Detecting Protein–Glycolipid Interactions Using Glycomicelles and CaR-ESI-MS

This study reports on the use of the catch-and-release electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (CaR-ESI-MS) assay, combined with glycomicelles, as a method for detecting specific interactions between water-soluble proteins and glycolipids (GLs) in aqueous solution. The B subunit homopentamers of cholera toxin (CTB₅) and Shiga toxin type 1 B (Stx1B₅) and the gangliosides GM1, GM2, GM3, GD1a, GD1b, GT1b, and GD2 served as model systems for this study. The CTB₅ exhibits broad specificity for gangliosides and binds to GM1, GM2, GM3, GD1a, GD1b, and GT1b; Stx1B₅ does not recognize gangliosides. The CaR-ESI-MS assay was used to analyze solutions of CTB₅ or Stx1B₅ and individual gangliosides (GM1, GM2, GM3, GD1a, GD1b, GT1b, and GD2) or mixtures thereof. The high affinity interaction of CTB₅ with GM1 was successfully detected. However, the apparent affinity, as determined from the mass spectra, is significantly lower than that of the corresponding pentasaccharide or when GM1 is presented in model membranes such as nanodiscs. Interactions between CTB₅ and the low affinity gangliosides GD1a, GD1b, and GT1b, as well as GD2, which served as a negative control, were detected; no binding of CTB₅ to GM2 or GM3 was observed. The CaR-ESI-MS results obtained for Stx1B₅ reveal that nonspecific protein-ganglioside binding can occur during the ESI process, although the extent of binding varies between gangliosides. Consequently, interactions detected for CTB₅ with GD1a, GD1b, and GT1b are likely nonspecific in origin. Taken together, these results reveal that the CaR-ESI-MS/glycomicelle approach for detecting protein–GL interactions is prone to false positives and false negatives and must be used with caution.

Open image in new window

Graphical Abstract <!-- [INSERT GRAPHICAL ABSTRACT TEXT HERE] -->

     

Measuring Positive Cooperativity Using the Direct ESI-MS Assay. Cholera Toxin B Subunit Homopentamer Binding to GM1 Pentasaccharide

Direct electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) assay was used to investigate the stepwise binding of the GM1 pentasaccharide β-D-Galp-(1→3)-β-D-GalpNAc-(1→4)[α-D-Neu5Ac-(2→3)]-β-D-Galp-(1→4)-β-D-Glcp (GM1os) to the cholera toxin B subunit homopentamer (CTB₅) and to establish conclusively whether GM1os binding is cooperative. Apparent association constants were measured for the stepwise addition of one to five GM1os to CTB₅ at pH 6.9 and 22 °C. The intrinsic association constant, which was established from the apparent association constant for the addition of a single GM1os to CTB₅, was found to be (3.2 ± 0.2) × 10⁶ M^–1. This is in reasonable agreement with the reported value of (6.4 ± 0.3) × 10⁶ M^–1, which was measured at pH 7.4 and 25 °C using isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC). Analysis of the apparent association constants provides direct and unambiguous evidence that GM1os binding exhibits small positive cooperativity. Binding was found to be sensitive to the number of ligand-bound nearest neighbor subunits, with the affinities enhanced by a factor of 1.7 and 2.9 when binding occurs next to one or two ligand-bound subunits, respectively. These findings, which provide quantitative support for the binding model proposed by Homans and coworkers [14], highlight the unique strengths of the direct ESI-MS assay for measuring cooperative ligand binding.

Detecting Protein–Glycolipid Interactions Using CaR-ESI-MS and Model Membranes: Comparison of Pre-loaded and Passively Loaded Picodiscs

