Effect of surface character of filler particles on rheology of heat-set whey protein emulsion gels

Small-deformation and large-deformation rheological properties of heat-set whey protein emulsion gels containing active and inactive filler particles have been investigated using a controlled stress rheometer. The results suggest that the contributions to the gel network are quite different for pure protein gels and emulsion gels having similar storage moduli. An emulsion gel containing inactive filler has a larger phase angle due to the energy dissipation at the ‘slippery’ droplet surface under the influence of the applied shear stress. The large-deformation rheology of the heat-set protein gel has behaviour intermediate between that for an entropic biopolymer gel and that for a particle gel. Emulsion gels containing active or inactive fillers behave more like typical particle gel systems.     

The heat stability of milk protein-stabilized oil-in-water emulsions: A review

The knowledge on the factors affecting the heat-induced physicochemical changes of milk proteins and milk protein stabilized oil-in-water emulsions has been advanced for the last decade. Most of the studies have emphasized on the understanding of how milk-protein-stabilized droplets and the non-adsorbed proteins determine the physicochemical and rheological properties of protein-concentrated dairy colloids. The physical stability of concentrated protein-stabilized emulsions (i.e., against creaming or phase separation/gelation after heat treatment) can be modulated by carefully controlling the colloidal properties of the protein-stabilized droplets and the non-adsorbed proteins in the aqueous phase. This article focusses on the review of the physical stability of concentrated milk protein-stabilized oil-in-water emulsions as influenced by physicochemical factors, interparticle interactions (i.e., protein–protein, and droplet–droplet interactions) and processing conditions. Emphasis has been given to the recent advances in the formation, structure and physical stability of oil-in-water emulsions prepared with all types of milk proteins, reviewing in particular the impact of pre- and post-homogenization heat treatments. In addition, the importance of common components found in the continuous phase of heat-treated nutritional emulsions that can promote aggregation (polymers, sugars, minerals) will be highlighted. Finally, the routes of manipulating the steric stabilization of these emulsions to control heat-induced aggregation—through protein–surfactant, protein–protein, protein–polysaccharide interactions and through the incorporation of protein based colloidal particles—are reviewed.     

Influence of sodium dodecyl sulfate on the physicochemical properties of whey protein-stabilized emulsions

The influence of sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) on the flocculation of droplets in 20 wt.% soybean oil-in-water emulsions stabilized by whey protein isolate (WPI) was investigated by light scattering, rheology and creaming measurements. The SDS concentrations used were low enough to prevent depletion flocculation by surfactant micelles and extensive protein displacement. In the absence of SDS, emulsions were prone to droplet flocculation near the isoelectric point of the proteins (4<pH<6), but were stable at a higher and lower pH. Flocculation led to an increase in emulsion viscosity, pronounced shear thinning behavior and accelerated creaming. When the surfactant-to-protein molar ratio was increased from 0 to 10, the emulsion instability range shifted to lower pH values due to binding of the negatively charged SDS molecules to the droplets. Our results indicate that the physicochemical properties of protein-stabilized emulsions can be modified by utilizing surfactant–protein interactions.     

Effects of heat on physicochemical properties of whey protein-stabilised emulsions

The effect of heating has been studied for whey protein-stabilised oil-in-water emulsions (25.0% (w/w) soybean oil, 3.0% (w/w) whey protein isolate, pH 7.0). These emulsions were heated between 55 and 95 °C as a function of time and the effect on particle size distribution, adsorbed protein amount, protein conformation and rheological properties was determined. Heating the emulsions as a function of temperature for 25 min resulted in an increase of the mean diameter (d₃₂) and shear viscosity with a maximum at 75 °C. Heating of the emulsions at different temperatures as a function of time in all cases resulted in a curve with a maximum for d₃₂. A maximum increase of d₃₂ was observed after about 45 min at 75 °C and after 6–8 min at 90 °C. Similar trends were observed with viscosity measurements. Confocal scanning laser micrographs showed that after 8 min of heating at 90 °C large, loose aggregates of oil droplets were formed, while after 20 min of heating compact aggregates of two or three emulsion droplets remained. An increase of the adsorbed amount of protein was found with increasing heating temperature. Plateau values were reached after 10 min of heating at 75 °C and after 5 min of heating at 90 °C. Based on these results we concluded that in the whole process of aggregation of whey protein-stabilised emulsions an essential role is played by the non-adsorbed protein fraction, that the kinetics of the aggregation of whey protein-stabilised emulsions follow similar trends as those for heated whey protein solutions and that upon prolonged heating rearrangements take place leading to deaggregation of initially formed large, loose aggregates of emulsion droplets into smaller, more compact ones.     

