Unraveling the mechanism of epoxide formation from sulfur ylides and aldehydes

Sulfur ylides R(2)S(+)-C(-)HR' react with aldehydes R' '-CHO to form epoxides, predominantly as the trans isomers, in a synthetically useful reaction which is increasingly used in its asymmetric variant with chiral sulfides. The mechanisms of the "model" reaction (R = Me, R' = R' ' = H) and the reaction forming stilbene oxide (R = Me, R' = R' ' = Ph) have been studied in detail using density functional theory, the B3LYP density functional, and flexible basis sets. It has been shown that for this reaction involving highly polar intermediates, continuum solvation models need to be used throughout to obtain reasonable results. For the reaction of benzaldehyde with dimethylsulfonium benzylide, the key steps are shown to be quasi 2 + 2] addition of the ylide to the aldehyde to form a betaine R'-CH(S(+)Me(2))-CH(O(-))-R' ' in which the charged groups are gauche to one another, and torsional rotation around the C-C single bond of the betaine to form its rotamer with the two charged groups anti. The final step, elimination of sulfide from this second rotamer of the betaine, is found to be facile. In the case of the anti pathway, leading to trans-stilbene epoxide, the initial addition is found to be rate-determining, whereas for the diastereomeric syn pathway, leading to the cis-epoxide, it is instead the torsional rotation which is slowest. These results are in excellent agreement with experiment, unlike previous computational work. The unexpected and apparently unprecedented (for C-C bond-forming reactions) importance of the torsional rotation step, especially in the syn case, is due to the fact that all the barriers involved are low-lying. This novel picture of the mechanism provides a sound basis for the future development of chiral sulfides for enantioselective epoxide synthesis.