Catch-and-release electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (CaR-ESI-MS), implemented using model membranes (MMs), is a promising approach for the discovery of glycolipid ligands of glycan-binding proteins (GBPs). Picodiscs (PDs), which are lipid-transporting complexes composed of the human sphingolipid activator protein saposin A and phospholipids, have proven to be useful MMs for such studies. The present work compares the use of conventional (pre-loaded) PDs with passively loaded PDs (^PLPDs) for CaR-ESI-MS screening of glycolipids against cholera toxin B subunit homopentamer (CTB₅). The pre-loaded PDs were prepared from a mixture of purified glycolipid and phospholipid or a mixture of lipids extracted from tissue, while the ^PLPDs were prepared by incubating PDs containing only phospholipid with glycolipid-containing lipid mixtures in aqueous solution. Time-dependent changes in the composition of the ^PLPDs produced by incubation with glycomicelles of the ganglioside GM1 were monitored using collision-induced dissociation of the gaseous PD ions and from the extent of ganglioside binding to CTB₅ measured by ESI-MS. GM1 incorporation into PDs was evident within a few hours of incubation. At incubation times ≥ 10 days, GM1 binding to CTB₅ was indistinguishable from that observed with pre-loaded PDs produced directly from GM1 at the same concentration. Comparison of ganglioside binding to CTB₅ measured for pre-loaded PDs and ^PLPDs prepared from glycolipids extracted from pig and mouse brain revealed that the ^PLPDs allow for the detection of a greater number of ganglioside ligands. Together, the results of this study suggest ^PLPDs may have advantages over conventionally prepared PDs for screening glycolipids against GBPs using CaR-ESI-MS.

Open image in new window

Graphical Abstract ?

     

Synthesis and cholera toxin binding properties of multivalent GM1 mimics

Dendrimers based on the 3,5-di-(2-aminoethoxy)-benzoic acid branching unit were used to attach multiple copies of a GM1 mimic for inhibition of cholera toxin binding. Systems up to octavalent were synthesized along with relevant reference compounds that contained in one case the ligand in a monovalent format and in another case the scaffold but not the ligand. Using a surface plasmon resonance inhibition assay the prepared inhibitors showed good inhibition. While the monovalent GM1 mimic showed the expected inhibition in the 200 microM range the multivalent scaffolds led to increased binding. The tetravalent compound was shown to be 440-fold more potent than its monovalent counterpart. The octavalent analog, however, was the most potent compound as determined using an ELISA assay.     

Dissociation of Multisubunit Protein–Ligand Complexes in the Gas Phase. Evidence for Ligand Migration

The results of collision-induced dissociation (CID) experiments performed on gaseous protonated and deprotonated ions of complexes of cholera toxin B subunit homopentamer (CTB₅) with the pentasaccharide (β-D-Galp-(1→3)-β-D-GalpNAc-(1→4)[α-D-Neu5Ac-(2→3)]-β-D-Galp-(1→4)-β-D-Glcp (GM1)) and corresponding glycosphingolipid (β-D-Galp-(1→3)-β-D-GalpNAc-(1→4)[α-D-Neu5Ac-(2→3)]-β-D-Galp-(1→4)-β-D-Glcp-Cer (GM1-Cer)) ligands, and the homotetramer streptavidin (S₄) with biotin (B) and 1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine-N-(biotinyl) (Btl), are reported. The protonated (CTB₅ + 5GM1)ⁿ⁺ ions dissociated predominantly by the loss of a single subunit, with the concomitant migration of ligand to another subunit. The simultaneous loss of ligand and subunit was observed as a minor pathway. In contrast, the deprotonated (CTB₅ + 5GM1)^n- ions dissociated preferentially by the loss of deprotonated ligand; the loss of ligand-bound and ligand-free subunit were minor pathways. The presence of ceramide (Cer) promoted ligand migration and the loss of subunit. The main dissociation pathway for the protonated and deprotonated (S₄ + 4B)^n+/– ions, as well as for deprotonated (S₄ + 4Btl)^n– ions, was loss of the ligand. However, subunit loss from the (S₄ + 4B)ⁿ⁺ ions was observed as a minor pathway. The (S₄ + 4Btl)ⁿ⁺ ions dissociated predominantly by the loss of free and ligand-bound subunit. The charge state of the complex and the collision energy were found to have little effect on the relative contribution of the different dissociation channels. Thermally-driven ligand migration between subunits was captured in the results of molecular dynamics simulations performed on protonated (CTB₅ + 5GM1)¹⁵⁺ ions (with a range of charge configurations) at 800 K. Notably, the migration pathway was found to be highly dependent on the charge configuration of the ion. The main conclusion of this study is that the dissociation pathways of multisubunit protein–ligand complexes in the gas phase depend, not only on the native topology of the complex, but also on structural changes that occur upon collisional activation.

