A high-resolution solid-state NMR approach for the structural studies of bicelles

Bicelles are increasingly being used as membrane mimicking systems in NMR experiments to investigate the structure of membrane proteins. In this study, we demonstrate the effectiveness of a 2D solid-state NMR approach that can be used to measure the structural constraints, such as heteronuclear dipolar couplings between 1H, 13C, and 31P nuclei, in bicelles without the need for isotopic enrichment. This method does not require a high radio frequency power unlike the presently used rotating-frame separated-local-field (SLF) techniques, such as PISEMA. In addition, multiple dipolar couplings can be measured accurately, and the presence of a strong dipolar coupling does not suppress the weak couplings. High-resolution spectra obtained from magnetically aligned DMPC:DHPC bicelles even in the presence of peptides suggest that this approach will be useful in understanding lipid-protein interactions that play a vital role in shaping up the function of membrane proteins.     

Morphology of magnetically aligning DMPC/DHPC aggregates-perforated sheets, not disks

The morphology of DMPC/DHPC mixtures at total lipid concentration cL = 5% (w/w) and DMPC/DHPC ratio q approximately 3, doped with small amounts of DMPG or CTAB, was investigated. 31P NMR was used to identify the magnetically aligning phase, and cryo-transmission electron microscopy (cryo-TEM) was employed for structural characterization. Magnetic alignment was found to occur between approximately 30 and approximately 45 degrees C, and cryo-TEM showed that the magnetically aligning phase consisted of extended sheets with a lacelike structure. The aggregates are best described as intermediates between two-dimensional networks of flattened, highly branched, cylindrical micelles and lamellar sheets perforated by large irregular holes. DHPC most likely covers the edges of the holes, while DMPC makes up the bilayer bulk of the aggregates. However, 20-43% of the DHPC takes part in the bilayer, corresponding to 6-12% of the bilayer being made up of DHPC. This fraction increases with increasing temperature. At temperatures above 45 degrees C, the aligning phase collapses.     

Comprehensive examination of mesophases formed by DMPC and DHPC mixtures

Mixtures of long- and short-chain phospholipids, specifically 14:0 and 6:0 phosphatidylcholines (DMPC and DHPC), have been used successfully in NMR studies as magnetically alignable substrates for membrane-associated proteins. However, recent publications have shown that the phase behavior of these mixtures is much more complex than originally thought. Using polarized light microscopy and small-angle neutron scattering, phase diagrams of DMPC/DHPC mixtures at molar ratios of 2, 3.2, and 5 have been determined. Generally, at temperatures below the main-chain melting transition of DMPC (T(M) = 23 degrees C), an isotropic phase of disk-like micelles is found. At high temperatures (T > 50 degrees C), a lamellar phase consisting of either multilamellar vesicles (MLV) or extended lamellae is formed, which at low lipid concentrations (e.g., MLV) coexists with an excess of water. At intermediate temperatures and lipid concentrations, a chiral nematic phase made up of worm-like micelles was observed.     

Temperature dependence of proton–proton residual dipolar couplings in adenosine dissolved in charged phospholipid bicelles. Application of a two‐dimensional selective refocusing method

¹H NMR spectra of nucleoside adenosine were recorded in 7.5% (w/v) DMPC/DHPC bicelles doped with CTAB. Despite the small size of adenosine in comparison with the distances between discoidal bicelles, intramolecular ¹H,¹H residual dipolar couplings D were observed at 29.5–38°C. The absolute values of ¹H,¹H spin interactions Δ (sum of J‐ and D‐couplings) were measured selectively by a series of 2D SERF experiments as a function of temperature. At lower temperatures dipolar couplings are scaled down, which leads to simplification of the ¹H NMR spectra. For some pairs of protons, which are simultaneously J‐ and D‐coupled, the exact values of D can be determined from temperature dependence of Δ. Copyright © 2002 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

High-resolution 2D NMR spectroscopy of bicelles to measure the membrane interaction of ligands

