Ball milling in organic synthesis: solutions and challenges

During the last decade numerous protocols have been published using the method of ball milling for synthesis all over the field of organic chemistry. However, compared to other methods leaving their marks on the road to sustainable synthesis (e.g. microwave, ultrasound, ionic liquids) chemistry in ball mills is rather underrepresented in the knowledge of organic chemists. Especially, in the last three years the interest in this technique raised continuously, culminating in several high-quality synthetic procedures covering the whole range of organic synthesis. Thus, the present tutorial review will be focused on the highlights using this method of energy transfer and energy dissipation. The central aim is to motivate researchers to take notice of ball mills as chemical reactors, implementing this technique in everyday laboratory use and thus, pave the ground for future activities in this interdisciplinary field of research.     

Fast, ligand- and solvent-free copper-catalyzed click reactions in a ball mill

A new, ligand- and solvent-free method for the Huisgen 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition (click reaction) was developed using a planetary ball mill. Besides various alkynes and azides, a propargyl functionalized polymer was converted by mill clicking. Moreover, it was possible to carry out a click polymerization in a ball mill.     

Chiral Fluorinated α‐Sulfonyl Carbanions: Enantioselective Synthesis and Electrophilic Capture,Racemization Dynamics,and Structure

Enantiomerically pure triflones R¹CH(R²)SO₂CF₃ have been synthesized starting from the corresponding chiral alcohols via thiols and trifluoromethylsulfanes. Key steps of the syntheses of the sulfanes are the photochemical trifluoromethylation of the thiols with CF₃Hal (Hal=halide) or substitution of alkoxyphosphinediamines with CF₃SSCF₃. The deprotonation of RCH(Me)SO₂CF₃ (R=CH₂Ph, iHex) with nBuLi with the formation of salts [RC(Me)? SO₂CF₃]Li and their electrophilic capture both occurred with high enantioselectivities. Displacement of the SO₂CF₃ group of (S)‐MeOCH₂C(Me)(CH₂Ph)SO₂CF₃ (95 % ee) by an ethyl group through the reaction with AlEt₃ gave alkane MeOCH₂C(Me)(CH₂Ph)Et of 96 % ee. Racemization of salts [R¹C(R²)SO₂CF₃]Li follows first‐order kinetics and is mainly an enthalpic process with small negative activation entropy as revealed by polarimetry and dynamic NMR (DNMR) spectroscopy. This is in accordance with a C_α? S bond rotation as the rate‐determining step. Lithium α‐(S)‐trifluoromethyl‐ and α‐(S)‐nonafluorobutylsulfonyl carbanion salts have a much higher racemization barrier than the corresponding α‐(S)‐tert‐butylsulfonyl carbanion salts. Whereas [PhCH₂C(Me)SO₂tBu]Li/DMPU (DMPU = dimethylpropylurea) has a half‐life of racemization at ?105 °C of 2.4 h, that of [PhCH₂C(Me)SO₂CF₃]Li at ?78 °C is 30 d. DNMR spectroscopy of amides (PhCH₂)₂NSO₂CF₃ and (PhCH₂)N(Ph)SO₂CF₃ gave N? S rotational barriers that seem to be distinctly higher than those of nonfluorinated sulfonamides. NMR spectroscopy of [PhCH₂C(Ph)SO₂R]M (M=Li, K, NBu₄; R=CF₃, tBu) shows for both salts a confinement of the negative charge mainly to the C_α atom and a significant benzylic stabilization that is weaker in the trifluoromethylsulfonyl carbanion. According to crystal structure analyses, the carbanions of salts {[PhCH₂C(Ph)SO₂CF₃]Li? L }₂ ( L =2 THF, tetramethylethylenediamine (TMEDA)) and [PhCH₂C(Ph)SO₂CF₃]NBu₄ have the typical chiral C_α? S conformation of α‐sulfonyl carbanions, planar C_α atoms, and short C_α? S bonds. Ab initio calculations of [MeC(Ph)SO₂tBu]^? and [MeC(Ph)SO₂CF₃]^? showed for the fluorinated carbanion stronger n_C→σ* and n_O→σ* interactions and a weaker benzylic stabilization. According to natural bond orbital (NBO) calculations of [R¹C(R²)SO₂R]^? (R=tBu, CF₃) the n_C→σ*_{S? R} interaction is much stronger for R=CF₃. Ab initio calculations gave for [MeC(Ph)SO₂tBu]Li ? 2 Me₂O an O,Li,C_α contact ion pair (CIP) and for [MeC(Ph)SO₂CF₃]Li ? 2 Me₂O an O,Li,O CIP. According to cryoscopy, [PhCH₂C(Ph)SO₂CF₃]Li, [iHexC(Me)SO₂CF₃]Li, and [PhCH₂C(Ph)SO₂CF₃]NBu₄ predominantly form monomers in tetrahydrofuran (THF) at ?108 °C. The NMR spectroscopic data of salts [R¹(R²)SO₂R³]Li (R³=tBu, CF₃) indicate that the dominating monomeric CIPs are devoid of C_α? Li bonds.     

Quantitative determination of chloride by means of flow injection analysis with spectrophotometric detection in the UV/VIS range

Chloride is determined indirectly by Spectrophotometric flow injection analysis. Two systems are compared, both based on the principle of ion exchange of easily detectable anions versus chloride from suitable mercury salts. The first method is based on the exchange of chloride with chloranilate which is detected at 332 nm or at 306 nm in neutral or in acidic medium respectively. In the second case, chloride reacts with Hg(SCN)₂. The liberated thiocyanate forms a strongly coloured complex with Fe(III) in acidic solution with an absorption maximum at 460 nm. Both methods have a detection limit of about 5 mol Cl^–/l (175 ng/ml). In the case of the thiocyanate method, the relative standard deviation is about 2% (7 measurements) in the range of 5 to 150 mol/l and decreases significantly to a value of approximately 0.2% at higher concentrations; for the chloranilate method it is 10% for lower and about 1% for higher concentrations respectively.     

