Temporal onset-order discrimination through the tactual sense: effects of frequency and site of stimulation

This research extends the study of temporal resolution of the tactual sensory system through measurements of temporal-onset order discrimination for continuous tonal signals addressing (a) the effects of frequency separation of the two stimuli whose onset orders are to be discriminated and (b) the effects of redundant coding of frequency and site of stimulation on performance. Sinusoidal signals were presented either at two separate digits (thumb and index finger of the left hand) or at a single site of stimulation (left index finger) using a multifinger tactual stimulation system. Measurements were obtained using a one-interval two-alternative forced choice procedure in which each interval consisted of the random-order presentation of two different stimuli with roving values of amplitude and duration. Thresholds were estimated from psychometric functions of d' as a function of stimulus-onset asynchrony (SOA). On average, temporal onset-order thresholds were larger for one-finger conditions (mean SOA of 74.8 ms) than for two-finger conditions (mean SOA of 48.5 ms) and decreased as frequency separation increased, particularly for single-site presentation. Redundant coding of frequency and site of stimulation resulted in higher resolution by a factor of 1.5 compared to frequency alone and by a factor of 1.2 compared to site alone.     

Vibrotactile temporal gap detection as a function of age

The ability of subjects to detect temporal gaps between bursts of sinusoids or bursts of bandlimited noise was measured to evaluate the phenomenon of tactile "sensory persistence" in older persons. Vibratory stimuli were delivered to the right thenar eminence of 27 subjects ranging in age from 8-75 years. The subjects' task was to detect the presence of a silent interval or "gap" between flanking 350-ms vibrotactile stimuli. The gap-detection threshold, expressed as the amplitude of vibration relative to the absolute detection threshold, decreased as the gap duration increased and was higher for gaps in noise than for gaps in sinusoids. The threshold for detecting short gaps increased with age for noise stimuli, but not for sinusoidal stimuli. Furthermore, the gap-detection threshold recovered more rapidly in older subjects for noise stimuli, but less rapidly in older subjects for sinusoidal stimuli. Because of these differences, it appears that the effects of age on gap detection cannot be due to a simple increase in sensory persistence, but may be due to multiple processes.     

Vibrotactile intensity discrimination measured by three methods

The difference threshold for the detection of changes in vibration amplitude was measured as a function of the intensity and frequency of stimuli delivered through a 2.9-cm2 contactor to the thenar eminence. Stimuli were either 25- or 250-Hz sinusoids, narrow-band noise centered at 250 Hz, or wideband noise. Thresholds were measured by two-interval, forced-choice tracking under three methods of stimulus presentation. In the gated-pedestal method, subjects had to judge which of two 700-ms bursts of vibration separated by 100 ms was more intense. In the continuous-pedestal method, subjects had to detect a 700-ms increment in the amplitude of an ongoing pedestal of vibration. In the two-burst-continuous-pedestal method with 1500-ms pedestals, the subject had to detect which of two successively presented pedestals contained a 500-ms amplitude increment. Thresholds were consistently lower for detecting increments in the amplitude of a continuous pedestal of vibration than for detecting amplitude differences between briefly presented successive pedestals or amplitude increments in successive pedestals. A "near miss" to Weber's law was found both for sinusoidal and for noise stimuli. The difference threshold was not affected by stimulus frequency condition.     

Sensitivity to amplitude-modulated vibrotactile signals

Temporal modulation transfer functions were measured for sinusoidally amplitude-modulated vibratory stimuli delivered to the thenar eminence of the hand. Results for sinusoidal carriers at 25, 50, 100, and 250 Hz reflected greater sensitivity to modulation than those for either broadband or narrow-band noise carriers. The correspondence of these results to other measures of temporal sensitivity in the tactile system was examined. In addition, findings are discussed in view of their relevance to comparisons across sensory modalities, and to the design of vibrotactile aids for hearing-impaired persons.     

The shape of the ear's temporal window

This article examines the idea that the temporal resolution of the auditory system can be modeled using a temporal window (an intensity weighting function) analogous to the auditory filter measured in the frequency domain. To estimate the shape of the hypothetical temporal window, threshold was measured for a brief sinusoidal signal presented in a temporal gap between two bursts of noise. The duration of the gap was systematically varied and the signal was placed both symmetrically and asymmetrically within the gap. The data were analyzed by assuming that the temporal window had the form of a simple mathematical expression with a small number of free parameters. The values of the parameters were adjusted to give the best fit to the data. The analysis assumed that, for each condition, the temporal window was centered at the time giving the highest signal-to-masker ratio, and that threshold corresponded to a fixed ratio of signal energy to masker energy at the output of the window. The data were fitted well by modeling each side of the window as the sum of two rounded-exponential functions. The window was highly asymmetric, having a shallower slope for times before the center than for times after. The equivalent rectangular duration (ERD) of the window was typically about 8 ms. The ERD increased slightly when the masker level was decreased, but did not differ significantly for signal frequencies of 500 and 2000 Hz. The temporal-window model successfully accounts for the data from a variety of experiments measuring temporal resolution. However, it fails to predict certain aspects of forward masking and of the detection of amplitude modulation at high rates.     

