An investigation into detector limitations using evaporative light-scattering detectors for pharmaceutical applications

Evaporative light-scattering detection (ELSD) high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) is an alternative technology to low-wavelength UV analysis that is often employed when compounds lack sufficient absorptivity. Although ELSD provides an additional detector option for liquid chromatographers, studies in our laboratory indicate analyte properties may adversely affect the ability to detect certain molecules. In this investigation, a series of low-molecular-weight compounds of pharmaceutical interest are evaluated with two commercially available ELSDs. It is observed that melting point is a useful analyte property to consider in optimizing ELSD detectors. The melting point of the analyte should be significantly higher than what the compound will experience in the nebulizer/evaporator chambers to achieve the best analyte response. It is found that some analytes could not be distinguished from the evaporated mobile phase background when ELSD temperatures exceed the melting point of the compound. Though useful for many applications and of particular interest for compounds that are weak chromophores, ELSD falls short of being a "universal detector" technology. In addition to boiling points of mobile phase components, scientists should also consider the melting point and volatility of the analyte(s) when optimizing ELSD response.     

高效液相色谱-蒸发光散射检测法直接检测20种未衍生基本氨基酸

应用国产蒸发光散射检测器(ELSD),建立了一种采用反相高效液相色谱-蒸发光散射检测器(RHPLC-ELSD)直接测定20种未衍生基本氨基酸的分析方法,并将其用于氨基酸注射液中氨基酸含量的测定。采用BISCHOFFTM　C18 AQ PLUS色谱柱(250 mm×4.6 mm, 5 μm)分离,以甲醇-0.2%七氟丁酸溶液(含0.1%三氟乙酸)为流动相进行梯度洗脱,流速0.8 mL/min,ELSD飘移管温度40 ℃,载气流量2.5 L/min,对20种基本氨基酸进行分离检测。氨基酸的质量浓度在30～300 mg/L范围内,其峰面积的对数值与进样质量的对数值呈良好的线性关系;氨基酸的检出限(信噪比(S/N)＞3)介于24 ～100 ng之间,样品加标回收率为90.6%～106.0%。结果表明,该系统及方法操作简便快速、准确可靠,无需依靠专门的氨基酸分析仪或衍生处理氨基酸即可直接测定氨基酸注射液中氨基酸含量,为药品、食品及化工生产等领域混合氨基酸样品的直接检测提供了参考。     

Comparison of two aerosol-based detectors for the analysis of gabapentin in pharmaceutical formulations by hydrophilic interaction chromatography

Comparison of hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) columns coupled with an evaporative light scattering detector (ELSD) or charged aerosol detector (CAD) was done for the detection of gabapentin in pharmaceutical formulations. The chromatographic separations were achieved on four HILIC columns: ZIC HILIC, ZIC pHILIC, Luna HILIC, and Atlantis HILIC. Experimental factors such as mobile phase composition, acetonitrile content, and mobile phase pH were evaluated. Validation of method was done in terms of linearity, sensitivity, accuracy, and precision. The performance of ELSD detection method is comparable to that of CAD. The intra-day and inter-day variations were below 1.7% and 3.2% for CAD and 2.8%, and 3.4% for ELSD, respectively. In addition, detection sensitivities of ELSD, CAD, and UV detectors were also compared for HILIC and reversed phase (RP) modes and the highest sensitivities were obtained in the HILIC mode when connected with CAD and ELSD. The developed HILIC aerosol based detection methods were successfully applied to the analysis of gabapentin in commercial tablets and capsules.     

Liquid chromatography analysis of phosphonic acids on porous graphitic carbon stationary phase with evaporative light-scattering and mass spectrometry detection.

The analysis of several phosphonic acids has been investigated by liquid chromatography (LC), using porous graphitic carbon as stationary phase with mass spectrometry (MS) or evaporative light-scattering detection (ELSD). In both detection modes (MS and ELSD), the mobile phase must be volatile and, due to the porous graphitic carbon (PGC) properties, should promote electronic interactions. Among the various hydrogeno- and perfluorocarboxylic acids tested, trifluoroacetic acid (0.1%, v/v) was selected as electronic competitor for solute retention. The baseline resolution of a phosphonic acids mixture required a trifluoroacetic-acetonitrile gradient elution. This methodology was then applied to the identification of phosphonic acids in a spiked tap water sample. Quantitative analyses are successfully achieved with a good correlation coefficient.     