Magnetically aligned bicelles are increasingly being used as model membranes in solution- and solid-state NMR studies of the structure, dynamics, topology, and interaction of membrane-associated peptides and proteins. These studies commonly utilize the PISEMA pulse sequence to measure dipolar coupling and chemical shift, the two key parameters used in subsequent structural analysis. In the present study, we demonstrate that the PISEMA and other rotating-frame pulse sequences are not suitable for the measurement of long-range heteronuclear dipolar couplings, and that they provide inaccurate values when multiple protons are coupled to a 13C nucleus. Furthermore, we demonstrate that a laboratory-frame separated-local-field experiment is capable of overcoming these difficulties in magnetically aligned bicelles. An extension of this approach to accurately measure 13C-31P and 1H-31P couplings from phospholipids, which are useful to understand the interaction of molecules with the membrane, is also described. In these 2D experiments, natural abundance 13C was observed from bicelles containing DMPC and DHPC lipid molecules. As a first application, these solid-state NMR approaches were utilized to probe the membrane interaction of an antidepressant molecule, desipramine, and its location in the membrane.     

Is styrene planar in liquid phases?

The proton NMR spectra of two (13)C-labeled isotopomers of styrene dissolved in two liquid crystalline solvents have been obtained and analyzed to yield four sets each of 24 dipolar couplings. These couplings were then used to investigate the structure of the ring and the ene fragments of the molecule, and the position of the maximum, phi(0), in the ring-ene bond rotational probability distribution. To do this, the effect on the dipolar couplings of small-amplitude vibrational motion was taken into account using vibrational wave functions calculated by molecular orbital and density functional methods. It is concluded that the NMR data are consistent with the ring fragment, averaged over the ring-ene rotation, planar, while the ene fragment is not. The value of phi(0) is found to be 18.0 degrees +/-0.2 degrees for the two solutions, compared with a value of 27 degrees calculated by the molecular method MP2/6-31G(*).     

NMR “Crystallography” for Uniformly (13C, 15N)-Labeled Oriented Membrane Proteins

In oriented-sample (OS) solid-state NMR of membrane proteins, the angular-dependent dipolar couplings and chemical shifts provide a direct input for structure calculations. However, so far only ¹H–¹⁵N dipolar couplings and ¹⁵N chemical shifts have been routinely assessed in oriented ¹⁵N-labeled samples. The main obstacle for extending this technique to membrane proteins of arbitrary topology has remained in the lack of additional experimental restraints. We have developed a new experimental triple-resonance NMR technique, which was applied to uniformly doubly (¹⁵N, ¹³C)-labeled Pf1 coat protein in magnetically aligned DMPC/DHPC bicelles. The previously inaccessible ¹H_α–¹³C_α dipolar couplings have been measured, which make it possible to determine the torsion angles between the peptide planes without assuming α-helical structure a priori. The fitting of three angular restraints per peptide plane and filtering by Rosetta scoring functions has yielded a consensus α-helical transmembrane structure for Pf1 protein.     

Molecular conformations in a phospholipid bilayer extracted from dipolar couplings: a computer simulation study

This paper describes an analysis of NMR dipolar couplings in a bilayer formed by dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC). The couplings are calculated from a trajectory generated in a molecular dynamics (MD) simulation based on a realistic atom-atom interaction potential. The analysis is carried out employing a recently developed approach that focuses on the construction of the conformational distribution function. This approach is a combination of two models, the additive potential (AP) model and the maximum entropy (ME) method, and is therefore called APME. In contrast to the AP model, the APME procedure does not require an intuition-based choice of the functional form of the torsional potential and is, unlike the ME method, applicable to weakly ordered systems. The conformational distribution function for the glycerol moiety of the DMPC molecule derived from the APME analysis of the dipolar couplings is in reasonable agreement with the "true" distributions calculated from the trajectory. Analyses of dipolar couplings derived from MD trajectories can, in general, serve as guidelines for experimental investigations of bilayers and other complex biological systems.     

