAD was found to be 3.6–42 times more sensitive than the ELSD. The HPLC method was applied to the purity testing of 8 samples of pharmaceutical grade and reagent grade Asp and of 12 samples of Ala supplied by various manufacturers. Both substances were found to be of high purity (greater than 99.8% for Asp and greater than 99.9% for Ala). Malic acid and Ala were the major impurities in Asp. Asp and glutamic acid (Glu) were the only detectable impurities in Ala.     

Comparison of the response of four aerosol detectors used with ultra high pressure liquid chromatography

The responses of four different types of aerosol detectors have been evaluated and compared to establish their potential use as a universal detector in conjunction with ultra high pressure liquid chromatography (UHPLC). Two charged-aerosol detectors, namely Corona CAD and Corona Ultra, and also two different types of light-scattering detectors (an evaporative light scattering detector, and a nano-quantity analyte detector [NQAD]) were evaluated. The responses of these detectors were systematically investigated under changing experimental and instrumental parameters, such as the mobile phase flow-rate, analyte concentration, mobile phase composition, nebulizer temperature, evaporator temperature, evaporator gas flow-rate and instrumental signal filtering after detection. It was found that these parameters exerted non-linear effects on the responses of the aerosol detectors and must therefore be considered when designing analytical separation conditions, particularly when gradient elution is performed. Identical reversed-phase gradient separations were compared on all four aerosol detectors and further compared with UV detection at 200 nm. The aerosol detectors were able to detect all 11 analytes in a test set comprising species having a variety of physicochemical properties, whilst UV detection was applicable only to those analytes containing chromophores. The reproducibility of the detector response for 11 analytes over 10 consecutive separations was found to be approximately 5% for the charged-aerosol detectors and approximately 11% for the light-scattering detectors. The tested analytes included semi-volatile species which exhibited a more variable response on the aerosol detectors. Peak efficiencies were generally better on the aerosol detectors in comparison to UV detection and particularly so for the light-scattering detectors which exhibited efficiencies of around 110,000 plates per metre. Limits of detection were calculated using different mobile phase compositions and the NQAD detector was found to be the most sensitive (LOD of 10 ng/mL), followed by the Corona CAD (76 ng/mL), then UV detection at 200 nm (178 ng/mL) using an injection volume of 25 μL.     

Retention Mechanism Studies of Selected Amino Acids and Vitamin B6 on HILIC Columns with Evaporative Light Scattering Detection

The goal of the study was to investigate separation mechanism of selected “essential” amino acids (leucine, isoleucine, threonine, tryptophan, proline, and glycine) and vitamin B6 in hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) with the evaporative light scattering detection. Chromatographic measurements were made on three different HILIC columns: amide-silica (TSK-gel Amide-80), amino-silica (TSK-gel NH₂-100), and cross-linked diol (Luna HILIC). The retention behaviour of the analytes was investigated as a function of different binary hydro-organic mobile phases containing 10–90 % (v/v) acetonitrile. The compounds studied were separated under isocratic and gradient conditions. The best results of tested biologically active compounds separation were obtained on the TSK-gel NH₂-100 column. TSK-gel NH₂ column showed mixed HILIC–ion-exchange mechanism, the highest separation efficiency and better selectivity and resolution for tested analytes than the other studied column, especially at concentration of water in mobile phase lower than 30 % (v/v). Special attention was dedicated to the study of interactions among the stationary phase, mobile phase and the analytes.     

Investigation of polar organic solvents compatible with Corona Charged Aerosol Detection and their use for the determination of sugars by hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography

A range of organic solvents (ethanol, isopropanol and acetone) has been investigated as alternatives to acetonitrile and methanol when used in conjunction with Corona Charged Aerosol Detection (Corona CAD). These solvents have been evaluated with regard to their effect on the response of the Corona CAD. Three dimensional response surfaces were constructed using raw data showing the relationship between detector response, analyte concentration and percentage of organic solvent in the mobile phase, using sucralose or quinine as the test analyte. The detector response was non-linear in terms of analyte concentration for all solvents tested. However, detector response varied in an approximately linear manner with percentage of organic solvent over the range 0–40% for ethanol or isopropanol and 0–80% for acetone and methanol. The chromatographic performance of the various solvents when used as aqueous–organic mobile phases was evaluated for isocratic and gradient separations of sugars and sugar alcohols by hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) using an Asahipak NH2P-504E column coupled with Corona CAD detection. It was found that whilst acetonitrile provided the highest column efficiencies and lowest detection limits of the solvents studied, acetone also performed well and could be used to resolve the same number of analytes as was possible with acetonitrile. Typical efficiencies and detection limits of 5330 plates m⁻¹ and 1.25 μg mL⁻¹, respectively, were achieved when acetone was used as the organic modifier. Acetone was utilised successfully as an organic modifier in the HILIC separation of carbohydrates in a beer sample and also for a partially digested dextran sample.     

Quantitative determination of beta-cyclodextrin in a powder insulin formulation for nasal delivery using hydrophilic interaction chromatography with evaporative light scattering detection

This study demonstrated the first application of hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) with evaporative light scattering detection (ELSD) for the analysis of beta-cyclodextrin in a peptide nasal formulation. The method utilized an Accucore? 150 Amide HILIC packing together with an isocratic mobile phase of 65% acetonitrile/35% water with a runtime of 10?minutes and easily separated alpha-, beta- and gamma-cyclodextrins. The method was validated with respects to accuracy, precision, reproducibility, stability, specificity and sensitivity. This method provided better sensitivity compared to other reversed phase HPLC methods and was easier to run than other techniques for the quantitation of cyclodextrins in pharmaceutical formulations.     