Integration of auditory and vibrotactile stimuli: effects of frequency

Perceptual integration of vibrotactile and auditory sinusoidal tone pulses was studied in detection experiments as a function of stimulation frequency. Vibrotactile stimuli were delivered through a single channel vibrator to the left middle fingertip. Auditory stimuli were presented diotically through headphones in a background of 50 dB sound pressure level broadband noise. Detection performance for combined auditory-tactile presentations was measured using stimulus levels that yielded 63% to 77% correct unimodal performance. In Experiment 1, the vibrotactile stimulus was 250 Hz and the auditory stimulus varied between 125 and 2000 Hz. In Experiment 2, the auditory stimulus was 250 Hz and the tactile stimulus varied between 50 and 400 Hz. In Experiment 3, the auditory and tactile stimuli were always equal in frequency and ranged from 50 to 400 Hz. The highest rates of detection for the combined-modality stimulus were obtained when stimulating frequencies in the two modalities were equal or closely spaced (and within the Pacinian range). Combined-modality detection for closely spaced frequencies was generally consistent with an algebraic sum model of perceptual integration; wider-frequency spacings were generally better fit by a Pythagorean sum model. Thus, perceptual integration of auditory and tactile stimuli at near-threshold levels appears to depend both on absolute frequency and relative frequency of stimulation within each modality.     

Development of noise and vibration ride comfort criteria.

A laboratory investigation was directed at the development of criteria for the prediction of ride quality in a noise-vibration environment. The stimuli for the study consisted of octave bands of noise centered at 500 and 2000 Hz and vertical floor vibrations composed of either 5 Hz sinusoidal vibration, or random vibrations centered at 5 Hz and with a 5 Hz bandwidth. The noise stimuli were presented at A-weighted sound pressure levels ranging from ambient to 95 dB and the vibration and acceleration levels ranging from 0.02--0.13 grms. Results indicated that the total subjective discomfort response could be divided into two subjective components. One component consisted of subjective discomfort to vibration and was found to be a linear function of vibration acceleration level. The other component consisted of discomfort due to noise which varied logarithmically with noise level (power relationship). However, the magnitude of the noise discomfort component was dependent upon the level of vibration present in the combined environment. Based on the experimental results, a model of subjective discomfort that accounted for the interdependence of noise and vibration was developed. The model was then used to develop a set of criteria (constant discomfort) curves that illustrate the basic design tradeoffs available between noise and vibration.     

Tactual display of consonant voicing as a supplement to lipreading

This research is concerned with the development and evaluation of a tactual display of consonant voicing to supplement the information available through lipreading for persons with profound hearing impairment. The voicing cue selected is based on the envelope onset asynchrony derived from two different filtered bands (a low-pass band and a high-pass band) of speech. The amplitude envelope of each of the two bands was used to modulate a different carrier frequency which in turn was delivered to one of the two fingers of a tactual stimulating device. Perceptual evaluations of speech reception through this tactual display included the pairwise discrimination of consonants contrasting voicing and identification of a set of 16 consonants under conditions of the tactual cue alone (T), lipreading alone (L), and the combined condition (L + T). The tactual display was highly effective for discriminating voicing at the segmental level and provided a substantial benefit to lipreading on the consonant-identification task. No such benefits of the tactual cue were observed, however, for lipreading of words in sentences due perhaps to difficulties in integrating the tactual and visual cues and to insufficient training on the more difficult task of connected-speech reception.     

The detectability of a tone added to narrow bands of equal-energy noise.

The ability to detect a 2000-Hz tone added to bands of noise centered at 2000 Hz was measured using a two-interval, forced-choice, pulsed-masker paradigm. The stimuli ranged in duration from 50-200 ms, and the maskers ranged in bandwidth from 5-320 Hz. In one condition, the bands of noise had equal energy across the two intervals of each trial and in a second condition the levels of the stimuli were independently and randomly chosen from a 30-dB range on a presentation-by-presentation basis. The energy model failed to predict the data obtained either in the presence or in the absence of level variation. Control experiments showed that exposure to level variation yielded an overall reduction in sensitivity, suggesting that the presence of level variation leads to changes in the listeners' detection strategies. Computer simulations indicated that changes in either the fine structure or envelopes of the waveforms were sufficient to account for detection when changes in stimulus energy were not reliable.     

