Experimental study of the depth influence on the band broadening effect in a cyclo-olefin polymer column containing an array of ordered pillars

An experimental study of a micromachined non-porous pillar array column performance under non-retentive conditions is presented. The same pillar structure has been fabricated in cyclo-olefin polymer (COP) chips with three different depths via hot embossing and pressure-assisted thermal bonding. The influence of the depth on the band broadening along with the already known contribution arising from the top and bottom cover plates has been studied. The experimental results exhibit reduced plate heights as low as 0.2, which are in agreement with the previous experimental work. Moreover, the constant values of the reduced Van Deemter expression are also in accordance with the previous studies. A more exhaustive study of the C-term band broadening is also presented, showing that comparing the space between the pillars with different open tubular rectangular channels offers a good estimation of the C-term band broadening that is obtained experimentally. These experimental results, hence, confirm that micromachined pillar array columns fabricated in COP can achieve the same performance as the ones fabricated in silicon for the presently studied pillar channel design.     

A study of the effects of column porosity on gradient separations of proteins

The type of the stationary phase for reversed-phase liquid chromatography significantly affects the sample elution. Hydrodynamic properties, efficiency and gradient elution of proteins were investigated on five commercial C18 columns with wide-pore totally porous particles, with superficially porous layer particles, non-porous particles and a silica-based monolithic bed. The efficiency in the terms of reduced plate height is higher for low-molecular ethylbenzene than for proteins, but depends on the character of the pores in the individual columns tested. The superficially porous Poroshell and the non-porous Micra columns provide the best efficiency for proteins at high mobile phase flow rates, probably because of similar pore architecture in the stationary phase. The Zorbax column with similar pore architecture as the Poroshell active layer, i.e. narrow pore distribution of wider pores shows better efficiency than the packed column with narrow pores and broad pore distribution. The monolithic column shows lower efficiency for proteins at high flow rates, but it performs better than the broad-pore distribution totally porous particulate columns. Different pore architecture affects also the retention and selectivity for proteins on the individual columns. The retention times on all columns can be predicted using the model for reversed-phase gradient elution developed originally for low-molecular compounds. Consideration of the limited pore volume accessible to the biopolymers has negligible effect on the prediction of retention on the columns packed with non-porous or superficially porous particles, but improves the accuracy of the predicted data for the totally porous columns with broad pore distribution.     

Integration of porous layers in ordered pillar arrays for liquid chromatography

The present paper describes a method for the production of partly porous micro-pillars in columns suitable for use in liquid chromatography. These layers increase the available surface at least two orders of magnitude without destroying the huge benefits of the ordered nature of the system. A process flow was developed that enabled us to create a 550 nm thick porous layer on the pillar array in a sealed channel configuration, withstanding pressures up to at least 70 bar. Measuring band broadening under non-retained conditions, only a modest increase in plate height was observed in the porous pillar array as compared to that in a non-porous pillar array. The homogeneity of the layers was demonstrated using an optical microscope and SEM pictures and by monitoring peak velocities at constant pressures. The internal porosity was determined using particles with a diameter larger than the mesopores in combination with a dye that could penetrate into the pores.     

On the optimisation of the bed porosity and the particle shape of ordered chromatographic separation media

We report on a theoretical study wherein we considered a large number of ordered two-dimensional porous pillar arrays with different pillar shapes and widely varying external porosity and calculated the flow resistance and the band broadening (under retentive conditions) over the complete range of practical velocities using a commercial computational fluid dynamics software package. It is found that the performance of the small porosity systems is very sensitive to the exact pillar shape, whereas this difference gradually disappears with increasing porosity. The obtained separation impedances are very small in comparison to packed bed and monolithic columns and decrease with increasing porosity. If accounting for the current micromachining limitations, a proper selection of the exact shape and porosity even becomes more critical, and different design rules are obtained depending on whether porous or non-porous pillars are considered.     

