Band broadening in size-exclusion chromatography of polydisperse samples

Understanding and controlling the band broadening is essential to obtain accurate molar-mass distributions by size-exclusion chromatography (SEC). In this paper, band broadening in SEC is reviewed from a contemporary perspective. The observed band broadening is due to dispersion inside and outside the chromatographic column (undesirable band broadening) and to the polydispersity of the sample (desirable SEC selectivity). The various contributors to band broadening are discussed. Integrity plots are introduced as a tool to evaluate the performance of specific SEC columns at given experimental conditions. For narrow polymer standards on single SEC columns the observed peak width is dominated by the chromatographic dispersion. MALDI-ToF-MS is demonstrated as an alternative to determine the PDI of narrowly distributed samples. The plate heights encountered at very high reduced velocities are found to be lower than expected. This is advantageous for fast separations by SEC.     

Factors influencing chromatographic data in fast gas chromatography with on‐column injection

The use of larger volume injection with on‐column injection and fast GC commercial instrumentation was evaluated with the model mixture of n‐alkanes of a broad range of volatility (C₁₀–C₂₈). The presented configuration allows introduction of 40–80‐fold larger sample volumes without any distortion of peak shapes compared to “usual” fast GC set‐ups using narrow‐bore columns. A normal‐bore retention gap (1–5 m×0.32 mm ID) was coupled to a narrow‐bore (5 m×0.1 mm ID×0.4 μm film thickness) analytical column using a standard press‐fit connector. The connection was tight and reliable, and hence suitable for hydrogen as carrier gas. The effect of pre‐column and analytical column connector, injection volume, pre‐column length, column inlet pressure, and analyte volatility on peak shape, peak broadening, and focusing are discussed. The precision of chromatographic data measurements and peak capacity under optimised temperature programmed conditions for fast separations with large volume injection were found to be very good. The presented fast GC set‐up with on‐column injection extends the applicability of the technique to trace analysis.     

Strategies in two‐dimensional liquid chromatographic separation of complex polymer systems

Complex synthetic polymer systems as for example copolymers exhibit distributions in at least two of the three basic molecular characteristics which are molar mass, chemical structure/composition and molecular architecture. Size exclusion chromatography (SEC) separates macromolecules according to their size in solution which simultaneously depends on all molecular characteristics. Therefore, multi‐dimensional liquid chromatographic techniques are to be applied to independently assess all different distributions present in the sample. So far, two‐dimensional separations have been attempted. In the first dimension separation column, selected liquid chromatographic mechanisms are intentionally combined to suppress effects of all but one molecular characteristic. Consequently, polymer species are separated exclusively or at least predominantly according to one single parameter. In the second dimension separation column, macromolecules are separated according to another molecular characteristic. In this contribution the methods are briefly reviewed in which effect of polymer molar mass on polymer retention is suppressed. The resulting ”one parameter separation systems” can be on‐line or off‐line connected to another separation system such as SEC to provide more detailed characterization of complex polymers. Besides, selected procedures for the re‐concentration of diluted polymer solutions are concisely treated. These may be utilized for increasing the concentration of sample(s) leaving the first dimension separation column. Eventually, some arrangements for controlled sample re‐introduction into the second dimension separation column are outlined.     

Effect of steric exclusion on the separation of proteins by hydrophilic size-exclusion chromatography

On the basis of studying the retention and band broadening of proteins on the TSK SW column, diffusion coefficients (Ds) of solute in stationary phase were obtained which elucidate the hydrodynamic process of chromatographic resolution of proteins by hydrophilic size-exclusion chromatography (SEC). After calculating the correlation between Ds and the molecular weight of the solute, the molecular dimensions of proteins in the process of chromatographic separation can be predicted. Deviations in diffusion coefficient of a protein from the calculated value reflect differences of measured molecular dimensions from molecular volumes predicted from the calibration curve of the SEC column. This study illustrates a convenient method for estimating the purity of proteins by SEC. Deviations from 2 lambda dp (where dp is the particle diameter) in the intercept of the theoretical plate height (H) versus flow-rate (U) curve from the band broadening equation H = CsU + 2 lambda dp + f(alpha M)T (where CsU represents mass transfer resistance caused by solute diffusion in the stationary phase and f(alpha M)T an added term for polydisperse solutes as proposed by Knox and McLennan [Chromatographia, 10 (1977) 75]) reflect impurities in the proteins.     

