Shadow pricing of undesirable outputs in nonparametric analysis

For three decades a growing interest in the modeling of desirable and undesirable outputs has led to a theoretical and methodological debate in the nonparametric literature on production technology and efficiency. The first main discussion is about the way of modeling ‘bad/undesirables’ as inputs or outputs, or by transformation functions. The second debate concerns the implications of the weak disposability assumption in the modeling of bad outputs, in particular the possibility of assigning unexpected signs to shadow prices of bad outputs. In addition, we point out a current error in the modeling of weak disposability under a variable returns to scale technology. In this paper we introduce a hybrid model to ensure the economically meaningful jointness of good and bad outputs while constraining shadow prices of bad outputs to their expected sign. We argue that it is a sound compromise to model undesirable outputs with a meaningful primal/dual economic interpretation. Finally we propose an extension to define shadow prices for undesirable outputs following the Law of One Price (LoOP) rule.     

Negative features of hyperbolic and directional distance models for technologies with undesirable outputs

In data envelopment analysis for environmental performance measurement the undesirable outputs are taken into account. Ones of the standard approaches for dealing with the undesirable outputs are the hyperbolic and the directional distance measures. They both allow a simultaneous expansion of desirable outputs and a contraction of undesirable outputs by means of a single parameter. To meet environmental requirements, a technology with no disposability of undesirable outputs is often considered and the outputs are assumed to be only weakly disposable. We show that the combination of this type of technology with the hyperbolic measure, (or with its linearization, which is a special type of the directional distance model) may lead to a misleading efficiency score of the unit under evaluation. We derive the dual of the hyperbolic model under the environmental technology and describe some of its properties. Then, we use the hyperbolic and directional distance dual models for developing a second-phase method. This enables to detect the misleading scores of the decision making units. We illustrate the results on a real world data set.     

DEA environmental assessment: Measurement of damages to scale with unified efficiency under managerial disposability or environmental efficiency

This study proposes a use of Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) for environmental assessment. Firms usually produce not only desirable but also undesirable outputs as a result of their economic activities. The concept of disposability on undesirable outputs is separated into natural and managerial disposability. Natural disposability is an environmental strategy in which firms decrease their inputs to reduce a vector of undesirable outputs. Given the reduced input vector, they attempt to increase desirable outputs as much as possible. Managerial disposability involves the opposite strategy of increasing an input vector. The concept of disposability expresses an environmental strategy that considers a regulation change on undesirable outputs as a new business opportunity. Firms attempt to improve their unified (operational and environmental) performance by utilizing new technology and/or new management. Considering the two disposability concepts, this study discusses how to measure unified efficiency under managerial disposability and then discusses how to measure environmental efficiency. The proposed uses of DEA can serve as an empirical basis for measuring new economic concepts such as “Scale Damages (SD)”, corresponding to scale economies for undesirable outputs, and “Damages to Scale (DTS)”, corresponding to returns to scale for undesirable outputs.     

Convexity,quality and efficiency in education

While Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) has many attractions as a technique for analysing the efficiency of educational organisations, such as schools and universities, care must be taken in its use whenever its assumption of convexity of the prevailing technology and associated production possibility set may not hold. In particular, if the convexity assumption does not hold, DEA may overstate the scope for improvements in technical efficiency through proportional increases in all educational outputs and understate the importance of improvements in allocative efficiency from changing the educational output mix. The paper therefore examines conditions under which the convexity assumption is not guaranteed, particularly when the performance evaluation includes measures related to the assessed quality of the educational outputs. Under such conditions, there is a need to deploy other educational efficiency assessment tools, including an alternative non-parametric output-orientated technique and a more explicit valuation function for educational outputs, in order to estimate the shape of the efficiency frontier and both technical and allocative efficiency.     

