Investigation of the flammability of different textile fabrics using micro-scale combustion calorimetry

Evaluating and analyzing the performance of flame retardant (FR) textiles are a critical part of research and development of new FR textiles products by the industry. The testing methods currently used in the industry have significant limitations. Most analytical and testing techniques are not able to measure heat release rate (HRR), the single most important parameter in evaluating the fire hazard of materials. It is difficult to measure HRR of textile fabrics using cone calorimetry because textile fabrics are dimensionally thin samples. The recently developed micro-scale combustion calorimetry (MCC) is able to measure the following flammability parameters for textile using milligram sample sizes: heat release capacity, HRR, temperature at peak heat release rate (PHRR), total heat release and char yield. In this research, we applied MCC to evaluate the flammability of different textile fabrics including cotton, rayon, cellulose acetate, silk, nylon, polyester, polypropylene, acrylic fibers, Nomex and Kevlar. We also studied the cotton fabrics treated with different flame retardants. We found that MCC is able to differentiate small differences in flammability of textile materials treated with flame retardants. We were also be able to calculate the limiting oxygen index (LOI) using the thermal combustion properties of various textile samples measured by the MCC. The calculated LOI data have yielded good agreement with experimental LOI results. Thus, we conclude that MCC is an effective new analytical technique for measuring textile flammability and has great potentials in the research and development of new flame retardants for textiles.     

Formaldehyde-free flame retardant finishing of silk using a hydroxyl-functional organophosphorus oligomer

Flame retardancy is a desirable property for silk textiles, and it becomes necessity when silk textiles are for interior decorative use in building with public access. However, the flame retardant finishing technology available for silk has significant limitations. In this research, we studied the use of the combination of a hydroxyl-functional organophosphorus oligomer (HFPO) and 1,2,3,4-butanetetracarboxylic acid (BTCA) as a formaldehyde-free flame retardant finishing system for silk. When BTCA is applied to silk, most of BTCA reacts with the hydroxyl group on silk by single ester linkage. In the presence of HFPO, BTCA is able to bond HFPO onto silk by either a BTCA “bridge” between silk and HFPO or a BTCA-HFPO-BTCA cross-linkage between two silk protein molecules. We evaluated the flammability and physical properties of the silk fabric treated with HFPO and BTCA. The treated silk fabric demonstrated a high level of flame retardancy with modest loss in fabric tensile strength. The treated silk passed the vertical flammability test after 15 hand wash (HW) cycles. Increasing the HFPO concentration from 20% to 30% does not show significant improvement in the flame retardant performance of the treated silk. The thermal analysis data demonstrated that HFPO reduces silk's initial thermal decomposition temperature and promotes char formation.     

Comparison of different reactive organophosphorus flame retardant agents for cotton. Part II: Fabric flame resistant performance and physical properties

N-Methylol dimethylphosphonopropionamide (MDPA) is one of the most commonly used durable flame retardant agents for cotton. In our previous research, we developed a new flame retardant finishing system based on a hydroxy-functional organophosphorus oligomer (HFPO) and bonding agents, such as dimethyloldihydroxyethyleneurea (DMDHEU) and trimethylolmelamine (TMM). In this research, we compared the flame resistant performance as well as physical properties of the cotton fabric treated with these two flame retardant finishing systems. The cotton fabric treated with MDPA/TMM has a higher initial limiting oxygen index (LOI) than that of the fabric treated with HFPO/TMM due to higher nitrogen content in the system. The LOI of the cotton fabric treated with the HFPO and MDPA systems becomes identical when the treated fabric contains equal amount of phosphorus and nitrogen. The MDPA/TMM shows higher laundering durability on cotton than HFPO/TMM system. The fabric treated with HFPO/TMM and MDPA/TMM has low wrinkle resistance and low strength loss whereas the fabric stiffness significantly increases when the TMM concentration is increased.     

