Retrospective dosimetry with ceramics

This paper reviews recent progress that has been made in the application of luminescence techniques with ceramic materials to the problem of dose reconstruction at: Hiroshima and Nagasaki; areas downwind of the Nevada Test Site; regions of Belarus, the Russian Federation and the Ukraine contaminated by fallout from Chernobyl; settlements along the Techa River affected by releases from the Mayak facility at Chelyabinsk; Kiisa, Estonia where a stolen ¹³⁷Cs irradiator source was discovered. Luminescence has an increasingly important role in radiological health studies at such sites because of the ability of the method to measure dose retrospectively in areas where radiation monitoring was lacking or sporadic following the incident. Commonly produced ceramics such as brick, tile and porcelain fittings and artefacts have been used to determine the integrated external gamma radiation dose (the transient dose). Evaluation of the reliability and accuracy with which the transient dose can be estimated when it approaches and drops below the level of the integrated natural background dose (<50 mGy for ceramic samples of age 20–30 y) is the subject of current research. In addition to various improvements in the performance of the experimental techniques and understanding of the luminescence properties of the minerals, other developments include improved integration with the requirements of dose reconstruction by the combined use of luminescence and computational modelling.     

The use of ceramics for retrospective dosimetry in the Chernobyl exclusion zone

The use of luminescence techniques with ceramic materials is playing an increasingly important role in retrospective dosimetry. Thermoluminescence measurements with ceramics at Hiroshima and Nagasaki and in areas downwind of the Nevada Test Site have shown that dose estimates may be obtained which are of value in comparisons with the results of modelling calculations. The Chernobyl accident has provided a recent example where retrospective dosimetry is urgently required in order to advance epidemiological studies of the population. This paper examines some of the approaches which are being used with luminescence techniques to provide dose estimates for samplesfrom Pripyat and how they can be used to contribute to the wider problem of dose reconstruction in the 30 km Exclusion Zone.     

Optically stimulated luminescence (OSL) of dental enamel for retrospective assessment of radiation exposure

This paper briefly reviews the optically stimulated luminescence (OSL) properties of dental enamel and discusses the potential and challenges of OSL for filling the technology gap in biodosimetry required for medical triage following a radiological/nuclear accident or terrorist event. The OSL technique uses light to stimulate a radiation-induced luminescence signal from materials previously exposed to ionizing radiation. This luminescence originates from radiation-induced defects in insulating crystals and is proportional to the absorbed dose of ionizing radiation. In our research conducted to date, we focused on fundamental investigations of the OSL properties of dental enamel using extracted teeth and tabletop OSL readers. The objective was to obtain information to support the development of the necessary instrumentation for retrospective dosimetry using dental enamel in laboratory, or for in situ and non-invasive accident dosimetry using dental enamel in emergency triage. An OSL signal from human dental enamel was detected using blue, green, or IR stimulation. Blue/green stimulation associated with UV emission detection seems to be the most appropriate combination in the sense that there is no signal from un-irradiated samples and the shape of the OSL decay is clear. Improvements in the minimum detection level were achieved by incorporating an ellipsoidal mirror in the OSL system to maximize light collection. Other possibilities to improve the sensitivity and research steps necessary to establish the feasibility of the technique for retrospective assessment of radiation exposure are also discussed.     

EPR spectroscopy of radiation-induced centers in tooth enamel and its application for retrospective dosimetry in chernobyl case

A specific EPR tooth enamel dosimetry is discussed which appears to have genuine utility in retrospective dosimetry. The sample preparation technology, digital form of the native background and radiation-induced signals, and their separation from the experimentally observed spectrum are discussed. The possibility of dose estimation from the single initial EPR spectrum of randomly irradiated teeth and the uncertainty of such evaluation are discussed. The method has been used for dose reconstruction of a group of people irradiated due to the Chernobyl accident, and some results are presented.     

Limits of retrospective accident dosimetry by EPR and TL with natural materials

The radiation response of natural materials and domestic articles was investigated by EPR and TL to select suitable materials for retrospective dose assessment in accident dosimetry. The thermal stability and the influence of UV-exposure to the radiation-induced EPR centres were investigated. Based on a required precision of ±20% for dosimetry the lower limits of applicability of the materials were determined. The lowest dosimetry limits of 0.5 Gy were found using sugar, boiler scale and egg shells by EPR and 0.3 Gy by using TL with boiler scale. A list of materials found not to be applicable for retrospective radiation accident EPR dosimetry is also given.     

