Explaining inefficiency in nonparametric production models: the state of the art

The performance of economic producers is often affected by external or environmental factors that, unlike the inputs and the outputs, are not under the control of the Decision Making Units (DMUs). These factors can be included in the model as exogenous variables and can help to explain the efficiency differentials, as well as improve the managerial policy of the evaluated units. A fully nonparametric methodology, which includes external variables in the frontier model and defines conditional DEA and FDH efficiency scores, is now available for investigating the impact of external-environmental factors on the performance. In this paper, we offer a state-of-the-art review of the literature, which has been proposed to include environmental variables in nonparametric and robust (to outliers) frontier models and to analyse and interpret the conditional efficiency scores, capturing their impact on the attainable set and/or on the distribution of the inefficiency scores. This paper develops and complements the approach of B?din et al. (2012) by suggesting a procedure that allows us to make local inference and provide confidence intervals for the impact of the external factors on the process. We advocate for the nonparametric conditional methodology, which avoids the restrictive “separability” assumption required by the two-stage approaches in order to provide meaningful results. An illustration with real data on mutual funds shows the usefulness of the proposed approach.     

Efficiency and equity in private and public education: A nonparametric comparison

We present a nonparametric approach for (1) efficiency and (2) equity evaluation in education. Firstly, we use a nonparametric (Data Envelopment Analysis) model that is specially tailored to assess educational efficiency at the pupil level. The model accounts for the fact that typically minimal prior structure is available for the behavior (objectives and feasibility set) under evaluation. It allows for uncertainty in the data, while it corrects for exogenous ‘environmental’ characteristics that are specific to each pupil. Secondly, we propose two multidimensional stochastic dominance criteria as naturally complementary aggregation criteria for comparing the performance of different school types (private and public schools). While the first criterion only accounts for efficiency, the second criterion also takes equity into consideration. The model is applied for comparing private (but publicly funded) and public primary schools in Flanders. Our application finds that no school type robustly dominates another type when controlling for the school environment and taking equity into account. More generally, it demonstrates the usefulness of our nonparametric approach, which includes environmental and equity considerations, for obtaining ‘fair’ performance comparisons in the public sector context.     

The effects of exogenous variables in efficiency measurement—A monte carlo study

A Monte Carlo study is conducted to compare the stochastic frontier method and the data envelopment analysis (DEA) method in measuring efficiency in situations where firms are subject to the effects of factors which are beyond managerial control. In making efficiency measurements and comparisons, one must separate the effects of the environment (the exogenous factors) and the effects of the productive efficiency. There are two basic approaches to account for the effects of exogenous variables: (1) an one-step procedure which includes the exogenous variables directly in estimating the efficiency measures, and (2) a two-step procedure which first estimates the relative ‘gross’ efficiencies using inputs and outputs, then analyzes the effects of the exogenous variables on the ‘gross’ efficiency. The results show that the magnitude of exogenous variables does not appear to have any significant effect on the performance of the one-step stochastic frontier method as long as the exogenous variables are correctly identified and accounted for. However, the effects of exogenous variables are significant for the two-step approach, especially for the DEA methods.     

Optimal bandwidth selection for conditional efficiency measures: A data-driven approach

In productivity analysis an important issue is to detect how external (environmental) factors, exogenous to the production process and not under the control of the producer, might influence the production process and the resulting efficiency of the firms. Most of the traditional approaches proposed in the literature have serious drawbacks. An alternative approach is to describe the production process as being conditioned by a given value of the environmental variables (Cazals, C., Florens, J.P., Simar, L., 2002. Nonparametric Frontier estimation: A robust approach. Journal of Econometrics 106, 1–25; Daraio, C., Simar, L., 2005. Introducing environmental variables in nonparametric Frontier models: A probabilistic approach. Journal of Productivity Analysis 24(1), 93–121). This defines conditional efficiency measures where the production set in the input ×$\times$ output space may depend on the value of the external variables. The statistical properties of nonparametric estimators of these conditional measures are now established (Jeong, S.O., Park, B.U., Simar, L., 2008. Nonparametric conditional efficiency measures: Asymptotic properties. Annals of Operations Research doi: 10.1007/s10479-008-0359-5). These involve the estimation of a nonstandard conditional distribution function which requires the specification of a smoothing parameter (a bandwidth). So far, only the asymptotic optimal order of this bandwidth has been established. This is of little interest for the practitioner. In this paper we fill this gap and we propose a data-driven technique for selecting this parameter in practice. The approach, based on a Least Squares Cross Validation procedure (LSCV), provides an optimal bandwidth that minimizes an appropriate (weighted) integrated Squared Error (ISE). The method is carefully described and exemplified with some simulated data with univariate and multivariate environmental factors. An application on real data (performances of Mutual Funds) illustrates how this new optimal method of bandwidth selection works in practice.     

