High-performance chromatofocusing using linear and concave pH gradients formed with simple buffer mixtures. II. Separation of proteins

The separation of proteins using high-performance chromatofocusing with linear or concave pH gradients formed using simple mixtures of buffering species in the elution buffer is investigated experimentally. The separation achieved is comparable to that using polyampholyte elution buffers with these types of systems. More specifically, protein band widths at one half of the band height in the range between 0.1 and 0.025 pH units were observed, and good resolution was achieved of protein variants differing by a single amino acid residue in separation times of 30 min or less. An especially useful elution buffer is investigated that contains only four buffering species and that produces a linear pH gradient in the range between pH 9.5 and 6.0 when used together with a particular high-performance column packing made specifically for chromatofocusing. This elution buffer and column packing combination is evaluated by using it for the chromatofocusing of equine myoglobin and human hemoglobin variants. Additional applications are described in which a polyethyleneimine derivatized silica column packing and a pH gradient that is concave in shape are used for the separation of proteins in an E. coli cell lysate.     

Characterization of unstable ion-exchange chromatographic separation of proteins.

Very fine separation of proteins by stepwise elution ion-exchange chromatography is very often a unstable process. To characterize the unstability of such processes the elution volume variations were examined by the model equation which contained the ion-exchange capacity and the number of adsorption sites. The data needed for the model calculation were obtained from gradient elution experiments. As a model separation system stepwise elution of a model protein (beta-lactoglobulin) near the isoelectric point on a weak cation-exchange chromatography column was chosen. The elution volume varied significantly with a small change in the ion-exchange capacity. It was found that the ionic strength of the elution buffer must be adjusted in order to compensate a change in the elution volume due to the ion-exchange capacity variations. The ionic strength and the pH of the elution buffer were also found to be important variables affecting the elution volume. In this model separation system, it was indicated that the pH should be within +/-0.1 unit and the ionic strength within +/-0.002 mol/l in order to meet the criteria (+/-5% elution volume variation). It is recommended that gradient elution data be obtained for predicting elution volume variations in stepwise elution. By using the gradient elution data the process diagnosis can be performed, and the important information on the process stability can be obtained.     

High-performance cation-exchange chromatofocusing of proteins

Chromatofocusing using high-performance cation-exchange column packings, as opposed to the more commonly used anion-exchange column packings, is investigated with regard to the performance achieved and the range of applications possible. Linear or convex gradients in the range from pH 2.6 to 9 were formed using a variety of commercially available column packings that provide a buffering capacity in different pH ranges, and either polyampholytes or simple mixtures having a small number (three or fewer) of buffering species as the elution buffer. The resolutions achieved using cation-exchange or anion-exchange chromatofocusing were in general comparable, although for certain pairs of proteins better resolution could be achieved using one type of packing as compared to the other, evidently due to the way electrostatic charges are distributed on the protein surface. Several chromatofocusing methods were investigated that take advantage of the acid-base properties of commercially available cation-exchange column packings. These include the use of gradients with a composite shape, the use of very low pH ranges, and the use of elution buffers containing a single buffering species. The advantages of chromatofocusing over ion-exchange chromatography using a salt gradient at constant pH were illustrated by employing the former method and a cation-exchange column packing to separate beta-lactoglobulins A and B, which is a separation reported to be impossible using the latter method and a cation-exchange column packing. Trends in the apparent isoelectric points determined using cation- and anion-exchange chromatofocusing were interpreted using applicable theories. Results of this study indicate that cation-exchange chromatofocusing is a useful technique which is complementary to anion-exchange chromatofocusing and isoelectric focusing for separating proteins at both the analytical and preparative scales.     

Gradient chromatofocusing-mass spectrometry: A new technique in protein analysis

A new analytical technique, gradient chromatofocusing-mass spectrometry (gCF-MS), was developed employing ion-exchange high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) interfaced to an electrospray-quadrupole mass spectrometer in the determination of proteins. There have been few reports, if any, of a HPLC-MS technique for proteins in which the ion-exchange column is directly interfaced to the mass spectrometer. The employment of a linear pH gradient elution scheme directly interfaced to mass spectrometry is also unique in the present work. The technique was demonstrated by the separation of six proteins (carbonic anhydrase II, enolase, beta-lactoglobulin A, lactoglobulin B, soybean trypsin inhibitor, and amyloglucosidase) employing a descending linear pH gradient from pH 9 to 2.6 on a 50 mm x 2.1 mm DEAE HPLC column using volatile buffer components. A signal enhancement solution consisting of 8% formic acid in acetonitrile was pumped post-column and was mixed 1:1 with column effluent and then directed on-line into the mass spectrometer. Molecular masses of the proteins were determined within +/-0.010% to 0.033% (+/-100 to 330 ppm) with peak height total ion current detection limits of 4 to 78 pmol of injected amounts (S/N = 3). This technique is applicable to the analysis of proteins and other charged molecules.     