Analysis of triacylglycerols on porous graphitic carbon by high temperature liquid chromatography

The retention behaviour of several triacylglycerols (TAGs) and fats on Hypercarb, a porous graphitic carbon column (PGC), was investigated in liquid chromatography (LC) under isocratic elution mode with an evaporative light scattering detector (ELSD). Mixtures of chloroform/isopropanol were selected as mobile phase for a suitable retention time to study the influence of temperature. The retention was different between PGC and non-aqueous reversed phase liquid chromatography (NARP-LC) on octadecyl phase. The retention of TAGs was investigated in the interval 30-70 degrees C. Retention was greatly affected by temperature: it decreases as the column temperature increases. Selectivity of TAGs was also slightly influenced by the temperature. Moreover, this chromatographic method is compatible with a mass spectrometer (MS) detector by using atmospheric pressure chemical ionisation (APCI): same fingerprints of cocoa butter and shea butter were obtained with LC-ELSD and LC-APCI-MS. These preliminary results showed that the PGC column could be suitable to separate quickly triacylglycerols in high temperature conditions coupled with ELSD or MS detector.     

Improving the universal response of evaporative light scattering detection by mobile phase compensation

Mobile phase compensation, first reported for the charged aerosol detector (CAD), was used as a suitable method to overcome problems related to the mobile phase-dependent response of the evaporative light scattering detector (ELSD). Mobile phase compensation was effectively performed both in the flow injection- and in gradient modes. Without compensation, the response factors of the ELSD for six sulfonamide drugs differed by a factor of two when varying the mobile phase composition between 10 and 90% acetonitrile. This change could be effectively eliminated using the technique of mobile phase compensation, where a secondary pump with a reversed gradient was used to provide the detector with a constant composition of the mobile phase. For identical experimental conditions, the ELSD showed a nearly constant, albeit somewhat reduced, response with compensation. This indicates that under such conditions, the ELSD behaved as a concentration-sensitive detector. The analysis of sulfonamides drugs at 0.05% level using gradient UPLC-ELSD separation with mobile phase compensation is demonstrated.     

Determination of Biodiesel and Triacylglycerols in Diesel Fuel by LC

A high performance liquid chromatographic method was developed for quantifying blends of biodiesel (simple alkyl esters of fatty acids) in petrodiesel. The method uses a silica column with an isocratic mobile phase consisting of hexane and methyl t-butyl ether. Separated components were quantitated using either an evaporative light scattering detector (ELSD) or UV detector. Precision of injection and linearity of response of the ELSD and UV detectors over a range of biodiesel-petrodiesel blends [1–30 v/v %] were established by use of standards. The method also can be used for quantitating similar levels of oils or fats (triacylglycerols) in petrodiesel.     

Mechanism of response enhancement in evaporative light scattering detection with the addition of triethylamine and formic acid

Triethylamine with an equimolar amount of formic acid added to the mobile phase provides an enhancement of the evaporative light scattering detector (ELSD) response. After characterization of the influence of various parameters on the ELSD response, a sequential strategy was defined to elucidate this response enhancement. The response enhancement was more marked at low mobile phase flow rate, and was highly dependent on solutes and solvents. The influence of drift tube temperature on response enhancement with various solutes demonstrated that triethylamine and formic acid mainly act as mass amplifiers by the inclusion of triethylamine-formic acid clusters inside the droplets.     

Determination of seven compounds in Tang Maikang granule by high-performance liquid chromatography

An accurate and sensitive high-performance liquid chromatography method is developed and applied to the determination of seven compounds in a kind of traditional Chinese medicinal preparation of Tang Maikang Granule. The method is performed on Hypersil C(18) column (250- x 4.6-mm i.d., 5 microm), and different mobile phases and detectors are selected according to the various compounds. For astragaloside IV, an evaporative light scattering detector (ELSD) is used with a gradient of methanol-water at an eluent gas rate of 2.0 mL/min, under a drift tube temperature of 80 degrees C. Formononetin and calycosin are also eluted by a gradient of methanol-water, but a photodiode array (PDA) detector is used at a wavelength of 254 nm for formononetin and calycosin. A PDA detector at a wavelength of 230 nm is used for paeoniflorin, with methanol-water (30:70, v/v) as the mobile phase. For danshensu and protocate chualdehyde, an eluent of methanol-0.5% acetic acid (12:88, v/v) is used, with PDA detection at 280 nm. For berberine, methanol and water containing 0.1% sodium dodecanesulphonate (SDS) and 0.1% phosphorous acid (70:30, v/v) is employed as the mobile phase, also using a PDA detector, but the detection wavelength is 265 nm. The intra- and interrun precision (relative standard deviation) of this method is less than 5% for seven analytes.     

