Fast development of separation methods for the chiral analysis of amino acid derivatives using capillary electrophoresis and experimental designs

The use of experimental design in method development was studied for the chiral separation of several amino acid derivatives with capillary electrophoresis. The aim of this study was to define rapidly experimental conditions under which the enantiomers can be sufficiently separated for quantification and to derive a methodology for the separation of new compounds. Three modified cyclodextrins (CDs) were used as chiral selectors: hydroxypropyl-beta-cyclodextrin, carboxymethyl-beta-CD and sulfobutylether-beta-CD. The following factors were examined: the type of cyclodextrin, the CD concentration, the pH and the % of organic modifier (methanol) of the electrolyte. Two types of fractional factorial design were used depending on the type of analyte and on the number of factors selected: a 3(4-2) fractional factorial design (4 factors studied at 3 different levels) and a 2(3-1) fractional factorial design (3 factors at 2 different levels). From the 14 compounds investigated, 12 could be separated with one or another CD and not more than 9 experiments were required. No generalisation of the best analysis conditions was possible within this family of compounds. Specific analysis conditions must be defined for each analyte. Experimental designs have shown to be very useful to determine rapidly conditions under which each enantiomer can be separated with an acceptable resolution.