Purification of the glycoprotein glucose oxidase from Penicillium amagasakiense by high-performance liquid chromatography

Fast protein liquid chromatography (FPLC) in combination with ion-exchange chromatography on a Mono Q column was used to purify glucose oxidase from Penicillium amagasakiense to homogeneity. Purification was performed with a mixed pH and salt gradient, with 20 mM phosphate buffer (pH 8.5) as starting buffer (A) and 50 mM acetate buffer (pH 3.6) with 0.1 M NaCl as elution buffer (B). Elution conditions were optimized to permit the simultaneous purification and separation of the glucose oxidase isoforms. Three peaks, each consisting of 1-2 isoforms and exhibiting a homogeneous titration curve profile, were resolved with a very flat linear gradient of 5.0-5.1% B in 40 ml. Three more peaks, each consisting of several isoforms, were eluted at 10%, 30% and 100% B. Optimization of the elution conditions and separation of the glucose oxidase isoforms was only possible because of the rapidity of each purification step and the high resolution provided by FPLC and Mono Q.     

Separation of proteins by hydrophobic interaction chromatography at low salt concentration

We investigated protein separation by hydrophobic interaction chromatography (HIC) at low salt concentration on the supports of various hydrophobicities. Hydrophobic proteins could be successfully separated with more than 90% recovery by gradient elution of ammonium sulfate from 0.3-0.5 M to 0 in 50 mM phosphate buffer (pH 6.8) by using supports whose hydrophobicities were properly adjusted individually for each protein. Satisfactory results were also obtained by isocratic elution without ammonium sulfate and gradient elution of ethanol from 0 to 10%. HIC at low salt concentration was compatible with other modes of liquid chromatography like ion-exchange chromatography. On the other hand, it was not successful to separate hydrophilic proteins at low salt concentration. Recoveries of hydrophilic proteins decreased before they were retained enough as support hydrophobicity increased. Therefore, it is inevitable to use a higher concentration of salt, e.g., 1-2 M ammonium sulfate, on hydrophilic or moderately hydrophobic support in order to retain hydrophilic proteins without decrease in recovery.     

Band broadening arising from stepwise alterations in mobile phase composition in micellar electrokinetic chromatography

Summary Gradient elution in micellar electrokinetic chromatography has been proposed as a technique for extending the elution range and adjusting retention factors for optimum values. It is shown that this approach in practice has not only to be evaluated for adjustment of retention factors but also for the reduced efficiency of the chromatographic system arising from alterations in the separation buffer during the run. Stepwise gradient elution, feasible with commercial instrumentation, results in marked peak broadening attributable to effects of the border zone passing the solute zone.     

Theoretical background of short chromatographic layers. Optimization of gradient elution in short columns

Although linear salt gradient elution ion-exchange chromatography (IEC) of proteins is commonly carried out with relatively short columns, it is still not clear how the column length affects the separation performance and the economics of the process. The separation performance can be adjusted by changing a combination of the column length, the gradient slope and the flow velocity. The same resolution can be obtained with a given column length with different combinations of the gradient slope and the flow velocity. This results in different separation time and elution volume at the same resolution. Based on our previous model, a method for determining the separation time and the elution volume relationship for the same resolution (iso-resolution curve) was developed. The effect of the column length and the mass transfer rate on the iso-resolution curve was examined. A long column and/or high mass transfer rate results in lesser elution volume. The resolution data with porous bead packed columns and monolithic columns were in good agreement with the calculated iso-resolution curves. Although the elution volume can be reduced with increasing column length, the pressure drop limits govern the optimum conditions.     

