Cobalt-centered ten-vertex germanium clusters: the pentagonal prism as an alternative to polyhedra predicted by the Wade-Mingos rules

One of the most exciting recent (2009) discoveries in metal cluster chemistry is the pentagonal prismatic Co@Ge(10)(3-) ion, found in K(2,2,2-crypt)](4)Co@Ge(10)]Co(1,5-C(8)H(12))(2)]·toluene and characterized structurally by X-ray diffraction. The complete absence of triangular faces in the pentagonal prismatic structure of Co@Ge(10)(3-) contradicts expectations from the well-established Wade-Mingos rules, which predict polyhedral structures having mainly or entirely triangular faces. A theoretical study on Co@Ge(10)(z) systems (z = -5 to +1) predicts a singlet D(5h) pentagonal prismatic global minimum for the trianion Co@Ge(10)(3-) in accord with this experimental result. Redox reactions on this pentagonal prismatic Co@Ge(10)(3-) trianion generate low-energy pentagonal prismatic structures for Co@Ge(10)(z) where z = 0, -1, -2, -4, and -5 having quartet, triplet, doublet, doublet, and triplet spin states, respectively. Similar theoretical methods predict a singlet C(3v) polyhedral structure for the monoanion Co@Ge(10)(-), similar to previous theoretical predictions on the isoelectronic neutral Ni@Ge(10) and the structure realized experimentally in the isoelectronic Ni@In(10)(10-) found in the K(10)In(10)Ni intermetallic. Redox reactions on this C(3v) polyhedral Co@Ge(10)(-) monoanion generate low energy C(3v) polyhedral structures for Co@Ge(10)(z) where z = 0, -2, -3, and -4 having doublet, doublet, triplet, and quartet spin states, respectively.