Evaluation of protein, peptide, and amino acid retention on C5 hydride-based stationary phases

A pentyl (C5) stationary phase is synthesized on a hydride surface using both 100 and 300 A silica particles. The aqueous normal phase properties of these new phases are evaluated using amino acids at high concentrations of ACN in the mobile phase containing 0.1% formic acid. The RP properties of the materials are tested by using peptides and proteins in order to evaluate the effect of pore size on retention. Comparisons of retention as well as efficiencies and peak symmetry with a C18 phase are used to determine the influence of the hydrophobic properties of the bonded material. An evaporative light scattering detector (ELSD) is used in all phases of the study and compared with UV detector for gradient elution of proteins.     

HPLC‐ELSD analysis of spectinomycin dihydrochloride and its impurities

A simple, rapid and reliable reversed‐phase ion‐pair chromatography method by HPLC coupled to an evaporative light scattering detector (ELSD) has been developed to simultaneously determine chloride, spectinomycin and its related substances in a sample. The column was a TSKgel ODS‐100V. The mobile phase was ACN/aqueous solution of 15 mM ammonium acetate adjusted with TFA to pH 3.0 (2:98 v/v), in an isocratic mode. The drift tube temperature was set at 50°C and the nebulizing gas flow rate of air was 3.5 L/min for ELSD detection. Almost all of the reported degradation compounds of spectinomycin such as actinamine, actinospectinoic acid and biosynthesis intermediates such as dihydrospectinomycin diastereoisomers were baseline separated. MS was utilized for the identification of spectinomycin and its seven related substances. The method for the assay of spectinomycin was successfully validated with respect to accuracy, precision (RSD less than 2%), linearity (throughout the linear range 0.025–3 mg/mL, r=0.9993), sensitivity (LOD: 100 ng on column) and robustness. The experimental results demonstrated that the simultaneous determination of chloride, spectinomycin and related substances is feasible in a single run, which suggests applicability in routine assays.     

Development of a system to evaluate compound identity, purity, and concentration in a single experiment and its application in quality assessment of combinatorial libraries and screening hits

The development and use of a new assay system for the simultaneous determination of identity, purity, and concentration of sample components from combinatorial libraries produced by parallel synthesis are described. The system makes use of high-performance liquid chromatography with UV/vis photodiode array (PDA), evaporative light scattering (ELSD), chemiluminescent nitrogen (CLND), and time-of-flight mass spectrometer (TOFMS) detectors (HPLC-PDA-ELSD-CLND-TOFMS). Although these detectors have previously been utilized separately for the analysis of combinatorial chemistry libraries, the use of TOFMS along with CLND provides a synergistic combination enabling target and side-product structures to be identified and their concentrations and purities determined in a single experiment from a solution containing microgram levels of material. The CLND was found to give a linear response based on the number of moles of nitrogen present. Therefore, if the number of nitrogens per molecule is known, the concentration of each nitrogen-containing sample component may be determined utilizing an unrelated co-injected standard. A molecular formula for an impurity may often be calculated from the exact mass determined by the TOFMS and knowledge of the chemistry involved. Thus, if the sample components contain nitrogen, the concentration of every identified HPLC peak may be determined even in the absence of primary standards. This combination of detectors enabled the characterization of both target compounds and byproducts in combinatorial libraries, allowing the optimization of library synthetic procedures. This system was also used to survey the quality of libraries, enabling the selection of the best libraries for screening. This method also facilitated the characterization of samples from combinatorial libraries found as hits in high-throughput screening to establish the potency of the leads based on their actual concentration. In addition, concentrations and potencies of impurities were determined after identification of their structures, utilizing exact mass data, determination of charge states, and knowledge of the synthetic chemistry.     