Single-step approach to beta-cyclodextrin-bonded silica as monolithic stationary phases for CEC

A novel single-step sol-gel approach for the preparation of beta-CD-bonded silica monolithic electrochromatographic columns is established. The porous silica networks were fabricated inside fused-silica capillaries using sol-gel processing of tetramethoxysilane and an organfunctional silicon alkoxide that contains beta-CD. Scanning electron micrographs and nitrogen adsorption-desorption data showed that these functional monolithic columns have double pores structures with micrometer-size co-continuous through-pores and silica skeletons with open mesopores. The beta-CD monolithic columns have successfully been applied to the separation of several neutral and negatively charged isomers by CEC. The column performance was evaluated by using positional isomers of naphthalenedisulfonic acid as model compounds. A plate height of less than 10 mum for the first eluted isomer of naphthalenedisulfonic acid was obtained at an optimal flow rate (0.47 mm/s) of the mobile phase. Moreover, the columns have been proved to be stable for more than 100 runs during 3 months period and show reasonable column reproducibility.     

Efficiency enhancements in micellar liquid chromatography through selection of stationary phase and alcohol modifier

Micellar liquid chromatography (MLC) remains hindered by reduced chromatographic efficiency compared to reversed phase liquid chromatography (RPLC) using hydro-organic mobile phases. The reduced efficiency has been partially explained by the adsorption of surfactant monomers onto the stationary phase, resulting in a slow mass transfer of the analyte within the interfacial region of the mobile phase and stationary phase. Using an array of 12 columns, the effects of various bonded stationary phases and silica pore sizes, including large-pore short alkyl chain, non-porous, superficially porous and perfluorinated, were evaluated to determine their impact on efficiency in MLC. Additionally, each stationary phase was evaluated using 1-propanol and 1-butanol as separate micellar mobile phase alcohol additives, with several columns also evaluated using 1-pentanol. A simplified equation for calculation of A' and C' terms from reduced plate height (h) versus reduced velocity (nu) plots was used to compare the efficiency data obtained with the different columns and mobile phases. Analyte diffusion coefficients needed for the h versus nu plots were determined by the Taylor-Aris dispersion technique. The use of a short alkyl chain, wide-pore silica column, specifically, Nucleosil C4, 1000A, was shown to have the most improved efficiency when using a micellar mobile phase compared to a hydro-organic mobile phase for all columns evaluated. The use of 1-propanol was also shown to provide improved efficiency over 1-butanol or 1-pentanol in most cases. In a second series of experiments, column temperatures were varied from 40 to 70 degrees C to determine the effect of temperature on efficiency for a subset of the stationary phases. Efficiency improvements ranging from 9% for a Chromegabond C8 column to 58% for a Zorbax ODS column were observed over the temperature range. Based on these observed improvements, higher column temperatures may often yield significant gains in column efficiency, assuming the column is thermally stable.     

Using principal component analysis for the study of the retention behaviour of phenol derivatives under reversed-phase conditions

Summary The retention time of 11 ring-substituted phenol derivatives was measured on six different reversed-phase HPLC columns and the log k, theoretical plate number (N) and asymmetry factor (F) values were calculated for each solutes on each column. The similarities and dissimilarities among the columns and solutes were elucidated by principal component analysis followed with nonlinear mapping technique and cluster analysis. Calculations indicated that the retention characteristics of porous graphitized carbon stationary phase considerably deviate from those of octadecyl- and hexyl-coated silica, octadecyl-coated polystyrene-divinylbenzene polymer and polybutadiene-coated alumina. The differences among these columns were markedly smaller. The retention behaviour of aminophenols differed from those of other phenol derivatives proving the importance of molecular polarity in the retention. It was established that the mode of calculation slightly modifies the similarity and dissimilarity among the columns and solutes, therefore, the use of more than one calculation method is proposed.     

