Valuation and hedging of participating life-insurance policies under management discretion

The valuation and hedging of participating life insurance policies, also known as with-profits policies, is considered. Such policies can be seen as European path-dependent contingent claims whose underlying security is the investment portfolio of the insurance company that sold the policy. The fair valuation of these policies is studied under the assumption that the insurance company has the right to modify the investment strategy of the underlying portfolio at any time. Furthermore, it is assumed that the issuer of the policy does not setup a separate portfolio to hedge the risk associated with the policy. Instead, the issuer will use its discretion about the investment strategy of the underlying portfolio to hedge shortfall risks. In that sense, the insurer’s investment portfolio serves simultaneously as the underlying security and as the hedge portfolio. This means that the hedging problem can not be separated from the valuation problem. We investigate the relationship between risk-neutral valuation and hedging of these policies in complete and incomplete financial markets.     

The role of index bonds in universal currency hedging

This study examines the demand for index bonds and their role in hedging risky asset returns against currency risks in a complete market where equity is not hedged against inflation risk. Avellaneda's uncertain volatility model with non-constant coefficients to describe equity price variation, forward price variation, index bond price variation and rate of inflation, together with Merton's intertemporal portfolio choice model, are utilized to enable an investor to choose an optimal portfolio consisting of equity, nominal bonds and index bonds when the rate of inflation is uncertain. A hedge ratio is universal if investors in different countries hedge against currency risk to the same extent. Three universal hedge ratios (UHRs) are defined with respect to the investor's total demand for index bonds, hedging risky asset returns (i.e. equity and nominal bonds) against currency risk, which are not held for hedging purposes. These UHRs are hedge positions in foreign index bond portfolios, stated as a fraction of the national market portfolio. At equilibrium all the three UHRs are comparable to Black's corrected equilibrium hedging ratio. The Cameron-Martin-Girsanov theorem is applied to show that the Radon-Nikodym derivative given under a P -martingale, the investor's exchange rate (product of the two currencies) is a martingale. Therefore the investors can agree on a common hedging strategy to trade exchange rate risk irrespective of investor nationality. This makes the choice of the measurement currency irrelevant and the hedge ratio universal without affecting their values.     

Hedging Large Portfolios of Options in Discrete Time*

The problem studied is that of hedging a portfolio of options in discrete time where underlying security prices are driven by a combination of idiosyncratic and systematic risk factors. It is shown that despite the market incompleteness introduced by the discrete time assumption, large portfolios of options have a unique price and can be hedged without risk. The nature of the hedge portfolio in the limit of large portfolio size is substantially different from its continuous time counterpart. Instead of linearly hedging the total risk of each option separately, the correct portfolio hedge in discrete time eliminates linear as well as second and higher order exposures to the systematic risk factors only. The idiosyncratic risks need not be hedged, but disappear through diversification. Hedging portfolios of options in discrete time thus entails a trade‐off between dynamic and cross‐sectional hedging errors. Some computations are provided on the outcome of this trade‐off in a discrete‐time Black–Scholes world.     

Optimal hedging strategies for multi-period guarantees in the presence of transaction costs: A stochastic programming approach

Multi-period guarantees are often embedded in life insurance contracts. In this paper we consider the problem of hedging these multi-period guarantees in the presence of transaction costs. We derive the hedging strategies for the cheapest hedge portfolio for a multi-period guarantee that with certainty makes the insurance company able to meet the obligations from the insurance policies it has issued. We find that by imposing transaction costs, the insurance company reduces the rebalancing of the hedge portfolio. The cost of establishing the hedge portfolio also increases as the transaction cost increases. For the multi-period guarantee there is a rather large rebalancing of the hedge portfolio as we go from one period to the next. By introducing transaction costs we find the size of this rebalancing to be reduced. Transaction costs may therefore be one possible explanation for why we do not see the insurance companies performing a large rebalancing of their investment portfolio at the end of each year.     