The impact of the concentration of casein micelles and whey protein-stabilized fat globules on the rennet-induced gelation of milk

The rennet-induced aggregation of skim milk recombined with whey protein-stabilized emulsion droplets was studied using diffusing wave spectroscopy (DSW) and small deformation rheology. The effect of different volume fractions of casein micelles and fat globules was investigated by observing changes in turbidity (1/l*), apparent radius, elastic modulus and mean square displacement (MSD), in addition to confocal imaging of the gels.Skim milk containing different concentration of casein micelles showed comparable light-scattering profiles; a higher volume fraction of caseins led to the development of more elastic gels.By following the development of 1/l* in recombined milks, it was possible to describe the behaviour of the fat globules during the initial stages of rennet coagulation. Increasing the volume fraction of fat globules showed a significant increase in gel elasticity, caused by flocculation of the oil droplets. The presence of flocculated oil globules within the gel structure was confirmed by confocal microscopy observations. Moreover, a lower degree of κ-casein hydrolysis was needed to initiate casein micelles aggregation in milk containing whey protein-stabilized oil droplets compared to skim milk.This study for the first time clearly describes the impact of a mixture of casein micelles and whey protein-stabilized fat globules on the pre-gelation stages of rennet coagulation, and further highlights the importance of the flocculation state of the emulsion droplets in affecting the structure formation of the gel.     

Effects of various whey protein hydrolysates on the emulsifying and surface properties of hydrolysed lecithin

Oil-in-water emulsions (30 wt% sunflower oil) containing various concentrations of commercial whey protein hydrolysates (0-4 wt%) and hydrolysed lecithin (0.4-1.8 wt%) were prepared by means of a high pressure homogeniser. The degrees of hydrolysis used ranged from 10 to 27%. The individual and interactive effects of these factors on the particle size distribution, emulsion stability, consistency and interfacial tension were investigated using a three-level factorial design according to the principle of response surface methodology. The properties of the emulsions containing both hydrolysed lecithin and whey protein hydrolysate (WPH) were significantly influenced by the degree of hydrolysis of WPH, the protein content and the second-order interaction between both. Addition of WPH, with a 10-20% degree of hydrolysis, improved the stability of lecithin-stabilised emulsions and slightly decreased the average droplet size, compared to those emulsions with only protein or hydrolysed lecithin. However, when extensively hydrolysed WPH (DH=27%) was mixed with hydrolysed lecithin, rapid coalescence and oiling-off of the emulsion droplets resulted, suggesting competition between the surface active components of this WPH and the hydrolysed lecithin. High amounts of such an extensively hydrolysed WPH, together with low lecithin concentrations, were found to be especially detrimental. The different behaviour of partially and extensively hydrolysed WPH in oil-in-water emulsions containing hydrolysed lecithin, was in good agreement with their interfacial activity, as measured by the drop volume method.     

Effects of spray drying on physicochemical properties of milk protein-stabilised emulsions

