Chiral separations by capillary electromigration techniques in nonaqueous media. I. Enantioselective nonaqueous capillary electrophoresis

Enantiomer separations by CE employing nonaqueous conditions are reviewed. The general focus of this article is directed towards solvent effects on chiral recognition and the separation mechanism. After a general discussion of solvent effects on the individual processes involved in CE enantiomer separation, specifics for various selector classes are discussed together with a few applications of enantioselective nonaqueous CE.     

Polymethacrylate-type monoliths functionalized with chiral amino phosphonic acid-derived strong cation exchange moieties for enantioselective nonaqueous capillary electrochromatography and investigation of the chemical composition of the monolithic polymer

In situ prepared monolithic poly(glycidyl methacrylate-co-ethylene dimethacrylate) (poly(GMA-co-EDMA)) capillary columns were activated to reactive thiol-monoliths and subsequently functionalized with (S)-N-(4-allyloxy-3,5-dichlorobenzoyl)-2-amino-3,3-dimethylbutanephosphonic acid as chiral selector by radical addition to afford enantioselective strong cation exchanger (SCX) capillary columns (100 microm inner diameter (ID)). These monolithic capillaries were devised for the enantioseparation of chiral bases by nonaqueous and aqueous capillary electrochromatography (CEC) and the results obtained for mefloquine and its tert-butylcarbamate as test compounds were compared to those obtained with particulate silica-based analogs (packed columns). Despite abolishment of nonspecific ionic interactions between the cationic solutes and residual silanols that may diminish separation factors of the silica-based chiral SCX particles, the poly(GMA-co-EDMA)-supported SCX monolith did not, as expected, show better enantioselectivities, which was assumed to be due to detrimental nonspecific interactions between the analytes and the lipophilic polymer backbone. In order to minimize these unfavorable contributions, less lipophilic monoliths were developed by copolymerization of different amounts of the hydrophilic monomer 2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate (HEMA) with GMA and EDMA, leading to GMA-co-HEMA-co-EDMA-terpolymeric monoliths. By this increase of the hydrophilicity of the monolithic support the enantioselectivity of the resultant SCX stationary phase could be enhanced and reached values comparable to the packed silica-based enantioselective SCX capillaries. Additionally, the mobile phase composition and other variables were examined and it could be shown that the separation factors are considerably affected by diverse parameters such as acetonitrile-methanol ratio and type and concentration of the counterion. Mefloquine enantiomers could be separated with alpha-values up to 1.56 and a maximum plate count of ca. 60,000 m(-1) could be achieved.     

Enantioseparations in nonaqueous capillary liquid chromatography and capillary electrochromatography using cellulose tris(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate) as chiral stationary phase

The potential of the widely used chiral stationary phase for high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) enantioseparations, cellulose tris(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate) (CDMPC, sold under the trade name Chiralcel OD) was evaluated under the conditions of nonaqueous capillary electrochromatography (CEC). The effect of the particle size of the silica gel, the loading of CDMPC on the silica gel and nature of the organic solvent, as well as electrolyte salts on the separation characteristics were investigated. This study illustrates the applicability of CDMPC for obtaining highly efficient enantioseparations under the conditions of nonaqueous CEC. Comparative study of enantioseparations in capillary liquid chromatography (CLC) and CEC indicated the significant advantages of CEC such as higher plate number at the similar linear flow rates of the mobile phase as well as better tolerance of higher linear flow rates.     

Recent progress in enantiomeric separation by capillary electrochromatography

Recent progress in enantiomeric separations by capillary electrochromatography (CEC) is reviewed. The development of simple and robust CEC column technologies plays an important role for popularization of CEC. During the last several years, various approaches for the preparation of enantioselective columns have been reported. Currently, the monolithic column technology (continuous beds) represents the most advanced approach for the preparation of CEC columns. The development of new chiral stationary phase used for CEC is another important issue in this field. Fundamental investigations on electrochromatographic behaviors of various CSPs are necessary in order to understand the separation mechanism and thus improve the separation performance. Some chiral stationary phases performed better under nonaqueous CEC conditions than reversed-phase conditions. Coupling CEC with mass spectrometry (MS) provides a powerful tool for enantiomeric separation. Finally, some applications of enantiomeric separation by CEC are summarized.     

