The singlet—triplet accidental degeneracy versus two local doublets problem in copper(II) dimers

In a copper(II) dimer, two situations, I and II, may lead to a J = 0 singlet—triplet energy gap. In situation I, the metal ions do not interact and all the contributions to J vanish. In situation II, the metal ions interact, but the positive and negative contributions cancel. The aim of this letter is to specify the differences between these situations, to analyse how they can be distinguished from a physical point of view, particularly from EPR spectroscope, and to propose some typical geometries corresponding to both situations.