Upper comonotonicity and convex upper bounds for sums of random variables

It is well-known that if a random vector with given marginal distributions is comonotonic, it has the largest sum with respect to convex order. However, replacing the (unknown) copula by the comonotonic copula will in most cases not reflect reality well. For instance, in an insurance context we may have partial information about the dependence structure of different risks in the lower tail. In this paper, we extend the aforementioned result, using the concept of upper comonotonicity, to the case where the dependence structure of a random vector in the lower tail is already known. Since upper comonotonic random vectors have comonotonic behavior in the upper tail, we are able to extend several well-known results of comonotonicity to upper comonotonicity. As an application, we construct different increasing convex upper bounds for sums of random variables and compare these bounds in terms of increasing convex order.     

Characterizations of counter-monotonicity and upper comonotonicity by (tail) convex order

In this paper, we characterize counter-monotonic and upper comonotonic random vectors by the optimality of the sum of their components in the senses of the convex order and tail convex order respectively. In the first part, we extend the characterization of comonotonicity by  Cheung (2010) and show that the sum of two random variables is minimal with respect to the convex order if and only if they are counter-monotonic. Three simple and illuminating proofs are provided. In the second part, we investigate upper comonotonicity by means of the tail convex order. By establishing some useful properties of this relatively new stochastic order, we prove that an upper comonotonic random vector must give rise to the maximal tail convex sum, thereby completing the gap in  Nam et al. (2011)’s characterization. The relationship between the tail convex order and risk measures along with conditions under which the additivity of risk measures is sufficient for upper comonotonicity is also explored.     

Characterization of comonotonicity using convex order

It is well known that if a random vector with given marginal distributions is comonotonic, it has the largest sum with respect to the convex order. In this paper, we prove that the converse is also true, provided that each marginal distribution is continuous.     

Characterization of comonotonicity using convex order

It is well known that if a random vector with given marginal distributions is comonotonic, it has the largest sum with respect to the convex order. In this paper, we prove that the converse is also true, provided that each marginal distribution is continuous.     

Characterizing a comonotonic random vector by the distribution of the sum of its components

In this article, we characterize comonotonicity and related dependence structures among several random variables by the distribution of their sum. First we prove that if the sum has the same distribution as the corresponding comonotonic sum, then the underlying random variables must be comonotonic as long as each of them is integrable. In the literature, this result is only known to be true if either each random variable is square integrable or possesses a continuous distribution function. We then study the situation when the distribution of the sum only coincides with the corresponding comonotonic sum in the tail. This leads to the dependence structure known as tail comonotonicity. Finally, by establishing some new results concerning convex order, we show that comonotonicity can also be characterized by expected utility and distortion risk measures.     

A new proof of Cheung’s characterization of comonotonicity

It is well known that if a random vector with given marginal distributions is comonotonic, it has the largest sum in the sense of the convex order. Cheung (2008) proved that the converse of this assertion is also true, provided that all marginal distribution functions are continuous and that the underlying probability space is atomless. This continuity assumption on the marginals was removed by Cheung (2010). In this short note, we give a new and simple proof of Cheung’s result without the assumption that the underlying probability space is atomless.     

Comonotonic bounds on the survival probabilities in the Lee–Carter model for mortality projection

In the Lee–Carter framework, future survival probabilities are random variables with an intricate distribution function. In large homogeneous portfolios of life annuities, value-at-risk or conditional tail expectation of the total yearly payout of the company are approximately equal to the corresponding quantities involving random survival probabilities. This paper aims to derive some bounds in the increasing convex (or stop-loss) sense on these random survival probabilities. These bounds are obtained with the help of comonotonic upper and lower bounds on sums of correlated random variables.     

Unifying practical uncertainty representations. II: Clouds

There exist many simple tools for jointly capturing variability and incomplete information by means of uncertainty representations. Among them are random sets, possibility distributions, probability intervals, and the more recent Ferson’s p-boxes and Neumaier’s clouds, both defined by pairs of possibility distributions. In the companion paper, we have extensively studied a generalized form of p-box and situated it with respect to other models. This paper focuses on the links between clouds and other representations. Generalized p-boxes are shown to be clouds with comonotonic distributions. In general, clouds cannot always be represented by random sets, in fact not even by two-monotone (convex) capacities.     

Bounds on stochastic convex allocation problems

We consider a stochastic convex program arising in a certain resource allocation problem. The uncertainty is in the demand for a resource which is to be allocated among several competing activities under convex inventory holding and shortage costs. The problem is cast as a two–period stochastic convex program and we derive tight upper and lower bounds to the problem using marginal distributions of the demands, which may be stochastically dependent. It turns out that these bounds are tighter than the usual bounds in the literature which are based on limited moment information of the underlying random variables. Numerical examples illustrate the bounds.     

On sums of two counter-monotonic risks

In risk management, capital requirements are most often based on risk measurements of the aggregation of individual risks treated as random variables. The dependence structure between such random variables has a strong impact on the behavior of the aggregate loss. One finds an extensive literature on the study of the sum of comonotonic risks but less, in comparison, has been done regarding the sum of counter-monotonic risks. A crucial result for comonotonic risks is that the Value-at-risk and the Tail Value-at-risk of their sum correspond respectively to the sum of the Value-at-risk and Tail Value-at-risk of the individual risks. In this paper, our main objective is to derive such simple results for the sum of counter-monotonic risks. To do so, we examine separately different contexts in the class of bivariate strictly continuous distributions for which we obtain closed-form expressions for the Value-at-risk and Tail Value-at-risk of the sum of two counter-monotonic risks. The expressions for the subadditive Tail Value-at risk allow us to quantify the maximal diversification benefit. Also, our findings allow us to analyze the tail of the distribution of the sum of two identically subexponentially distributed counter-monotonic random variables.     