Robust strategies for natural gas procurement

In order to serve their customers, natural gas local distribution companies (LDCs) can select from a variety of financial and non-financial contracts. The present paper is concerned with the choice of an appropriate portfolio of natural gas purchases that would allow a LDC to satisfy its demand with a minimum tradeoff between cost and risk, while taking into account risk associated with modeling error. We propose two types of strategies for natural gas procurement. Dynamic strategies model the procurement problem as a mean-risk stochastic program with various risk measures. Naive strategies hedge a fixed fraction of winter demand. The hedge is allocated equally between storage, futures and options. We propose a simulation framework to evaluate the proposed strategies and show that: (i) when the appropriate model for spot prices and its derivatives is used, dynamic strategies provide cheaper gas with low risk compared to naive strategies. (ii) In the presence of a modeling error, dynamic strategies are unable to control the variance of the procurement cost though they provide cheaper cost on average. Based on these results, we define robust strategies as convex combinations of dynamic and naive strategies. The weight of each strategy represents the fraction of demand to be satisfied following this strategy. A mean–variance problem is then solved to obtain optimal weights and construct an efficient frontier of robust strategies that take advantage of the diversification effect.     

Hedging mortality/longevity risks of insurance portfolios for life insurer/annuity provider and financial intermediary

In this paper, we propose two risk hedge schemes in which a life insurer (an annuity provider) can transfer mortality (longevity) risk of a portfolio of life (annuity) exposures to a financial intermediary by paying the hedging premium of a mortality-linked security. The optimal units of the mortality-linked security which maximize hedge effectiveness for a life insurer (an annuity provider) can be derived as closed-form formulas under the risk hedge schemes. Numerical illustrations show that the risk hedge schemes can significantly hedge the downside risk of loss due to mortality (longevity) risk for the life insurer (annuity provider) under some stochastic mortality models. Besides, finding an optimal weight of a portfolio of life and annuity business, the financial intermediary can reduce the sensitivity to mortality rates but the model risk; a security loading may be imposed on the hedge premium for a higher probability of gain to compensate the financial intermediary for the inevitable model risk.     

组合投资β调整与效用最大化的套期比的选择

为了针对市场风险对风险资产的组合投资进行套期保值，一般认为要选择将组合投资多头和期货合同空头结合起来的头寸方差最小化的套期保值比率，也就是要选择使某一特定函数的期望效用最大化的套期保值比率。但是本认为，由于种种原因，人们更倾向于选择对简单风险最小头寸的套期保值比率。     

Portfolio optimization with serially correlated, skewed and fat tailed index returns

This paper finds that mean-variance portfolio optimization of stocks, bonds, hedge funds, real estate investment trusts and commodities is sufficiently exact to optimize the investor’s utility. We approximate the expected utility using a Taylor series expansion including terms involving third and fourth order moments. The empirical findings for monthly data from August 1994–August 2009 suggest that the incorporation of skewness and kurtosis cause no noticeable change in the optimal portfolio allocation. However, the serial correlations of smoothed returns of hedge funds and real estate investment trusts indeed cause major changes in optimal portfolio allocation. Consequently, attention needs to be drawn to significant serial correlation and not to potential deviations from normality due to skewed and fat-tailed return distributions. The out-of-sample analysis using a moving window gives evidence that the optimal portfolio weight differ significantly considering serial correlation. The optimization using smoothed returns leads to the highest terminal wealth after 10 years. The highest utility is reached with smoothed as well as shrinked returns, while using unsmoothed as well as shrinked returns leads to an out-of-sample disaster. These findings have practical implications for investors who are willing to diversify their portfolios with hedge funds and real estate investment trusts.     

