Analysis of brake squeal noise using the finite element method: A parametric study

Brake squeal noise has been under investigation by automotive manufacturers for decades due to consistent customer complaints and high warranty costs. J.D. Power surveys consistently show brake noise as being one of the most critical vehicle quality measurements. Furthermore, the development of methods to predict noise occurrence during the design of a brake system has been the target of many researchers in recent years.This paper summarizes the application of complex eigenvalue analysis in a finite element model of a commercial brake system. The effect of the operational parameters (friction coefficient, braking pressure and brake temperature) and wear on the dynamic stability of the brake system is examined. After identifying unstable frequencies and the behavior of the brake system under different conditions, the performance of some control methods are tested. Changes in material properties and the application of brake noise insulators are presented and their effects discussed.The results show that the effect of brake temperature changes the coupling mechanisms between rotor and pad, which in some cases can be useful in order to reduce the instabilities and generated noise. Wear is an operational condition that has an strong effect on the system instability, since stiffness properties of brake pads are influenced by the changes on geometry and on the friction material, leading to high-frequency noise generation when the system is in the end of its lifetime. Application of brake insulators requires a detailed investigation of the system since, for some cases, an increase on the system damping does not balance changes on stiffness, leading the system to instability and noise.     

Analysis of disc brake squeal using the complex eigenvalue method

A new functionality of ABAQUS/Standard, which allows for a nonlinear analysis prior to a complex eigenvalue extraction in order to study the stability of brake systems, is used to analyse disc brake squeal. An attempt is made to investigate the effects of system parameters, such as the hydraulic pressure, the rotational velocity of the disc, the friction coefficient of the contact interactions between the pads and the disc, the stiffness of the disc, and the stiffness of the back plates of the pads, on the disc squeal. The simulation results show that significant pad bending vibration may be responsible for the disc brake squeal. The squeal can be reduced by decreasing the friction coefficient, increasing the stiffness of the disc, using damping material on the back plates of the pads, and modifying the shape of the brake pads.     

Brake squeal reduction of vehicle disc brake system with interval parameters by uncertain optimization

An uncertain optimization method for brake squeal reduction of vehicle disc brake system with interval parameters is presented in this paper. In the proposed method, the parameters of frictional coefficient, material properties and the thicknesses of wearing components are treated as uncertain parameters, which are described as interval variables. Attention is focused on the stability analysis of a brake system in squeal, and the stability of brake system is investigated via the complex eigenvalue analysis (CEA) method. The dominant unstable mode is extracted by performing CEA based on a linear finite element (FE) model, and the negative damping ratio corresponding to the dominant unstable mode is selected as the indicator of instability. The response surface method (RSM) is applied to approximate the implicit relationship between the unstable mode and the system parameters. A reliability-based optimization model for improving the stability of the vehicle disc brake system with interval parameters is constructed based on RSM, interval analysis and reliability analysis. The Genetic Algorithm is used to get the optimal values of design parameters from the optimization model. The stability analysis and optimization of a disc brake system are carried out, and the results show that brake squeal propensity can be reduced by using stiffer back plates. The proposed approach can be used to improve the stability of the vehicle disc brake system with uncertain parameters effectively.     

A new treatment for predicting the self-excited vibrations of nonlinear systems with frictional interfaces: The Constrained Harmonic Balance Method,with application to disc brake squeal

Brake squeal noise is still an issue since it generates high warranty costs for the automotive industry and irritation for customers. Key parameters must be known in order to reduce it. Stability analysis is a common method of studying nonlinear phenomena and has been widely used by the scientific and the engineering communities for solving disc brake squeal problems. This type of analysis provides areas of stability versus instability for driven parameters, thereby making it possible to define design criteria. Nevertheless, this technique does not permit obtaining the vibrating state of the brake system and nonlinear methods have to be employed. Temporal integration is a well-known method for computing the dynamic solution but as it is time consuming, nonlinear methods such as the Harmonic Balance Method (HBM) are preferred. This paper presents a novel nonlinear method called the Constrained Harmonic Balance Method (CHBM) that works for nonlinear systems subject to flutter instability. An additional constraint-based condition is proposed that omits the static equilibrium point (i.e. the trivial static solution of the nonlinear problem that would be obtained by applying the classical HBM) and therefore focuses on predicting both the Fourier coefficients and the fundamental frequency of the stationary nonlinear system.The effectiveness of the proposed nonlinear approach is illustrated by an analysis of disc brake squeal. The brake system under consideration is a reduced finite element model of a pad and a disc. Both stability and nonlinear analyses are performed and the results are compared with a classical variable order solver integration algorithm.Therefore, the objectives of the following paper are to present not only an extension of the HBM (CHBM) but also to demonstrate an application to the specific problem of disc brake squeal with extensively parametric studies that investigate the effects of the friction coefficient, piston pressure, nonlinear stiffness and structural damping.     

