Influence of the precision of spectral backscatter measurements on the estimation of scatterers size in cancellous bone

The goal of this study is to propose a model for the ultrasonic frequency-dependent backscatter coefficient in femoral cancellous bone. This model has been developed with success to predict backscatter in human calcaneal bone Jenson, Ultr. Med. Biol. 2003]. A weak scattering model is used and the backscatter coefficient is expressed in terms of a Gaussian autocorrelation function of the medium. The backscatter coefficient is computed and comparison is made with experimental data for 37 specimens and for frequency ranging from 0.4 to 1.2 MHz. An excellent agreement between experimental data and predictions is found for both the magnitude and the frequency-dependence of the backscatter coefficient. Then, a nonlinear regression is performed for each specimen, and the mean trabecular thickness is estimated. Experimental data and theoretical predictions are averaged over the 37 specimens. We also find a close agreement between theoretical predictions obtained using the Gaussian autocorrelation function (scatterer size=134+/-15 microm) and the mean trabecular thickness (Tb.Th=132+/-12 microm) derived from the analysis of bone 3-D micro-architecture using high-resolution micro-tomography. However, the correlation between individual experimental and estimated Tb.Th values is moderate (R(2)=0.44). The performance of the estimator are limited mainly by two factors: interference noise due to random positioning of the scatterers and attenuation. We show that the fundamental limitation of our estimator due to the speckle noise is around 5 microm for trabecular thickness estimation. This limitation is lower than the observed biological variability which is around 30 microm and should not be a limiting factor for individual prediction. A second limitation is the tremendous attenuation encountered in highly scattering media such as cancellous bone, which results in highly damped backscatter signals. The compensation for attenuation is difficult to perform, and it may be a critical point that limits the precision of the estimator.