Application of a chromatography model with linear gradient elution experimental data to the rapid scale-up in ion-exchange process chromatography of proteins

We applied the model described in our previous paper to the rapid scale-up in the ion exchange chromatography of proteins, in which linear flow velocity, column length and gradient slope were changed. We carried out linear gradient elution experiments, and obtained data for the peak salt concentration and peak width. From these data, the plate height (HETP) was calculated as a function of the mobile phase velocity and iso-resolution curve (the separation time and elution volume relationship for the same resolution) was calculated. The scale-up chromatography conditions were determined by the iso-resolution curve. The scale-up of the linear gradient elution from 5 to 100mL and 2.5L column sizes was performed both by the separation of beta-lactoglobulin A and beta-lactoglobulin B with anion-exchange chromatography and by the purification of a recombinant protein with cation-exchange chromatography. Resolution, recovery and purity were examined in order to verify the proposed method.     

Ion-exchange separation of nucleic acid constituents by high-performance liquid chromatography

The high-performance liquid chromatographic separation of a large variety of nucleic acid constituents on a silica-based, weak-anion exchange column was accomplished. Using this technique it was possible to achieve some relatively difficult separations, such as the separation of 2'-, 3'-, and 5'-AMP, and the separation of a mixture of ribo- and deoxyribo-nucleosides and -nucleotides. A number of other separations are demonstrated by isocratic or gradient elution. These include the separation of a mixture of nucleoside monophosphates, the separation of a mixture of nucleoside mono-, di-, and triphosphates, the separation of a mixture of nucleosides and bases, and the separation of a mixture of nucleotide oligomers. These chromatographic separations were accomplished using relatively simple experimental procedures at ambient temperatures and involved relatively short analysis times. Excellent separations were obtained, in most cases, by adjustment of buffer concentration and pH, or by addition of an organic modifier. In some cases, it was necessary to use gradient elution to achieve optimum resolution.     

Quasi-linear gradients for capillary liquid chromatography with mass and tandem mass spectrometry

Gradient elution, capillary liquid chromatography mass spectrometry was performed with linear, static gradients constructed by laminar flowing ten, 1.5 microL volume steps of decreasing organic concentration into tubing of small internal diameter. Sample loading, gradient formation, and sample elution were accomplished entirely by means of a commercially available micro-autosampler and single-syringe drive pump. The procedure was simple, fast, stable, and reproducible. Essentially linear gradients were produced without the use of additional valves, mixers, pumps or software. It took less than 10 minutes to form a gradient and less than 30 minutes to construct the set of individual buffer vials. The gradients were shown to be stable to storage. One hour after forming, peak retention times were reproduced to +/-0.5%. Long-term retention time reproducibility was found to vary by +/-2%. Chromatographic resolution was comparable or superior to that obtained by gradient elution with conventional dynamic mixing and split flow. The procedure was adapted with a 'peak parking' method which extended the time for generating peptide fragmentation data up to 10 minutes per peptide with the triple quadruple mass spectrometer. Using this technique, collision data were collected at the 25 femtomole level on nine of ten tryptic peptides in a single run.     

Optimization of monoclonal antibody purification by ion-exchange chromatography. Application of simple methods with linear gradient elution experimental data

Simple methods for the optimization of ion-exchange chromatography of proteins in our previous papers were applied to cation-exchange chromatography purification of monoclonal antibodies (Mab). We carried out linear gradient elution experiments, and obtained the data for the peak salt concentration and the peak width. From these data, the distribution coefficient as a function of salt concentration, and the height equivalent to a theoretical plate (HETP) as a function of mobile phase velocity were calculated. The optimized linear gradient elution conditions were determined based on the relationship between buffer consumption and separation time. The optimal stepwise elution conditions were determined based on the relationship between the distribution coefficient and the salt concentration.     

Fractionation and separation of human salivary proteins by pH-gradient ion exchange and reversed phase chromatography coupled to mass spectrometry

In the present work, a 2-D capillary liquid chromatography method for fractionation and separation of human salivary proteins is demonstrated. Fractionation of proteins according to their pI values was performed in the 1-D employing a strong anion exchange (SAX) column subjected to a wide-range descending pH gradient. Polystyrene-divinylbenzene (PS-DVB) RP columns were used for focusing and subsequent separation of the proteins in the 2-D. The SAX column was presaturated with a high pH buffer (A) consisting of 10 mM amine buffering species, pH 9.0, and elution was performed with a low pH elution buffer (B) having the same buffer composition and concentration as buffer A, but pH 3.5. Isoelectric point fractions eluting from the 1-D column were trapped on PS-DVB trap columns prior to back-flushed elution onto the PS-DVB analytical column for separation of the proteins. The 1-D fraction eluting at pH 9.0-8.7 was chosen for further analysis. After separation on the RP analytical column, nine RP protein fractions were collected and tryptic digested for subsequent analyses by MALDI TOF MS and column switching capillary LC coupled to ESI TOF MS and ESI QTOF MS. Eight proteins and two peptides were identified in the pH 9.0-8.7 fraction using peptide mass fingerprinting and uninterpreted MS/MS data.     

