Quantum mechanical study of stereoselectivity in the oxazaborolidine-catalyzed reduction of acetophenone

Chiral oxazaborolidines, known as CBS catalysts after the work of Corey, Bakshi and Shibata, are used for the stereoselective reduction of prochiral ketones to secondary chiral alcohols. Due to their relative low cost, ease of use, and high selectivity, their popularity has remarkably grown in the last 15 years. Oxazaborolidine-catalyzed reductions have been much studied, both experimentally and computationally, by means of semiempirical methods. Though, a more accurate high level quantum mechanical study on the complete system, capable of elucidating reliably the origins of stereoselectivity, is still lacking. Therefore, the acetophenone (PhMK) reduction with Corey's oxazaborolidine has been modeled for the first time with ab initio and DFT-B3LYP calculations on the complete system as well as with AM1. Calculations on the complexation of BH(3) to CBS, which can occur only in a cis fashion with respect to the hydrogen on the stereogenic C-4 carbon atom, have allowed us to confirm the great rigidity of Corey's catalyst, possibly determining its excellent enantioselectivity. Acetophenone-CBS-BH(3) complexes were characterized at various levels of theory, and it was found that the picture obtained depends heavily on the method adopted. A computational strategy for identifying the hydride transfer transition states of the competing pathways was developed and tested, using a model system for which the transition state geometry was already known. The application of the TS search method to the reduction of acetophenone allowed the characterization of the TS's for the competing pathways in this reaction, making it possible to predict with good quantitative accuracy the stereochemical outcome of the reaction at all the levels of theory adopted. The characterization of the intermediate oxazadiboretane products confirmed that the highly exothermic hydride transfer provides the thermodynamical drive for the reaction.