表面化学接枝改性阻燃棉织物的制备与性能

采用高碘酸钠对棉织物表面进行选择性氧化生成醛基,选取乙二胺与醛基反应,通过膦氢化加成反应将阻燃剂亚磷酸二甲酯接枝到棉织物表面,最后通过三羟甲基三聚氰胺对棉织物表面进行接枝改性,制备了含三羟甲基三聚氰胺/乙二胺/亚磷酸二甲酯阻燃棉织物.通过傅里叶红外光谱（FTIR）对改性后棉织物的结构进行了表征,通过极限氧指数（LOI）测试研究了其阻燃性能,通过锥形量热测试研究了其燃烧行为,通过在40℃皂水中洗涤10次考察了其耐水性能,通过扫描电子显微镜测试了其表面及燃烧后炭层的形貌.研究结果表明,经表面改性后,棉织物的LOI值由（19.5±1.0）%提高到了（43.1±1.0）%,经耐水洗测试后,LOI值仅下降至（42.6±1.0）%,保持了非常好的阻燃性能,表明通过表面接枝方法制备的三羟甲基三聚氰胺/乙二胺/亚磷酸二甲酯阻燃棉织物具有非常好的耐水洗性能.表面阻燃改性提高了棉织物在燃烧过程中的成炭性能,形成的连续膨胀的炭层较好地保护了内部织物,抑制了织物的降解和燃烧,从而提高了棉织物的阻燃性能.     

Synthesis and characterization of a novel phosphorus–nitrogen‐containing flame retardant and its application for textile

The economic and environmentally friendly flame‐retardant compound, tetramethyl (6‐chloro‐1,3,5‐triazine‐2,4‐diyl)bis(oxy)bis(methylene) diphosphonate ( CN‐1 ), was synthesized by a simple two‐step procedure from dimethyl phosphate, and its chemical structure was characterized by ¹H, ¹³C, and ³¹P nuclear magnetic resonance and gas chromatography mass spectroscopy. Using the traditional pad–dry–cure method, we obtained several different add‐ons (wt%) by treating cotton twill fabric with flame retardant ( CN‐1 ). Thermogravimetric analysis, in an air and nitrogen atmosphere, of the modified cotton showed that decomposition occurred ~230°C with 16% residue weight char yield at 600°C, indicating high thermal stability for all treated levels. Limiting oxygen index (LOI) and the vertical flammability test were employed to determine the effectiveness of the flame‐retardant treatments on the fabrics. LOI values increased from ~18 vol% oxygen in nitrogen for untreated fabric to maximum of 34 vol% for the highest treatment level. Fabrics with higher levels of flame retardant also easily passed the vertical flammability test. Furthermore, Fourier transform infrared and scanning electron microscopy were utilized to characterize the chemical structure as well as the surface morphology of the flame‐retardant treated twill fabrics, including char area and the edge between unburned fabric and char area. Copyright © 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Durable flame‐retardant finishing for polyamide 66 fabrics by surface hydroxymethylation and crosslinking

This paper describes an attempt to develop a durable finishing method in order to improve the fire performance of polyamide 66 fabrics. Hydroxymethylation with a 36% formaldehyde aqueous solution in association with a pad‐curing process to enable the fabric to react with flame‐retardant solutions was used in the finishing process. The fire performance of treated samples was characterized by limiting oxygen index (LOI) and vertical flammability tests, and the results show that the LOI value can increase from 21.6% to 46.2%. The thermal behavior of untreated and treated polyamide 66 fabrics was investigated by using thermogravimetic analysis and differential scanning calorimetry. Furthermore, residual char of treated fabric sample is much higher than that of untreated fabric sample. Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy proves that the substituted hydroxymethyl groups do exist on the molecular chain of polyamide fabric sample after surface modification. The morphology of residue char of polyamide 66 fabric samples was analyzed by scanning electron microscope, and the mechanical properties were also investigated and discussed. Copyright © 2012 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

The comparison of differences in flammability and thermal degradation between cotton fabrics treated with phosphoramidate derivatives