A new approach for technical efficiency estimation in multiple output production

The nonparametric technique of Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) has been used to measure technical efficiency. This approach has proven useful because, unlike regression analyses, it allows multiple outputs and does not require a priori functional form specification. DEA does, however, require correct model specification; inclusion of inappropriate variables or omission of relevant variables leads to distortions. The purpose of this paper is to develop an alternative methodology based on canonical correlation to measure technical efficiency for multiple output production correspondences. Using simulated data, the new methodology is compared with DEA. The results indicate that the canonical regression approach outperforms DEA in most cases.     

How to measure the impact of environmental factors in a nonparametric production model

The measurement of technical efficiency allows managers and policy makers to enhance existing differentials and potential improvements across a sample of analyzed units. The next step involves relating the obtained efficiency estimates to some external or environmental factors which may influence the production process, affect the performances and explain the efficiency differentials. Recently introduced conditional efficiency measures (,  and ), including conditional FDH, conditional DEA, conditional order-m and conditional order-α, have rapidly developed into a useful tool to explore the impact of exogenous factors on the performance of Decision Making Units in a nonparametric framework. This paper contributes in a twofold fashion. It first extends previous studies by showing that a careful analysis of both full and partial conditional measures allows the disentangling of the impact of environmental factors on the production process in its two components: impact on the attainable set and/or impact on the distribution of the efficiency scores. The authors investigate these interrelationships, both from an individual and a global perspective. Second, this paper examines the impact of environmental factors on the production process in a new two-stage type approach but using conditional measures to avoid the flaws of the traditional two-stage analysis. This novel approach also provides a measure of inefficiency whitened from the main effect of the environmental factors allowing a ranking of units according to their managerial efficiency, even when facing heterogeneous environmental conditions. The paper includes an illustration on simulated samples and a real data set from the banking industry.     

动态变系数回归模型的识别与非参数GMM估计

主要研究关于面板数据的有限阶固定效应的动态变系数回归模型(简称FDVCM)的统计推断问题.基于B-样条函数和广义矩估计(简称GMM)方法,首先建立了未知系数函数的非参数GMM估计,并证明大样本情形下该估计达到最优非参数收敛速度且具有渐近正态性质.然而实际问题中模型的动态阶数完全未知,也可能存在其它冗余的回归变量,文中借助文[Fan J,Li R.Variable selection via penalized likelihood and its oracle properties.Journal of the American Statistical Association,2001,96(456):1348-1360]中的smoothly clipped absolute deviation(简称SCAD)惩罚函数同时识别真实的动态阶数和显著的外生回归变量.同时建立了压缩估计的Oracle性质,即所识别的模型与真实模型中的参数估计具有相同的渐近分布.最后,无论是数值试验还是实例数据分析都验证了本文方法的合理性和可行性.     

Joint use of DEA and constrained canonical correlation analysis for efficiency valuations involving categorical variables

The research on efficiency valuations has used two distinct approaches. One is the nonparametric approach known as data envelopment analysis (DEA), the other is the parametric approach based on regression analysis or its extension such as constrained canonical correlation analysis (CCCA). Interestingly, a recent study has employed a hybrid approach that cross-fertilizes DEA and CCCA to compensate for the drawbacks of the two methods and capture their positive aspects. This approach first applies DEA to select efficient units and then utilizes CCCA to identify a smooth efficient frontier with the selected efficient units only. We extend it to incorporate a categorical variable that reflects an environmental effect on efficiency performance. The need for considering a categorical variable arises in practice for an equitable efficiency valuation, as illustrated by managerial performance evaluation of the branches of a fast-food company, where the location of branches such as commercial or noncommercial area significantly affects their performance. We demonstrate various possible ways to handle such a categorical variable in the framework of a hybrid approach and characterize each of the methods. Based on this study, we suggest one method that simultaneously utilizes an extension of DEA, referred to as DEA with categorical variable, and CCCA employing a dummy variable, as in multiple regressions with dummy variables. Through an application to the branches of a fast-food company, we show the efficacy of the suggested method in terms of penalizing the advantageous location effect and compensating for the disadvantageous location effect. We also provide some discussions on the limitations underlying the hybrid approach in order to guide a proper use of this approach to the other potential applications.     