Simultaneous extraction and fate of linear alkylbenzene sulfonates, coconut diethanol amides, nonylphenol ethoxylates and their degradation products in wastewater treatment plants, receiving coastal waters and sediments in the Catalonian area (NE Spain)

A simple, isocratic liquid chromatographic (LC) method using volatile mobile phase constituents for the identification of related substances in erythromycin samples is described. For method development, evaporative light scattering detection (ELSD) was used. An XTerra RP18 column was used at 70 degrees C with a mobile phase consisting of acetonitrile-isopropanol-0.2M ammonium acetate pH 7.0-water (165:105:50:680). Mass spectral data were acquired on an ion trap mass spectrometer equipped with an electrospray interface operated in the positive ion mode. First, a library was created using MS/MS and MS(n) spectra of reference substances available in the laboratory. Using these reference spectra as interpretative templates, eight novel related substances in erythromycin samples were identified: N-demethylerythromycin E, erythromycin E N-oxide, anhydroerythromycin C, N-demethylerythromycin B, anhydro-N-demethylerythromycin A, pseudoerythromycin E enol ether, EF lacking the neutral sugar and EA lacking the neutral sugar.     

Polyketide analysis using mass spectrometry,evaporative light scattering,and charged aerosol detector systems

In this study, a mass spectrometer (MS), an evaporative light scattering detector (ELSD), and a charged aerosol detector (CAD) were used to analyze an erythromycin precursor (termed 6-deoxyerythronolide B). The work highlights the capabilities of each detector to analyze a representative polyketide compound that does not possess a natural chromophore, and presents the first comparison to include a charged aerosol system. Each detector was evaluated based upon limit of detection (LOD), dynamic range, and precision in the context of polyketide analysis. Due to its low LOD, wide dynamic range, and ability to provide molecular weight information, the MS was deemed the best detection option for the analysis of low-concentration, poorly identified polyketide compounds. Alternatively, both the CAD and ELSD systems studied showed better precision and accuracy. The ELSD demonstrated the best precision at 3%, but its LOD was limited to concentrations primarily greater than or equal to 1 mg/L. The Corona CAD demonstrated a LOD (0.012 mg/L) and dynamic range comparable to mass spectroscopy and therefore serves as a more cost-efficient alternative for polyketide production schemes with low titers.     

Comparison between evaporative light scattering detection and charged aerosol detection for the analysis of saikosaponins

Saikosaponins are triterpene saponins derived from the roots of Bupleurum falcatum L. (Umbelliferae), which has been traditionally used to treat fever, inflammation, liver diseases, and nephritis. It is difficult to analyze saikosaponins using HPLC-UV due to the lack of chromophores. Therefore, evaporative light scattering detection (ELSD) is used as a valuable alternative to UV detection. More recently, a charged aerosol detection (CAD) method has been developed to improve the sensitivity and reproducibility of ELSD. In this study, we compared CAD and ELSD methods in the simultaneous analysis of 10 saikosaponins, including saikosaponins-A, -B₁, -B₂, -B₃, -B₄, -C, -D, -G, -H and -I. A mixture of the 10 saikosaponins was injected into the Ascentis^® Express C18 column (100 mm × 4.6 mm, 2.7 μm) with gradient elution and detection with CAD and ELSD by splitting. We examined various factors that could affect the sensitivity of the detectors including various concentrations of additives, pH and flow rate of the mobile phase, purity of nitrogen gas and the CAD range. The sensitivity was determined based on the signal-to-noise ratio. The best sensitivity for CAD was achieved with 0.1 mM ammonium acetate at pH 4.0 in the mobile phase with a flow rate of 1.0 mL/min, and the CAD range at 100 pA, whereas that for ELSD was achieved with 0.01% acetic acid in the mobile phase with a flow rate at 0.8 mL/min. The purity of the nitrogen gas had only minor effects on the sensitivities of both detectors. Finally, the sensitivity for CAD was two to six times better than that of ELSD. Taken together, these results suggest that CAD provides a more sensitive analysis of the 10 saikosaponins than does ELSD.     

Comparison of the response of four aerosol detectors used with ultra high pressure liquid chromatography