A theoretical basis for parameter selection and instrument design in comprehensive size-exclusion chromatography x liquid chromatography

A novel approach for the selection of the operational parameters (linear velocity, column length) for a comprehensive 2D-LC system is discussed. Starting point for the calculations is a given second dimension ((2)D) separation and a desired peak capacity for the 2D system. Using the theory developed here the optimum settings for the first dimension ((1)D) column can be derived. Theory clearly indicates that the choice of the (1)D conditions is basically limited to just one set of column lengths and linear velocities. The new method is tested on a comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatography system which uses size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) followed by reversed phase liquid chromatography (RPLC). A novel LC/LC interface, using a six-port valve rather than storage loops, joins the two chromatographic dimensions. From a theoretical comparison of continuous low flow and stop-flow operation the latter method was found to be an attractive mode of interfacing. The common idea that stop-flow operation results in additional band broadening is shown to be incorrect. The new interface design operated in the stop-flow mode permits the use of conventional analytical diameter HPLC columns, 7.8mm for SEC and 4.6mm for RPLC. The reversed phase chromatography utilizes a monolithic C-18 modified silica column, which produces fast and efficient analyses. As test samples complex mixtures of peptides were analyzed.     

Rapid determination of molecular parameters of synthetic polymers by precipitation/redissolution high‐performance liquid chromatography using “molded” monolithic column

Rapid high‐performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) of polystyrenes, poly(methyl methacrylates), poly(vinyl acetates), and polybutadienes using a monolithic 50 × 4.6 mm i.d. poly(styrene‐co‐divinylbenzene) column have been carried out. The separation process involves precipitation of the macromolecules on the macroporous monolithic column followed by progressive elution utilizing a gradient of the mobile phase. Depending on the character of the separated polymer, solvent gradients were composed of a poor solvent such as water, methanol, or hexane and increasing amounts of a good solvent such as THF or dichloromethane. Monolithic columns are ideally suited for this technique because convection through the large pores of the monolith enhances the mass transport of large polymer molecules and accelerates the separation process. Separation conditions including the selection of a specific pair of solvent and precipitant, flow rate, and gradient steepness were optimized for the rapid HPLC separations of various polymers that differed broadly in their molecular weights. Excellent separations were obtained demonstrating that the precipitation‐redissolution technique is a suitable alternative to size‐exclusion chromatography (SEC). The molecular weight parameters calculated from the HPLC data match well those obtained by SEC. However, compared to SEC, the determination of molecular parameters using gradient elution could be achieved at comparable flow rates in a much shorter period of time, typically in about 1 min. © 2000 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Polym Sci A: Polym Chem 38: 2767–2778, 2000     

Preliminary results for 2‐D separation with high‐performance thin‐layer chromatography and pressurized planar electrochromatography

Preliminary results of 2‐D separation of test dye mixture using high‐performance thin‐layer chromatography (HPTLC) and pressurized planar electrochromatography (PPEC) are demonstrated. The advantage of 2‐D HPTLC/PPEC separation is based on different separation selectivities obtained in both HPTLC and PPEC systems. HPTLC RP18 W plates of 5×20 cm from Merck were used in the investigations. In the first dimension, a HPTLC process was performed using 5 cm length of the plate and in the second dimension PPEC separation was obtained applying plate of 20 cm length. PPEC process followed prewetting the chromatographic plate with sample zones on it, which were partly separated after first dimensional (HPTLC) separation. In the experiments, the modified version of PPEC device for 20 cm long chromatographic plate and the reservoir for prewetting the adsorbent layer were applied.     