Modeling of salt and pH gradient elution in ion‐exchange chromatography

The separation of proteins by internally and externally generated pH gradients in chromatofocusing on ion‐exchange columns is a well‐established analytical method with a large number of applications. In this work, a stoichiometric displacement model was used to describe the retention behavior of lysozyme on SP Sepharose FF and a monoclonal antibody on Fractogel SO₃ (S) in linear salt and pH gradient elution. The pH dependence of the binding charge B in the linear gradient elution model is introduced using a protein net charge model, while the pH dependence of the equilibrium constant is based on a thermodynamic approach. The model parameter and pH dependences are calculated from linear salt gradient elutions at different pH values as well as from linear pH gradient elutions at different fixed salt concentrations. The application of the model for the well‐characterized protein lysozyme resulted in almost identical model parameters based on either linear salt or pH gradient elution data. For the antibody, only the approach based on linear pH gradients is feasible because of the limited pH range useful for salt gradient elution. The application of the model for the separation of an acid variant of the antibody from the major monomeric form is discussed.     

HPLC of nucleotides. II. General methods and their development for analysis and preparative separation. An approach to selectivity control

In order to develop efficient separation methods for nucleotides according to their size and heterocyclic composition, the application of ion-exchange, reverse-phase, and normal-phase adsorption HPLC has been studied. The comparative investigation of retention power and selectivity of various packings (non-polar bonded-phase and amino silicas) in relation to nucleotide length and composition yields data which enable suitable packings to be selected and a method of preparing the new packing for a particular separation problem to be formulated. Thus a new anion exchanger with high selectivity and dynamic mass transfer has been prepared for fractionation of large oligonucleotides. The effect of the eluent pH and composition (organic modifier, salt) on retention, selectivity, and resolution in ion-exchange and reverse-phase HPLC has been studied. The optimum separation conditions comprise elution with oppositely directed gradients of the salt and the modifier, use of a precolumn packing that provides the best protection for the main column without loss of its efficiency, and the optimum gradient program for the desired retention of the component of interest. The relation between loading and sample concentration has been studied and the system for gradient elution improved. Our work shows that two-dimensional separation is the most reliable and informative method for preparation of homogeneous oligonucleotides. The hydrophobic-pair ion-exchange mechanism is proposed for ion-pair chromatography. Protected and partially deblocked oligonucleotides, chemically synthesized for genetic engineering studies, have been separated with high selectivity by adsorption (normal-phase) HPLC which is efficient for gradient elution with isohydric eluents. The analysis of a monomeric composition of nano-(pico-) molar amounts of oligonucleotides has been developed; the procedure involves microcolumn digestion of the oligonucleotides with immobilized enzymes followed by microcolumn separation of the nucleoside-mononucleotide mixture. Also, a new slurry method for packing stable HPLC columns with a tightly consolidated, nonshrinkable bed of particles has been developed.     

A microfluidic chip with a staircase pH gradient generator,a packed column and a fraction collector for chromatofocusing of proteins

A microfluidic device for pH gradient chromatofocusing is presented, which performs creation of a micro‐column, pH gradient generation, and fraction collection in a single device. Using a sieve micro‐valve, anion exchange particles were packed into a microchannel in order to realize a solid‐phase absorption column. To fractionate proteins according to their isoelectric points, elution buffer solutions with a stepwise pH gradient were prepared in 16 parallel mixing reactors and flowed through the micro‐column, wherein a protein mixture was previously loaded. The volume of the column is only 20 nL, hence it allows extremely low sample consumption and fast analysis compared with a conventional system. We demonstrated separation of two proteins, albumin–fluorescein isothiocyanate conjugate (FITC‐BSA) and R‐Phycoerythrin (R‐PE), by using a microcolumn of commercial charged polymeric particles (Source 15Q). The microfluidic device can be used as a rapid diagnostic tool to analyse crude mixtures of proteins or nucleic acids and determine adsorption/desorption characteristics of various biochemical products, which can be helpful for scientific fundamental understanding as well as instrumental in various industrial applications, especially in early stage screening and process development.     