The responses of four different types of aerosol detectors have been evaluated and compared to establish their potential use as a universal detector in conjunction with ultra high pressure liquid chromatography (UHPLC). Two charged-aerosol detectors, namely Corona CAD and Corona Ultra, and also two different types of light-scattering detectors (an evaporative light scattering detector, and a nano-quantity analyte detector [NQAD]) were evaluated. The responses of these detectors were systematically investigated under changing experimental and instrumental parameters, such as the mobile phase flow-rate, analyte concentration, mobile phase composition, nebulizer temperature, evaporator temperature, evaporator gas flow-rate and instrumental signal filtering after detection. It was found that these parameters exerted non-linear effects on the responses of the aerosol detectors and must therefore be considered when designing analytical separation conditions, particularly when gradient elution is performed. Identical reversed-phase gradient separations were compared on all four aerosol detectors and further compared with UV detection at 200 nm. The aerosol detectors were able to detect all 11 analytes in a test set comprising species having a variety of physicochemical properties, whilst UV detection was applicable only to those analytes containing chromophores. The reproducibility of the detector response for 11 analytes over 10 consecutive separations was found to be approximately 5% for the charged-aerosol detectors and approximately 11% for the light-scattering detectors. The tested analytes included semi-volatile species which exhibited a more variable response on the aerosol detectors. Peak efficiencies were generally better on the aerosol detectors in comparison to UV detection and particularly so for the light-scattering detectors which exhibited efficiencies of around 110,000 plates per metre. Limits of detection were calculated using different mobile phase compositions and the NQAD detector was found to be the most sensitive (LOD of 10 ng/mL), followed by the Corona CAD (76 ng/mL), then UV detection at 200 nm (178 ng/mL) using an injection volume of 25 μL.     

Comparison of LC–UV, LC–ELSD and LC–MS Methods for the Determination of Sesquiterpenoids in Various Species of Artemisia

Simple and specific analytical methods for the quantitative determination of sesquiterpenoids from various species of Artemisia plant samples were developed. By LC–UV, LC–ELSD, the separation was achieved by reversed-phase chromatography on a C18 column with water and acetonitrile both containing 0.025% trifluoroacetic acid as the mobile phase. In the LC–MS system, trifluoroacetic acid was replaced by 0.1% formic acid. The wavelength used for quantification of sesquiterpenoids with a diode array detector was 205 nm. The limits of detection by LC–MS was found to be 5, 10, 25, 50, 50 ng mL^?1. The limits of detection by LC–UV and LC–ELSD were found to be 5.0, 3.0, 100, 100, 7.5 μg mL^?1, by LC–UV and 50, 25, 30, 100 and 75 μg mL^?1 by LC–ELSD. LC–mass spectrometry coupled with electrospray ionization (ESI) interface is described for the identification and quantification of sesquiterpenoids in various plant samples. This method involved the use of the [M + H]⁺ ions of sesquiterpenoids in the positive ion mode with extractive ion monitoring.     

Wheat digalactosyldiacylglycerol molecular species profiling using porous graphitic carbon stationary phase

The potential of porous graphitic carbon stationary phase (PGC) was assessed for the separation of molecular species of digalactosyldiacylglycerol (DGDG). Detection was by an evaporative light scattering detector (ELSD). A conventional optimization strategy allowed definition of a quaternary non-aqueous mobile phase and separation of 9 wheat DGDG molecular species with isocratic elution: methanol/toluene/tetrahydrofuran/chloroform 64.3/21.5/13.7/0.5 v/v with 0.1% of triethylamine and a stoichiometric amount of formic acid. The molecular species were identified by LC/MS. The chromatographic behavior of DGDG on PGC was then compared to previous studies. The addition of a carbon double bond on the alkyl chain decreased the retention. This contribution was less important when the number of unsaturations increased in the alkyl chain. The consequence of this retention behavior with PGC was an elution order of molecular species which did not agree with the partition number as observed with C18 grafted stationary phases.     

Prediction of isocratic nonaqueous reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography retention parameters and response factors of triacylglycerols detected by an ultraviolet-diode array-evaporative light-scattering on-line system

Nonaqueous reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography of 10 homogeneous triacylglycerol molecular species (TAG), both saturated and unsaturated, is carried out. The eluate from the column is detected by an ultraviolet diode array detector (DAD) on-line with an evaporative light-scattering detector (ELSD). The retention parameters (as selectivities, alpha) for 220 TAGs are determined, and the obtained values are related to the following structural parameters: total carbon number; mono-, di-, and triunsaturated fatty acid residues number/molecule; and monounsaturated fatty acid carbon number. Multiple regression analysis is carried out to obtain a relationship for the prediction of alpha values of any TAG when the same experimental conditions are used. In regard to the quantitative analysis of the separated TAG species, the dependence of response of the two on-line detectors on the aforementioned structural parameters is studied. Three different wavelengths (205, 210, and 215 nm) are considered for TAG detection by DAD; in each case, the obtained multiple regression model shows a good correlation between the dependent variable and predictive values of the TAG species (response factors and considered structural parameters, respectively). The ELSD gives responses exponentially related to injected amounts. Also, in this case, an attempt to relate the response factors of each considered detector to some structural parameters of TAG species is carried out. The results of this study are used to analyze the TAG fraction from an olive oil.