A Protein‐Based Pentavalent Inhibitor of the Cholera Toxin B‐Subunit

Protein toxins produced by bacteria are the cause of many life‐threatening diarrheal diseases. Many of these toxins, including cholera toxin (CT), enter the cell by first binding to glycolipids in the cell membrane. Inhibiting these multivalent protein/carbohydrate interactions would prevent the toxin from entering cells and causing diarrhea. Here we demonstrate that the site‐specific modification of a protein scaffold, which is perfectly matched in both size and valency to the target toxin, provides a convenient route to an effective multivalent inhibitor. The resulting pentavalent neoglycoprotein displays an inhibition potency (IC₅₀) of 104 pM for the CT B‐subunit (CTB), which is the most potent pentavalent inhibitor for this target reported thus far. Complexation of the inhibitor and CTB resulted in a protein heterodimer. This inhibition strategy can potentially be applied to many multivalent receptors and also opens up new possibilities for protein assembly strategies.     

Affinity capillary electrophoresis for the assessment of binding affinity of carbohydrate‐based cholera toxin inhibitors

Developing tools for the study of protein carbohydrate interactions is an important goal in glycobiology. Cholera toxin inhibition is an interesting target in this context, as its inhibition may help to fight against cholera. For the study of novel ligands an affinity capillary electrophoresis (ACE) method was optimized and applied. The method uses unlabeled cholera toxin B‐subunit (CTB) and unlabeled carbohydrate ligands based on ganglioside GM1‐oligosaccharides (GM1os). In an optimized method at pH 4, adsorption of the protein to the capillary walls was prevented by a polybrene‐dextran sulfate‐polybrene coating. Different concentrations of the ligands were added to the BGE. CTB binding was observed by a mobility shift that could be used for dissociation constant (K_d) determination. The K_d values of two GM1 derivatives differed by close to an order of magnitude (600 ± 20 nM and 90 ± 50 nM) which was in good agreement with the differences in their reported nanomolar IC₅₀ values of an ELISA‐type assay. Moreover, the selectivity of GM1os towards CTB was demonstrated using Influenza hemagglutinin (H5) as a binding competitor. The developed method can be an important platform for preclinical development of drugs targeting pathogen‐induced secretory diarrhea.     

Characterization and crystal structure of a high-affinity pentavalent receptor-binding inhibitor for cholera toxin and E. coli heat-labile enterotoxin

Multivalent ligand design constitutes an attractive avenue to the inhibition of receptor recognition and other biological events mediated by oligomeric proteins with multiple binding sites. One example is the design of multivalent receptor blockers targeting members of the AB(5) bacterial toxin family. We report here the synthesis and characterization of a pentavalent inhibitor for cholera toxin and Escherichia coli heat-labile enterotoxin. This inhibitor is an advance over the symmetric pentacyclen-derived inhibitor described in our earlier work in that it presents five copies of m-nitrophenyl-alpha-D-galactoside (MNPG) rather than five copies of beta-D-galactose. The approximately 100-fold higher single-site affinity of MNPG for the toxin receptor binding site relative to galactose is found to yield a proportionate increase in the affinity and IC50 measured for the respective pentavalent constructs. We show by dynamic light scattering that inhibition of receptor binding by the pentavalent inhibitor is due to 1:1 inhibitor:toxin association rather than to inhibitor-mediated aggregation. This 1:1 association is in complete agreement with a 1.46 A resolution crystal structure of the pentavalent inhibitor:toxin complex, which shows that the favorable single-site binding interactions of MNPG are retained by the five arms of the 5256 Da pentavalent MNPG-based inhibitor and that the initial segment of the linking groups interacts with the surface of the toxin B pentamer.     