Resonance properties of the vocal folds: in vivo laryngoscopic investigation of the externally excited laryngeal vibrations

The study presents the first attempt to investigate resonance properties of the living vocal folds by means of laryngoscopy. Laryngeal vibrations were excited via a shaker placed on the neck of a male subject and observed by means of videostroboscopy and videokymography (VKG). When the vocal folds were tuned to the phonation frequency of 110 Hz and sinusoidal vibration with sweeping frequency (in the range 50-400 Hz) was delivered to the larynx, three clearly pronounced resonance peaks at frequencies around 110, 170, and 240 Hz were identified in the vocal fold tissues. Different modes of vibration of the vocal folds, observed as distinct lateral-medial oscillations with one, two, and three half-wavelengths along the glottal length, respectively, were associated with these resonance frequencies. At the external excitation frequencies below 100 Hz, vibrations of the ventricular folds, aryepiglottic folds and arytenoid cartilages were dominant in the larynx.     

Level discrimination of sinusoids as a function of duration and level for fixed-level, roving-level, and across-frequency conditions

The ability of listeners to detect level differences between two sinusoidal stimuli in a two-interval forced-choice procedure was measured as a function of duration and level in three conditions: (1) the pedestal was fixed in level and the stimuli in the two intervals had the same frequency of either 1 or 2 kHz (fixed-level condition); (2) the pedestal was roved in level over a 20-dB range from trial to trial, but the stimuli still had the same frequency of either 1 or 2 kHz (roving-level condition); and (3) the pedestal was roved in level over a 20-dB range and the two stimuli differed in frequency, such that one was around 1 kHz while the other was around 2 kHz (across-frequency condition). In the fixed-level conditions, difference limens decreased (improved) with both increasing duration and level, as found in previous studies. In the roving-level conditions, difference limens increased and the dependence on duration and level decreased. Difference limens in the across-frequency conditions were generally highest and showed very little dependence on either stimulus duration or level. The results may be understood in terms of different internal noise components with additive variances: In the fixed-level conditions, sensation noise, which is dependent on stimulus attributes such as duration and level, is dominant. In more difficult conditions, where trace-memory and/or across-channel comparisons are required, a more central, stimulus-independent noise dominates.     

Bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops truncatus) steady-state evoked responses to multiple simultaneous sinusoidal amplitude modulated tones

Auditory steady-state evoked potentials were measured in a bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops truncatus) in response to single and multiple sinusoidal amplitude modulated (SAM) tones. Tests were conducted in air using a "jawphone" sound projector. Evoked potentials were recorded noninvasively using surface electrodes embedded in suction cups. Sound stimuli consisted of SAM tones with 1, 2, 3, or 4 carrier frequencies (10, 20, 30, 40 kHz), each with a unique modulation frequency. Stimulus sound pressure levels were varied in 5-dB steps from approximately 120 to 60-75 dB re 1 microPa, depending on frequency. Evoked potentials followed the temporal envelope of each stimulus, resulting in spectral components at each unique modulation frequency. Spectral analysis was used to evaluate the response amplitude for each carrier as a function of stimulus level. There were no significant differences between thresholds obtained with single and multiple stimuli at 10, 30, and 40 kHz. At 20 kHz, thresholds obtained with three components were higher than those obtained with four components, possibly revealing interactions between stimuli with less than one octave frequency separation. The use of multiple SAM stimuli may offer substantial advantages for studies of marine mammal hearing, where testing time and access to subjects are typically limited.     

Tactile information transfer: a comparison of two stimulation sites

Two experiments on the discrimination of time-varying tactile stimuli were performed, with comparison of stimulus delivery to the distal pad of the right index finger and to the right wrist (palmar surface). Subjects were required to perceive differences in short sequences of computer-generated stimulus elements (experiment 1) or differences in short tactile stimuli derived from a speech signal (experiment 2). The pulse-train stimuli were distinguished by differences in frequency (i.e., pulse repetition rate) and amplitude, and by the presence/absence of gaps (approximately 100-ms duration). Stimulation levels were 10 dB higher at the wrist than at the fingertip, to compensate for the lower vibration sensitivity at the wrist. Results indicate similar gap detection at wrist and fingertip and similar perception of frequency differences. However, perception of amplitude differences was found to be better at the wrist than at the fingertip. Maximum information transfer rates for the stimuli in experiment 1 were estimated at 7 bits s(-1) at the wrist and 5 bits s(-1) at the fingertip.     