Development of an improved online comprehensive hydrophilic interaction chromatography × reversed‐phase ultra‐high‐pressure liquid chromatography platform for complex multiclass polyphenolic sample analysis

In this study, an improved online comprehensive two‐dimensional liquid chromatography platform coupled to tandem mass spectrometry was developed for the analysis of complex polyphenolic samples. A narrowbore hydrophilic interaction chromatography column (150 × 2.0 mm, 3.0 μm, cross‐linked diol) was employed in the first dimension, while a reversed‐phase column based on monodisperse sub‐2 μm fully porous particles (50 × 3.0 mm, 1.9 μm d.p.) with high surface area (410 m²/g) was employed in the second dimension. The combination of a trapping column modulation interface with the high retentive fully porous monodisperse reversed‐phase column in the second dimension resulted in higher peak capacity values (1146 versus 867), increased sensitivity, sharper and more symmetrical peaks in comparison with a conventional loop‐based method, with the same analysis time (70 min). The system was challenged against a complex polyphenolic extract of a typical Italian apple cultivar, enabling the simultaneous separation of multiple polyphenolic classes, including oligomeric procyanidins, up to degree of polymerization of 10. Hyphenation with an ion trap time‐of‐flight mass spectrometer led to the tentative identification of 121 analytes, showing how this platform could be a powerful analytical tool for the accurate profiling of complex polyphenolic samples.     

Evaluation and application of a mixed‐mode chromatographic stationary phase in two‐dimensional liquid chromatography for the separation of traditional Chinese medicine

In this study, two mixed‐mode chromatography stationary phases (C8SAX and C8SCX) were evaluated and used to establish a two‐dimensional liquid chromatography system for the separation of traditional Chinese medicine. The chromatographic properties of the mixed‐mode columns were systematically evaluated by comparing with other three columns of C8, strong anion exchanger, and strong cation exchanger. The result showed that C8SAX and C8SCX had a mixed‐mode retention mechanism including electrostatic interaction and hydrophobic interaction. Especially, they were suitable for separating acidic and/or basic compounds and their separation selectivities could be easily adjusted by changing pH value. Then, several off‐line 2D‐LC systems based on the C8SAX in the first dimension and C8SAX, C8SCX, or C8 columns in the second dimension were developed to analyze a traditional Chinese medicine—Uncaria rhynchophylla. The two‐dimensional liquid chromatography system of C8SAX (pH 3.0) × C8SAX (pH 6.0) exhibited the most effective peak distribution. Finally, fractions of U. rhynchophylla prepared from the first dimension were successfully separated on the C8SAX column with a gradient pH. Thus, the mixed‐mode stationary phase could provide a platform to separate the traditional Chinese medicine in practical applications.     

Two-dimensional liquid chromatography analysis of synthetic polymers using fast size exclusion chromatography at high column temperature

In recent years, two-dimensional liquid chromatography (2D-LC) has been used increasingly for the analysis of synthetic polymers. A 2D-LC analysis provides richer information than a single chromatography analysis at the cost of longer analysis time. The time required for a comprehensive 2D-LC analysis is essentially proportional to the analysis time of the second dimension separation. Many of 2D-LC analyses of synthetic polymers have employed size exclusion chromatography (SEC) for the second-dimension analysis due to the relatively short analysis time in addition to the wide use in the polymer analysis. Nonetheless, short SEC columns are often used for 2D-LC analyses to reduce the separation time, which inevitably deteriorates the resolution. In this study, we demonstrated that high temperature SEC can be employed as an efficient second-LC in the 2D-LC separation of synthetic polymers. By virtue of high temperature operation (low solvent viscosity and high diffusivity of the polymer molecules), a normal length SEC column can be used at high flow rate with little loss in resolution.     

Size-exclusion chromatography using deuterated mobile phases

The effect of deuterated solvents in size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) was studied by comparing intrinsic viscosity measurements, SEC calibration curves, and column efficiency using water-soluble polymers. For aqueous SEC, the use of deuterium oxide slightly increases the SEC elution volume. To verify that adsorption onto the packing was absent, data from exclusion experiments were compared at 35 and 50 degrees C. Our results indicate that adsorption is not occurring for pullulan or polyethylene glycol (PEG)/poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO); for the latter, however, the elution volume increased using both D2O and H2O, indicative of slight hydrodynamic volume contraction of PEG/PEO at higher temperatures. A moderate increase in band broadening (moderate decrease in column efficiency) was observed using D2O. Finally, the effects of chloroform versus deuterated chloroform were evaluated, but no hydrodynamic volume changes were observed.     

