Studies on Radical Cations,III. The Type C Valence-Isomeric System Quadricyclane Radical Cation/Norbornadiene Radical Cation

The previously discussed principles involved in electrocyclic reactions of openshell ions are exemplified for a type C system, the radical cation couple quadricyclane⁺ ( Q ⁺)/norbornadiene⁺ ( NBD ⁺). Exhaustive calculations (MINDO/3) for the various states of the ions support the general predictions for such types of systems. The barrier of interconversion Q ⁺ → NBD ⁺ is estimated to be significantly lower than that for the corresponding neutrals. Experimental support to this prediction is obtained by γ-irradiation of Q or NBD in an electron scavenging matrix. In both cases only NBD ⁺ is observed, indicating that Q ⁺ is not stable at 77 K. Previous observations and propositions referring to the system Q ⁺/ NBD ⁺ are discussed in view of the present findings.