The differences between Kurepa trees and Jech-Kunen trees

Summary By an ₁ we mean a tree of power ₁ and height ₁. An ₁-tree is called a Kurepa tree if all its levels are countable and it has more than ₁ branches. An ₁-tree is called a Jech-Kunen tree if it has branches for some strictly between ₁ and . In Sect. 1, we construct a model ofCH plus , in which there exists a Kurepa tree with not Jech-Kunen subtrees and there exists a Jech-Kunen tree with no Kurepa subtrees. This improves two results in Ji1] by not only eliminating the large cardinal assumption for Ji1, Theorem 2] but also handling two consistency proofs of Ji1, Theorem 2 and Theorem 3] simultaneously. In Sect. 2, we first prove a lemma saying that anAxiom A focing of size ₁ over Silver's model will not produce a Kurepa tree in the extension, and then we apply this lemma to prove that, in the model constructed for Theorem 2 in Ji1], there exists a Jech-Kunen tree and there are no Kurepa trees.