Macrocellular silicone polymers are obtained after solidification of the continuous phase of a poly(dimethylsiloxane) emulsion, which contains poly(ethylene glycol) drops of sub‐millimetric dimensions. Coalescence of the liquid template emulsion is prohibited by a reactive blending approach. The relationship is investigated in detail between the interfacial properties and the emulsion stability, and micro‐ and millifluidic techniques are used to generate macrocellular polymers with controlled structural properties over a wider range of cell sizes (0.2–2 mm) and volume fractions of the continuous phase (0.1%–40%). This approach could easily be transferred to a wide range of polymeric systems.