The effectiveness of a phosphoramidate tetraethyl piperazine‐1,4‐diyldiphosphoramidate (TEPP) as a flame retardant on cotton twill fabrics was compared with that of a previously studied diethyl 4‐methylpiperazin‐1‐ylphosphoramidate (DEPP). TEPP was formed in a reaction between two phosphonates and a piperazine then cotton twill fabrics were treated with TEPP at different levels of add‐on (2–19 wt%) and characterized using vertical flammability, limiting oxygen index, microscale combustion calorimetry, and thermogravimetric analysis methods. The results showed better flame retardancy and thermal behavior for TEPP fabrics when compared with DEPP fabrics. When the morphological structure of the formed char from the burned areas was examined by scanning electron microscopy, the results revealed a fairly insignificant difference in the mode of action between the two types of fabric. Copyright © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Maintaining hand and improving fire resistance of cotton fabric through ultrasonication rinsing of multilayer nanocoating

Thin films of environmentally benign polyelectrolytes, cationic chitosan (CH) and anionic poly(sodium phosphate) (PSP), were deposited on cotton fabric via layer-by-layer (LbL) assembly to reduce flammability. This CH–PSP nanocoating promotes charring of the cotton, rendering the fabric self-extinguishing. The coated fabric was rinsed in an ultrasonication bath between deposition steps to improve the softness (i.e., hand) of the coated fabric. Ultrasonication is believed to remove weakly adhered polyelectrolyte, preventing the fabric from becoming stiff, while improving anti-flammable behavior at a given coating weight. At 17 bilayers, only 9.1 wt% was added to the cotton, yet the coated cotton consistently passed vertical flame testing. Electron microscopy provides evidence of intumescence and confirms the cleaner deposition afforded by ultrasonication. The reduction in peak heat release rate and total heat release, as measured by micro cone calorimetry, were 73 and 81 % respectively, which is a new benchmark in LbL flame retardant coating on cotton. The mechanical properties of the fabric were measured using the Kawabata evaluation system, which showed that ultrasonication rinsing significantly improved the hand. The ability to render cotton fabric self-extinguishing, while maintaining a soft hand, marks a major milestone in the development of these environmentally-benign nanocoatings.     

Preparation and flammability of EPDM/PP/Mg(OH)2 dynamic vulcanizates

Magnesium hydroxide (MH) flame retardant dynamic vulcanized ethylene‐propylene‐diene terpolymer (EPDM)/polypropylene (PP) thermoplastic vulcanizates (TPVs) were prepared by a twin‐screw extruder. Influences of MH on their morphology, mechanical properties, flammability, and crystallization behavior have been investigated. Static tensile measurements exhibited that TPVs have higher mechanical properties than un‐vulcanized EPDM/PP/MH blends (UVBs). Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) studies showed that the formation of the larger‐size “micro‐encapsulated structure” where the MH aggregates were covered with a cross‐linked rubber phase improved the interaction between MH and polymer matrix. Results of limiting oxygen index (LOI) and microscale combustion calorimetry (MCC) confirmed that TPVs had superior fire‐resistant properties to UVBs. SEM images showed that more uniform and compact charred layers were generated in TPVs. The differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) results indicated that the crystallization behavior of the flame retardant TPVs changed marginally with increase in MH content. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Thermal properties of cotton fabric modified with poly (propylene imine) dendrimers

For the first time, thermal stability and flame retardant properties of cotton fabrics modified with poly (propylene imine) dendrimer (PPI-dendrimer) using cross linking agents have been reported. The PPI-dendrimers can be considered as novel nitrogen flame retardant agents, because they contain a large number of nitrogen-containing groups (amine end groups), which may release nitrogen gas or ammonia. In this paper, the effect of the PPI-dendrimers on thermal behavior of cotton fabric is investigated through thermogravimetric analysis, differential scanning calorimetry, flammability (in vertical configuration) and limiting oxygen index tests. Indeed, both thermal stability and flame retarancy of the modified fabrics have significantly enhanced. Furthermore, field emission scanning electron microscopy micrographs have been studied in order to evaluate morphology of the cotton samples. Crystallinity and physical properties including crease recovery angle, breaking strength, whiteness index and hygroscopicity of the samples have been also assessed.     