Separation of enantiomers by capillary electrochromatography

The current popularity of capillary electrochromatography (CEC) has led to an increasing number of studies on the development and evaluation of enantioselective CEC systems. These studies clearly demonstrate that the most prominent advantage of electrically driven separation methods, the vastly increased column efficiency as compared to pressure-driven chromatography, can also be experimentally achieved for the separations of enantiomers. In analogy to high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) and capillary electrophoresis (CE), several approaches have been used. The addition of a chiral selector to the mobile phase is the simplest method. Less erroneous and more elegant approaches are those that use open-tubular, conventional packed, and monolithic columns containing chiral stationary phases that stereoselectively interact with enantiomers. This review evaluates the new techniques and compares them to enantioselective HPLC and CE. Further, it describes the various concepts of enantioselective CEC and focuses on the current ‘state-of-the-art' column technology.     

Enantiomer separation by nonaqueous and aqueous capillary electrochromatography on cyclodextrin stationary phases

Native beta- and gamma-cyclodextrin bound to silica (ChiraDex-beta and ChiraDex-gamma) were packed into capillaries and used for enantiomer separation by capillary electrochromatography (CEC) under aqueous and nonaqueous conditions. Negatively charged analytes (dansyl-amino acids) were resolved into their enantiomers by nonaqueous CEC (NA-CEC). The addition of a small amount of water to the nonaqueous mobile phase enhanced the enantioselectivity but increased the elution time. The choice of the background electrolyte (BGE) determined the direction of the electroosmotic flow (EOF). With 2-(N-morpholino) ethanesulfonic acid (MES) or triethylammonium acetate (TEAA) as BGE an inverse EOF (anodic EOF) was observed while with phosphate a cathodic EOF was found. The apparent pH (pH*), the concentration of the BGE, and the nature of the mobile phase strongly influenced the elution time, the theoretical plate number and the chiral separation factor of racemic analytes.     

Chiral silica-based monoliths in chromatography and capillary electrochromatography

Chiral-modified silica-based monoliths have become well-established stationary phases for both high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) and capillary electrochromatography (CEC). The silica-based monoliths were fabricated either in situ in the capillaries for nano-HPLC and CEC or in a mould for “conventional” HPLC. The present review summarizes the chiral modification of silica monoliths and the recent development in the field of enantioselective separations by nano-HPLC and CEC.     

Chiral separations in capillary high-performance liquid chromatography and nonaqueous capillary electrochromatography using helically chiral poly(diphenyl-2-pyridylmethyl methacrylate) as chiral stationary phase.

Enantioseparations in nonaqueous capillary electrochromatography (CEC) are reported in this study for the first time, using wide-pore aminopropyl silica gel coated with helically chiral poly(diphenyl-2-pyridylmethyl methacrylate) (PDPM) as chiral stationary phase (CSP). The anodic electroosmotic flow (EOF) in a methanolic solution of ammonium acetate was used for the migration of neutral analytes through the packed bed in the capillaries. Four different techniques, high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) in common-size columns, capillary HPLC, pressure-assisted CEC and CEC were compared from the viewpoint of separation parameters. The latter three were performed with the same experimental setup, varying the relative contribution of the pressure-driven and the electrically driven flow to the overall mobility of the analyte. Capillary HPLC offers clear advantages compared to enantioseparations in common-size columns. However, for a given particle size of the packing material, CEC was not obviously advantageous compared to pressure-driven separations.     

Novel enantioselective strong cation exchangers based on sulfodipeptide selectors: evaluation for enantiomer separation of chiral bases by nonaqueous capillary electrochromatography

Strong cation exchange (SCX)-type chiral stationary phases (CSPs) based on beta-amino sulfonic acid-terminated dipeptide derivatives as chiral selectors, immobilized on thiol-modified silica particles (3.5 microm), were synthesized and applied to enantiomer separations of chiral bases by nonaqueous capillary electrochromatography (CEC). The effect of structural variations of the sulfodipeptide selectors on the separation factors alpha was investigated. These studies included variation of the acid-terminal amino sulfonic acid residue, variation of the configurations, i.e., comparison of the diastereomeric (S,S)- and (R,S)-configurations of the sulfodipeptides, and finally comparison of sulfodipeptide selectors with corresponding beta-amino sulfonic acid analogs. In general, the capillary columns (100 microm ID) packed with the new SCX-type CSPs showed enantioselectivity for an elaborated set of chiral basic drugs in CEC acting by an enantioselective cation-exchange retention mechanism. N-[N-(4-Allyloxy-3,5-dichlorobenzoyl)-leucyl]-2-amino-3,3-dimethylbutane sulfonic acid, in particular with (R,S)-configuration, turned out to be a more effective SCX-type selector than a more rigid analog based on N-[N-(4-Allyloxy-3,5-dichlorobenzoyl)-leucyl]-2-pyrrolidinemethane sulfonic acid. Both of the former diastereomers were capable to baseline-resolve the enantiomers of ca. 40% of the tested basic chiral solutes including sympathomimetics and beta-blockers, while for the latter SCX-type CSPs only 10-20% of the selected solutes afforded resolutions > 1.5.     

