| Abstract: | Atomic monopoles are routinely determined through a least squares fit to molecular electrostatic potentials. We report studies of the variation in atomic monopoles with variation in conformation for the zwitterionic polar head group of lecithins, a common class of lipid. The monopole of one atom, a relatively buried carbon, varied by 1.3 electron units between different conformers. “Exterior” atoms, as seen previously, showed smaller changes in charge and smaller estimated standard deviations. The total charge of local groups of atoms varied less than the charge of individual atoms, indicating that shifts in charge occurred mostly between neighboring atoms. This effect might be reflected in the high correlations seen between charges of many neighboring atoms. These correlations, while present for many logical groupings of atoms (such as within methylene and methyl groups), are curiously absent between some bonded atoms. Monopoles were fit to multiple conformations simultaneously to provide a charge set that could optimally reproduce the electrostatic potential of all the conformers as a means of generating monopoles for molecular dynamics simulations or other studies where conformation varies. In some cases, the charges on chemically equivalent atoms (e.g., the hydrogen atoms in a methyl group) were different by more than their estimated error of fit. These studies lead to the suggestion that a minimum error in reported charges is on the order of 10%. All conformations show that the positive charge of the trimethylalkyl ammonium group is carried by the methyl hydrogens; the total charge on the nine hydrogens is over 2 electron units, counterbalanced by negative monopoles on the carbons. The presence of this diffuse cloud of substantial charge would appear to be a disindicator of the use of a “united” atoms approach for these methyl groups. The effects of the charge variation on intermolecular interactions is also examined. |
