Latin Squares without Orthogonal Mates

In 1779 Euler proved that for every even n there exists a latin square of order n that has no orthogonal mate, and in 1944 Mann proved that for every n of the form 4k + 1, k ≥ 1, there exists a latin square of order n that has no orthogonal mate. Except for the two smallest cases, n = 3 and n = 7, it is not known whether a latin square of order n = 4k + 3 with no orthogonal mate exists or not. We complete the determination of all n for which there exists a mate-less latin square of order n by proving that, with the exception of n = 3, for all n = 4k + 3 there exists a latin square of order n with no orthogonal mate. We will also show how the methods used in this paper can be applied more generally by deriving several earlier non-orthogonality results.