Unhedgeable inflation risk within pension schemes

Pension schemes generally aim to protect the purchasing power of their participants, but cannot completely do this when due to market incompleteness inflation risk cannot be fully hedged. Without a market price for inflation risk the value of a pension contract depends on the investor’s risk appetite and inflation risk exposure. We develop a valuation framework to deal with two sources of unhedgeable inflation risk: the absence of instruments to hedge general consumer price inflation risk and differences in group-specific consumption bundles from the economy-wide bundle. We find that the absence of financial instruments to hedge inflation risks may reduce lifetime welfare by up to 6% of certainty-equivalent consumption for commonly assumed degrees of risk aversion. Regulators face a dilemma as young (workers) and old participants (retirees) have different capacities to absorb losses from unhedgeable inflation risks and as a consequence have a different risk appetite.     

期货套期保值最大概率与最小风险分析

研究套期保值的最大概率和最小风险问题 ,导出最大概率的套期比和最小风险的套期比 ,并且说明它们是一致的 .因此 ,所得到的套期比具有最大概率和最小风险这两大优点 .使投资者用这样的套期比进行套期保值 ,就可以最大概率保证其收益 ,并且使其风险最小 .     

Risk management strategies via minimax portfolio optimization

Recent extreme economic developments nearing a worst-case scenario motivate further examination of minimax linear programming approaches for portfolio optimization. Risk measured as the worst-case return is employed and a portfolio from maximizing returns subject to a risk threshold is constructed. Minimax model properties are developed and parametric analysis of the risk threshold connects this model to expected value along a continuum, revealing an efficient frontier segmenting investors by risk preference. Divergence of minimax model results from expected value is quantified and a set of possible prior distributions expressing a degree of Knightian uncertainty corresponding to risk preference determined. The minimax model will maximize return with respect to one of these prior distributions providing valuable insight regarding an investor’s risk attitude and decision behavior. Linear programming models for financial firms to assist individual investors to hedge against losses by buying insurance and a model for designing variable annuities are proposed.     

Assessing the solvency of insurance portfolios via a continuous-time cohort model

This paper evaluates the solvency of a portfolio of assets and liabilities of an insurer subject to both longevity and financial risks. Liabilities are evaluated at fair-value and, as a consequence, interest-rate risk can affect both the assets and the liabilities. Longevity risk is described via a continuous-time cohort model. We evaluate the effects of natural hedging strategies on the risk profile of an insurance portfolio in run-off. Numerical simulations, calibrated to UK historical data, show that systematic longevity risk is of particular importance and needs to be hedged. Natural hedging can improve the solvency of the insurer, if interest-rate risk is appropriately managed. We stress that asset allocation choices should not be independent of the composition of the liability portfolio of the insurer.     

关于无风险资产不存在时资产组合选择的研究

以往关于资产组合选择的研究大多假设市场上存在无风险资产,但无风险资产实际上是不存在的.当不存在无风险资产时,假设投资者的效用定义在消费上,消费一直是投资者财富的一个固定比例,投资者的最优资产组合由两部分组成:短视的资产组合和对冲组合.假设只有股票和债券两种风险资产,当股票和债券的风险具有负的相关性时,投资者现在会消费更多,同时也会在股票上投资更多;两者正相关时,投资者无法降低风险,会减持股票并降低当前消费;两者不相关时,投资者持有的股票权重和存在无风险资产时一样.最后,还推导出了多种资产情况下最优消费和资产组合的解析表达式.     

基于通货膨胀风险和Heston随机波动率下的最优资产配置

本文考虑了基于均值-方差准则下的连续时间投资组合选择问题。为了对冲市场中的利率风险和通货膨胀风险,假定市场上存在可供交易的零息名义债券和零息通货膨胀指数债券。另外,投资者还可以投资一个价格具有Heston随机波动率的风险资产。首先建立了基于均值-方差框架下的最优投资组合问题,然后将原问题进行转换,利用随机动态规划方法和对偶Lagrangian原理,获得了均值-方差准则下的有效投资策略以及有效前沿的解析表达形式,最后对相关参数的敏感性进行了分析。     

