Mass spectrometry of pyridine compounds–IV: The formation and decomposition of the [M – methyl]+ ion [C8H10N]+ from 4-t-butylpyridine in comparison with that of the [M – methyl]+ ion [C9H11]+ from t-butylbenzene,as studied by D- and 13C-labelling

A strong secondary isotope effect is observed in the preferred loss of methyl vs. trideutero-methyl from the molecular ions of appropriately labelled 4-t-butylpyridine and t-butylbenzene decomposing in the first and second field free regions of a double focusing mass spectrometer. This has been rationalised by invoking the theory of radiationless transitions², which can account for the higher population of activated states responsible for loss of methyl vs. that for trideuteromethyl. ¹³C-Labelling at the central carbon atom of the t-butyl group indicates that the [M – methyl]⁺ ions, decomposing further by elimination of ethylene, cannot be represented exclusively by a pyridylated (or phenylated) cyclopropane ion if present at all. It is concluded that ions with structures generated by 1,2-hydrogen-, 1,2-pyridyl- (or 1,2-phenyl-) and 1,2-methyl shifts must also play a role. D-labelling further shows an extensive randomisation of side-chain hydrogen atoms in the [M-methyl]⁺ ions of 4-t-butylbenzene; in this case, however, the expelled ethylene also contains ring hydrogen atoms (≤2). Presumably this is caused by exchange between the side-chain and ortho-hydrogen atoms in the initially generated phenyldimethylcarbinyl carbenium ion.