Factors affecting perception thresholds of vertical whole-body vibration in recumbent subjects: Gender and age of subjects, and vibration duration

Some factors that may affect human perception thresholds of the vertical whole-body vibrations were investigated in two laboratory experiments with recumbent subjects. In the first experiment, the effects of gender and age of subjects on perception were investigated with three groups of 12 subjects, i.e., young males, young females and old males. For continuous sinusoidal vibrations at 2, 4, 8, 16, 31.5 and 63 Hz, there were no significant differences in the perception thresholds between male and female subjects, while the thresholds of young subjects tended to be significantly lower than the thresholds of old subjects. In the second experiment, the effect of vibration duration was investigated by using sinusoidal vibrations, at the same frequencies as above, modulated by the Hanning windows with different lengths (i.e., 0.5, 1.0, 2.0 and 4.0 s) for 12 subjects. It was found that the peak acceleration at the threshold tended to decrease with increasing duration of vibration. The perception thresholds were also evaluated by the running root-mean-square (rms) acceleration and the fourth power acceleration method defined in the current standards. The differences in the threshold of the transient vibrations for different durations were less with the fourth power acceleration method. Additionally, the effect of the integration time on the threshold was investigated for the running rms acceleration and the fourth power acceleration. It was found that the integration time that yielded less differences in the threshold of vibrations for different durations depended on the frequency of vibration.     

Temporal window shape as a function of frequency and level

In an earlier article [Moore et al., J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 83, 1102-1116 (1988)], preliminary work on the temporal-window model of temporal resolution in the auditory system was described. The temporal window is conceived of as a temporal integrator that slides in time and that is implemented as an intensity-weighting function. The shape of the temporal window was estimated by measuring the threshold for a brief sinusoidal signal presented in a temporal gap between two bursts of noise as a function of the duration of the gap and the position of the signal within the gap. In this paper, a much more thorough examination of the effects of level and frequency on the shape of the window is presented, using the same basic technique. Temporal window shapes were measured at four different frequencies (300, 900, 2700, and 8100 Hz) and at three different masker levels covering a 20-dB range at each frequency. The shape of the temporal window was well described by modeling each side as the sum of two rounded-exponential (roex) functions. The equivalent rectangular duration (ERD) of the window decreased from about 13 to 9 ms as the center frequency increased from 300 to 900 Hz, but decreased only slightly, to 7 ms, as the center frequency increased to 8100. The greater ERD at 300 Hz does not seem to be explicable in terms of "ringing" in the auditory filter. The ERD decreased somewhat with increasing level, for example, having a value of about 10 ms at 2700 Hz with a 20-dB masker spectrum level and about 7 ms with a 40-dB masker spectrum level.     

Detection of quasitrapezoidal frequency and amplitude modulation

It has been proposed that the detection of frequency modulation (FM) of sinusoidal carriers can be mediated by two mechanisms; a place mechanism based on FM-induced amplitude modulation (AM) in the excitation pattern, and a temporal mechanism based on phase locking in the auditory nerve. The temporal mechanism appears to be "sluggish" and does not play a role for FM rates above about 10 Hz. It also does not play a role for high carrier frequencies (above about 5 kHz). This experiment provided a further test of the hypothesis that the effectiveness of the temporal mechanism depends upon the time spent close to frequency extremes during the modulation cycle. Psychometric functions for the detection of AM and FM were measured for two carrier frequencies, 1 and 6 kHz. The modulation waveform was quasitrapezoidal. Within each modulation period, P, a time Tss was spent at each extreme of frequency or amplitude. The transitions between the extremes, with duration Ttrans had the form of a half-cycle of a cosine function. The modulation rate was 2, 5, 10, or 20 Hz, giving values of P of 500, 200, 100, and 50 ms. TSS varied from 0 ms (sinusoidal modulation) up to 160, 80, 40, or 20 ms, for rates of 2, 5, 10, and 20 Hz, respectively. The detectability of AM was not greatly affected by modulation rate or by the value of TSS, except for a slight improvement with increasing TSS for the lowest modulation rates; this was true for both carrier frequencies. For FM of the 6-kHz carrier, the pattern of results was similar to that found for AM, which is consistent with an excitation-pattern model of FM detection. For FM of the 1-kHz carrier, performance improved markedly with increasing TSS, especially for the lower FM rates; there was no change in performance with TSS for the 20-Hz modulation rate. The results are consistent with the idea that detection of FM of a 1-kHz carrier is partly mediated by a sluggish temporal mechanism. That mechanism benefits from greater time spent at frequency extremes of the modulation cycle for rates up to 10 Hz.     