Preparation of high efficiency and highly retentive monolithic silica capillary columns for reversed-phase chromatography by chemical modification by polymerization of octadecyl methacrylate

High efficiency and highly retentive monolithic silica capillary columns were obtained by polymerization of octadecyl methacrylate using alpha,alpha'-azobis-isobutyronitrile (AIBN) as a free radical initiator. Hybrid type monolithic silica columns (25 cm total length x 200 microm I.D.) prepared from a mixture of tetramethoxysilane and methyltrimethoxysilane were used as a support. The effects of the monomer and the radical initiator concentrations in the reaction mixture were examined. The performance of the columns was tested in terms of column efficiency and retention behavior by using alkylbenzenes and a few other compounds as solutes and compared with that of hybrid monolithic silica columns modified with octadecylsilyl-(N,N-diethylamino)silane (ODS-DEA). Highly retentive monolithic silica columns were obtained by polymerization at high monomer concentrations. Although a decrease in column efficiency was observed with the increase in the monomer concentration in a feed mixture, an improvement in efficiency was achieved (a plate height value lower than 10 microm) by increasing an initiator concentration without significant variations in column retention properties. Results obtained by polymerization using other monomers are also presented to demonstrate the applicability of the preparation method.     

On the 3-dimensional effects in etched chips for high performance liquid chromatography-separations

In an attempt to quantify the potential of photolithographically etched micro-pillar arrays as a perfectly ordered alternative for the packed bed of spheres, the additional band broadening originating from the top and bottom plate has been investigated using computational fluid dynamics simulations. These calculations provide insight in the theoretical expectations that can be made for the experimental work that is currently being conducted by a number of groups. The calculations show that the additional band broadening contribution can be expected to go through a transient regime as a function of the axial distance along the array. In its fully developed regime and in the most relevant velocity range, the top and bottom wall contribution almost doubles the band broadening compared to the band broadening in a perfectly ordered array of non-porous, non-retentive pillars without top and bottom wall. Compared to the band broadening in an array of porous, retentive pillars on the other hand, the top and bottom wall-effect can be expected to become negligible. A simplified, phenomenological model yielding a first principles prediction of both the transient and the steady-state top and bottom wall band broadening as a function of the inter-pillar distance and the pillar height is proposed and shows good qualitative agreement with the exact calculations.     

A numerical study of the assumptions underlying the calculation of the stationary zone mass transfer coefficient in the general plate height model of chromatography in two-dimensional pillar arrays

The present study investigates the validity of one of the key assumptions underlying the general plate height model of chromatography, i.e., the presumed independency of the individual band broadening contributions. More precisely, it is investigated under which conditions the mass transfer inside the stationary zone (e.g., porous pillars) is independent from the axial transport of species outside this zone, and how strongly any such dependency would affect the validity of the general plate height model of chromatography. For this purpose, detailed calculations of the species concentration distribution inside and outside the porous pillars of a computer-mimic of a porous pillar array column have been made. These simulations revealed a clear interplay between the mass transfer inside and outside the pillars, manifesting itself as an asymmetry of the species concentration distribution inside the pillars. The latter is in disagreement with the basic assumption used to calculate the value of the C_s-term of the general plate height model. The asymmetry-effect is largest at low reduced velocities, high retention factors and high intra-pillar diffusion coefficients. Fortunately, these are conditions where the C_s-term is relatively small, which might explain why the general plate height model of chromatography (and based on the symmetry assumption) can represent the band broadening in a porous pillar array within an accuracy on the order of some 1–2%.     

Chromatographic characterization of hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography stationary phases: hydrophilicity, charge effects, structural selectivity, and separation efficiency

Fourteen commercially available particle-packed columns and a monolithic column for hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) were characterized in terms of the degree of hydrophilicity, the selectivity for hydrophilic-hydrophobic substituents, the selectivity for the regio and configurational differences in hydrophilic substituents, the selectivity for molecular shapes, the evaluation of electrostatic interactions, and the evaluation of the acidic-basic nature of the stationary phases using nucleoside derivatives, phenyl glucoside derivatives, xanthine derivatives, sodium p-toluenesulfonate, and trimethylphenylammonium chloride as a set of samples. Principal component analysis based on the data of retention factors could separate three clusters of the HILIC phases. The column efficiency and the peak asymmetry factors were also discussed. These data on the selectivity for partial structural differences were summarized as radar-shaped diagrams. This method of column characterization is helpful to classify HILIC stationary phases on the basis of their chromatographic properties, and to choose better columns for targets to be separated. Judging from the retention factor for uridine, these HILIC columns could be separated into two groups: strongly retentive and weakly retentive stationary phases. Among the strongly retentive stationary phases, zwitterionic and amide functionalities were found to be the most selective on the basis of partial structural differences. The hydroxyethyl-type stationary phase showed the highest retention factor, but with low separation efficiency. Weakly retentive stationary phases generally showed lower selectivity for partial structural differences.     