Insect wings as retrospective/accidental/forensic dosimeters: An optically stimulated luminescence investigation

Estimation of the radiation released during nuclear accidents or radiological terrorist events is imperative for the prediction of health effects following such an exposure. In addition, in several cases there is a need to identify the prior presence of radioactive materials at buildings or sites (nuclear forensics). To this direction, several materials have been the research object of numerous studies the last decade in an attempt to identify potentially new retrospective/accidental/forensic dosimeters.However, the studies targeting biological materials are limited and their majority is mainly focused on the luminescence behavior of human biological material. Consequently, the use of such materials in retrospective dosimetry presumes the exposure of humans in the radiation field. The present work constitutes the first attempt to seek non-human biological materials, which can be found in nature in abundance or in/on other living organisms. To this end, the present work investigates the basic optically stimulated luminescence behavior of insect wings, which exhibit several advantages compared to other materials. Insects are ubiquitous, have a short life expectancy and exhibit a low decomposition rate after their death.Findings of the present study are encouraging towards the potential use of insects' wings at retrospective/accidental/forensic dosimetry, since they exhibit linear OSL response over a wide dose range and imperceptible loss of signal several days after their irradiation when they are kept in dark. On the other hand, the calculated lower detection limit is not low enough to allow their use as emergency dosimeters when individuals are exposed to non-lethal doses. In addition, wings exhibit strong optical fading when they are exposed to daylight and thus special care should be taken during the sampling procedure in order to use the wings as accidental/forensic dosimeters, by seeking (dead) insects in dark places, such as behind furniture, equipment or in air-shafts.Finally, a new single aliquot measurement protocol is also successfully tested on the wings for the dose estimation, while further work is in progress to validate it on other (heat-sensitive) materials as well.     

Study of TSL and OSL properties of dental ceramics for accidental dosimetry applications

Interest is increasing in the development of new methodologies for accidental dose assessment, exploiting the luminescence and dosimetric properties of objects and materials which can be usually found directly on exposed subjects and/or in the contaminated area.In this work, several types of ceramics employed for dental prosthetics restoration, including both innovative materials used as sub-frames for the construction of the inner part of dental crowns (core), and conventional porcelains used for the fabrication of the external layer (veneer), were investigated with regard to their thermally and optically stimulated luminescence (TSL and OSL respectively) properties, in view of their potential application in accidental dosimetry.The sensitivity to ionizing radiation proved to strongly depend on the type and brand of ceramic, with minimum detectable dose ranging from few mGy up to several tens of mGy. A linear dose–response was observed for most of the samples. However, the luminescence signals were characterised by a significant fading, which has to be taken into account for a reliable accidental dose assessment after a radiation exposure event.     

Advantages and disadvantages of luminescence dosimetry

Owing to their excellent dosimetric properties, luminescence detectors of ionizing radiation are now extensively applied in individual dosimetry services. The most frequently used personal dosemeters are based on Optically Stimulated Luminescence (OSL), radiophotoluminescence (RPL) or thermoluminescence (TL). Luminescence detectors have also found several applications in clinical dosimetry, especially around new radiation modalities in radiotherapy, such as Intensity Modulated Radiotherapy (IMRT) or ion beam radiotherapy. Requirements of luminescence detectors applied in individual and clinical dosimetry and some recent developments in luminescence of detectors and techniques leading to significant improvements of the functionality and accuracy of dosimetry systems are reviewed and discussed.     

TL/OSL properties of crystalline inclusions from heavy,barytes loaded,concrete

In the present work, we report the luminescence data obtained from heavy, barytes loaded, concrete containing many crystalline inclusions, extracted from a shielding block located at CERN. The use of both Thermoluminescence (TL) and Optically Stimulated Luminescence (OSL) signals, resulting from a specific trap at about 200 °C, is investigated for retrospective dosimetry purposes. By applying thermal cleaning experiments the TL signal of interest was isolated. Basic TL and OSL properties as thermal and optical stability, repeatability and mainly the linearity of the TL and OSL signals as a function of beta dose were investigated. The implications of all these luminescence properties to retrospective dosimetry are also briefly discussed.     

Biodosimetry versus physical dosimetry for emergency dose assessment following large-scale radiological exposures

Existing data on intercomparisons involving biodosimetry or physical dosimetry methods are analyzed and the results interpreted regarding their efficacy in triage in emergency dosimetry following mass casualty radiological events. The biodosimetry technique examined is dicentric chromosome aberrations (DCA). The physical dosimetry techniques include electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) of biological material (teeth) and physical material (smartphone screen glass), and optically stimulated luminescence (OSL) of electronic components (surface mount resistors) from mobile phones. Issues relating to calibration and interpretation of the data are discussed. An important conclusion of the analysis is that more research is critically needed to interpret the efficacy of the various methods. Included in this needed research are intercomparisons of the various methods in controlled experiments and the need to harmonize protocols.     