Simultaneous determination of three anticon‐vulsants using hydrophilic interaction LC‐MS

A specific and automated method was developed to quantify the anticonvulsants gabapentin, pregabalin and vigabatrin simultaneously in human serum. Samples were prepared with a protein precipitation. The hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) with a mobile phase gradient was used to divide off ions of the matrix and for separation of the analytes. Four different HILIC‐columns and two different column temperatures were tested. The Tosoh‐Amid column gave the best results: single small peaks. The anticonvulsants were detected in the multiple reaction monitoring mode (MRM) with ESI‐MS‐MS. Using a volume of 100 μL biological sample the lowest point of the standard curve, i.e. the lower LOQs were 312 ng/mL. The described HILIC‐MS‐MS method is suitable for therapeutic drug monitoring and for clinical and pharmcokinetical investigations of the anticonvulsives.     

Comparison of universal detectors for high-temperature micro liquid chromatography

This study compares, through micro high-temperature liquid chromatography (microHTLC), three commercial universal detectors that allow a direct detection of lipids. The detectors are: the charged aerosol detector (CAD), the evaporative light-scattering detector (ELSD) and the ion trap mass spectrometer with atmospheric pressure chemical ionization (APCI) and electrospray ionization (ESI) sources (APCI-MS and ESI-MS). This study shows the feasibility to use the high temperature with these detectors and hybrid behavior between concentration and mass flow rate detector in microHTLC. The detectors were compared in terms of response intensity, linearity and limit of detection for different high temperatures. The charged aerosol detector shows a linear response from 5 to 500 microg/mL and the correlation coefficients (r(2)) obtained for squalene, cholesterol and ceramide IIIB exceed 0.99.     

Size exclusion chromatography with Corona charged aerosol detector for the analysis of polyethylene glycol polymer

A technique of using size exclusion chromatography (SEC) with the Corona charged aerosol detector (CAD) was developed and evaluated in comparison with refractive index (RI) and evaporative light scattering detection (ELSD) for fast screening of polyethylene glycol (PEG), a polymer used in preparing pegylated pharmaceutical compounds. These detection techniques were used in the analysis of multiple lots of PEG reagents. CAD was found to provide more accurate impurity and polydispersity profiles of PEG reagents that better differentiate their quality, while RI was not suitable for this application due to its low sensitivity and ELSD led to underestimation of the impurity and polydispersity. The accuracy of polydispersity determination by SEC-CAD was validated against a commercial reference standard of known polydispersity. The SEC-CAD technique and the observed differences between the three detectors can also be applied to polymer analysis in general.     

Performance evaluation of evaporative light scattering detection and charged aerosol detection in reversed phase liquid chromatography

In pharmaceutical industry ultraviolet (UV) detection is often used as the preferred detection technique in HPLC analysis since most pharmaceutical compounds possess a UV-absorbing chromophore. However, in case the active pharmaceutical ingredient (API) does not have a UV-absorbing chromophore, or if some of the impurities present lack a chromophore, they will not be detected in routine HPLC analysis employing only a UV detector and alternative detection schemes have to be used. Refractive index detection or mass spectroscopy (MS) can be used but these detectors have their intrinsic weaknesses, such as lack of sensitivity or high cost. With the appearance of semi-universal techniques such as evaporative light scattering detection (ELSD), and more recent, charged aerosol detection (CAD), detection of non-UV-absorbing compounds became feasible without having to resort to such complex or costly detection methods. This paper evaluates the different performance characteristics such as sensitivity, linearity, accuracy and precision of both the ELSD and CAD detector coupled to HPLC. One disadvantage of this type of detector is the non-linear response behaviour which makes direct linear regression for making calibration curves inaccurate.     

Evaluation of a monolithic silica column operated in the hydrophilic interaction chromatography mode with evaporative light scattering detection for the separation and detection of counter-ions

In this work a monolithic silica column operated in the hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) mode in conjunction with an evaporative light scattering detector (ELSD) was investigated. Lithium, sodium and potassium were used as the test counter-ions for this evaluation. Chromatographic properties of this column operated in the HILIC mode were determined by varying key mobile phase parameters, such as pH, flow rate, buffer strength, acid and organic modifier. As organic content was increased from 60 to 90% acetonitrile, retention time increased on average by a factor of seven for the test cations listed above. Buffer concentration and pH were also observed to have an effect, although not as significant as the HILIC effect that was observed by changing organic content. Flow rates up to 5 mL/min were utilized to perform counter-ion separations in less than 3 min. After examining the changes in retention, resolution, and peak shape an optimized method was established and then further evaluated for linearity, reproducibility, and limit of detection (LOD) for sodium. Linearity was acceptable with an R2 value of 0.999 across the working-standard range and a LOD of 0.1 microg/mL was calculated. The reproducibility on the counter-ion determination from pharmaceutical sodium salts was 1.6% R.S.D. on average, and the accuracy of the counter-ion prediction was approximately 3% from theory when salt content was corrected for potency.     

Evaluation of column bleed by using an ultraviolet and a charged aerosol detector coupled to a high-temperature liquid chromatographic system

In this study, five different HPLC columns were heated to 200 degrees C using a homemade heating system which can be operated in temperature programmed mode. The column bleed as an indicator of induced degradation of the stationary phase material was evaluated using a charged aerosol detector (CAD) and an ultraviolet diode array detector (UV-DAD) at different wavelengths. The silica based C-18 stationary phase gave the highest bleed, and the carbon clad titanium dioxide column the lowest bleed. This was independent of both the detection technique and the wavelength.