Observation of opposite 4f-surface core level binding energy shifts for W(111) and Ta(111)

Surface 4f core level binding energy shifts have been measured in photoemission from W(111) and Ta(111). The surface shift was found to change sign across the row of 5d-metals: for the topmost layer of Ta(111) a +0.40 eV shift toward higher binding energy is found, whereas for W(111) the shift is -0.43 eV toward lower binding energy. The shifts are shown to be dependent on surface crystallography. Chemical shifts are determined for saturation coverage of hydrogen.