Effects of small neutral molecules on phospholipid bicelle ordering

The effects of small neutral molecules on the liquid-crystalline ordering of dimyristoyl-phosphatidylcholine (DMPC)/dihexanoyl-phosphatidylcholine (DHPC) bicelles (q = 3.0 and 3.5) were studied via 2H, 31P, and 13C variable-temperature NMR. The addition of chloroform (up to approximately 90 mM, with a lipid concentration of approximately 120 mM) was observed to reduce the temperature onset of bicelle ordering by up to approximately 10 degrees C, likely resulting from the depression of the DMPC phase transition temperature. The temperature for the collapse of the bicelle phase was also significantly reduced; the observed effects amount to a downward shift in temperature (and reduction in range) of the liquid-crystalline portion of the bicelle phase diagram with increasing dopant concentration. Other model dopants (e.g., tetrahydrofuran and benzene) yielded smaller effects. Additionally, the variable bicelle alignment permitted the characterization of the ordering of chloroform molecules within the lipid phase.     

Protein structural motif recognition via NMR residual dipolar couplings.

NMR residual dipolar couplings have great potential to provide rapid structural information for proteins in the solution state. This information even at low resolution may be used to advantage in proteomics projects that seek to annotate large numbers of gene products for entire genomes. In this paper, we describe a novel approach to the structural interpretation of dipolar couplings which is based on structural motif pattern recognition, where a predefined gapless structural template for a motif is used to search a set of residual dipolar couplings for good matches. We demonstrate the applicability of the method using synthetic and experimental data. We also provide an analysis of the statistical power of the method and the effects of order tensor frame orientation, motif size, and structural complexity on motif detection. Finally, we discuss remaining problems that must be overcome before the method can be used routinely to identify protein homologies.     

Temperature driven annealing of perforations in bicellar model membranes

Bicellar model membranes composed of 1,2-dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC) and 1,2-dihexanoylphosphatidylcholine (DHPC), with a DMPC/DHPC molar ratio of 5, and doped with the negatively charged lipid 1,2-dimyristoylphosphatidylglycerol (DMPG), at DMPG/DMPC molar ratios of 0.02 or 0.1, were examined using small angle neutron scattering (SANS), (31)P NMR, and (1)H pulsed field gradient (PFG) diffusion NMR with the goal of understanding temperature effects on the DHPC-dependent perforations in these self-assembled membrane mimetics. Over the temperature range studied via SANS (300-330 K), these bicellar lipid mixtures exhibited a well-ordered lamellar phase. The interlamellar spacing d increased with increasing temperature, in direct contrast to the decrease in d observed upon increasing temperature with otherwise identical lipid mixtures lacking DHPC. (31)P NMR measurements on magnetically aligned bicellar mixtures of identical composition indicated a progressive migration of DHPC from regions of high curvature into planar regions with increasing temperature, and in accord with the "mixed bicelle model" (Triba, M. N.; Warschawski, D. E.; Devaux, P. E. Biophys. J.2005, 88, 1887-1901). Parallel PFG diffusion NMR measurements of transbilayer water diffusion, where the observed diffusion is dependent on the fractional surface area of lamellar perforations, showed that transbilayer water diffusion decreased with increasing temperature. A model is proposed consistent with the SANS, (31)P NMR, and PFG diffusion NMR data, wherein increasing temperature drives the progressive migration of DHPC out of high-curvature regions, consequently decreasing the fractional volume of lamellar perforations, so that water occupying these perforations redistributes into the interlamellar volume, thereby increasing the interlamellar spacing.     

Micelle-induced curvature in a water-insoluble HIV-1 Env peptide revealed by NMR dipolar coupling measurement in stretched polyacrylamide gel

The structure of a water-insoluble fragment encompassing residues 282-304 of the HIV envelope protein gp41 is studied when solubilized by dihexanoyl phosphatidylcholine (DHPC) and by small bicelles, consisting of a 4:1 molar ratio of DHPC and dimyristoyl phosphatidylcholine (DMPC). Weak alignment with the magnetic field was accomplished in a stretched polyacrylamide gel, permitting measurement of one-bond (1)H-(15)N, (13)Ca-(13)C', and (13)C'-(15)N dipolar couplings, which formed the basis for determining the peptide structure. In both detergent systems, the peptide adopts an alpha-helical conformation from residue 4 through 18. In the presence of the DHPC micelles the helix is strongly curved towards the hydrophobic surface, whereas in the presence of bicelles a much weaker curvature in the opposite direction is observed.     