The bonding of a hydroxy-functional organophosphorus oligomer to nylon fabric using the formaldehyde derivatives of urea and melamine as the bonding agents

In this research, we studied the mechanism of bonding a hydroxy-functional organophosphorus oligomer (HFPO) to nylon 6.6 fabric using the formaldehyde derivatives of urea and melamine, including dimethyloldihydroxyethyleneurea (DMDHEU) and trimethylolmelamine (TMM), as the bonding agents. The nylon fabric treated with HFPO/DMDHEU or HFPO/TMM retained significant amount of phosphorus after multiple launderings. The laundering durability of the HFPO applied to nylon was probably attributed to the formation of a crosslinked polymeric network on the nylon fiber. The nylon fabric treated with HFPO/DMDHEU showed higher percent phosphorus retention than that treated with HFPO/TMM. The percent phosphorus retention of the treated nylon increased as the DMDHEU or TMM concentration was increased, and the nylon fabric's stiffness follows the same trend. The micro-scale combustion calorimetry and thermal analysis data indicate that the HFPO bound to nylon reduced peak heat release rate and heat release capacity of the nylon fabric, decreased decomposition temperature and promoted the char formation of the treated fabric. The nylon/cotton blend military fabric treated with HFPO/DMDHEO or HFPO/TMM demonstrated flame retardant performance after 10 laundering cycles.     

Combustion properties and thermal degradation behavior of polylactide with an effective intumescent flame retardant

An intumescent flame retardant spirocyclic pentaerythritol bisphosphorate disphosphoryl melamine (SPDPM) has been synthesized and its structure was characterized by Fourier transformed infrared spectrometry (FTIR), ¹H and ³¹P nuclear magnetic resonances (NMR). A series of polylactide (PLA)-based flame retardant composites containing SPDPM were prepared by melt blending method. The combustion properties of PLA/SPDPM composites were evaluated through UL-94, limiting oxygen index (LOI) tests and microscale combustion calorimetry (MCC) experiments. It is found that SPDPM integrating acid, char and gas sources significantly improved the flame retardancy and anti-dripping performance of PLA. When 25 wt% flame retardant was added, the composites achieved UL-94 V0, and the LOI value was increased to 38. Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) showed that the weight loss rate of PLA was decreased by introduction of SPDPM. In addition, the thermal degradation process and possible flame retardant mechanism of PLA composites with SPDPM were analyzed by in situ FTIR.     

Synthesis of a novel synergistic flame retardant based on cyclopolysiloxane and its flame retardant coating on cotton fabric

A synergistic flame retardant (silicon, phosphorus and nitrogen) based on cyclic polysiloxane, ammonium salt of tetramethylcyclosiloxyl-piperazin-phosphinic acid (APCTSi) was successfully prepared and firmly bonded to cotton fabric through a chemical grafting method. The chemical structure of APCTSi was characterized by Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy, ¹H and ³¹P nuclear magnetic resonance (¹H NMR and ³¹P NMR). The scanning electron microscopy coupled with energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (SEM–EDX) proved that APCTSi successfully adhered to the surface of cotton fabric and the elements on the surface of cotton fabric were evenly distributed. The flame retardant properties were characterized by limiting oxygen index (LOI), vertical burning test, thermogravimetric (TG) analysis and TG-FTIR. The limiting oxygen index (LOI) can reach 30.9% with a char length of 8.7 cm for the weight gain of APCTSi was 16.2%. The combustion behavior was characterized by cone calorimetry test. The peak heat release rate (pHRR) and total heat release (THR) values of treated cotton fabric decreased by 30% and 48% respectively compared to that of pure cotton fabric. All the results proved that the cotton fabric treated by APCTSi had the flame retardant effect of condensed phase (forming stable char layer) and gas phase (releasing nonflammable gases).

Graphic abstract

     

The anti-dripping intumescent flame retardant finishing for nylon-6,6 fabric

Nylon-6,6 fabric has been widely used in military and civilian area for many years. However, the melting drip problem has not been effectively solved despite the efforts made in the last two decades. An intumescent flame retardant system, containing ammonium polyphosphate, melamine and pentaerythritol, has been proved to be effective on preventing melting drip during burning of nylon-6,6 fabric in this study. The LOI and the vertical flammability test indicate that this IFR (intumescent flame retardant) system could improve the flame retardancy and impart dripping resistance to nylon-6,6 fabric. Thermal behaviour of nylon-6,6 fabric treated with IFR system was investigated by thermogravimetric (TG) and differential scanning calorimetric(DSC) experiments. The results indicate that char residue of treated samples are above 13%, and the highest value could reach up to 24% at 750 °C which is much higher than that of the untreated fabric. SEM graphs of residue of treated and untreated nylon-6,6 fabric show that IFR could promote formation of residual char which impart anti-dripping property to nylon-6,6 fabric. The tensile property test shows that tensile strength of treated fabric decreased.     