The effect of spray drying and reconstitution has been studied for oil-in-water emulsions (20.6% maltodextrin, 20% soybean oil, 2.4% protein, 0.13 M NaCl, pH 6.7) with varying ratios of sodium caseinate and whey protein, but with equal size distribution (d₃₂=0.77 μm). When the concentration of sodium caseinate in the emulsion was high enough to entirely cover the oil–water interface, the particle size distribution was hardly affected by spray drying and reconstitution. However, for emulsions of which the total protein consisted of more than 70% whey protein, spray drying resulted in a strong increase of the droplet size distribution. The adsorbed amount of protein ranged from 3 mg m⁻² for casein-stabilised emulsions to 4 mg m⁻² for whey protein-stabilised emulsions with a maximum of 4.2 mg m⁻² for emulsions containing 80% whey protein on total protein, which means that for all these emulsions about one quarter of the available protein was adsorbed at the oil–water interface. The adsorbed amount of protein was hardly affected by spray drying. After emulsion preparation casein proteins adsorbed preferentially at the oil–water interface. As a result of spray drying, the relative amount of β-lactoglobulin in the adsorbed layer increased strongly at the expense of _s1-casein and β-casein. Percentages of _s2-casein and κ-casein in the adsorbed layer remained largely unchanged. The changes in the protein composition of the adsorbed layer as a result of spray drying and reconstitution were the largest when beforehand hardly any whey protein was present in the adsorbed layer and hardly any sodium caseinate in the aqueous phase. Apparently, during spray drying conditions have been such that β-lactoglobulin could unfold, aggregate, and react with other cystein-containing proteins changing the particle size distribution of the emulsions and the composition of the adsorbed layer. It seemed, however, that non-adsorbed sodium caseinate in some way was able to protect the adsorbed casein proteins from being displaced by aggregating whey protein.     

Interfacial rheological properties of adsorbed protein layers and surfactants: a review

Proteins and low molecular weight (LMW) surfactants are widely used for the physical stabilisation of many emulsions and foam based food products. The formation and stabilisation of these emulsions and foams depend strongly on the interfacial properties of the proteins and the LMW surfactants. Therefore these properties have been studied extensively. In this review an overview is given of interfacial properties of proteins at a mesoscopic scale and the effect of LMW surfactants (emulsifiers) on them. Properties addressed are the adsorbed amount, surface tension (reduction), network formation at interfaces and possible conformational changes during and after adsorption. Special attention is given to interfacial rheological behaviour of proteins at expanding and compressing interfaces, which simulate the behaviour in real emulsions and foams. It will be illustrated that information on interfacial rheological properties, protein conformation and interactions between adsorbed molecules can be obtained by changing experimental conditions. The relation between interfacial rheology and emulsion and foam stabilisation is subsequently addressed. It is concluded that there is a need for new measuring devices that monitor several interfacial properties on a mesoscopic and microscopic scale at the same time, and for physical models describing the various processes of importance for proteins. Real progress will only be possible if both are combined in an innovative way.     

Interfacial rheology of protein–surfactant mixtures

The distribution of proteins and surfactants at fluid interfaces (air–water and oil–water) is determined by the competitive adsorption between the two types of emulsifiers and by the nature of the protein–surfactant interactions, both at the interface and in the bulk phase, with a pronounced impact on the interfacial rheological properties of these systems. Therefore, the interfacial rheology is of practical importance for food dispersion (emulsion or foam) formulation, texture, and stability. In this review, the existence of protein–surfactant interactions, the mechanical behaviour and/or the composition of emulsifiers at the interface are indirectly determined by interfacial rheology of the mixed films. The effect on the interfacial rheology of protein–surfactant mixed films of the protein, the surfactant, the interface and bulk compositions, the method of formation of the interfacial film, the interactions between film forming components, and the displacement of protein by surfactant have been analysed. The last section tries to understand the role of interfacial rheology of protein–surfactant mixed films on food dispersion formation and stability. The emphasis of the present review is on the interfacial dilatational rheology.     

蛋白质膜界面流变行为研究进展

随着界面流变测量技术以及相关的光学辅助仪器的发展,近10年来界面流变学在食品、化妆品、医药等领域发挥了重要作用。本文介绍了近年来蛋白质膜界面流变行为的研究进展,着重介绍了蛋白质界面流变学在泡沫和乳液方面的研究。本文主要分为3个部分,内容包括:蛋白质膜界面流变学行为与泡沫、乳液稳定性的相互关系,蛋白质-多聚糖的界面流变行为研究,蛋白质-表面活性物质的界面流变行为研究。界面流变学在泡沫和乳液方面取得的较快研究进展不仅促进了人们对蛋白质膜界面流变行为更为深刻的理解,而且为更好地开发和应用蛋白质及其混合物作为表面活性物质和胶体稳定剂而提供重要的理论依据和指导。     

Filler effects of oil droplets on the rheology of heat-set emulsion gels prepared with egg yolk and egg yolk fractions