Transfer-volume effects in two-dimensional chromatography: adsorption-phenomena in second-dimension size-exclusion chromatography

Gradient-elution LC × LC is a valuable technique for the characterization of complex biological samples as well as for synthetic polymers. Breakthrough and viscous fingering may yield misleading information on the sample characteristics or deteriorate separation. In LC × SEC another phenomenon may jeopardize the separation. If the analytes adsorb on the SEC column under the injection-plug conditions, peak splitting may occur. In LC × LC the effluent from the first column is the sample solvent for the analytes injected into the second dimension. If a gradient-elution LC × SEC setup is used (i.e. if reversed-phase gradient-elution LC is coupled to organic SEC and if normal-phase gradient-elution LC is coupled to SEC with a polar solvent), the percentage of weak solvent may be significant, especially at short analysis times. In this case adsorption in the first-dimension-effluent zone on the second-dimension SEC column can become an issue and two peaks--the first eluting in size-exclusion mode and the second undergoing adsorption--can be obtained. The work presented in this paper documents peak splitting in LC × SEC of polymers. The adsorption of the polymer on the size-exclusion column was proven in one-dimensional isocratic runs. The observed effects were modeled and visualized through simulation. Studies on the influence of the transfer volume were carried out. Keeping the transfer volume as small as possible helped to minimize peak splitting due to adsorption.     

Improved performance of protein separation by continuous annular chromatography in the size-exclusion mode.

In size-exclusion chromatography (SEC), proteins and peptides are separated according to their molecular size in solution. SEC is especially useful as an effective fractionation step to separate a vast amount of impurities from the components of interest and/or as final step for the separation of purified proteins from their aggregates, in a so-called polishing step. However, the throughput in SEC is low compared to other chromatographic processes as good resolution can be achieved only with a limited feed volume (i.e., maximal approximately 5% of the column volume can be loaded). This limitation opposed widespread application of conventional SEC in industry despite its excellent separation potential. Therefore a continuous separation process (namely preparative continuous annular chromatography) was developed and compared to a conventional SEC system both using Superdex 200 prep grade as sorbent. An immunoglobulin G sample with a high content of aggregates was chosen as a model protein solution. The influence of the feed flow-rate, eluent flow-rate and rotation rate on the separation efficiency was investigated. The height equivalent to a theoretical plate was lower for preparative continuous annular chromatography which could be explained by reduced extra column band broadening. The packing quality was proved to be identical for both systems. The productivity of conventional batch SEC was lower compared to continuous SEC, consequently buffer consumption was higher in batch mode.     

An automated food protein isolation approach on preparative scale by two‐dimensional liquid chromatography with active modulation interface

In this work, an automated 2D‐LC approach for protein isolation from egg samples on preparative scale is proposed. The method is based on the use of a C18 guard column installed in a switching valve to focus the proteins coming from the first dimension column, before their elution in the second column. For the first dimension separation, a size‐exclusion column, packed with 3 μm ultrapure silica particles was used. An RP column based on core‐shell technology was used for the second dimension separation. A standard mixture of BSA, β‐lactoglobulin, and glucose oxidase, chosen as a protein model system, was used to optimize the chromatographic separation conditions. The fully automated workflow allowed to isolate, in a single‐chromatographic analysis, a protein amount of 50 μg for each peak fraction, with a total time of 15 min for the first separation and additional 30 min of the second separation for each trapped protein. The final aim was the development of proper analytical tools for protein isolation from foodstuffs to be used for the molecular identification by MS, as well as for biotherapeutic uses, allergy testing, and large‐scale investigations in biological systems.     

Assessing the detectability of antioxidants in two‐dimensional high‐performance liquid chromatography

This paper explores the analytical figures of merit of two‐dimensional high‐performance liquid chromatography for the separation of antioxidant standards. The cumulative two‐dimensional high‐performance liquid chromatography peak area was calculated for 11 antioxidants by two different methods—the areas reported by the control software and by fitting the data with a Gaussian model; these methods were evaluated for precision and sensitivity. Both methods demonstrated excellent precision in regards to retention time in the second dimension (%RSD below 1.16%) and cumulative second dimension peak area (%RSD below 3.73% from the instrument software and 5.87% for the Gaussian method). Combining areas reported by the high‐performance liquid chromatographic control software displayed superior limits of detection, in the order of 1 × 10^?6 M, almost an order of magnitude lower than the Gaussian method for some analytes. The introduction of the countergradient eliminated the strong solvent mismatch between dimensions, leading to a much improved peak shape and better detection limits for quantification.     

