Biradical and zwitterionic cyclizations of oxy-substituted enyne-allenes

see reaction]. Oxyanion substitution of enyne-allenes causes both Myers-Saito and Schmittel cyclizations to switch their product formation preferences from diradicals to polar, closed-shell singlets. The oxyanion stabilization is larger for the Schmittel products than the Myers-Saito products because the latter must sacrifice aromaticity to maximize interaction. The changing character of the different reaction paths is reflected in their activation energies.