Solution and crystallographic studies of branched multivalent ligands that inhibit the receptor-binding of cholera toxin

The structure-based design of multivalent ligands offers an attractive strategy toward high affinity protein inhibitors. The spatial arrangement of the receptor-binding sites of cholera toxin, the causative agent of the severe diarrheal disease cholera and a member of the AB(5) bacterial toxin family, provides the opportunity of designing branched multivalent ligands with 5-fold symmetry. Our modular synthesis enabled the construction of a family of complex ligands with five flexible arms each ending with a bivalent ligand. The largest of these ligands has a molecular weight of 10.6 kDa. These ligands are capable of simultaneously binding to two toxin B pentamer molecules with high affinity, thus blocking the receptor-binding process of cholera toxin. A more than million-fold improvement over the monovalent ligand in inhibitory power was achieved with the best branched decavalent ligand. This is better than the improvement observed earlier for the corresponding nonbranched pentavalent ligand. Dynamic light scattering studies demonstrate the formation of concentration-dependent unique 1:1 and 1:2 ligand/toxin complexes in solution with no sign of nonspecific aggregation. This is in complete agreement with a crystal structure of the branched multivalent ligand/toxin B pentamer complex solved at 1.45 A resolution that shows the specific 1:2 ligand/toxin complex formation in the solid state. These results reiterate the power of the structure-based design of multivalent protein ligands as a general strategy for achieving high affinity and potent inhibition.     

Anchor-based design of improved cholera toxin and E. coli heat-labile enterotoxin receptor binding antagonists that display multiple binding modes

The action of cholera toxin and E. coli heat-labile enterotoxin can be inhibited by blocking their binding to the cell-surface receptor GM1. We have used anchor-based design to create 15 receptor binding inhibitors that contain the previously characterized inhibitor MNPG as a substructure. In ELISA assays, all 15 compounds exhibited increased potency relative to MNPG. Binding affinities for two compounds, each containing a morpholine ring linked to MNPG via a hydrophobic tail, were characterized by pulsed ultrafiltration (PUF) and isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC). Crystal structures for these compounds bound to toxin B pentamer revealed a conserved binding mode for the MNPG moiety, with multiple binding modes adopted by the attached morpholine derivatives. The observed binding interactions can be exploited in the design of improved toxin binding inhibitors.     

Second-generation mimics of ganglioside GM1 oligosaccharide: a three-dimensional view of their interactions with bacterial enterotoxins by NMR and computational methods

As a step to delineate a strategy of ligand design for cholera toxin (CT), NMR studies were performed on several mimics of the GM1 ganglioside oligosaccharide. The conformation of these analogues was investigated first in solution and then upon binding to cholera toxin by transferred nuclear Overhauser effect (TR-NOE) measurements. It was demonstrated that CT selects a conformation similar to the global minima of the free saccharides from the ensemble of presented conformations. No evidence of major conformational distortions was obtained, but one or two of the available conformers of the hydroxyacid side chain appear to be selected in the bound state. The NMR data were interpreted with the aid of computer models, generated and analyzed by using a combination of different approaches (MacroModels' MC/EM and MC/SD, Autodock, and GRID). Analysis of the NMR data supported by computational studies allowed us to interpret the experimental observations and to derive workable models of the ligand:toxin complexes. These models suggest that the higher affinity of the (R)-lactic acid derivative 3 may stem from lipophilic interactions with a hydrophobic area in the toxin binding site located in the vicinity of the sialic acid side chain binding region of the CT:GM1 complex, and formed by the side chain of Ile-58 and Lys-34. Thus, the models obtained have allowed us to make useful design suggestions for the improvement of ligand affinity.     

Construction of supported lipid membrane modified piezoelectric biosensor for sensitive assay of cholera toxin based on surface-agglutination of ganglioside-bearing liposomes

A novel piezoelelctric biosensor has been developed for cholera toxin (CT) detection based on the analyte-mediated surface-agglutination of ganglioside (GM1)-functionalized liposomes. To achieve a CT-specific agglutination at the surface, the gold electrode is modified by a GM1-functionalized supported lipid membrane via spontaneous spread of the liposomes on a self-assembled monolayer of a long-chain alkanethiol. In the presence of CT, the GM1-incorporated liposomes in assay medium will rapidly specifically agglutinate at the electrode surface through the binding of CT to GM1 on the electrode surface and the liposome interface. This results in an enormous mass loading on the piezoelelctric crystal as well as a significant increase of density and viscosity at the interface, thereby generating a decrease in frequency of the piezoelelctric crystal. The combination of mass loading with interfacial change in the surface-agglutination reaction allows the developed piezoelelctric biosensor to show substantial signal amplification in response to the analyte CT. The detection limit can be achieved as low as 25 ng mL⁻¹ CT. This is the first demonstration on CT detection based on specific surface-agglutination of GM1-modified liposomes. The supported lipid layer based sensing interface can be prepared readily and renewably, making the developed technique especially useful for simple, reusable and sensitive determination of proteins.     

