Comparison of extraction methods to monitor pesticide residues in surface water

A regular monitoring program to study the pesticide concentration in surface waters has been carried out since 1976 in Hungary by the National Plant Protection Organization of the Ministry of Agriculture and Regional Development jointly with the Regional Water Authorities. At the beginning of this program a liquid-liquid partition method is used to extract the pesticides from water samples. After checking the pH value, one sample aliquot is extracted to analyze the basic and neutral compounds. Another aliquot is acidified to pH 2 and extracted to analyze acidic compounds. Disadvantages of this method are high solvent consumption and the need to apply solvents (methylene chloride and diethyl ether) that are harmful to human health. Therefore, the solid-phase extraction method has been introduced. This method has another advantage in that by using the vacuum manifold a number of samples can be extracted simultaneously depending on the capacity (number of ports) of the manifold. Three types of cartridges (LiChrolut EN, ISOLUTE ENV+, and Carbograph) are tested. The suitability and reproducibility of the extraction on various cartridges is studied and compared through recovery experiments. Recoveries are done for 22 active ingredients at spiking levels of 1-5 times the limit of determination (in the range of 0.05-2.5 microg/L) with each extraction method. Individual recovery values as well as average recoveries for all methods are between 70% and 100%, with the relative standard deviation generally below 20%. Carbograph is the only cartridge among those studied that can be used to extract both neutral and acidic compounds in one sample loading step using two different consecutive elution steps.