Planar mesh refinement cannot be both local and regular

We show that two desirable properties for planar mesh refinement techniques are incompatible. Mesh refinement is a common technique for adaptive error control in generating unstructured planar triangular meshes for piecewise polynomial representations of data. Local refinements are modifications of the mesh that involve a fixed maximum amount of computation, independent of the number of triangles in the mesh. Regular meshes are meshes for which every interior vertex has degree 6. At least for some simple model meshing problems, optimal meshes are known to be regular, hence it would be desirable to have a refinement technique that, if applied to a regular mesh, produced a larger regular mesh. We call such a technique a regular refinement. In this paper, we prove that no refinement technique can be both local and regular. Our results also have implications for non-local refinement techniques such as Delaunay insertion or Rivara's refinement. Received August 1, 1996 / Revised version received February 28, 1997