Deconvolution of electrokinetic and chromatographic contributions to solute migration in stereoselective ion-exchange capillary electrochromatography on monolithic silica capillary columns

A monolithic silica stationary phase functionalized with an enantioselective strong cation exchanger based on an aminosulfonic acid derivative was used for chiral separations of basic test solutes by nonaqueous CEC and capillary LC. The effects of the applied electric field as well as the ionic strength in the eluent on electrokinetic and chromatographic contributions to the overall separation performance in the electrically driven mode were investigated. Hence, under the utilized experimental conditions, i. e., at an electric field strength in the range of approximately 120-720 V/cm (applied voltages 4-24 kV) and an ionic strength of the counterion between 5 and 25 mM (at constant acid-to-base, i. e., co- to counterion ratio of 2:1), no deviations from the expected linearity of the EOF were observed. This led to the conclusion that an occurrence of the so-called electrokinetic effects of the second kind resulting from electric double layer overlap inside the mesopores of the monolithic stationary phase and concentration polarization phenomena were largely negligible. Additional support to this conclusion was inferred from the observed independence of CEC retention factors on the electric field strength across the investigated ionic strength range of the BGE. As a consequence, a simple framework allowing for calculation of the CEC mobilities from the individual separation contributions, viz. electroosmotic and electrophoretic mobilities as well as retention factors, could be applied to model CEC migration. There was a reasonable agreement between calculated and experimental CEC mobility data with deviations typically below 5%. The deconvolution of the individual contributions to CEC migration and separation is of particular value for the understanding of the separation processes in which electrophoretic migration of ionic sample constituents plays a significant role like in ion-exchange CEC and may aid the optimization procedure of the BGE and other experimental conditions such as the optimization of the surface chemistry of the stationary phase. In combination with the remarkable column performance evident from the low theoretical plate heights observed under CEC conditions for all test solutes (3.5-7.5 microm in the flow rate range of 0.4-1.2 mm/s, corresponding to (130,000-300,000 plates per meter), the presented framework provides an attractive tool as the basis for the assessment of chromatographic selectivities in a miniaturized CEC screening of new selectors and chiral stationary phases (CSPs), respectively, from experimental CEC data and known CE mobilities.     

Enantiomeric impurity profiling in ephedrine samples by enantioselective capillary electrochromatography

This study reports on the development and preliminary validation of a capillary electrochromatographic (CEC) method for the enantioselective impurity profiling of D-ephedrine. As chiral selector a novel low-molecular-weight strong chiral cation exchanger, based on penicillamine sulfonic acid, immobilized on thiol-modified silica particles (3.5 microm) was employed. Under optimized conditions, the ephedrine enantiomers were separated on this chiral stationary phase (CSP) with an enantioselectivity of 1.11, an average efficiency of 321 550 plates per meter, and a resolution value of 4.77. A preliminary method validation was carried out to demonstrate the applicability of CEC for enantiomeric excess (ee) determination. Run-to-run repeatabilities (n = 5) reached relative standard deviation values (RSD) of 0.18 and 0.19% for the migration times of L- and D-enantiomer, respectively, 0.3% for the resolution, and about 0.9% for the peak efficiencies. An approach called self-internal standard method was utilized to measure a standard calibration curve. Excellent linearity with a correlation coefficient of R(2) = 0.9998 was found for samples with concentrations in the range between 0.03 and 5 mg.mL(-1) D-ephedrine spiked with L-ephedrine at a constant concentration of 0.2 mg.mL(-1). The high loadability of the investigated CSP and good peak sensitivity allowed us to determine less than 0.1% enantiomeric impurity with good accuracy. The limit of detection (LOD) for the L-enantiomer in a 3 mg.mL(-1) D-ephedrine solution was found to be 0.035% (S/N = 3) and the limit of quantitation (LOQ) 0.058% (S/N = 5). For L-ephedrine samples the strong cation-exchange (SCX)-type CSP with opposite configuration was utilized so that the enantiomeric impurity eluted before the main component peak yielding similar results in terms of separation and validation. Based on these results, the presented nonaqueous CEC methods are assessed as principally suitable for ee determination of ephedrine in terms of repeatability and method sensitivity.     

