Reactivities of carbocations and monomers in carbocationic polymerization and copolymerization

In carbocationic polymerization and copolymerization, a recent publication concluded that the substituent effect on carbocation reactivity is much larger than its effect on monomer reactivity, and this by a factor 10⁶ in the case of the rate constant k_12capp for p‐methylstyrene addition (monomer M₂) on, respectively, poly(p‐methoxystyrene)^± or poly(p‐methylstyrene)^± (M). This conclusion is disputed, as well as the assumption that the rate constants of capping (k_12capp) obtained in deactivation reactions of poly(p‐methoxystyrene)^± are identical with cross propagation rate constants in copolymerization (k_12copol). It is shown that the large calculated k_12capp are based on propagation constant values for p‐methylstyrene (k ≈ 10⁹) obtained by the diffusion‐clock method. They are 10⁴ times smaller as found for all styrenes, that is, between 10⁴ and 10⁵ when they are based on the ionic species concentrations. In such a case, the available data are still in agreement with an approximate compensation between the reactivities of a monomer and of the corresponding carbocation. It is also shown that copolymerization data for styrenes are not compatible with k values near to diffusion control, and that variations of log k_12capp and log k_12copol with the nucleophilicity parameter N of the monomers indicate a much lower selectivity of the monomers in the case of copolymerization. © 2010 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem 48: 2666–2680, 2010