Assessing European primary school performance through a conditional nonparametric model

This paper uses a fully nonparametric framework to assess the efficiency of primary schools using data about schools in 16 European countries participating in PIRLS 2011. This study represents an original enterprise since most of the empirical research in the field is restricted to evaluations at regional or national level and focused on secondary education. For our purpose, we adapt the metafrontier framework to compare and decompose the technical efficiency of primary schools operating in heterogeneous contexts, which in our case is represented by different educational systems or countries. Similarly, we use an extension of the conditional nonparametric robust approach to test the potential influence of a mixed set of environmental school factors and variables representing cultural values of each country. Our results indicate that the intergenerational transmission of non-cognitive skills such as responsibility or perseverance are significantly related to school efficiency, whereas most school factors do not seem to have a significant influence on school performance.     

空间的生产可能集和技术效率

技术效率的估计方法有参数法和非参数法,由于传统效率分析指标--资金K、劳动力L和产出Y,识别不出资产技术的差异,部分文献在参数法中采用资金装备率k（或加职工人数L）和劳动生产率y来估计企业技术效率.为探讨这一指标体系下的非参数技术效率分析方法,本文将传统（K,L,Y）空间的规模不变生产可能集映射到（k,y）空间,得到（k,y）空间的规模非增生产可能集.我们证明,决策单元在（k,y）空间的规模非增技术效率等于决策单元在传统（K,L,Y）空间的规模不变技术效率（C^2R技术效率）.这一结果简化了传统C^2R技术效率的计算,而且可以在（k,y）空间得到资产物理技术的最佳近似值--资产运营前沿技术.     

A robust nonparametric approach to evaluate and explain the performance of mutual funds

The topic of the measurement of mutual funds’ performance is receiving an increasing interest both from an applied and a theoretical perspective. Beside the traditional financial literature, a growing body of studies has started to apply the tools of frontier analysis for benchmarking comparisons in portfolio analysis. Our paper contributes to this literature proposing a robust nonparametric approach for analysing mutual funds. It is based on the concept of order-m frontier [Cazals, C., Florens, J.P., Simar, L., 2002. Nonparametric frontier estimation: A robust approach. Journal of Econometrics 106, 1–25] and on a probabilistic approach [Daraio, C., Simar, L., 2005. Introducing environmental variables in nonparametric frontier models: A probabilistic approach. Journal of Productivity Analysis 24 (1), 93–121] to find out the factors explaining mutual funds’ performance. Within this framework, a decomposition of conditional efficiency is proposed, and its usefulness for economic interpretation analysed. Our approach is illustrated by using US mutual funds data, grouped for category by objective. Economies of scale, slacks and market risks are investigated. A comparison of traditional, nonparametric and robust performance measures is also offered.     

One-stage and two-stage DEA estimation of the effects of contextual variables

Two-stage data envelopment analysis (2-DEA) is commonly used in productive efficiency analysis to estimate the effects of operational conditions and practices on performance. In this method the DEA efficiency estimates are regressed on contextual variables representing the operational conditions. We re-examine the statistical properties of the 2-DEA estimator, and find that it is statistically consistent under more general conditions than earlier studies assume. We further show that the finite sample bias of DEA in the first stage carries over to the second stage regression, causing bias in the estimated coefficients of the contextual variables. This bias is particularly severe when the contextual variables are correlated with inputs. To address this shortcoming, we apply the result that DEA can be formulated as a constrained special case of the convex nonparametric least squares (CNLS) regression. Applying the CNLS formulation, we develop a new semi-nonparametric one-stage estimator for the coefficients of the contextual variables that directly incorporates contextual variables to the standard DEA problem. The proposed method is hence referred to as one-stage DEA (1-DEA). Evidence from Monte Carlo simulations suggests that the new 1-DEA estimator performs systematically better than the conventional 2-DEA estimator both in deterministic and noisy scenarios.     

Semiparametric estimation of average treatment effect through a random coefficient dummy endogenous variable model

This paper provides an estimation procedure for average treatment effect through a random coefficient dummy endogenous variable model. A leading example of the model is estimating the effect of a training program on earnings. The model is composed of two equations: an outcome equation and a decision equation. Given the linear restriction in outcome and decision equations, Chen (1999) provided a distribution-free estimation procedure under conditional symmetric error distributions. In this paper we extend Chen’s estimator by relaxing the linear index into a nonparametric function, which greatly reduces the risk of model misspecification. A two-step approach is proposed: the first step uses a nonparametric regression estimator for the decision variable, and the second step uses an instrumental variables approach to estimate average treatment effect in the outcome equation. The proposed estimator is shown to be consistent and asymptotically normally distributed. Furthermore, we investigate the finite performance of our estimator by a Monte Carlo study and also use our estimator to study the return of college education in different periods of China. The estimates seem more reasonable than those of other commonly used estimators.     