Hen egg yolk is a traditional ingredient used in a wide variety of food emulsions, especially fluid sauces. Industrial processing of these sauces generally involves heat treatments in order to pasteurise or sterilise them. These heat treatments may cause undesired gelation of the emulsion, because egg yolk proteins are particularly thermosensitive. Heat gelation of oil-in-water emulsions prepared with egg yolk may differ from that of egg yolk solutions, because of the influence of oil droplets on network formation. In this study, we investigated the influence of oil droplets on the gelation of oil-in-water emulsions made with yolk. We studied three pH values: 3.0, 5.0 and 7.0 with a constant NaCl concentration: 0.55 M. Oil droplet size was controlled after emulsification, gelation of solutions and emulsions was monitored in situ by coupling heating with recording viscoelastic properties, and transmission electron microscopy was conducted in heat-set emulsion gels. In an attempt to target the proteins that impose the kinetic of gelation of egg yolk, we repeated the experiment with plasma and granules, the main fractions of yolk. In situ rheology showed that, in our experimental conditions [especially oil volume fraction (0.3) and oil droplet size (d3.2=1 &mgr;m)], emulsions made with yolk and plasma have a similar gelation process with oil droplets acting as inactive fillers. Furthermore, transmission electron microscopy showed similar network characteristics between heated emulsions made with yolk and plasma. Moreover, we demonstrated that acidic conditions provided the fastest gelation of yolk solutions and emulsions. On the other hand, in emulsions prepared with granules, oil droplets behaved as active filler particles and reinforced the gel strength.     

Effect of electrolyte in silicone oil-in-water emulsions stabilised by fumed silica particles

Partially hydrophobised fumed silica particles are used to make silicone oil-in-water emulsions at natural pH of the aqueous phase. The stability and rheological properties of the emulsions and suspensions are studied at NaCl concentrations in the range 0-100 mM. It is found that all emulsions are very stable to coalescence irrespective of the NaCl concentration. However, a strong effect of electrolyte on the creaming and rheological properties is observed and linked to the particle interactions in aqueous suspensions. The creaming rate and extent are large at low electrolyte concentrations but both abruptly decrease at salt concentrations exceeding the critical flocculation concentration of the suspension (approximately 1 mM NaCl). The drastic improvement of the stability to creaming is attributed to the formation of a visco-elastic three-dimensional network of interconnected particles and emulsion droplets.     

HEAT-SET WHEY PROTEIN EMULSION GELS: ROLE OF ACTIVE AND INACTIVE FILLER PARTICLES

Viscoelastic properties of heat-set whey protein emulsion gels containing active filler (protein-covered droplets) and inactive filler (surfactant-covered droplets) have been investigated at small and large deformations using a controlled stress rheometer. Data are reported as a function of protein concentration, oil volume fraction, and average emulsion droplet size. The active filler enhances the gel strength, whereas the inactive filler reduces the gel strength. The higher the elastic modulus of the protein gel matrix, the less the effect of the active filler, but the greater the effect of the inactive filler (and vice versa). Higher oil volume fraction and reduced particle size both intensify the effect of the filler. The large deformation behaviour of a heat-set protein gel or a heat-set emulsion gel containing up to 20 vol% oil is entropic in character, whereas an emulsion gel of higher filler content behaves more like a typical enthalpic particle gel.     

Thermodynamics, adsorption kinetics and rheology of mixed protein-surfactant interfacial layers