Synthesis,Biological Evaluation,WAC and NMR Studies of S‐Galactosides and Non‐Carbohydrate Ligands of Cholera Toxin Based on Polyhydroxyalkylfuroate Moieties

The synthesis of several non‐carbohydrate ligands of cholera toxin based on polyhydroxyalkylfuroate moieties is reported. Some of them have been linked to D ‐galactose through a stable and well‐tolerated S‐glycosidic bond. They represent a novel type of non‐hydrolyzable bidentate ligand featuring galactose and polyhydroxyalkylfuroic esters as pharmacophoric residues, thus mimicking the GM1 ganglioside. The affinity of the new compounds towards cholera toxin was measured by weak affinity chromatography (WAC). The interaction of the best candidates with this toxin was also studied by saturation transfer difference NMR experiments, which allowed identification of the binding epitopes of the ligands interacting with the protein. Interestingly, the highest affinity was shown by non‐carbohydrate mimics based on a polyhydroxyalkylfuroic ester structure.     

Strong inhibition of cholera toxin binding by galactose dendrimers

Galactose-containing dendrimers with long spacer arms inhibit cholera toxin binding as strongly as the natural ganglioside GM1 oligosaccharide does.     

Discrete Arrays of Liquid‐Crystal‐Supported Proteolipid Monolayers as Phantom Cell Surfaces

The phospholipid bilayers of living cell membranes exist almost universally in a liquid state. This enables motion and spatial reorganization of membrane components on multiple length scales, which is an essential feature of many biological processes. There is great interest in the development of molecularly defined interfaces between synthetic materials and living cells. To this end, there is a need for solid substrate materials that can be derivatized with fluid, membrane‐like interfaces. Herein, we describe array fabrication of discrete liquid‐crystal areas supporting phospholipid monolayer membranes, and characterize the interactions with several different membrane surface proteins [avidin series, cholera toxin, green fluorescent protein (GFP), intercellular adhesion molecule (ICAM) and major histocompatibility complex (MHC)]. Three different linkage strategies (biotin, nickel chelating lipids complexing with histidine, and the choleratoxin binding unit (CTB) associating with G_M1 are evaluated. Additionally, experiments with live immunological T cells forming active synapses at the interface exhibit the specific nature of the surface.     

Über Perowskitphasen in den Systemen BaO–SE2O3–UO2,x mit SE = Seltene Erden,La und Y. II. Verbindungen der Zusammensetzung Ba2(SE0,67U0,33)UO6,17

In the BaO–SE₂O₃–UO_2.x system the formation of the compounds Ba₂(SE_0,67U_0.33)UO_6.17 is observed. They crystallize in a pseudocubic ordered perovskite lattice, and contain tetravalent and pentavalent uranium in the ratio 1:3. Their magnetic and spectroscopic properties are reported.     

Manipulation of Electrostatic and Saccharide Linker Interactions in the Design of Efficient Glycopolypeptide‐Based Cholera Toxin Inhibitors

Multivalent, glycopolymer inhibitors designed for the treatment of disease and pathogen infection have shown improvements in binding correlated with general changes in glycopolymer architecture and composition. We have previously demonstrated that control of glycopolypeptide backbone extension and ligand spacing significantly impacts the inhibition of the cholera toxin B subunit pentamer (CT B₅) by these polymers. In the studies reported here, we elucidate the role of backbone charge and linker length in modulating the inhibition event. Peptides of the sequence AXPXG (where X is a positive, neutral or negative amino acid), equipped with the alkyne functionality of propargyl glycine, were designed and synthesized via solid‐phase peptide synthetic methods and glycosylated via Cu(I)‐catalyzed alkyne‐azide cycloaddition reactions. The capacity of the glycopeptides to inhibit the binding of the B₅ subunit of cholera toxin was evaluated. These studies indicated that glycopeptides with a negatively charged backbone show improved inhibition of the binding event relative to the other glycopeptides. In addition, variations in the length of the linker between the peptide and the saccharide ligand also affected the inhibition of CT by the glycopeptides. Our findings suggest that, apart from appropriate saccharide spacing and polypeptide chain extension, saccharide linker conformation and the systematic placement of charges on the polypeptide backbone are also significant variables that can be tuned to improve the inhibitory potencies of glycopolypeptide‐based multivalent inhibitors.