Organic–inorganic detectors with Al2O3:C microcrystallites

Optically stimulated luminescence (OSL) is a known phenomenon with several applications in various fields of radiation dosimetry. This phenomenon may be used for estimating dose of absorbed radiation as well as the age of archeological and geological samples. For some applications (e.g. in medicine) it would be develop detectors in the form of high-area flexible foils. This could be achieved by incorporating small grains of typical inorganic crystalline OSL phosphors into organic (polymer) matrix. In the present study we prepared samples containing Al₂O₃:C microcrystalline grains in polymeric matrices. Polymer matrices change the OSL readout and significantly influence the total OSL response. We observed that the dose responses of investigated hybrid materials are linear in the studied range and depend on the types of the matrix and radiation.     

Electron paramagnetic resonance radiation dosimetry in fingernails

There is now an increased need for accident dosimetry due to the increased risk of significant exposure to ionizing radiation from terrorism or accidents. In such scenarios, dose measurements should be made in individuals rapidly and with sufficient accuracy to enable effective triage. Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) is a physical method of high potential for meeting this need, providing direct measurements of the radiation-induced radicals, which are unambiguous signatures of exposure to ionizing radiation. For individual retrospective dosimetry, EPR in tooth enamel is a proven and effective technique when isolated teeth can be obtained. There are some promising developments that may make these measurements feasible without the need to remove the teeth, but their field applicability remains to be demonstrated. However, currently it is difficult under emergency conditions to obtain tooth enamel in sufficient amounts for accurate dose measurements. Since fingernails are much easier to sample, they can be used in potentially exposed populations to determine if they were exposed to life-threatening radiation doses. Unfortunately, only a few studies have been carried out on EPR radiation-induced signals in fingernails, and, while there are some promising aspects, the reported results were generally inconclusive. In this present paper, we report the results of a systematic investigation of the potential use of fingernails as retrospective radiation dosimeters.     

Emergency OSL dosimetry with commonplace materials

Several commonplace materials were studied as possible emergency optically stimulated luminescence (OSL) dosimeters. The materials included: paper currency (banknotes) and coins of different denomination and from different countries; plastic cards of different types (credit and debit cards, driver's license cards, membership cards, etc.), parts and details of clothing and shoes as well as samples of different fabrics.The samples displayed significant variability in their OSL properties. They differed in the intensity of the initial ‘native’ signal; the bleaching time of the OSL signal; the sensitivity to light of different wavelengths; the fading rate of OSL signals, etc. Procedures of OSL analysis were proposed to account for this variety.Values of the minimum measurable dose (MMD) were below 2 Gy for most tested samples if OSL measurements were conducted within one week of exposure and the samples were kept in dark since exposure (except samples of shoes that were kept under environmental light).The OSL signals in banknotes appear to originate from compounds containing aluminum, silicon, calcium and titanium – these elements were detected using X-ray microanalysis. For coins, the source of the OSL signals is speculated to be small particles of quartz, which were detected on the coins' surfaces. The X-ray microanalysis spectra from fabrics and shoes revealed sodium, aluminum, titanium, iron and nickel as elements that appeared to be responsible for the radiation sensitivity of those samples.It was concluded that, under certain constrained circumstances, paper and metallic money, personal plastic cards, clothing and shoes could be used as emergency OSL dosimeters in triage applications.     

Investigations of OSL properties of LiMgPO4:Tb,B based dosimeters

Lithium magnesium phosphate LiMgPO₄ (LMP) doped with Tb and B is one of new materials intended for use in optically stimulated luminescence (OSL) dosimetry. LMP doped with Tb and B luminophors were synthetized at IFJ PAN in Krakow. The investigations were carried out on self-developed dosimeters consisting of a slide with four LMP detectors and a light tight cover. LMP detectors were investigated in regard to their OSL properties using OSL reader named HELIOS adopted to the readouts of dosimetric cards. New LMP detectors showed high sensitivity to the ionizing radiation, good repeatability of OSL signal and good dose response, 25% of fading in the first two weeks after irradiation. Also, the pronounced dependence of OSL response on the energy of the measured radiation requires to apply the compensation filters.     