The impact of managerial and organizational aspects on hospital wards’ efficiency: Evidence from a case study

In spite of its acknowledged relevance, the impact of managerial and organizational aspects on hospital wards’ efficiency has been so far overlooked by the literature. In order to explore this issue, this paper presents a model of the relations between the decision making process of a hospital ward and its technical efficiency. In order to test the model, a two-step approach has been adopted. In the first step the technical efficiency of wards belonging to a large Italian Hospital Enterprise has been calculated using DEA. In the second step, efficiency scores have been regressed on a set of variables capturing managerial goals and actions internal to the ward, as well as re-organizations imposed by the hospital central management. Responses to a questionnaire administered to the heads of ward were used to build the independent variables. Results show that both decisions internal to the ward and exogenous re-organizations affect the ward’s efficiency, and suggest that these variables are more significant in explaining efficiency than environmental ones.     

A statistical test for detecting influential observations in DEA

This paper deals with the problem of detecting influential observations in deterministic nonparametric DEA models. The technique we present is intended to classify for a further analysis those sample observations considerably affecting the measured efficiency for the remaining units. Then, the analyst will have to check whether these observations are contaminated by data errors or not. This approach also allows to determine when efficiency changes due to the presence of a given unit in the sample are statistically significant. Thus, ours is a statistical alternative to approach the problem of detecting influential observations in deterministic nonparametric DEA models.     

Influential observations in frontier models,a robust non-oriented approach to the water sector

This paper suggests an outlier detection procedure which applies a nonparametric model accounting for undesired outputs and exogenous influences in the sample. Although efficiency is estimated in a deterministic frontier approach, each potential outlier initially benefits of the doubt of not being an outlier. We survey several outlier detection procedures and select five complementary methodologies which, taken together, are able to detect all influential observations. To exploit the singularity of the leverage and the peer count, the super-efficiency and the order-m method and the peer index, it is proposed to select these observations as outliers which are simultaneously revealed as atypical by at least two of the procedures. A simulated example demonstrates the usefulness of this approach. The model is applied to the Portuguese drinking water sector, for which we have an unusually rich data set.     

Stochastic data envelopment analysis in measuring the efficiency of Taiwan commercial banks

Conventional data envelopment analysis (DEA) for measuring the efficiency of a set of decision making units (DMUs) requires the input/output data to be constant. In reality, however, many observations are stochastic in nature; consequently, the resulting efficiencies are stochastic as well. This paper discusses how to obtain the efficiency distribution of each DMU via a simulation technique. The case of Taiwan commercial banks shows that, firstly, the number of replications in simulation analysis has little effect on the estimation of efficiency means, yet 1000 replications are recommended to produce reliable efficiency means and 2000 replications for a good estimation of the efficiency distributions. Secondly, the conventional way of using average data to represent stochastic variables results in efficiency scores which are different from the mean efficiencies of the presumably true efficiency distributions estimated from simulation. Thirdly, the interval-data approach produces true efficiency intervals yet the intervals are too wide to provide valuable information. In conclusion, when multiple observations are available for each DMU, the stochastic-data approach produces more reliable and informative results than the average-data and interval-data approaches do.     

Input, output and graph technical efficiency measures on non-convex FDH models with various scaling laws: An integrated approach based upon implicit enumeration algorithms

In a recent article, Briec, Kerstens and Vanden Eeckaut (2004) develop a series of nonparametric, deterministic non-convex technologies integrating traditional returns to scale assumptions into the non-convex FDH model. They show, among other things, how the traditional technical input efficiency measure can be analytically derived for these technology specifications. In this paper, we develop a similar approach to calculate output and graph measures of technical efficiency and indicate the general advantage of such solution strategy via enumeration. Furthermore, several analytical formulas are established and some algorithms are proposed relating the three measurement orientations to one another.     

On the measurement of technical efficiency in the public sector

Existing measures of technical inefficiency obtained through linear programming models in the public sector do not properly control for environmental variables that affect production. It will be shown that the consequences of not controlling for these fixed factors are biased estimates of technical efficiency. This paper extends the mathematical programming approach to frontier estimation known as Data Envelopment Analysis to allow for environmental variables. This modified model will be then contrasted with the existing model that purportedly controls for exogeneous factors to measure public sector efficiency with simulated data. The results provide evidence that the existing Data Envelopment Analysis model will overestimate the level of technical inefficiency and that the modified model developed in this paper does a better job controlling for exogenous factors. The modified model is also applied to analyze the technical efficiency of school districts.     

连锁分析的非参数方法研究进展

连锁分析是基因定位研究中广泛采用的一种方法。按分析方法的不同,大致分为参数&非参数的两类。本文拟就连锁分析的非参数方法研究进展做一简要介绍。