Comparison of physicochemical speciation procedures with metal toxicity to chlorella pyrenoidosa

Metal speciation as measured by anodic stripping voltammetry (ASV), adsorption on a resin with adsorbed hydrated aluminium oxide, and dialysis with receiving resins is compared with the toxicity of the metals to the freshwater green alga Chlorella pyrenoidosa Chick. In the presence of natural and synthetic ligands, similar labile fractions of metals were obtained for ASV at three electrodes (hanging mercury drop electrode, mercury film electrode and Nafion-coated mercury film electrode). The toxic fractions determined by ASV and bioassay were in reasonable agreement for zinc, cadmium and copper, and alteration of the analytical conditions provided some measure of agreement for lead. The resin with adsorbed hydrated aluminium oxide correlated well with bioassay for copper, but over-estimated lead toxicity and under-estimated cadmium toxicity. Dialysis with receiving resins under-estimated metal bioaccumulation in the presence of ligands. Metal speciation analysis for water samples gave higher toxic fractions for metals in samples of polluted river water and road runoff samples than those found in pristine river water.