Preparation and characterization of grafted imprinted monolith for capillary electrochromatography

In this paper, a molecularly imprinted polymer (MIP) coating grafted to a trimethylolpropane trimethacrylate (TRIM) core material for CEC was reported. The core monolith was prepared with a solution of 20% (w/w) TRIM in a mixture of porogen and a polymerization precursor, which can generate a stable electroosmotic flow due to the formation of ionizable groups after postpolymerization hydrolization. Graft polymerization took place on the resultant TRIM monolith with a mixture of template, methacrylic acid, and ethylene glycol dimethacrylate. Strong recognition ability (selectivity factor was 5.83) for S‐amlodipine and resolution of enatiomers separation (up to 7.99) were obtained on the resulting grafted imprinted monolith in CEC mode. The influence of CEC conditions on chiral separation, including the composition of mobile phase, pH value, and the operating voltages was studied. These results suggest that the method of grafted polymerization reported here allows a rapid development of MIP monolith once core materials with desired properties are available, and is a good alternative to prepare CEC‐based monolithic MIPs.     

A glycopeptide antibiotic chiral stationary phase for the enantiomer resolution of hydroxy acid derivatives by capillary electrochromatography

Separation of hydroxy acid enantiomers was achieved by using capillary electrochromatography (CEC) employing a chiral stationary phase (CSP) based on MDL 63,246 (Hepta-Tyr), a macrocyclic antibiotic of the teicoplanin family. The chiral selector was chemically bonded to 5 num diol-modified silica particles and the CSP mixed with amino silica (3:1 w/w) was packed into a 75 num ID fused-silica capillary. The CEC experiments were carried out by using an aqueous reversed-phase mode for the enantiomeric resolution of hydroxy acid compounds. Good enantioresolution was achieved for mandelic acid (MA), m-hydroxymandelic acid (m-OH-MA), p-OH-MA, and 3-hydroxy-4-methoxymandelic acid (3-OH-4-MeO-MA). The CEC system was less enantioselective towards 2-phenyllactic acid (2-PhL) and 3-PhL while mandelic acid methyl ester (MA-Et-Est) enantiomers were not resolved. Several experimental parameters, such as organic solvent type and concentration, buffer pH, capillary temperature, on enantioresolution factor, retention time, and retention factor were studied.     

Enantioseparations using nonaqueous capillary electrochromatography on cellulose and amylose tris(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamates) coated on silica gels of various pore and particle size

Enantioseparations of chiral compounds were studied in nonaqueous capillary electrochromatography (NAQ CEC) with cellulose and amylose tris(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamates) (Chiralcel OD and Chiralpak AD, respectively) coated on the silica gels of various pore and particle size. Increasing intraparticle perfusive transport with increasing pore size of silica favorably affected peak efficiency and resolution of enantiomers, although some decrease of separation factor was observed in the pore size range 60-200 A. Further improvement of peak efficiency was observed when the particle size of silica was reduced from 5 to 3 microm. The effects of a separation medium and temperature are also reported and the data obtained in the same capillaries in CEC and capillary liquid chromatography (LC) mode are compared.     

Efficiency studies in nonaqueous capillary electrophoresis

Nonaqueous capillary electrophoresis (NACE) is a relatively new area with several advantages that include enhanced efficiency and improved detection sensitivity. The goal of this study was to investigate the influence of NACE compared to aqueous CE on the separation efficiency of oligosaccharides. The applied voltage and buffer concentration were optimized for the aqueous and nonaqueous buffer media to minimize the band broadening effects of Joule heating and electrophoretic dispersion. At the optimized conditions a 1.5-fold enhancement in efficiency was obtained with the nonaqueous buffer medium.     

Alcohols and wide-bore capillaries in nonaqueous capillary electrophoresis.

The feasibility of using C1-C5 alcohols as electrolyte solutions in nonaqueous capillary zone electrophoresis was investigated. The separation of basic narcotic analgesics and acidic diuretics was modified by changing the alcohol in an electrolyte solution containing alcohol-acetonitrile-acetic acid (50:49:1, v/v) and 20 mM ammonium acetate while other experimental conditions were kept constant. The alcohols studied were methanol, ethanol, 1-propanol, 2-propanol, 1-butanol, 2-butanol, and 1-pentanol. The results indicate that even longer-chain alcohols can be used in nonaqueous capillary zone electrophoresis and, because of the lower currents they allow, they are especially advantageous in wider capillaries. Basic analytes were separated in 200 microm and 320 microm ID capillaries with 1-butanol-acetonitrile-acetic acid (50:49:1, v/v) containing 20 mM ammonium acetate as electrolyte solution. Problems related to the use of wide-bore capillaries are discussed.     