A note on convex risk statistic

By weakening the comonotonic subadditivity axiom, we give the definition of the comonotonic convex risk statistic. Motivated by Ahmed et al. (2008) [1], we establish the representation results for the comonotonic convex risk statistics and the law-invariance convex risk statistics by using the convex analysis.     

Distorted Mix Method for constructing copulas with tail dependence

This paper introduces a method for constructing copula functions by combining the ideas of distortion and convex sum, named Distorted Mix Method. The method mixes different copulas with distorted margins to construct new copula functions, and it enables us to model the dependence structure of risks by handling the central and tail parts separately. By applying the method we can modify the tail dependence of a given copula to any desired level measured by tail dependence function and tail dependence coefficients of marginal distributions. As an application, a tight bound for asymptotic Value-at-Risk of order statistics is obtained by using the method. An empirical study shows that copulas constructed by this method fit the empirical data of SPX 500 Index and FTSE 100 Index very well in both central and tail parts.     

Reducing model risk via positive and negative dependence assumptions

We give analytical bounds on the Value-at-Risk and on convex risk measures for a portfolio of random variables with fixed marginal distributions under an additional positive dependence structure. We show that assuming positive dependence information in our model leads to reduced dependence uncertainty spreads compared to the case where only marginals information is known. In more detail, we show that in our model the assumption of a positive dependence structure improves the best-possible lower estimate of a risk measure, while leaving unchanged its worst-possible upper risk bounds. In a similar way, we derive for convex risk measures that the assumption of a negative dependence structure leads to improved upper bounds for the risk while it does not help to increase the lower risk bounds in an essential way. As a result we find that additional assumptions on the dependence structure may result in essentially improved risk bounds.     

Second order tail asymptotics for the sum of dependent, tail-independent regularly varying risks

In this paper we consider dependent random variables with common regularly varying marginal distribution. Under the assumption that these random variables are tail-independent, it is well known that the tail of the sum behaves like in the independence case. Under some conditions on the marginal distributions and the dependence structure (including Gaussian copula’s and certain Archimedean copulas) we provide the second-order asymptotic behavior of the tail of the sum.     

Upper comonotonicity

In this article, we study a new notion called upper comonotonicity, which is a generalization of the classical notion of comonotonicity. A random vector is upper-comonotonic if its components are moving in the same direction simultaneously when their values are greater than some thresholds. We provide a characterization of this new notion in terms of both the joint distribution function and the underlying copula. The copula characterization allows us to study the coefficient of upper tail dependence as well as the distributional representation of an upper-comonotonic random vector. As an application to financial economics, we show that the several commonly used risk measures, like the Value-at-Risk, the Tail Value-at-Risk, and the expected shortfall, are additive, not only for sum of comonotonic risks, but also for sum of upper-comonotonic risks, provided that the level of probability is greater than a certain threshold.     

Risk measures with comonotonic subadditivity or convexity and respecting stochastic orders

This paper proposes some new classes of risk measures, which are not only comonotonic subadditive or convex, but also respect the (first) stochastic dominance or stop-loss order. We give their representations in terms of Choquet integrals w.r.t. distorted probabilities, and show that if the physical probability is atomless then a comonotonic subadditive (resp. convex) risk measure respecting stop-loss order is in fact a law-invariant coherent (resp. convex) risk measure.     

Risk measures with comonotonic subadditivity or convexity and respecting stochastic orders

This paper proposes some new classes of risk measures, which are not only comonotonic subadditive or convex, but also respect the (first) stochastic dominance or stop-loss order. We give their representations in terms of Choquet integrals w.r.t. distorted probabilities, and show that if the physical probability is atomless then a comonotonic subadditive (resp. convex) risk measure respecting stop-loss order is in fact a law-invariant coherent (resp. convex) risk measure.     

Risk measures with comonotonic subadditivity or convexity on product spaces

In this paper, by an axiomatic approach, we propose the concepts of comonotonic subadditivity and comonotonic convex risk measures for portfolios, which are extensions of the ones introduced by Song and Yan(2006)Representation results for these new introduced risk measures for portfolios are given in terms of Choquet integralsLinks of these newly introduced risk measures to multi-period comonotonic risk measures are representedFinally, applications of the newly introduced comonotonic coherent risk measures to capital allocations are provided.     

同单调相依结构下两重生命模型的概率分布

在寿险实务中,在处理涉及到多个生命的问题时往往假设各个生命之间是独立的,但事实上,因为受某些相同因素影响的生命之间总是存在一定的正相依性．本文证明了在给定边际分布的二维随机向量中,同单调相依结构是在相关序意义下最强的正相依结构,研究了在此相依结构下的两重生命模型的概率分布,并给出了随机序意义下两个状态消亡时间的随机上界和随机下界．     

Tail dependence between order statistics

In this work, we introduce the s,k-extremal coefficients for studying the tail dependence between the s-th lower and k-th upper order statistics of a normalized random vector. If its margins have tail dependence then so do their order statistics, with the strength of bivariate tail dependence decreasing as two order statistics become farther apart. Some general properties are derived for these dependence measures which can be expressed via copulas of random vectors. Its relations with other extremal dependence measures used in the literature are discussed, such as multivariate tail dependence coefficients, the coefficient η of tail dependence, coefficients based on tail dependence functions, the extremal coefficient ?, the multivariate extremal index and an extremal coefficient for min-stable distributions. Several examples are presented to illustrate the results, including multivariate exponential and multivariate Gumbel distributions widely used in applications.