Synthesis of a novel polyphosphazene/triazine bi‐group flame retardant in situ doping nano zinc oxide and its application in poly (lactic acid) resin

A novel polyphosphazene/triazine bi‐group flame retardant in situ doping nano ZnO (A4‐d‐ZnO) was synthesized and applied in poly (lactic acid) (PLA). Fourier transform infrared (FTIR), solid state nuclear magnetic resonance (SSNMR), X‐ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), scanning electron microscope (SEM), transmission electron microscope (TEM), and energy dispersive spectrometer (EDS) were used to confirm the chemical structure of A4‐d‐ZnO. The thermal stability and the flame‐retardant properties of the PLA composites were characterized by thermogravimetric analysis (TGA), differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), limiting oxygen index (LOI), vertical burning test (UL‐94), and micro combustion calorimeter (MCC) test. The results of XPS showed that A4‐d‐ZnO has been synthesized, and the doping ratio of ZnO was 7.2% in flame‐retardant A4‐d‐ZnO. TGA results revealed that A4‐d‐ZnO had good char forming ability (40 wt% at 600°C). The results of LOI, vertical burning test, and MCC showed that PLA/5%A4‐d‐ZnO composite acquired a higher LOI value (24%), higher UL94 rating, and lower pk‐HRR (501 kW/m²) comparing with that of pure PLA. It indicated that a small amount of flame‐retardant A4‐d‐ZnO could achieve great flame‐retardant performance in PLA composites. The catalytic chain scission effect of A4‐d‐ZnO could make PLA composites drip with flame and go out during combustion, which was the reason for the good flame‐retardant property. Moreover, after the addition of A4‐d‐ZnO, the impaired mechanical properties of PLA composites are minimal enough.     

Development of an environmentally friendly halogen‐free phosphorus–nitrogen bond flame retardant for cotton fabrics

A novel flame retardant diethyl 4‐methylpiperazin‐1‐ylphosphoramidate (CN‐3) containing phosphorous and nitrogen was prepared. Its chemical structure was confirmed by nuclear magnetic resonance (¹H‐, ¹³C‐, and ³¹P‐NMR), Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy, and elemental analysis. Print cloth and twill fabrics were treated with CN‐3 to achieve different levels of add‐on (7–22 wt% add‐ons for print cloth and 3–18 wt% add‐ons for twill). Thermogravimetric analysis, vertical flame test, and limiting oxygen index (LOI) were performed on the treated cotton fabrics and showed promising results. When the treated print cloth and twill fabric samples were tested using the vertical flame test (ASTM D6413‐08), we observed that the ignited fabrics self‐extinguished and left behind a streak of char. Treated higher add‐ons fabrics were neither consumed by flame nor produced glowing ambers upon self‐extinguishing. LOI (ASTM 2863–09) was used to determine the effectiveness of the flame retardant on the treated fabrics. LOI values increased from 18 vol% oxygen in nitrogen for untreated print cloth and twill fabrics to maximum of 28 and 31 wt% for the highest add‐ons of print cloth and twill, respectively. The results from cotton fabrics treated with CN‐3 demonstrated a higher LOI value as well as a higher char yield because of the effectiveness of phosphorus and nitrogen as a flame retardant for cotton fabrics. Furthermore, FT‐IR and SEM were used to characterize the chemical structure on the treated fabrics as well as the surface morphology of char areas of treated and untreated fabrics. Published 2012. This article is a US Government work and is in the public domain in the USA.     