Strong Restricted-Orientation Convexity

Strong restricted-orientation convexity is a generalization of standard convexity. We explore the properties of strongly convex sets in multidimensional Euclidean space and identify major properties of standard convex sets that also hold for strong convexity. We characterize strongly convex flats and halfspaces, and establish the strong convexity of the affine hull of a strongly convex set. We then show that, for every point in the boundary of a strongly convex set, there is a supporting strongly convex hyperplane through it. Finally, we show that a closed set with nonempty interior is strongly convex if and only if it is the intersection of strongly convex halfspaces; we state a condition under which this result extends to sets with empty interior.     

Statistical inference for DEA estimators of directional distances

In productivity and efficiency analysis, the technical efficiency of a production unit is measured through its distance to the efficient frontier of the production set. The most familiar non-parametric methods use Farrell–Debreu, Shephard, or hyperbolic radial measures. These approaches require that inputs and outputs be non-negative, which can be problematic when using financial data. Recently, Chambers et al. (1998) have introduced directional distance functions which can be viewed as additive (rather than multiplicative) measures efficiency. Directional distance functions are not restricted to non-negative input and output quantities; in addition, the traditional input and output-oriented measures are nested as special cases of directional distance functions. Consequently, directional distances provide greater flexibility. However, until now, only free disposal hull (FDH) estimators of directional distances (and their conditional and robust extensions) have known statistical properties (Simar and Vanhems, 2012). This paper develops the statistical properties of directional d estimators, which are especially useful when the production set is assumed convex. We first establish that the directional Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) estimators share the known properties of the traditional radial DEA estimators. We then use these properties to develop consistent bootstrap procedures for statistical inference about directional distance, estimation of confidence intervals, and bias correction. The methods are illustrated in some empirical examples.     

Inner and outer estimates for the solution sets and their asymptotic cones in vector optimization

We use asymptotic analysis to develop finer estimates for the efficient, weak efficient and proper efficient solution sets (and for their asymptotic cones) to convex/quasiconvex vector optimization problems. We also provide a new representation for the efficient solution set without any convexity assumption, and the estimates involve the minima of the linear scalarization of the original vector problem. Some new necessary conditions for a point to be efficient or weak efficient solution for general convex vector optimization problems, as well as for the nonconvex quadratic multiobjective optimization problem, are established.     

Weakly Convex Sets and Their Properties

In this paper, the notion of a weakly convex set is introduced. Sharp estimates for the weak convexity constants of the sum and difference of such sets are given. It is proved that, in Hilbert space, the smoothness of a set is equivalent to the weak convexity of the set and its complement. Here, by definition, the smoothness of a set means that the field of unit outward normal vectors is defined on the boundary of the set; this vector field satisfies the Lipschitz condition. We obtain the minimax theorem for a class of problems with smooth Lebesgue sets of the goal function and strongly convex constraints. As an application of the results obtained, we prove the alternative theorem for program strategies in a linear differential quality game.     

Book review of Israel Gohberg,Seymour Goldberg,Marinus A. Kaashoek,Basic Classes of Linear Operators,Birkhäuser Verlag,Basel–Boston–Berlin 2003, 423 p. ISBN 3-7643-6930-2

In projective space three notions of convexity (weak convexity, strong convexity, p-convexity) are regarded systematically. Since these notions are defined only by incidence relations, there can be introduced dual notions. We consider relations.between the introduced notions and the most essential properties of convex sets. To all assertions. can be formulated dual assertions, too. The most important theorems given by Fenchel can be generalised. The property of a point set (a set of hyperplanes) to be strongly convex or p-convex, respectively, is invariant with respect to correlations.     

The structure of weak Pareto solution sets in piecewise linear multiobjective optimization in normed spaces

In general normed spaces,we consider a multiobjective piecewise linear optimization problem with the ordering cone being convex and having a nonempty interior.We establish that the weak Pareto optimal solution set of such a problem is the union of finitely many polyhedra and that this set is also arcwise connected under the cone convexity assumption of the objective function.Moreover,we provide necessary and suffcient conditions about the existence of weak(sharp) Pareto solutions.