Finite element modelling for the investigation of in-plane modes and damping shims in disc brake squeal

Squeal propensity of the in-plane modes and the constrained-layer type damping shims for disc brake system is investigated by using the finite element method. Theoretical formulation is derived for a rotating disc in contact with two stationary vibrating pads attached to the damping shim components. By the conversion from the theoretical to FE brake model, the full equations of motion for the actual disc brake system describes the disc rotation, the in-plane friction characteristics and damping shims in association with squeal vibration. It is concluded from the results that the in-plane torsion modes can be generated by the negative friction slope, but they cannot be controlled by the damping shims. The in-plane radial mode is also investigated and found to be very insensitive in squeal generation.     

Chaos in brake squeal noise

Brake squeal has become an increasing concern to the automotive industry because of warranty costs and the requirement for continued interior vehicle noise reduction. Most research has been directed to either analytical and experimental studies of brake squeal mechanisms or the prediction of brake squeal propensity using finite element methods. By comparison, there is a lack of systematic analysis of brake squeal data obtained from a noise dynamometer. It is well known that brake squeal is a nonlinear transient phenomenon and a number of studies using analytical and experimental models of brake systems (e.g., pin-on-disc) indicate that it could be treated as a chaotic phenomenon. Data obtained from a full brake system on a noise dynamometer were examined with nonlinear analysis techniques. The application of recurrence plots reveals chaotic structures even in noisy data from the squealing events. By separating the time series into different regimes, lower dimensional attractors are isolated and quantified by dynamic invariants such as correlation dimension estimates or Lyapunov exponents. Further analysis of the recurrence plot of squealing events by means of recurrence quantification analysis measures reveals different regimes of laminar and random behaviour, periodicity and chaos-forming recurrent transitions. These results help to classify brake squeal mechanisms and to enhance understanding of friction-related noise phenomena.     

Minimal models for disk brake squeal

Numerous publications on the modeling of disk brake squeal can be found in the literature. Recent publications describe the onset of disk brake squeal as an instability of the trivial solution resulting from the non-conservative friction forces even for a constant friction coefficient. Therefore, a minimal model of disk brake squeal must contain at least two degrees of freedom. A literature review of minimal models shows that there is still a lack of a minimal model describing the basic behavior of disk brake squeal which can easily be associated to an automotive disk brake.Therefore, a new minimal model of a disk brake is introduced here, showing an obvious relation to the technical system. In this model, the vibration of the disk is taken into account, as it plays a dominant role in brake squeal. The model is analyzed with respect to its stability behavior, and consequences in using it in the optimization of disk brake systems are discussed.     

The method of feed-in energy on disc brake squeal

Brake squeal is studied in this paper by feed-in energy analysis. Based on the brake closed-loop coupling model, a calculation method of feed-in energy for squeal mode is derived. Result of the feed-in energy indicates squeal tendency of the brake system, while formula for calculating it discloses the relation among brake squeal phenomenon and structural parameters, such as frictional coefficient, geometric shape of brake pads, elastic modulus of frictional material, substructure modal shape, etc. The method also helps to analyze the effectiveness of various structural modification schemes attempted to eliminate the squeal noise. Finally, this method is illustrated by application to a typical squealing disc brake.     

Squeal and chatter phenomena generated in a mountain bike disc brake

This paper examines squeal and chatter phenomena generated experimentally in mountain bike disc brakes. There are two kinds of frictional self-excited vibrations in the bike disc brakes, called squeal with frequency of 1 kHz and chatter with frequency of 500 Hz. In order to reproduce the squeal and chatter, a bench test apparatus using an actual bike was set up to determine the associated frequency characteristics experimentally. The results show the frequencies to be independent of pad temperature and disc rotating speed. Squeal is shown to be in-plane vibration in the direction of the disc surface which is caused by the frictional characteristics having negative slope with respect to the relative velocity in the vibrating system, which includes brake unit, spokes and hub. Chatter is generated within a limited high temperature region. Again, it is frictional vibration in which the squeal and out-of-plane vibration of the disc due to Coulomb friction combine through the internal resonance relation between in-plane and out-of-plane nonlinear vibration caused by the temperature increase of the disc during braking.     

