Energy Minimization and Flux Domain Structure in the Intermediate State of a Type-I Superconductor

The intermediate state of a type-I superconductor involves a fine-scale mixture of normal and superconducting domains. We take the viewpoint, due to Landau, that the realizable domain patterns are (local) minima of a nonconvex variational problem. We examine the scaling law of the minimum energy and the qualitative properties of domain patterns achieving that law. Our analysis is restricted to the simplest possible case: a superconducting plate in a transverse magnetic field. Our methods include explicit geometric constructions leading to upper bounds and ansatz-free inequalities leading to lower bounds. The problem is unexpectedly rich when the applied field is near-zero or near-critical. In these regimes there are two small parameters, and the ground state patterns depend on the relation between them.