Hydrodynamic chromatography of polystyrene microparticles in micropillar array columns

We report on the possibility to perform HDC in micropillar array columns and the potential advantages of such a system. The HDC performance of a pillar array column with pillar diameter = 5 μm and an interpillar distance of 2.5 μm has been characterized using both a low MW tracer (FITC) and differently sized polystyrene bead samples (100, 200 and 500 nm). The reduced plate height curves that were obtained for the different investigated markers all overlapped very well, and attained a minimum value of about h_min = 0.3 (reduction based on the pillar diameter), corresponding to 1.6 μm in absolute value and giving good prospects for high efficiency separations. The obtained reduced retention time values were in fair agreement with that predicted by the Di Marzio and Guttman model for a flow between flat plates, using the minimal interpillar distance as characteristic interplate distance.     

逆流法对凝胶色谱峰加宽效应的研究

在以无孔玻璃珠为填料的色谱柱上研究了流动相中的分离能力和峰加宽效应。得到一定的分离能力。根据Kelley和Billmeyer描述流动相中峰加宽效应的理论,塔板高度和溶液的分子量有关而和分子量分布无关。但实验表明,对于具有相同分子量,但分子量分布不同的样品峰宽不同。苯的逆流峰加宽因子h稍大于直流峰加宽因子h′。产生这个差别的原因可以用在逆转过程中流速场受到干扰来解释。 在以多孔硅胶为填料的柱中对一系列不同分子量、分子量分布和化学结构的样品考察了逆流峰加宽因子,h,和淋出体积,Ve,之间的关系。实验表明h和Ve之间的关系具有普适性,这个结果和Tung的一致。在多孔填料柱上对苯同样得到h>h′。这个结果意味着用逆流法得到的h来校正GPC体系造成的峰加宽稍嫌不够。 只有对于分子量分布很窄的样品,其逆流淋出曲线的形状才非常接近高斯分布。     

Dynamics of capillary electrochromatography. II. Comparison of column efficiency parameters in microscale high-performance liquid chromatography and capillary electrochromatography.

In capillary electrochromatography (CEC) the flow of the mobile phase is generated by electrosmotic means in high electric field. This work compares band spreading measured experimentally in several packed capillaries with electrosmotic flow (EOF) and viscous flow under otherwise identical conditions. The data were fitted to the simplified van Deemter equation for the theoretical plate height, H = A + B/u + Cu, in order to evaluate parameters A and C in each mode of flow in the different columns. The ratio of these two parameters obtained with the same column in microscale HPLC (mu-HPLC) and CEC was used to quantify the attenuation of their contribution to band spreading upon changing from viscous flow (in mu-HPLC) to electrosmotic flow (in CEC). The capillary columns used in this study were packed with stationary phases of different pore sizes as well as retentive properties and measurements were carried out under different mobile phase conditions to examine the effects of the retention factor and buffer concentration. In the CEC mode, the value of both column parameters A and C was invariably by a factor of two to four lower than in the mu-HPLC mode. This effect may be attributed to the peculiarities of the EOF flow profile in the interstitial space and to the generation of intraparticle EOF inside the porous particles of the column packing. Thus, band spreading due to flow maldistribution and mass transfer resistances is significantly lower when the mobile phase flow is driven by voltage as in CEC, rather than by pressure as in mu-HPLC.     