Enantioseparations using capillary electromigration techniques in nonaqueous buffers

This review summarizes recent developments in the field of enantioseparations in capillary electromigration techniques using nonaqueous background electrolytes. The more established and rather intensively reviewed field of nonaqueous chiral capillary electrophoresis (NAQ-CE) is covered in less detail whereas more attention is paid to the relatively new field of nonaqueous capillary electrochromatography (NAQ-CEC).     

Separation of enantiomers by nanoliquid chromatography and capillary electrochromatography using a bonded cellulose trisphenylcarbamate stationary phase

A cellulose trisphenylcarbamate-bonded chiral stationary phase was applied to nano-liquid chromatography (nano-LC) and capillary electrochromatography (CEC) with nonaqueous and aqueous solutions as the mobile phases. Several chiral compounds were successfully resolved on the prepared phase by nano-LC. The applicability of nonaqueous CEC on a cellulose derivative stationary phase was investigated with the organic solvents methanol, hexane, 2-propanol, and tetrahydrofuran (THF) containing acetic acid, as well as triethylamine as the mobile phases. Enantiomers of warfarin and praziquantel were baseline-resolved with plate numbers of 82,300 and 38,800 plates/m, respectively, for the first eluting enantiomer. The influence of applied voltage, concentration of nonpolar solvent, apparent pH, and buffer concentration in the mobile phase on the electroosmotic flow (EOF) and the mobility of the enantiomers was evaluated. Enantioseparations of trans-stilbene oxide and praziquantel were also achieved in aqueous CEC with plate numbers of 111,100 and 107,400 plates/m, respectively, for the first eluting enantiomer. A comparison between nonaqueous CEC and aqueous CEC based on a cellulose trisphenylcarbamate stationary phase was discussed. Pressure-assisted CEC was examined for the chiral separation of praziquantel and faster analysis with high enantioselectivity was acquired with the proper pressurization of the inlet vial.     

Enantioselective silica-based monoliths modified with a novel aminosulfonic acid-derived strong cation exchanger for electrically driven and pressure-driven capillary chromatography

Silica monoliths modified with trans-(1S,2S)-2-(N-4-allyloxy-3,5-dichlorobenzoyl)amino cyclohexanesulfonic acid were tested for enantioselective separations of various chiral bases by aqueous and nonaqueous CEC as well as nano-HPLC. The optimization of the immobilization procedure showed that an intermediate selector (SO) coverage, as does result from a single static immobilization cycle in the capillary at 60 degrees C with an 8% (m/v) SO solution in methanol, affords maximal EOF and optimal enantioselectivity values, while a second immobilization cycle does not lead to any improvements. Furthermore, the mobile phase composition was examined regarding the effectiveness of aqueous phases (ACN/water and methanol/water) compared to nonaqueous eluents (ACN/methanol) in terms of separation selectivity and efficiency. Additionally, different acids of varying strengths were tested as co-ions in the ion-exchange process, including formic acid, acetic acid, methanesulfonic acid, and TFA (pK(a) from 4.75 to 0.5). It turned out that the effects regarding EOF and enantioselectivity were largely negligible. The chromatographic efficiencies of the new capillary columns were compelling and remarkable for bases. H-u curves established for mefloquine revealed a C-term contribution (resistance to mass transfer) by a factor of about six lower in CEC than in nano-HPLC and an A-term (flow maldistribution) about three times lower in the CEC mode. Theoretical plate heights as low as around 3-5 mum could be obtained in CEC over a wide flow range (0.5-1.5 mm/s). Run-to-run repeatabilities like in HPLC and excellent system stability promise the practical usefulness of the novel monolithic capillary column for enantiomeric composition analysis of pharmaceuticals by CEC.     

Enantiomeric separations by nonaqueous capillary electrophoresis

This paper reviews the recent advances in enantioseparations by nonaqueous capillary electrophoresis (NACE) and the effect of organic solvents on mobility of enantiomers, separation selectivity and resolution. In general, the enantioseparation systems in NACE are similar to those of aqueous capillary electrophoresis (CE) except pure organic solvents are used. The influence of important parameters such as concentration and type of chiral selectors, apparent pH, ionic strength, temperature, and control of electroosmotic flow is discussed. In addition, the reported applications of NACE separations of racemates are presented.