Difference in spin crossover pathways among saddle-shaped six-coordinated iron(III) porphyrin complexes

The electronic states of a series of saddle-shaped porphyrin complexes Fe(OMTPP)L(2)](+) and Fe(TBTXP)L(2)](+) have been examined in solution by (1)H NMR, (13)C NMR, and EPR spectroscopy and by magnetic measurements. While Fe(OMTPP)(DMAP)(2)](+) and Fe(TBTXP)(DMAP)(2)](+) maintain the low-spin (S = (1)/(2)) state, Fe(OMTPP)(THF)(2)](+) and Fe(TBTXP)(THF)(2)](+) exhibit an essentially pure intermediate-spin (S = (3)/(2)) state over a wide range of temperatures. In contrast, the Py and 4-CNPy complexes of OMTPP and TBTXP exhibit a spin transition from S = (3)/(2) to S = (1)/(2) as the temperature was decreased from 300 to 200 K. Thus, the magnetic behavior of these complexes is similar to that of Fe(OETPP)Py(2)](+) reported in our previous paper (Ikeue, T.; Ohgo, Y.; Yamaguchi, T.; Takahashi, M.; Takeda, M.; Nakamura, M. Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. 2001, 40, 2617-2620) in the context that all these complexes exhibit a novel spin crossover phenomenon in solution. Close examination of the NMR and EPR data of Fe(OMTPP)L(2)](+) and Fe(TBTXP)L(2)](+) (L = Py, 4-CNPy) revealed, however, that these complexes adopt the less common (d(xz), d(yz))(4)(d(xy))(1) electron configuration at low temperature in contrast to Fe(OETPP)Py(2)](+) which shows the common (d(xy))(2)(d(xz), d(yz))(3) electron configuration. These observations have been attributed to the flexible nature of the OMTPP and TBTXP cores as compared with that of OETPP; the relatively flexible OMTPP and TBTXP cores can ruffle the porphyrin ring and adopt the (d(xz), d(yz))(4)(d(xy))(1) electron configuration at low temperature. Therefore, this study reveals that the rigidity of porphyrin cores is an important factor in determining the spin crossover pathways.