A note on safety-relevant vibrations induced by brake squeal

Brake squeal is mostly considered as a comfort problem only but there are cases in which self-excited vibrations of the brake system not only cause an audible noise but also result in safety-relevant failures of the system. In particular this can occur if lightweight design rims having very low damping are used. Considering the special conditions of lightweight design rims, a minimal model for safety-relevant self-excited vibrations of brake systems is presented. It is shown that most of the knowledge emanated from investigations of the comfort problem can be used to understand and avoid safety-relevant failures of the brake system.     

Eigenvalue optimization against brake squeal: Symmetry,mathematical background and experiments

Brake squeal is still a challenge for design engineers and scientists. Due to cost reasons for the avoidance of brake noise only passive measures are meaningful for a broad industrial range. Many countermeasures against squeal are based on the introduction of damping, for example by using shims. In the literature on the modeling of brake squeal, the structural properties of the brake disc are most often not considered. It has however been shown analytically and experimentally that the stiffness properties of the disc are important and that splitting of double modes of the disc has a stabilizing effect. This knowledge can be used for structural optimization of brake rotors. The goal of this paper is to exploit the potential and to discuss some mathematical difficulties. Furthermore, experimental evidence for the relation of rotor asymmetry and squeal is given.     

Modeling of automotive drum brakes for squeal and parameter sensitivity analysis

Many fundamental studies have been conducted to explain the occurrence of squeal in disc and drum brake systems. The elimination of brake squeal, however, still remains a challenging area of research. Here, a numerical modeling approach is developed for investigating the onset of squeal in a drum brake system. The brake system model is based on the modal information extracted from finite element models for individual brake components. The component models of drum and shoes are coupled by the shoe lining material which is modeled as springs located at the centroids of discretized drum and shoe interface elements. The developed multi degree of freedom coupled brake system model is a linear non-self-adjoint system. Its vibrational characteristics are determined by a complex eigenvalue analysis. The study shows that both the frequency separation between two system modes due to static coupling and their associated mode shapes play an important role in mode merging. Mode merging and veering are identified as two important features of modes exhibiting strong interactions, and those modes are likely candidates that lead to coupled-mode instability. Techniques are developed for a parameter sensitivity analysis with respect to lining stiffness and the stiffness of the brake actuation system. The influence of lining friction coefficient on the propensity to squeal is also discussed.     

Instabilities in the sliding of continua with surface inertias: An initiation mechanism for brake noise

This paper presents a model for friction-induced vibration in brake systems, which takes a homogeneous tribological layer on the brake pad into account. The derived model consists of two flat elastic bodies sliding against each other with a constant coefficient of friction. In brake tribology, like in most tribological processes, a surface structure is observed, which can be modeled as an additional film of homogenized mass distribution bonded on the moving continua. The developed mechanical model and its analytical solution show an excitation mechanism that bases on the interaction of normal and frictional shear force and on the elastic coupling of spatial directions. The derived solution allows to study stability and eigenforms of the sliding process: on the frictional plane traveling surface waves are generated, with stability properties depending on parameters of the tribological layer. A parameter study analyzes the frictional couple of brake disk and pad and the related surface state. It is found that increasing inertias of surface structures on the pad strengthen instabilities of the sliding system. A comparison with experiments suggests a similar dependency between surface state and stability as observed by the model under discussion.     

Modal Amplitude Stability Analysis and its application to brake squeal

In the present study, a new approach is proposed to predict the occurrence of squeal in brake systems. This strategy, called Modal Amplitude Stability Analysis (MASA), is based on the calculation of the first harmonic state-space system of nonlinear original equations using a specific linearization of the nonlinear contact forces at the frictional interfaces. An estimation of the occurrence and generation of increasing self-excited vibration is proposed on the basis of monitoring and the evolution of the real parts of the dynamic system considered as a function of modal amplitudes.     