     

Analysis of transmembrane dynamics of cholera toxin using photoreactive probes.

Using sodium dodecyl sulfate--polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and autoradiography, we have shown that 125I-labeled cholera toxin binds to Newcastle disease virus. Pretreatment of Newcastle disease virus with "cold" cholera toxin (at 37 degrees C for 30 minutes) inhibits the binding of 125I-labeled toxin in a subsequent incubation (at 37 degrees C for 30 minutes). These results suggest that cholera toxin binds to Newcastle disease virus in a specific manner. The precise receptor for toxin is unknown in Newcastle disease virus but it is presumed to be the ganglioside GM1. We have previously shown that the photoreactive probe 12-(4-azido-2-nitrophenoxy)stearoylglucosamine[1-14C] labels the membrane proteins of Newcastle disease virus. Since the reactive group of the probe, ie, N3, resides within the membrane bilayer, studies were initiated to determined which, if any, of the subunits of cholera toxin cross the membrane of Newcastle disease virus and become radioactively labeled upon photoactivation of the probe at 360 nm. After a 15-minute incubation of cholera toxin with Newcastle disease virus containing the photoreactive probe, irradiation effected the 14C-labeling of the active A1 subunit of cholera toxin. Irradiation of cholera toxin in solution with an equivalent amount of probe but without virus resulted in no labeling of toxin subunits.     

Direct measurement of recognition forces between proteins and membrane receptors

The interactions between the protein, cholera toxin B subunit attached to an atomic force microscope, AFM, cantilever, CTB and its receptor the ganglioside, GM1 have been measured in a dilute electrolyte solution, pH 5.5. Although there is variation in the force separation data obtained, particularly on approach of the AFM tip to the GM1 surface where usually, but not always an attraction is noted, an adhesion is always noted on separation of the surfaces. The strength of this adhesion varies from experiment to experiment, but appears to be quantised at a value of around 90 pN. Addition of cholera toxin to the aqueous electrolyte solution completely removes the attractive interaction and adhesion. This gives us confidence that in the earlier experiments, a specific interaction between the CTB and GM1 was measured.     

Photophysical Properties of Gilvocarcins V and M and Their Binding Constant to Calf Thymus DNA

Abstract— Absorption and emission techniques were used to characterize the ground (S₀), singlet (S|) and triplet states (T₁) of gilvocarcin V (GV) and gilvocarcin M (GM) in different solvents. Aggregation of GV with dimerization constant equal to 7800 M^?1is observed in 10% dimethyl-sulfoxide (DMSO)/water. The photophysical properties of the S, state of these molecules are more sensitive to changes in solvent characteristics than the corresponding ground states. The absorption of visible light by GV and GM results in a higher dipole moment of the excited state causing a red shift in the fluorescence spectra with increasing solvent polarity. The fluorescence quantum yield remains practically unchanged with changes in solvent properties unless water is present as a co-solvent. Both φ_f and φ_f values corresponding to GV in DMSO are larger than those of GM, whereas in 10% DMSO/H₂O the opposite is observed. Thus, GV is more susceptible to other deactivation pathways besides emission in the presence of water than GM. The relative phosphorescence quantum yield (φ_p= 0.03) and the triplet energy (E_T= 52 kcal/mol) of GV and GM are similar. The S₀-S₁ energy difference is 63 kcal/mol for GV, whereas for GM it is 67. Thus, the singlet-triplet energy difference is 11 and 15 kcal/mol, respectively. The PM3/CI calculated electronic structures of these compounds are consistent with the observed photophysical properties. The dark binding constants of GV to calf thymus DNA ([1.1–0.08] × 10⁶M^?1) are about an order of magnitude larger than those of GM ([0.24–0.018] × 10⁶M^?1) at different ionic strengths (0–2.00 M NaCl). Also, the number of gilvocarcin molecules bound per base pair is smaller for GM than for GV. These differences in dark DNA binding parameters between GV and GM could have implications in the large photocytotoxic ability of GV as compared to GM.