High-performance liquid chromatography of membrane proteins

Various modes of high-performance liquid chromatography, gel filtration, ion-exchange chromatography, hydrophobic interaction chromatography, reversed-phase chromatography and metal chelate affinity chromatography, were investigated for the separation of membrane proteins. All were found applicable to membrane proteins, although the usefulness of each mode differed. For satisfactory results it was important to select appropriate elution conditions. The type and concentration of detergent was of special importance. The effects of other conditions, flow-rate, gradient steepness, type of buffer and salt, eluent pH, etc., were similar to those observed for soluble proteins.     

A gradient anion exchange chromatographic method for the speciation of arsenic in lobster tissue extracts

A gradient anion exchange chromatographic technique was developed for the separation of arsenobetaine (AsB), arsenocholine (AsC), arsenite (As(III)), arsenate (As(V)), monomethylarsonic acid (MMAA) and dimethylarsinic acid (DMAA) in one chromatographic run. This technique used low residue ammonium carbonate buffer and the inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) chromatograms showed little baseline drift. Gradient elution improved peak shape and peak separation. The separation was completed in approximately 27 min with low detection limits (0.017-0.029 mug As kg(-1)). Baseline resolution of all the arsenic species evaluated was achieved when the concentration of AsC was less than approximately 12.5 mug As kg(-1). This technique was successfully applied to different extracts of a standard reference material, TORT-2, and lobster tissue. AsB was found to be the major arsenic species present. AsC, DMAA, MMAA and As(V) were also found, although MMAA was not detected in all of the TORT-2 extracts. Two unknown peaks found may be due to the presence of arsenosugars or other arsenic species. Discrepancy between extraction recoveries previously determined using flow injection-ICP-MS and the high-performance liquid chromatography-ICP-MS was observed in some cases. The differences may be due to the extraction technique and/or conditions at which the extractions were performed.     

Guanidine improves DEAE anion exchange-based analytical separation of plasmid DNA

Elution of strong and weak anion exchangers with sodium chloride gradients is commonly employed for analysis of sample mixtures containing different isomers of plasmid DNA. Gradient elution of a weak anion exchanger (diethylaminoethyl) in the presence of guanidine hydrochloride (Gdn) roughly doubles resolution between open-circular (oc) and supercoiled (sc) isomers. It also improves resolution among sc, linear, and multimeric/aggregated forms. Sharper elution peaks with less tailing increase sensitivity about 30%. However, elution with an exclusively Gdn gradient to 900 mM causes more than 10% loss of plasmid. Elution with a sodium chloride gradient while maintaining Gdn at a level concentration of 300 mM achieves close to 100% recovery of sc plasmid while maintaining the separation improvements achieved by exclusively Gdn elution. Corresponding improvements in separation performance are not observed on a strong (quaternary amine) anion exchanger. Other chaotropic salts do not produce a favorable result on either exchanger, nor does the inclusion of surfactants or EDTA. Selectivity of the diethylaminoethyl-Gdn method is orthogonal to electrophoresis, but with better quantification than agarose electrophoresis, better quantitative accuracy than CE, and resolution approaching CE.     

Development of a perfusion ion-exchange chromatography method for the separation of soybean proteins and its application to cultivar characterization

A perfusion ion-exchange chromatography method has been designed, for the first time, for the separation of soybean proteins and its application to the characterization of soybean cultivars. For that purpose, the gradient, the mobile phase composition (buffer concentration, buffer pH, and elution salt), and the temperature were optimized. The method consisted of a two-step gradient (0% B for 2 min and from 0 to 50% B in 10 min) being mobile phase A a 2 0mM borate buffer (pH 9) and mobile phase B a 20 mM borate buffer (pH 9) containing 1M sodium chloride. The procedure used for the preparation of sample solutions was significantly simpler than that proposed by other authors and basically consisted of dissolving in water. This method enabled the separation of soybean proteins from a soybean protein isolate in 11 peaks in about 9 min. The method was used to separate soybean proteins in different commercial soybeans. In general, the 11 peaks yielded by the soybean protein isolate were also observed in the chromatograms of all soybeans. However, the area percentages of every peak in every soybean enabled the differentiation between soybeans. Moreover, the method was also used to separate soybean proteins in the proteic fractions obtained from every soybean. Multivariate methods were used for patterns recognition and the classification of samples.