The fabrication of poly (polyethylene glycol diacrylate) monolithic porous layer open tubular (mono‐PLOT) columns and applications in hydrophilic interaction chromatography and capillary gas chromatography for small molecules

The easy shrinkage and swelling of polymer monolithic column when exposed to mobile phase with different polarity is a problem that cannot be ignored. To overcome this drawback, a convenient aqueous two‐phase polymerization approach was used to prepare poly (polyethylene glycol diacrylate, PEGDA) monolithic porous layer open tubular (mono‐PLOT) columns (150 μm). The poly(PEGDA) mono‐PLOT column with homogeneous polymer porous layer was synthesized successfully. A maximum plate number of 41,500 plates per meter for allyl thiourea was obtained under a velocity of 1.8 mm/s. Several kinds of polar molecule were separated on the proposed mono‐PLOT column and a typical hydrophilic interaction retention mechanism was observed. High speed separation of benzoic acids was also carried out, baseline separation of five benzoic acids was successfully achieved within 5 min with a 70 cm mono‐PLOT column at 50°C. Furthermore, the resulting PLOT column was also successfully applied to separate standard analytes of three DNA oxidative damage products and RNA‐modified nucleosides and four chlorophenols. At last, the column could separate alcohols, alkanes, and aromatic isomers via GC. It had more than 20,000 plates per meter for butanol – higher than commercial coatings open tubular columns.     

Effect of the silanization conditions on chromatographic behavior of an open-tubular capillary column coated with a modified silica-gel thin layer.

The performance of an open-tubular capillary column coated with a modified silica-gel thin layer was investigated, particularly concerning the effect of the silanization process on it. Although the increase in the octadecyltriethoxysilane (ODTES) concentration in the silanization process could enhance the retention factor of naphthalene, its theoretical plate number was significantly reduced (ODTES, 5 to 50%; k, 0.2 to 4.3; N, 79600 to 2600 m(-1)). Namely, the increase in the retention factor was accompanied by a decrease in the theoretical plate number. A similar phenomenon was also observed when octadecyldimethylchlorosilane (ODCS) was used as the silanization regent. However, increases in both the retention factor and the theoretical plate number could be achieved (sample, naphthalene; k, 0.05 to 0.09; N, 149000 to 220000 m(-1)) by a NaOH treatment to the fabricated thin porous silica-gel layer before silanization with ODCS. The electrochromatographic separation of proteins and peptides by using the NaOH-treated column could obtain more peaks than electrophoretic separation.     

Capillary electrochromatography with 1.5 μm ODS-modified non-porous silica spheres

Summary The particle realization of electrochromatography on capillaries packed with 1.5 μm ODS-modified non-porous silica spheres is demonstrated. In order to realize stable separation conditions it is crucial to add sodium dodecylsulphate (SDS) to the mobile phase and to pressurize both buffer vials at 10 bar. The presence of SDS stabilizes the current and makes the electro-osmotic flow in the packing more uniform so that no air bubbles are generated at high field strengths. The capillary columns are extremely efficient and on a 24 cm long column about 120,000 plates can be generated (a reduced plate height of about 1.3). The columns are very stable and no loss in efficiency was found after using a column continuously for two months.     

Pressure drop effects on selectivity and resolution in packed column supercritical fluid chromatography

The influence of pressure drop on retention, selectivity, plate height and resolution was investigated systematically in packed supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) using pure carbon dioxide as the mobile phase. Numerical methods developed previously which enabled the prediction of pressure gradients, diffusivities, capacity factors, plate heights and resolutions along the length of the column were used for the model calculations. The effects of inlet pressure and supercritical fluid flow rate on selectivity and resolution are studied. In packed column SFC with pure carbon dioxide as the mobile phase, the pressure drop can have a significant effect on resolution. The flow rate is shown to have a larger effect than generally realized. The calculated data are shown to be in good agreement with the experimental results. Finally, the variation of the chromatographic parameters along a 5.5 meter long model SFC column is illustrated. The possibilities and limitations of using long packed columns in SFC are discussed. It is demonstrated that long columns with large plate numbers do not necessarily yield better separations.     

Fast HPLC with non-porous packing materials in the pharmaceutical industry

Summary This paper demonstrates the possibilities in transfering HPLC methods from porous to non-porous stationary phases. The procedures are transferred from 125 or 250 mm columns packed with porous stationary phases to 33 mm columns packed with non-porous particles. It is demonstrated that fast HPLC using non-porous columns reduces analysis times by a factor four to eight. Precision is comparable to HPLC with porous stationary phases. The costs for HPLC with porous and with nonporous packing materials are similar. The implementation of these fast HPLC columns is easy because standard equipment can be used.