Octamethyl‐1, 1′‐di(2‐pyridyl)ferrocene: A Redox‐Active Ligand with a Pronounced Selectivity for Divalent Metal Ions

Octamethyl‐1, 1′‐di(2‐pyridyl)ferrocene ( 1 ) acts as molecular electrochemical sensor for magnesium, calcium, zinc, and cadmium ions in acetonitrile solution. The new redox peak, anodically shifted by ca. 0.40 V, which appears in the cyclic voltammogram of 1 in the presence of even small amounts (10 mol %) of these ions, is unaffected by an excess of alkali metal ions. Metal complexation is accompanied by a batho‐ and hyper‐chromic shift of the band in the visible region of the UV‐Vis spectrum of 1 . A detailed study of the behaviour of 1 towards zinc chloride in acetonitrile solution has revealed that 1 is able to accommodate a maximum of two zinc ions. Oxidation of zinc‐coordinated 1 leads to partial decomplexation. The N‐methyl and N‐benzyl species 1 Me⁺, 1 Me₂²⁺, 1 Bzl⁺ and 1 Bzl₂²⁺ have been synthesized and the former two structurally investigated by X‐ray diffraction. Alkylation causes an anodic shift of the redox potential of the ferrocene nucleus, which is linearly dependent on the number of alkyl groups introduced. Octamethyl‐1, 1′‐di(2‐thiophenyl)ferrocene ( 2 ) has also been synthesized and structurally characterized by X‐ray diffraction. Cyclic voltammetry has revealed that, in contrast to 1 , 2 does not respond to the divalent metal ions studied.     

Reply to the ‘Comment on “Uncommon structural and bonding properties in Ag16B4O10” by A. Lobato,Miguel Á. Salvadó, and J. Manuel Recio,Chem. Sci., 2021, 12, DOI: 10.1039/D1SC02152D

Where are the excess electrons in Ag₁₆B₄O₁₀?

Ag₁₆B₄O₁₀ features an exotic scheme of chemical bonding and extends the growing family of subvalent silver oxides. These findings constitute a new general and intrinsic facet of the chemistry of silver, which has not been fully understood, yet, and definitely deserves to be analysed from different perspectives. Against this background, we distinctly appreciate the efforts made by A. Lobato, Miguel Á. Salvadó, and J. Manuel Recio (LSR) in studying these phenomena at the example of the title compound.¹ While the computational results presented in the Comment article well comply with those published in our original paper,² the interpretations follow different routes. Whereas LSR focus on the analogy of pattern of the Electron Localization Function (ELF) in position space in the title compound with those found in elemental silver, we interpreted the electronic structure of Ag₁₆B₄O₁₀, both in position and reciprocal space, also considering the interactions between cationic and anionic partial structures.