Growth and fire resistance of colloidal silica-polyelectrolyte thin film assemblies

Thin films of colloidal silica were deposited on cotton fibers via layer-by-layer (LbL) assembly in an effort to reduce the flammability of cotton fabric. Negatively charged silica nanoparticles of two different sizes (8 and 27 nm) were paired with either positively charged silica (12 nm) or cationic polyethylenimine (PEI). PEI/silica films were thicker due to better (more uniform) deposition of silica particles that contributed to more than 90% of the film weight. Each coating was evaluated at 10 and 20 bilayers (BL). All coated fabrics retained their weave structure after being exposed to a vertical flame test, while uncoated cotton was completely destroyed. Micro combustion calorimetry confirmed that coated fabrics exhibited a reduced peak heat release rate, by as much as 20% relative to the uncoated control. The 10 BL PEI-8 nm silica recipe was the most effective because the coating is relatively thick and uniform relative to the other systems. Soaking cotton in basic water (pH 10) prior to deposition resulted in better assembly adhesion and flame-retardant behavior. These results demonstrate that LbL assembly is a useful technique for imparting flame retardant properties through conformal coating of complex substrates like cotton fabric.     

Flame‐retardancy of a Cellulosic Fabric by the Application of Synergistic Effect between Ammonium Bromide and Antimony(III) Oxide

The synergistic effect between ammonium bromide and antimony(III) oxide as a nondurable finish on the flammability of 100% woven plain cotton fabric (with a density of 144 g/m2, the number of yarns 21 per 10 mm), has been investigated in this study. The laundered totally-dried, weighed specimens were impregnated with suitable concentration individual aqueous ammonium bromide and/or antimony(III) oxide suspension solutions and some sets were impregnated with appropriate admixed solutions of the both chemicals. A vertical flame spread test was then carried-out to characterize the flammability of the samples. An acceptable synergistic effect was then experienced by using an admixed bath containing 0.1 molar ammonium bromide and 0.05 unit formal antimony trioxide solutions for impartation of flame-retardancy to a cotton fabric. The optimum mass of the mixture required to impart flame-retardancy was about 3.64 g of anhydrous additives per 100 g of fabric. The results obtained are in favor of Wall Effect Theory. Moreover synergistic effect indicating dehydration of the treated substrate by using this combination via thermogravimetry could be deduced.     

Pyrolysis products and thermal degradation mechanism of intrinsically flame-retardant calcium alginate fibre

Intrinsically flame-retardant calcium alginate fibre was prepared by wet spinning and its pyrolysis products and thermal degradation mechanism studied. Combustion behaviour and flammability were assessed using the limiting oxygen index (LOI) and cone calorimetry. LOI results showed that calcium alginate fibre was intrinsically flame retardant with LOI value of 48.0, as compared to about 20.0 for viscose fibre. Cone calorimetry indicated that heat release rate and total heat release values of intrinsically flame-retardant fibre were significantly less than those of viscose fibre. It also shown that intrinsically flame-retardant fibre combustion produced greater quantities of residues than did viscose fibre combustion. Combustion residues were examined using scanning electron microscopy, indicating that calcium alginate fibre produced consistent, thick residue crusts. Pyrolysis was investigated using pyrolysis-gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (Py-GC-MS) which showed that cracking products produced from calcium alginate fibres combustion were less than those in viscose fibre combustion, and pyrolysis of the intrinsically flame-retardant fibre was incomplete. Thermogravimetric analysis (TG) indicated that calcium alginate fibre generated more residues containing carbonaceous char and calcium carbonate, as compared with viscose fibre. We propose a condensed phase mechanism for the calcium alginate fibre flame-retardancy effect.     

The potential of ferric pyrophosphate for influencing the thermal degradation of cotton fabrics

Ferric pyrophosphate (FePP) was used as additive to study its synergistic effect of thermal degradation on cotton fabrics. The microscale combustion calorimetry (MCC), thermogravimetric analysis (TG), Raman spectroscopy and Real Time Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (RT-FTIR) were utilized to evaluate the synergistic effects of FePP on cotton/DIA. The MCC results revealed that cotton/DIA/FePP generated less combustion heat during heating than that of cotton/DIA. TG results showed that presence of FePP improved the thermal stability of materials. The Raman spectroscopy test showed that FePP can ameliorate the structural organization level of the carbon and the graphitization degree of the char. RT-FTIR data revealed the mechanism of the influence of FePP, which can catalyze the break of the flame retardant as well as promote the char forming.