"三书说"比较说略

唐兰、陈梦家、刘又辛、裘锡圭分别提出“三书说”理论。诸“三书说”的基本观点、形成原因、内涵价值等方面有一定的相似性，但其差异也是明显的，尤其是他们给汉字分类的标准不尽相同。“三书说”对传统“六书”有所突破，但由此又产生新的矛盾，其局限性依然存在。

Comparison and Remark of the Views on SANSHU

The views on the SANSHU have been put forward respectively by Tang Lan, Chen Mengjia, Liu Youxin and Qiu Xigui. There are some similarities among their views or values and among the causes arising the SANSHU, but there too are differences among theirs, especially their standards of dividing the Chinese character into different classification are of big difference. These scholars making the SANSHU all try to break through the traditional LIUSHU, but new contradictions have been arisen by them, and the limitations of the SANSHU are still obvious.