Comparison of constant-current stripping chronopotentiometry and anodic stripping voltammetry in metal speciation studies using mercury drop and film electrodes

Capabilities for heavy metal speciation of anodic stripping voltammetry (ASV) and constant-current stripping chronopotentiometry (SCP) in both mercury drop (HMDE) and mercury film rotating disk (MFE-RDE) electrodes are compared. For this purpose, the Cd(II)–glycine and Cd(II)–polymethacrylate (PMA) systems are used as models of simple labile and macromolecular labile complexes adsorbing onto the electrode, respectively. The results suggest that SCP could be a valuable alternative to the more widespread ASV in this kind of study. Concerning the electrode, the MFE-RDE is less user-friendly than the HMDE, but presents a better definition of both the hydrodynamic conditions during the deposition step and the stripping regime during the oxidation. An important interference in SCP is the dissolved oxygen, which can be minimised by combining relatively large oxidation currents and low stirring rates. Moreover, for Cd–PMA, double peaks have been observed in both ASV and SCP, which seems to be due to the lack of enough ligand excess to complex the metal ions released by the amalgam oxidation. Anyway, this problem can be minimised by optimising the rotation rate of the electrode and ensuring enough ligand excess.