How can automotive friction-induced noises be related to physical mechanisms?

Three main physical mechanisms are found in the literature to explain the occurrence of friction-induced noises: the stick–slip, the sprag-slip and the mode-coupling instabilities. In order to improve the understanding of the automotive friction-induced noises and regarding the variety of these noises and the systems concerned, the consideration of these three physical mechanisms in a unique model, called phenomenological model, is proposed. The relationships between the mechanisms at the origin of friction-induced noises and the different kinds of friction-induced noises that can be perceived in a vehicle are particularly investigated. First, a simple classification of automotive-friction induced noises is proposed and highlights three noise categories: squeal, squeak and creak noises. Time simulations carried out on the phenomenological model show the qualitative reproduction of the vibrational behaviors at the origin of these three noise categories. Conditions are then proposed to define the three noise categories, based on the contact states ratios encountered in the time response. In order to understand the relationships between the three physical mechanisms and the three noise categories, a fullfact design of experiments is carried out with the phenomenological model. A system with realistic dynamic properties is used and submitted to a large number of conditions of use, allowing the appearance of a wide diversity of responses. The results show that the three mechanisms as well as the three noise categories can be obtained on a same dynamic system. They also show that creak is caused by a stick–slip phenomenon, squeal is mainly due to a mode-coupling phenomenon, while squeak can be caused either by mode-coupling or stick–slip phenomena. Finally, the occurrence of each mechanism and noise category is independently analyzed for the given dynamic system, giving quite significant trends towards model parameters. These trends highlight some interesting design levers to reduce the propensity of noise for an automotive structure.     

Performances of some reduced bases for the stability analysis of a disc/pads system in sliding contact

The complex eigenvalue analysis is a widely used technique to investigate the stability of a dynamical system with frictional contact. In the case of brake systems, it is the most frequently employed method to study the propensity of the brake to generate squeal noise. When finite element models are considered, iterative solvers are needed to calculate the complex modes and eigenvalues with good precision. In practice, reduced real bases are often used in order to reduce the computational times. However, great attention should be focused on the errors introduced by the reduction, which is rarely done. In this paper, the performances of some reduced bases are investigated in the case of a simple disc/pads system. Bases composed of real coupled modes and bases provided by Component Mode Synthesis (CMS) techniques are tested. An enrichment of these bases is proposed in order to improve the precision of the results. In particular, new rubbing attachment modes are proposed to adapt free-interface CMS techniques to frictional contact. When real coupled modes are used, it is suggested to complete the basis by the static response to a first-order approximation of the friction forces. Applied to the disc/pads model, the different enrichment options allow a reduction of the errors on frequencies, divergence rates and mode shapes by a factor comprised between 10 and 100 without significantly increasing the computational times.     

Automotive disc brake squeal

Disc brake squeal remains an elusive problem in the automotive industry. Since the early 20th century, many investigators have examined the problem with experimental, analytical, and computational techniques, but there is as yet no method to completely suppress disc brake squeal. This paper provides a comprehensive review and bibliography of works on disc brake squeal. In an effort to make this review accessible to a large audience, background sections on vibrations, contact and disc brake systems are also included.     

Expansion-chamber muffler for impulse noise of pneumatic frictional clutch and brake in mechanical presses

A compound expansion-chamber muffler, which consists of a sound absorbing chamber and a switch valve, the chamber integrating structural features of impedance muffler and micropunch plate muffler, is proposed to diminish impulse exhaust noise of pneumatic friction clutch and pneumatic friction brake (PFC/B) in mechanical presses. The structure decreases the impulse exhaust noise of PFC/B over 30 dB(A). A one-dimensional flow model is applied to study the aerodynamic characteristics of compound exhaust process of the single acting cylinder and muffler because the exhaust time is a critical factor for application of muffler in PFC/B. The volume of sound absorbing chamber is found to be an important design parameter to minimize the exhaust resistance of pneumatic cylinder. Experiments are also conducted to validate analytical results. Then the effects of diameter of exhaust ducts and volume of muffler on the exhaust time are discussed in detail. The proposed one-dimensional computational method, which considers the coupling of air-flow field and sound field, gives satisfactory results for the preliminary design of an expansion-chamber muffler. This method has been applied to an existing model HKM3-40MN to reduce its impulse noise.