Depending on the bulk composition, adsorption layers formed from mixed protein/surfactant solutions contain different amounts of protein. Clearly, increasing amounts of surfactant should decrease the amount of adsorbed proteins successively. However, due to the much larger adsorption energy, proteins are rather strongly bound to the interface and via competitive adsorption surfactants cannot easily displace proteins. A thermodynamic theory was developed recently which describes the composition of mixed protein/surfactant adsorption layers. This theory is based on models for the single compounds and allows a prognosis of the resulting mixed layers by using the characteristic parameters of the involved components. This thermodynamic theory serves also as the respective boundary condition for the dynamics of adsorption layers formed from mixed solutions and their dilational rheological behaviour. Based on experimental studies with milk proteins (β-casein and β-lactoglobulin) mixed with non-ionic (decyl and dodecyl dimethyl phosphine oxide) and ionic (sodium dodecyl sulphate and dodecyl trimethyl ammonium bromide) surfactants at the water/air and water/hexane interfaces, the potential of the theoretical tools is demonstrated.The displacement of pre-adsorbed proteins by subsequently added surfactant can be successfully studied by a special experimental technique based on a drop volume exchange. In this way the drop profile analysis can provide tensiometry and dilational rheology data (via drop oscillation experiments) for two adsorption routes — sequential adsorption of the single compounds in addition to the traditional simultaneous adsorption from a mixed solution. Complementary measurements of the surface shear rheology and the adsorption layer thickness via ellipsometry are added in order to support the proposed mechanisms drawn from tensiometry and dilational rheology, i.e. to show that the formation of mixed adsorption layer is based on a modification of the protein molecules via electrostatic (ionic) and/or hydrophobic interactions by the surfactant molecules and a competitive adsorption of the resulting complexes with the free, unbound surfactant. Under certain conditions, the properties of the sequentially formed layers differ from those formed simultaneously, which can be explained by the different locations of complex formation.     

Physico-chemical characteristics of oil-in-water emulsions based on whey protein-phospholipid mixtures

Emulsions prepared with whey proteins, phospholipids and 10% of vegetable oil were used for a model typifying dressings, coffee whitener and balanced diets. For the present study, two whey proteins (partial heat-denatured whey protein concentrate (WPC) and undenatured whey protein isolate (WPI)) in combination with different phospholipids (hydrolysed and unmodified deoiled lecithin) were chosen to investigate the interactions between proteins, phospholipids and salt (sodium chloride) in such emulsion systems. Oil-in-water (o/w) emulsions (10 wt.% sunflower oil) containing various concentrations of commercial whey proteins (1-2%), phospholipids (0.39-0.78%) and salt (0.5-1.5%) were prepared using a laboratory high pressure homogeniser under various preparation conditions. Each emulsion was characterised by droplet size, creaming rate, flow behaviour and protein load. The dynamic surface activity of the whey proteins and lecithins at the oil-water interface was determined using the drop volume method. The properties of emulsions were significantly influenced by the content of whey protein. Higher protein levels improved the emulsion behaviour (smaller oil droplets and increased stability) independent of the protein or lecithin samples used. An increase of the protein content resulted in a lower tendency for oil droplet aggregation of emulsions with WPC to occur and emulsions tending towards a Newtonian flow behaviour. The emulsification temperature was especially important using the partial heat-denatured WPC in combination with the deoiled lecithin. A higher emulsification temperature (60 degrees C) promoted oil droplet aggregation, as well as an increased emulsion consistency. Emulsions with the WPC were significantly influenced by the NaCl content, as well as the protein-salt ratio. Increasing the NaCl content led to an increase of the droplet size, higher oil droplet aggregation, as well as to a higher creaming rate of the emulsions. An increase of the lecithin content from 0.39 to 0.78% in the emulsion system resulted in a small reduction of the single droplet size. This effect was more pronounced when using the hydrolysed lecithins.     

Cross linking and rheological characterization of adsorbed protein layers at the oil-water interface

The dilatational rheological properties of cross-linked protein layers adsorbed at the oil-water interface were investigated with help of a modified drop tensiometer allowing successive replacements of the external phase. This setup enables one to perform cross-linking reactions at the interface only, that is, without any contact between the cross-linking agent and protein molecules in solution, under continuous monitoring of the interfacial tension. The mechanical properties of the resulting interface were investigated with dilatational large strain experiments. Measured rheological properties were related to the expected stability of an emulsion against disproportionation by considering the ratio of the interfacial elasticity to the interfacial tension. In an attempt to increase this ratio to improve the resistance against disproportionation, experiments were performed with densified protein layers obtained via reduction of the droplet area prior to cross linking. To highlight the influence of the protein morphology on the dilatational rheological properties of the cross-linked adsorbed layers, experiments were performed with random coil (beta-casein) as well as globular (beta-lactoglobulin) proteins. Glutaraldehyde was used as a cross-linking agent. Experiments were performed at 55 degrees C and pH 7.0 in 20 mM imidazole buffer for later comparison with enzymatically cross-linked adsorbed protein layers. The present work demonstrated substantial qualitative and quantitative differences in the interfacial rheological properties of cross-linked random coil and globular proteins.     

