Coordinative saturation of cationic niobium– and rhodium–argon complexes

Mass spectra of Nb⁺ and Rh⁺ complexes with argon ligands exhibit `magic' peaks Nb⁺Ar₄ and Rh⁺Ar₆, similar to observations for V⁺Ar₄ and Co⁺Ar₆, indicating coordinative saturation. A consistent explanation is obtained by assuming that the rare gas ligands seek out electron density minima in the valence shell of the ion, which permit a closer approach to the metal core and a stronger charge-induced dipole bond. Ab initio density functional calculations, which predict stable square planar complexes for the d⁴ ions and octahedral for the d⁸ species, support this interpretation and show that rare gas complexes of d⁴ metal ions fit perfectly well into the coordination chemical framework based on the Jahn–Teller effect.