NMR “Crystallography” for Uniformly (13C, 15N)‐Labeled Oriented Membrane Proteins

In oriented‐sample (OS) solid‐state NMR of membrane proteins, the angular‐dependent dipolar couplings and chemical shifts provide a direct input for structure calculations. However, so far only ¹H–¹⁵N dipolar couplings and ¹⁵N chemical shifts have been routinely assessed in oriented ¹⁵N‐labeled samples. The main obstacle for extending this technique to membrane proteins of arbitrary topology has remained in the lack of additional experimental restraints. We have developed a new experimental triple‐resonance NMR technique, which was applied to uniformly doubly (¹⁵N, ¹³C)‐labeled Pf1 coat protein in magnetically aligned DMPC/DHPC bicelles. The previously inaccessible ¹H_α–¹³C_α dipolar couplings have been measured, which make it possible to determine the torsion angles between the peptide planes without assuming α‐helical structure a priori. The fitting of three angular restraints per peptide plane and filtering by Rosetta scoring functions has yielded a consensus α‐helical transmembrane structure for Pf1 protein.     

Dynamic properties of bicellar lipid mixtures observed by rheometry and quadrupole echo decay

In bicellar dispersions of 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DMPC) and 1,2-dihexanoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DHPC), the transition from isotropic reorientation to partial orientational order, on warming, is known to coincide with a sharp increase in viscosity. In this work, cone-and-plate rheometry, (2)H NMR spectroscopy, and quadrupole echo decay observations have been used to obtain new insights into the dynamics of phases observed in bicellar DMPC/DHPC mixtures. Samples with 25% of the DMPC component deuterated were used to correlate rheological measurements with phase behavior observed by (2)H NMR spectroscopy. Mixtures containing only normal DMPC (DMPC/DHPC) or only chain perdeuterated DMPC (DMPC-d(54)/DHPC) were used to refine rheology and quadrupole echo decay measurements respectively. The viscosity peaked at 4-9 Pa·s, just above the isotropic-to-nematic transition, and then dropped as samples were warmed through the nematic-to-lamellar transition. Quadrupole echo decay times above the nematic-to-lamellar transition were significantly longer than typically observed in the liquid crystalline phase of saturated lipid multilamellar vesicles. This may indicate a damping of slow bilayer undulations resulting from the coupling of opposite bilayer surfaces by DHPC-lined pores.     

De novo determination of bond orientations and order parameters from residual dipolar couplings with high accuracy

We report the de novo determination of 15N-1H bond orientations and motional order parameters for the protein ubiquitin with high accuracy based solely on NMR residual dipolar coupling measurements made in six distinct alignment media. The resulting bond orientations are in agreement with RDC-refined orientations of either solid or solution state coordinates to within approximately 2 degrees , which is also the estimated precision of the resulting orientations. The squared generalized order parameters, which reflect amplitudes of motion spanning the picosecond to millisecond time scales, exhibit a correlation with picosecond time scale order parameters derived from conventional NMR 15N spin relaxation methods. Provided that RDC measurements can be obtained using many different alignment media, this approach (called direct interpretation of dipolar couplings) may significantly impact the attainable accuracy and the molecular weight range accessible to NMR structure determination in the solution state, as well as provide a route for the study of motions occurring on the nanosecond to microsecond time scales, which have been traditionally difficult to study at atomic resolution.     

Theoretical analysis of residual dipolar coupling patterns in regular secondary structures of proteins

A new approach to the interpretation of residual dipolar couplings for the regular secondary structures of proteins is presented. This paper deals with the analysis of the steric and chiral requirements of protein secondary structures and establishes a quantitative correlation between structure periodicity and the experimental values of the backbone residual dipolar couplings. Building on the recent interpretation of the periodicity of residual dipolar couplings in alpha-helices (i.e., "dipolar waves"), a general parametric equation for fitting the residual dipolar couplings of any regular secondary structure is derived. This equation interprets the modulation of the residual dipolar couplings' periodicity in terms of the secondary structure orientation with respect to an arbitrary reference frame, laying the groundwork for using backbone residual dipolar couplings as a fast tool for determining protein folding by NMR spectroscopy.     