Transesterification and amide cis-trans isomerization in Zn and Cd complexes of the chelating amino acid ligand Boc-Asp(Dpa)-OBzl

The amino acid derivative Boc-Asp-OBzl (Boc=N-butyloxycarbonyl; Asp=aspartic acid; Bzl=benzyl) was functionalized by coupling its carboxylate side chain to dipicolylamine. This yielded the tridentate nitrogen donor ligand Boc-Asp(Dpa)-OBzl (-OBzl). The compound -OBzl contains three different carbonyl groups: a tertiary amide linkage between Asp and Dpa, a C-terminal benzyl ester function, and an N-terminal urethane protecting group. NMR spectra were used to compare the reactivity of these moieties. The Boc protecting group gives rise to two isomers, (E, 9%) and (Z, 91%). Coordination of Cd(NO3)2 and Zn(NO3)2 yielded the complexes and. These compounds have significantly reduced barriers to rotation about the tertiary amide C-N bond compared with the free ligand (-OBzl:18.5 kcal mol-1 in CDBr3;: 12.9 kcal mol-1 in (CD3)2CO;: 13.8 kcal mol-1 in (CD3)2CO). Both complexes readily undergo transesterification in methanol or CD3OD. Experimental pseudo-first order rate constants were determined in CD3OD and (CD3)2CO:CD3OD (3:1;). It was found that the zinc complex (k=(2.28+/-0.02)x10(-4) s-1) is significantly more reactive than the cadmium complex (k=(1.41+/-0.03)x10(-6) s-1). In order to study their tertiary amide cis-trans isomerization, the cadmium complex [(-OCH3)Cd(NO3)2] was synthesized, and the zinc complex [(-OCD3)Zn(NO3)2] was generated in situ in (CD3)2CO:CD3OD (3:1). The barriers to rotation were determined (:14.1 kcal mol-1 in CD3OD;: 13.4 kcal mol-1 in (CD3)2CO:CD3OD (3:1)). Our results show that the stronger Lewis-acid zinc(II) is significantly more active than cadmium(II) in the acceleration of the transesterification. This is in marked contrast to the tertiary amide bond rotation which is comparably fast with both metal ions.     

Rates of ligand exchange between >FeIII-OH2 functional groups on a nanometer-sized aqueous cluster and bulk solution

Variable-temperature 17O NMR experiments were conducted on the nanometer-sized Keplerate Mo72Fe30 cluster, with the stoichiometry [Mo72Fe30O252(CH3COO)12[Mo2O7(H2O)]2[H2Mo2O8(H2O)](H2O)91]. approximately 150H2O. This molecule contains on its surface 30 Fe(H2O) groups forming a well-defined icosidodecahedron, and we estimated the rates of exchange of the isolated >FeIII-OH2 waters with bulk aqueous solution. Both longitudinal and transverse 17O-relaxation times were measured, as well as chemical shifts, and these parameters were then fit to the Swift-Connick equations in order to obtain the rate parameters. Correspondingly, we estimate: k(ex)298 = 6.7(+/-0.8) x 106 s-1, which is about a factor of approximately 4 x 104 times larger than the corresponding rate coefficient for the Fe(OH2)63+ ion of k(ex)298 = 1.6 x 102 s-1 (Grant and Jordan, 1981; Inorg. Chem. 20, 55-60) and DeltaH and DeltaS are 26.3 +/- 0.6 kJ mol-1 and -26 +/- 0.9 J mol-1 K-1, respectively. High-pressure 17O NMR experiments were also conducted, but the cluster decomposed slightly under pressure, which precluded confident quantitative estimation of the DeltaV. However, the increase in the reduced transverse-relaxation time with pressure suggests a dissociative character, such as a D or Id mechanism. The enhanced reactivity of waters on the Mo72Fe30 cluster is associated with an increase in the FeIII-OH2 bond length in the solid state of approximately 0.1 A relative to the Fe(OH2)63+ ion, suggesting that a correlation exists between the FeIII-OH2 bond length and k(ex)298. Although there are only few high-spin Fe(III) complexes where both exchange rates and structural data are available, these few seem to support a general correlation.     

Coverage dependent structures of oligopyridine adlayers on (111) oriented Ag films

The coverage dependent formation of ordered structures in vapor deposited 2,4'-bis(terpyridine)derivatives (2,4'-BTP) on (111) oriented Ag films was investigated by STM. Following a two-dimensional (2D) disordered gas phase at lowest coverages, a sequence of at least three ordered structures is observed with increasing coverage. These include a 'parallel chain structure' (PCS), a 'quasi-quadratic network' (QQN) structure, and a 'packed windmill structure' (PWS), with ideal coverages of 0.37, 0.4, and 0.44 molecules nm(-2). At intermediate coverages between 0.37 and 0.44 molecules nm(-2), these structures coexist in larger islands. The energetics of the different phases, whose structures are mainly determined by attractive C-H[dot dot dot]N bridges, are discussed in a picture including C-H[dot dot dot]N and C-H[dot dot dot]H-C interactions and lateral variations in the substrate-adsorbate interactions.