Influence of the fat characteristics on the physicochemical behavior of oil-in-water emulsions based on milk proteins-glycerol esters mixtures

Oil-in-water emulsions based on 10% milk protein preparation, 0.3% mono-di-glycerides (MDG) and 8% vegetable oil were prepared for models typifying ice cream formulations. Two MDG (saturated and partially unsaturated) and four fats (oleic oil, hydrogenated and refined coconut oils, refined palm oil) were chosen to investigate the interactions occurring between the oil phase, the MDG and the milk proteins. Influence of temperature (4 °C) and ageing (24 h at 4 °C) was also tested. The emulsions were characterized for protein desorption, particle size distribution and rheological properties. The dynamic surface activity of the milk proteins and the MDG at the oil-water interface was also determined. At 20 °C, emulsions were mostly stabilized by proteins although the protein load at the globule surface strongly depended on the emulsifier and the oil phase natures. A displacement of the proteins adsorbed at the oil droplet interface by the lipid surfactant was a consequence of the temperature decrease and/or ageing step, suggesting a disruption of the interfacial protein interactions. This disruption was more or less marked depending on the physicochemical characteristics of the surfactant and the oil used (amount of crystallized matter, fatty acid chain length and unsaturation degree). In parallel, the variation of the apparent viscosity of the various emulsions upon temperature was well correlated with the solid fat content. On the whole, the results obtained suggested that not only the surfactant molecules, i.e. emulsifiers and proteins, but also the fat used in the emulsion formulation participated in the development of the interface characteristics and rheological properties.     

A study of oil-in-water emulsions stabilized by whey proteins

Like many other emulsifiers, whey protein concentrates stabilize oil-in-water emulsions. However, the emulsifying capacity of whey proteins is affected by several factors, e. g., type of homogenizer, degree of homogenization, protein concentration, oil volume fraction, pH and ionic strength of the aqueous phase. For the present study, oilin-water emulsions were made by homogenizing known amounts of whey protein concentrate with a vegetable oil (i. e. grapeseed oil) at different pH. The emulsifying properties of whey proteins are expressed as a function of the particle size and size distribution of oil droplets as measured by light scattering, and of the surface charge density derived from the electrophoretic mobility.The whey protein concentrate was shown to have an isoelectric point at pH 4.4. Near this pH value, the oil-in-water emulsions exhibited poor stability as expected from the low surface coverage.     

Structures and stability of lipid emulsions formulated with sodium caseinate

The physicochemical properties of emulsions play an important role in food systems as they directly contribute to texture, sensory and nutritional properties of foods. Sodium caseinate (NaCas) is a well-used ingredient because of its good solubility and emulsifying properties and its stability during heating. One of most significant aspects of any food emulsion is its stability. Among the methods used to study emulsion stability it may be mentioned visual observation, ultrasound profiling, microscopy, droplet size distribution, small deformation rheometry, measurement of surface concentration to characterize adsorbed protein at the interface, nuclear magnetic resonance, confocal microscopy, diffusing wave spectroscopy, and turbiscan. They have advantages and disadvantages and provide different insights into the destabilization mechanisms. Related to stability, the aspects more deeply investigated were the amount of NaCas used to prepare the emulsion, and specially the oil-to-protein ratio, the mobility of oil droplets and the interactions among emulsion components at the interface. It is known that the amount of protein required to stabilize oil-in-water emulsions depends, not only on the structure of protein at the interface, and the average diameters of the emulsion droplets, but also on the type of oils and the composition of the aqueous phase. Several authors have investigated the effect of a thickening agent or of a surface active molecule. Factors such as pH, temperature, and processing conditions during emulsion preparation are also very relevant to stability. There is a general agreement among authors that the most stable systems are obtained for conditions that produce size reduction of the droplets, an increase in viscosity of the continuous phase and structural changes in emulsions such as gelation. All these conditions decrease the molecular mobility and slow down phase separation.