Dose-dependent optically stimulated luminescence of synthetic quartz at room temperature

Physical conditions such as annealing temperature, duration of annealing, ionizing radiation, etc., play a significant role in the applications of optically stimulated luminescence (OSL) dating as well as OSL dosimetry. Many efforts are made to understand the effect of these physical parameters on quartz specimens owing to its use in such applications. Such factors induce changes in OSL decay pattern. The definite correlation between color centers and luminescence sensitivity can be established on account of such pre-treatments to the specimen.The purpose of present investigations is to study the effect of ionizing radiation under identical physical conditions on OSL properties measured at room temperature. The shapes of decay curve and dose-response data are considered for this purpose. This study can reveal the changes in color centers in response to the pre-conditions to the specimen. It was found that the OSL decay remains slow and OSL properties change systematically with the rise in beta dose up to a critical dose; however, it changes the pattern when the beta exposure to the specimen was increased higher than the critical dose. This critical dose was found to be different for different temperature of annealing. The shape of decay curve up to the critical dose was also studied by considering the difference of OSL intensities between two successive durations from the observed OSL decay data. The results are explained based on the changes in available shallow traps during OSL measurement at room temperature with changes in pre-conditions to the specimens. The results also have been confirmed with the corresponding changes in ESR signals.     

The study on optically stimulated luminescence dosimeter based on the SrS：Eu,Sm and CaS：Eu,Sm

With the increasing use of nuclear energy, there is a need for a wider range of efficient dosimeters for radiation detection and assessment. There has been a tremendous growth in the development of radiation detectors and devices in the past few decades. In recent years, the development of new materials for radiation dosimetry has progressed significantly. Alkaline earth sulfides （AES） have been known for a long time as excellent and versatile phosphor materials. In the present investigation, a number of phosphor samples such as mono-, binary and ternary sulfides of alkaline earths （II^a-VI^b） have been prepared and their TL properties have been studied with respect to exposure （x-ray） response and fading. In this paper, some results on SrS：Eu, Sm and CaS：Eu, Sm phosphors are presented. A type of novel OSL dosimeter is described. The dosimeter takes advantage of the characteristics of charge trapping materials SrS：Eu, Sm and CaS：Eu, Sm that exhibit optically stimulated luminescence （OSL）. The measuring range of the dosimeter is from 0.01 to 1000 Gy. The OSL dosimeters provide capability for remote monitoring radiation locations which are difficult to access and hazardous. This equipment is relatively simple, small in size and has low power consumption. The device is suitable for space radiation dose exploration. In addition, it also can be used in IC and other radiation occasions and has good prospects.     

Experimental Procedures for Sensitive and Reproducible In Situ EPR Tooth Dosimetry

In vivo electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) tooth dosimetry provides a means for non-invasive retrospective assessment of personal radiation exposure. While there is a clear need for such capabilities following radiation accidents, the most pressing need for the development of this technology is the heightened likelihood of terrorist events or nuclear conflicts. This technique will enable such measurements to be made at the site of an incident, while the subject is present, to assist emergency personnel as they perform triage for the affected population. At Dartmouth Medical School this development is currently being tested with normal volunteers with irradiated teeth placed in their mouths and with patients who have undergone radiation therapy. Here we describe progress in practical procedures to provide accurate and reproducible in vivo dose estimates.     

Using the OSL single-aliquot regenerative-dose protocol with quartz extracted from building materials in retrospective dosimetry

We report on the application of the single-aliquot regenerative-dose (SAR) protocol to the optically stimulated luminescence signal from quartz extracted from fired bricks and unfired mortar in retrospective dosimetry. The samples came from a radioactive materials storage facility, with ambient dose rates of about 0.1 mGy/h. A detailed dose-depth profile was analysed from one brick, and compared with dose records from area TL dosemeters. Small-aliquot dose-distributions were analysed from the mortar samples; one associated with the exposed brick, and one from a remote site exposed only to background radiation. We conclude that unfired materials have considerable potential in retrospective dosimetry.     

Spectral analysis of paramagnetic centers induced in human tooth enamel by x-rays and gamma radiation

Based on study of spectral and relaxation characteristics, we have established that paramagnetic centers induced in tooth enamel by x-rays and gamma radiation are identical in nature. We show that for the same exposure dose, the intensity of the electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) signal induced by x-radiation with effective energy 34 keV is about an order of magnitude higher than the amplitude of the signal induced by gamma radiation. We have identified a three-fold attenuation of the EPR signal along the path of the x-radiation from the buccal to the lingual side of a tooth, which is evidence that the individual had undergone diagnostic x-ray examination of the dentition or skull. We have shown that the x-ray exposure doses reconstructed from the EPR spectra are an order of magnitude higher than the applied doses, while the dose loads due to gamma radiation are equal to the applied doses. The data obtained indicate that for adequate reconstruction of individual absorbed doses from EPR spectra of tooth enamel in the population subjected to the combined effect of x-radiation and accidental external gamma radiation as a result of the disaster at the Chernobyl nuclear power plant, we need to take into account the contribution to the dose load from diagnostic x-rays in examination of the teeth, jaw, or skull.