Phospholipid bicelles that align with their normals parallel to the magnetic field

We have recently reported phospholipid bicelles (bilayered micelles) that have positive anisotropy of the magnetic susceptibility and align with their normals parallel to an external magnetic field [J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2001, 123, 1537]. Improvements have been made via the synthesis of a new phospholipid, 1-dodecanoyl-2-(4-(4-biphenyl)butanoyl)-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DBBPC). Bicelles can be formed by mixing DBBPC with a short-chain phospholipid, 1,2-dihexanoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DHPC) in a ratio between 5.1:1 and 6.5:1 in an aqueous medium. The (31)P NMR spectra clearly show that these bicelles align with their principal axes parallel to the magnetic field within a wide temperature range. The (31)P chemical shifts indicate that the conformation of the polar headgroup in these bicelles may be different from that in common bicelles. The phase behavior of a mixture of DBBPC/DHPC with 6:1 mole ratio was investigated in the temperature range of 10-75 degrees C using (31)P, (2)H, and (23)Na NMR. At lower temperatures (10-54 degrees C), the system is dominated by the bicellar phase. At higher temperatures (54-75 degrees C), isotropic micelles are formed and coexist with the bicelles. The partial alignment of maltotriose in the DBBPC/DHPC system was studied at three temperatures, and the (1)H-(13)C dipolar coupling constants are compared with those obtained for two other bicelle solutions.     

A novel method for the determination of stereochemistry in six-membered chairlike rings using residual dipolar couplings

A novel method for the determination of the relative stereochemistry of six-membered chairlike ring molecules by residual dipolar couplings is presented. C-H residual dipolar couplings were used to investigate the relative stereochemistry of 4,6-O-ethylidene-d-glucopyranose. For this and similar systems it is not necessary to acquire redundant dipolar couplings and to calculate the orientation order tensor. The presented methodology is a paradigmatic leap for the determination of the relative stereochemistry or remote stereochemistry in this kind of fused ring system. Residual dipolar coupling data were collected by 1D and 2D direct-measurement heteronuclear multiple quantum coherence (HMQC) spectroscopy. It was demonstrated that direct measurement of HMQC was quick and accurate for small molecules at natural abundance.     

Magnetic resonance investigations of lipid motion in isotropic bicelles

The dynamics of DMPC in different isotropic bicelles have been investigated by NMR and EPR methods. The local dynamics were obtained by interpretation of 13C NMR relaxation measurements of DMPC in the bicelles, and these results were compared to EPR spectra of spin-labeled lipids. The overall size of the bicelles was investigated by PFG NMR translational diffusion measurements. The dynamics and relative sizes were compared among three different bicelles: [DMPC]/[DHPC] = 0.25, [DMPC]/[DHPC] = 0.5, and [DMPC]/[CHAPS] = 0.5. The local motion is found to depend much more strongly on the choice of the detergent, rather than the overall size of the bicelle. The results provide an explanation for differences in apparent dynamics for different peptides, which are bound to bicelles. This in turn determines under what conditions reasonable NMR spectra can be observed. A model is presented in which extensive local motion, in conjunction with the overall size, affects the spectral properties. An analytical expression for the size dependence of the bicelles, relating the radius of the bilayer region with physical properties of the detergent and the lipid, is also presented.     

Measurement of Large Dipolar Couplings of a Liquid Crystal with Terminal Phenyl Rings and Estimation of the Order Parameters

NMR spectroscopy is a powerful means of studying liquid‐crystalline systems at atomic resolutions. Of the many parameters that can provide information on the dynamics and order of the systems, ¹H–¹³C dipolar couplings are an important means of obtaining such information. Depending on the details of the molecular structure and the magnitude of the order parameters, the dipolar couplings can vary over a wide range of values. Thus the method employed to estimate the dipolar couplings should be capable of estimating both large and small dipolar couplings at the same time. For this purpose, we consider here a two‐dimensional NMR experiment that works similar to the insensitive nuclei enhanced by polarization transfer (INEPT) experiment in solution. With the incorporation of a modification proposed earlier for experiments with low radio frequency power, the scheme is observed to enable a wide range of dipolar couplings to be estimated at the same time. We utilized this approach to obtain dipolar couplings in a liquid crystal with phenyl rings attached to either end of the molecule, and estimated its local order parameters.