Frequency resolution for diotic and dichotic listening conditions compared using the bandlimiting measure and a modified bandlimiting measure

Two experiments were performed that examined the relation between frequency selectivity for diotic and dichotic stimuli. Subjects were eight normal-hearing listeners. In each experiment, a 500-Hz pure tone of 400-ms duration was presented in continuous noise. In the diotic listening conditions, a signal and noise were presented binaurally with no interaural differences (So and No, respectively). In the dichotic listening conditions, the signal or noise at one ear was 180 degrees out-of-phase relative to the respective stimulus at the other ear (S pi and N pi, respectively). The first experiment examined frequency selectivity using the bandlimiting measure. Here, signal thresholds were determined as a function of masker bandwidth (50, 100, 250, 500, and 1000 Hz) for SoNo, S pi No, and SoN pi listening conditions. The second experiment used a modified bandlimiting measure. Here, signal thresholds (So and S pi) were determined with a relatively narrow No band of masker energy (50 Hz wide) centered about the signal. Then, a second No narrow-band masker (30 Hz wide) was added at another frequency region, and signal thresholds were reestablished. The results of the two experiments indicated that listeners process a wider band of frequencies when resolving dichotic stimuli than when resolving diotic or monotic stimuli. The results also indicated that the bandlimiting measure may underestimate the spectral band processed upon dichotic stimulation. Results are interpreted in terms of an across-ear and across-frequency processing of waveform amplitude envelope.     

Frequency modulation detection: effects of age, psychophysical method, and modulation waveform

As part of an ongoing study of auditory aging, detection of sinusoidal and quasitrapezoidal frequency modulation (FM) was measured with a 5-Hz modulation frequency and 500- and 4000-Hz carriers in two experiments. In Experiment 1, psychometric functions for FM detection were measured with several modulation waveform time patterns in younger adults with normal hearing. Detection of a three-cycle modulated signal improved when its duration was extended by a preceding unmodulated cycle, an effect similar to adding a modulated cycle. In Experiment 2, FM detection was measured for younger and older adults with normal hearing using two psychophysical methods. Similar to frequency discrimination, FM detection was poorer in older than younger subjects and age-related differences were larger at 500 Hz than at 4000 Hz, suggesting that FM detection with low modulation frequencies and frequency discrimination may share common underlying mechanisms. One mechanism is likely related to temporal information coded by neural phase locking which is strong at low frequencies and decreases with increasing frequency, as observed in animals. The frequency-dependent aging effect suggests that this temporal mechanism may be affected by age. The effect of psychophysical method was sizable and frequency dependent, whereas the effect of modulation waveform was minimal.     

Assessing the discomfort of dual-axis whole-body vibration

This paper reports on an experiment designed to provide information fundamental to the prediction of the discomfort of multi-axis vibration. Seated subjects were exposed to various level and phase combinations of 3·15 Hz vertical (a_z) and 3·15 Hz lateral (a_y) sinusoidal vibration. One part of the experiment determined the levels of two single-axis vibrations (a_zanda_y separately) which produced similar discomfort to a selection of dual-axis vibrations. In another part of the experiment subjects adjusted the level of a 3·15 Hz motion in one of the two axes to produced similar discomfort to each of seven levels of the same frequency in the other axis.It was concluded that for dual-axis motions of the type investigated the discomfort is not greatly influenced by the phase between the two single-axis components producing the motion. Thus, the discomfort caused by the circular motion given by the combinations of the two sinusoidal components differing in phase by 90 degrees is similar to that caused by the translational motion produced by the same components combined with zero phase shift. The results confirm that a meaningful estimate of the relative discomfort produced by dual-axis stimuli can be determined from the levels of a single-axis reference motion appropriately adjusted by subjects. The level of a single-axis motion giving similar discomfort to each of the dual-axis conditions in the experiment was well approximated by the root-mean-square of the two levels of this single-axis motion equivalent to the two separate components of each dual-axis motion.     

The effects of a surround on vibrotactile thresholds: evidence for spatial and temporal independence in the non-Pacinian I (NPI) channel

Detection thresholds were measured for sinusoidal vibrations applied to the thenar eminence and volar forearm. Stimuli were applied via a 0.72-cm2 circular contactor, with and without a rigid surround. At low frequencies, below about 40 Hz, the thresholds were higher without the surround than with the surround. However, in contrast to earlier reports, the shape of the threshold function was the same with and without the surround, suggesting that the temporal and spatial tuning characteristics of the non-Pacinian I (NPI) channel are independent.