Longevity risk in pension annuities with exchange options: The effect of product design

We consider defined benefit pension plans that, at retirement age, allow the participant to choose between a single life annuity and a joint and survivor annuity. We compare two plans that differ in terms of how pension rights are accrued. In one plan, the participant accrues the right to receive a single life annuity, and can exchange that annuity for an actuarially equivalent joint and survivor annuity at retirement date. The opposite holds in the other plan. We show that both plans are affected by longevity risk in two ways. First, the participants’ choices at retirement age affect the ratio of survivor benefits over single life benefits, and, therefore, affect the natural hedge potential that arises from combining single life and survivor annuities. Second, uncertainty in the rate at which the participant will be allowed to exchange one type of annuity for the other at retirement date induces uncertainty in the level of the nominal rights for single life and survivor annuities, respectively. We compare the two plans, and show that longevity risk is substantially lower in case rights are accrued in the form of a joint and survivor annuity.     

A stochastic Nash equilibrium portfolio game between two DC pension funds

In this paper, we study the stochastic Nash equilibrium portfolio game between two pension funds under inflation risks. The financial market consists of cash, bond and two stocks. It is assumed that the price index is derived through a generalized Fisher equation while the bond is related to the price index to hedge the risk of inflation. Besides, these two pension managers can invest in their familiar stocks. The goal of the pension managers is to maximize the utility of the weighted terminal wealth and relative wealth. Dynamic programming method is employed to derive the Nash equilibrium strategies. In the end, a numerical analysis is presented to reveal the economic behaviors of the two DC pension funds.     

Factor risk quantification in annuity models

Calculation of risk contributions of sub-portfolios to total portfolio risk is essential for risk management in insurance companies. Thanks to risk capital allocation methods and linearity of the loss model, sub-portfolio (or position) contributions can be calculated efficiently. However, factor risk contribution theory in non-linear loss models has received little interest. Our concern is the determination of factor risk contributions to total portfolio risk where portfolio risk is a non-linear function of factor risks. We employ different approximations in order to convert the non-linear loss model into a linear one. We illustrate the theory on an annuity portfolio where the main factor risks are interest-rate risk and mortality risk.     

Risk-minimization for life insurance liabilities with basis risk

In this paper we study the hedging of typical life insurance payment processes in a general setting by means of the well-known risk-minimization approach. We find the optimal risk-minimizing strategy in a financial market where we allow for investments in a hedging instrument based on a longevity index, representing the systematic mortality risk. Thereby we take into account and model the basis risk that arises due to the fact that the insurance company cannot perfectly hedge its exposure by investing in a hedging instrument that is based on the longevity index, not on the insurance portfolio itself. We also provide a detailed example within the context of unit-linked life insurance products where the dependency between the index and the insurance portfolio is described by means of an affine mean-reverting diffusion process with stochastic drift.     

基于APT的证券组合套期保值策略研究

为了解决含有非股票证券的一般证券组合的套期保值问题,依据套利定价理论,提出了一般证券组合的套期保值策略,并对该策略进行了分析研究。     

Multistage stochastic portfolio optimisation in deregulated electricity markets using linear decision rules

The deregulation of electricity markets increases the financial risk faced by retailers who procure electric energy on the spot market to meet their customers’ electricity demand. To hedge against this exposure, retailers often hold a portfolio of electricity derivative contracts. In this paper, we propose a multistage stochastic mean-variance optimisation model for the management of such a portfolio. To reduce computational complexity, we apply two approximations: we aggregate the decision stages and solve the resulting problem in linear decision rules (LDR). The LDR approach consists of restricting the set of recourse decisions to those affine in the history of the random parameters. When applied to mean-variance optimisation models, it leads to convex quadratic programs. Since their size grows typically only polynomially with the number of periods, they can be efficiently solved. Our numerical experiments illustrate the value of adaptivity inherent in the LDR method and its potential for enabling scalability to problems with many periods.