A high‐sample‐throughput LC–GC method for mineral oil determination

The present investigation deals with a method improvement to increase data throughput and reduce solvent consumption for both saturated and aromatic mineral oil hydrocarbon determination using a coupled liquid–gas chromatographic system. The starting point of this work was the method proposed by Biedermann, Fiselier, and Grob in 2009. A total time and solvent reduction of 34 and 23%, respectively, was obtained by speeding up the GC run and reducing the LC‐reconditioning step. The band broadening, occurring in the LC column during stop‐flow in the multitransfer mode, was assessed by comparing the variances of the perylene peak width recorded in the stop‐flow and normal modes. Band broadening directly proportional to the stop time of the LC pumps was observed, however, it did not affect the analytical reliability. A series of real samples (paperboards and pasta) was analyzed obtaining comparable results using both the reference and proposed method, both in the normal and multitransfer modes.     

Enantioselective comprehensive two‐dimensional gas chromatography of lavender essential oil

The enantiomeric composition of several chiral markers in lavender essential oil was studied by flow modulated comprehensive two‐dimensional gas chromatography operated in the reverse flow mode and hyphenated to flame ionization and quadrupole mass spectrometric detection. Two capillary column series were used in this study, 2,3‐di‐O‐ethyl‐6‐O‐tert‐butyldimethylsilyl‐β‐cyclodextrin or 2,3,6‐tri‐O‐methyl‐β‐cyclodextrin, as the chiral column in the first dimension and α polyethylene glycol column in the second dimension. Combining the chromatographic data obtained on these column series, the enantiomeric and excess ratios for α‐pinene, β‐pinene, camphor, lavandulol, borneol, and terpinen‐4‐ol were determined. This maybe a possible route to assess the authenticity of lavender essential oil.     

Study of two-dimensional liquid chromatography with high temperature NPLC and room temperature RPLC

To overcome the peak band broadening and to increase the peak capacity and separation efficiency of a two-dimensional liquid chromatographic system, a high-temperature normal phase liquid chromatography (HTNPLC) was used as the first dimension (1^st-D), and a RPLC was used as the second dimension (2^nd-D). The sample was first separated on the 1^st-D CN column and the primary eluent stored in the sampling-loop system alternatively (in HTNPLC×RPLC mode) or selectively (in HTNPLC/RPLC mode) and was then transferred to 2^nd-D C₁₈ column for further separation. The resolution and separation efficiency of the systems were greatly improved. The systems were evaluated by analyzing several polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and Glycyrrhiza uralensis extract. __________ Translated from Journal of Instrumental Analysis, 2008, 27(1) (in Chinese)     

Performance evaluation of ion‐exchange chromatography in capillary format

The performance of a recently introduced capillary ion‐exchange chromatography system was explored. Experiments were conducted in isocratic mode with a commercial capillary anion‐exchange column (id = 0.4 mm, L = 15 cm) using a five‐anion standard mixture. The achieved results were compared to the performance of a standard bore ion‐exchange system (id = 4 mm, L = 15 cm), which was considered as a reference. The first‐generation capillary columns exhibited a minimal reduced plate‐height value below two witnessing a good packing quality and system performance. However, compared to the standard bore system the capillary system displayed an increased apparent C‐term which could be due to a difference in packing morphology and/or possible external band‐broadening contributions. For fast separations, the standard bore system outperformed the capillary system, while for complex separations both systems performed nearly equally well. In addition, the retention characteristics of the capillary system were investigated. To illustrate the suitability of the capillary system, the analysis of real‐world water samples originating from two local Belgian rivers was demonstrated.     

Comprehensive Two‐Dimensional Gas Chromatography with a Rotating Thermal Desorption Modulator and Independently Temperature‐Programmable Columns

In comprehensive two‐dimensional gas chromatography, two individual separations are coupled by means of a rotating thermal desorption modulator interface. The injection pulse introduced via the interface onto the second column should be as short as possible. Parameters affecting the modulator operation are studied. In the set‐up used in this study, the temperature of the second column can be programmed independently from that of the first column. Optimization of the second‐dimension separation to minimize peak broadening and maximize resolution is discussed and an elegant approach to determine second‐dimension retention times using a non‐constant modulation frequency is demonstrated. The high separation power of the comprehensive system is demonstrated by the analysis of technical and biota samples containing chlorinated biphenyls and toxaphene.